Line shafting

A works of this period often had one engine or one water wheel, and the machines in it took its power from a turning iron bar overhead. How to run a line in the game is in the shaft power guide. This page is about the real shafting, why it looked as it did, and how far the game follows it.

A machine shop kept as it was, photographed for the Historic American Engineering Record: overhead line shafting, belts dropping to the machines below, one prime mover, a turbine on the far wall. Every pulley up there is turning whenever the shaft is.
A machine shop kept as it was, photographed for the Historic American Engineering Record: overhead line shafting, belts dropping to the machines below, one prime mover, a turbine on the far wall. Every pulley up there is turning whenever the shaft is.
Line shaft at Queen Street Mill, built 1894: a plain round bar running through cast-iron hangers bolted to the ceiling beams, with belt pulleys clamped on between them. The bar carries the power; each pulley takes off a share.
Line shaft at Queen Street Mill, built 1894: a plain round bar running through cast-iron hangers bolted to the ceiling beams, with belt pulleys clamped on between them. The bar carries the power; each pulley takes off a share.
Saltaire, Fairbairn's Fig. 242 (Fairbairn Mills II p. 103), a cross-section labelled for this page. Four engines, over 1,250 horse-power in all, and nearly 300 of it went up this one vertical shaft (Fairbairn Mills II p. 102). A bevel pair at a room turns the power through a right angle onto that room's horizontal line, and belts carry it the last step to the machines.
Saltaire, Fairbairn's Fig. 242 (Fairbairn Mills II p. 103), a cross-section labelled for this page. Four engines, over 1,250 horse-power in all, and nearly 300 of it went up this one vertical shaft (Fairbairn Mills II p. 102). A bevel pair at a room turns the power through a right angle onto that room's horizontal line, and belts carry it the last step to the machines.
The game's planned line shaft on its hanger: a wrought octagon 2 voxels across, 125 mm true, in a cast bracket with a brass step and a cap, as Fairbairn's plummer seats are built. Today the game has one cast shaft and no hangers., iso
The game's planned line shaft on its hanger: a wrought octagon 2 voxels across, 125 mm true, in a cast bracket with a brass step and a cap, as Fairbairn's plummer seats are built. Today the game has one cast shaft and no hangers.

One prime mover, and why the shaft exists at all

Before steam, a mill often had a water wheel for every machine or pair of machines (Fairbairn Mills II p. 50). Concentrating the prime movers saved water and then fuel, and it needed a way of carrying power across a building. That way was shafting, and Fairbairn traces the whole factory system to it: any number of processes under one roof, moved by a single engine at a convenient distance, through "lines of shafting coupled together in lengths, adapted to the bays or divisions of the building" (Fairbairn Mills II p. 50). Lines of 200 or 300 ft followed, and the shafting at Saltaire laid end to end would have run more than two miles (Fairbairn Mills II pp. 50-51).

The arrangement had a cost that every mill paid. A line of shafting turns whether or not the machines on it are working, and a long one is a load in its own right. Fairbairn says the ponderous shafts of about 1800, "generally of cast iron, square, and badly coupled", took in some cases almost as much power to turn as the machines they drove (Fairbairn Mills II p. 72).

Fast and thin, or slow and heavy

A shaft carries power as turning force times speed, so the same power at twice the speed needs half the turning force and a thinner bar. Fairbairn built his career on that: he credits his success to "increasing threefold the velocity of the shafting" (Fairbairn Mills II p. 72), and says a shaft at 50 revolutions a minute needs fully three times the weight of one doing the same work at the speed he recommends, about half that of the machines (Fairbairn Mills II p. 72). Slow shafts also block a room with large drums and pulleys and take away the light (Fairbairn Mills II p. 72).

The material followed the job. Wood with iron hoops was first and by Fairbairn's day obsolete. The main and vertical shafts stayed cast iron, which was cheap, stiff and good in torsion, and wrought iron took over the line shafting and wherever there was impact (Fairbairn Mills II p. 51). A long shaft was sized by what it bent as much as by what it could carry: no more than 1/1200 of its length under load, since "a stiff shaft, although heavier in itself, is lighter to retain in motion than a smaller one which bends" (Fairbairn Mills II pp. 60-61).

Lengths, and how they were joined and held

Fairbairn's circular half-lap coupling, Fig. 213 (Fairbairn Mills II p. 81), box shown in section. Two shaft ends cut to lap over each other, a round box over the lap, one key half in the box and half in the shaft, the whole turned in the lathe on the same centres as the bearings. The area of the coupling is twice the shaft's, the lap one diameter long and the box two.
Fairbairn's circular half-lap coupling, Fig. 213 (Fairbairn Mills II p. 81), box shown in section. Two shaft ends cut to lap over each other, a round box over the lap, one key half in the box and half in the shaft, the whole turned in the lathe on the same centres as the bearings. The area of the coupling is twice the shaft's, the lap one diameter long and the box two.

Shafts were cast or rolled in lengths and joined by the bay. The earliest joints were a square box slipped over two square ends, which rose and fell at every turn and wore out its own fit; the claw coupling, Hewes's half-lap with three keys, and the bolted disc followed (Fairbairn Mills II pp. 79-80). Fairbairn's own circular half-lap replaced them for general work, and he calls it "the most accurate and durable" (Fairbairn Mills II p. 81). A butt-ended cylinder coupling of the same proportions was cheaper, and weaker, since all the torque went through the key (Fairbairn Mills II p. 82).

A pedestal bolted to a wall, Fig. 230 (Fairbairn Mills II p. 94), side section and front view: a cast bracket through the masonry carrying a shell cap fixed by a cotter. Shafting was held "on foundation stones in the floor, beneath beams suspended from the ceiling, and to the walls" (Fairbairn Mills II p. 93), and every one of those was a brass step in a cast housing.
A pedestal bolted to a wall, Fig. 230 (Fairbairn Mills II p. 94), side section and front view: a cast bracket through the masonry carrying a shell cap fixed by a cotter. Shafting was held "on foundation stones in the floor, beneath beams suspended from the ceiling, and to the walls" (Fairbairn Mills II p. 93), and every one of those was a brass step in a cast housing.

Each bearing was a plummer block: a cast seat, a cap, and brass steps round the journal. Journals ran one and a half diameters long for cast iron and one and three-quarters for wrought (Fairbairn Mills II p. 73), and the collars next to them were to be hollowed and never cut square, since a square shoulder cost the shaft strength (Fairbairn Mills II p. 74). Oil was the running cost. The oiling of shafts was "generally left to the most negligent and most untidy person in the establishment", and in a large cotton mill a change in the quality of the oil could absorb ten to fifteen horse-power; the power needed on a Monday morning, after a cold Sunday, was always higher than on any other day (Fairbairn Mills II pp. 77-78). Fairbairn's preferred oiler was a small cistern on the plummer block feeding the journal through a woollen thread (Fairbairn Mills II p. 78).

Turning a corner: bevel wheels

The double bevel hanger, front and side, Figs. 238 and 239 (Fairbairn Mills II pp. 97-98). A cast frame on hooked bolts to the iron beam A carries the main line through its centre, with the crown wheel on it, and one small branch shaft to either side, each meshing the crown at right angles and turning in opposite directions.
The double bevel hanger, front and side, Figs. 238 and 239 (Fairbairn Mills II pp. 97-98). A cast frame on hooked bolts to the iron beam A carries the main line through its centre, with the crown wheel on it, and one small branch shaft to either side, each meshing the crown at right angles and turning in opposite directions.
Side elevation of the same arrangement. Double brass steps carry the main line and the two branches. Hooked bolts at a a grip the iron beam so that no holes need be bored through its flange, which would weaken it.
Side elevation of the same arrangement. Double brass steps carry the main line and the two branches. Hooked bolts at a a grip the iron beam so that no holes need be bored through its flange, which would weaken it.

Toothed wheels did the turning and the changing of speed. Lancashire and Yorkshire preferred them for the whole run, and American mills drove from a great drum by leather straps; Fairbairn found less journal friction with gearing, but agreed straps suited irregular work and the last step from shaft to machine, since they slip as they wear, which loses time and eases shocks (Fairbairn Mills II pp. 1-3). Gears set the speed too: a small mill's spur fly-wheel on a pinion "nearly doubled" the speed on its main shaft (Fairbairn Mills II p. 123), and at Taganrog a fly-wheel of 24 ft 5 in at 24.7 rpm drove a pinion at 87.7, a step of about 3.5 (Fairbairn Mills II pp. 127-128).

The game's planned bevel junction: a crown on the through shaft and a pinion on a branch, in a cast hanger after Fairbairn's Figs. 238 and 239. Today's bevel is a simple corner block with no frame., iso
The game's planned bevel junction: a crown on the through shaft and a pinion on a branch, in a cast hanger after Fairbairn's Figs. 238 and 239. Today's bevel is a simple corner block with no frame.

Flywheels and letting go

Between the strokes of an engine and the bites of a mill the demand on a shaft changes quickly, and a rotating mass smooths it: a heavy rim gives up a little speed when the load comes on and takes it back when the load goes off. An engine's fly-wheel did that job, and in an iron mill it did it hardest. Plate rolling wanted "the momentum of a large fly-wheel" to carry the plates through the rolls, and even then thin plates could cool before they were done (Fairbairn Mills II p. 259).

Fairbairn says it was "upwards of twenty years since" the fly-wheel became a first motion: teeth were cast on its rim and a pinion took the power straight off, which did away with the cumbrous gearing that had stood inside the mill (Fairbairn Mills II p. 100). Fairbairn's table of them runs from 12 to 300 horse-power and from 8 ft 11.5 in to 30 ft 1.5 in across (Fairbairn Mills II p. 101).

The game's normal flywheel, planned drawing, a disc on the main shaft that only stores. A period one might instead carry teeth and act as the first motion; the game does that work with a separate gearbox., iso
The game's normal flywheel, planned drawing, a disc on the main shaft that only stores. A period one might instead carry teeth and act as the first motion; the game does that work with a separate gearbox.
Fairbairn's disengaging coupling, Fig. 223 (Fairbairn Mills II p. 88). Part a is cast on a spur or bevel wheel and rides loose on the shaft; part b slides on a sunk key, thrown by the fork of lever d. Their faces carry alternate claws: thrown in, the wheel drives the shaft; thrown out, it spins free.
Fairbairn's disengaging coupling, Fig. 223 (Fairbairn Mills II p. 88). Part a is cast on a spur or bevel wheel and rides loose on the shaft; part b slides on a sunk key, thrown by the fork of lever d. Their faces carry alternate claws: thrown in, the wheel drives the shaft; thrown out, it spins free.

A works also needed to stop one thing without stopping everything. A form with sloped claws let a driven line overrun: the oblique faces fall out of contact and slide free when the driven side gets ahead, as where a water wheel and a steam engine share one line (Fairbairn Mills II pp. 88-89). Clutches between the upright and each room's shafting had been tried and were given up as "unsteady in practice" (Fairbairn Mills II p. 82).

Period basis, and what is the game's own

  • Period: main and vertical shafts cast, line shafts wrought and faster (Fairbairn Mills II pp. 51, 72). The game plans the same two sizes, a cast main and a wrought line, and today has one cast shaft.
  • Period: the line carried by floor pedestals, ceiling hangers and wall boxes, each a brass step in a cast seat, with a half-lap coupling at the joint beside the bearing (Fairbairn Mills II pp. 81, 93-98). The game plans these drawn at the supports it requires, and draws a half-lap at each joint.
  • Period: a standing load that grew with the line (Fairbairn Mills II p. 72). The game plans a standing torque per shaft length and today charges one figure per run.
  • Period: the bevel, spur and clutch hardware above. The game has the bevel, a two-to-one and a four-to-one gearbox with 2% lost at each geared station, and a clutch that joins two runs one to one; the disengaging coupling is built after Fig. 223, with a weighted lever, and its claws overrun.
  • The game's own: the flywheel stores only and carries no teeth, and it stays on the shaft with no separate pinion off its rim.
  • The game's own: no vanilla axle drives this shafting. Vanilla mechanical power is a speed with no storage and no turning force of its own; see vanilla against reality. The prime mover is the iron breast wheel, and a steam engine later.
  • The game's own: the shaft does not need oiling today, and a dry Monday costs nothing. Bearings carry an oil factor in the planned model, held at one until there is an oil to change it.

The numbers

Shafting keeps period figures at true size (scale and units, how we scale). "Planned" is the design value; values without that word are what the game has now.

In the gamePeriod figureHow it was scaledGame value
Line shaft diameterTable 8 sizes wrought shafting for 1 to 150 hp at 10 to 1000 rpm (Fairbairn Mills II p. 71)Whole voxels at true sizePlanned 125 mm (4.92 in), 2 voxels
Main shaft diameterSaltaire 10 in vertical (Fairbairn Mills II p. 102)Whole voxels at true sizePlanned 250 mm (9.84 in), 4 voxels; today's cast shaft is this section
Line torque ratingWrought shafting, d^3 = 250 H/R (Fairbairn Mills II p. 70)The rule at face valuePlanned 3.4 kN m working
Main torque ratingBuchanan's rule for fly-wheel shafts, d^3 = 400 H/R (Fairbairn Mills II p. 70)The rule at face valuePlanned 17.0 kN m working
Line power at rating, 19 rpmSameTorque x speedPlanned 6.8 kW, 9 hp
Main power at rating, 19 rpmSameTorque x speedPlanned 34 kW, 46 hp
Speed guide94 rpm Saltaire vertical, near 200 rpm spinning lines (Fairbairn Mills II pp. 102-105)Not enforcedPlanned 19 to 150 rpm line, 10 to 95 rpm main
Journal length1.5 diameters cast, 1.75 wrought (Fairbairn Mills II p. 73)The rule at true sizePlanned 1.5 d main, 1.75 d line
CouplingLap one diameter, box two (Fairbairn Mills II p. 81)Whole voxels, box to 2.4 d across for the keyPlanned, drawn at each joint
Span between supportsDeflection under 1/1200 of length (Fairbairn Mills II p. 60)Whole blocks; a span is the game's own choicePlanned 3 m line, 4 m main
Standing torqueGrows with line length (Fairbairn Mills II p. 72); no figure givenThe game's ownPlanned 4.3 N m a metre line, 32.5 N m main; today one figure per run
Gear ratioAbout 1.9 and 3.5 (Fairbairn Mills II pp. 123, 127-128)Whole ratios2:1 and 4:1 gearboxes, 2% lost per station
Bevel teeth ratingTredgold's rule, 400 lb per inch of breadth (Fairbairn Mills II pp. 43-44)Applied to the drawn wheelPlanned 4.1 kN m
Flywheel across8 ft 11.5 in to 30 ft 1.5 in (Fairbairn Mills II p. 101)Fits the block grid; much smaller than periodAbout 3 m and 5 m
Flywheel inertiaNone givenThe game's own, a disc's I scaling as R^4 x thickness10,000 and 150,000 kg m2 on the game's physical scale

Open, and what you can tell us

Fairbairn's table gives fly-wheels by power and speed, but none of the books at hand says how a mill chose the mass of the rim for the job it did. If you know a period rule for sizing a fly-wheel against a rolling or forging load, we would like to read it.

Picture credits

  • Line shaft: Jet Lowe, Historic American Engineering Record, public domain, cropped.
  • QSMM Line shaft brackets 3212: Clem Rutter, Rochester, Kent, CC BY 3.0, cropped.
  • Fig. 242, labelled for this page; Figs. 213, 230, 238, 239 and 223: Fairbairn, Treatise on Mills and Millwork, pt. II, pp. 103, 81, 94, 97, 98 and 88, Library page.
  • The game's line hanger, bevel and flywheel: the mod's planned drawings.