The machine shop

A casting comes out of the sand rough, oversize and with a hard skin. Before it can be part of an engine, the faces that meet, the holes that fit and the shafts that turn must be cut to size, and that was the work of the machine shop. The tools themselves are in the catalogue, from the lathe to the planer, and what drives them is in the shaft power guide. This page follows a casting through the shop as the workers did, then says what the game keeps of it.

Most of what follows comes from Rose's Modern Machine-Shop Practice (1901 printing of the 1887 work) and the Sellers catalogues of 1877 and 1895, so the practice they record is that of the end of the century.

A drilling machine in a works of uncertain date, perhaps in Austria-Hungary, driven by a belt from overhead into the stepped pulleys at its foot. Behind it stand lathes and the bed of a large machine. Every tool in such a shop took its power from the same shaft.
A drilling machine in a works of uncertain date, perhaps in Austria-Hungary, driven by a belt from overhead into the stepped pulleys at its foot. Behind it stand lathes and the bed of a large machine. Every tool in such a shop took its power from the same shaft.
A planing machine by J. Whitworth and Co., 1842. The work is bolted to the table, which carries it back and forth under a tool that stands still; the tool's slide on the cross rail moves over a little at each stroke.
A planing machine by J. Whitworth and Co., 1842. The work is bolted to the table, which carries it back and forth under a tool that stands still; the tool's slide on the cross rail moves over a little at each stroke.
The game's engine lathe in its planned drawing: its spindle runs in two brass bushes and its drive shaft couples to the iron shafting. The other four tools stand on the same shafting., iso
The game's engine lathe in its planned drawing: its spindle runs in two brass bushes and its drive shaft couples to the iron shafting. The other four tools stand on the same shafting.

The work in order

The first face. The first cut on a casting went under its skin, which dulls a tool (Rose p. 286). On a long casting the face that would rest on the foundation or the legs was planed first, with the casting supported evenly at each point so that it did not spring (Rose p. 420). Every later measurement could then start from a true face.

A Sellers planer (Rose Fig. 1565, p. 406). The long table runs on V-guides and carries the casting under the tool. Planing costs time on the way back, when nothing is cut, so the table returned quickly: Sellers rated one machine at 18 ft a minute cutting and 72 returning (Sellers 1895 p. 187), and open-side planers ran 3 or 4 to 1 (Rose p. 411).
A Sellers planer (Rose Fig. 1565, p. 406). The long table runs on V-guides and carries the casting under the tool. Planing costs time on the way back, when nothing is cut, so the table returned quickly: Sellers rated one machine at 18 ft a minute cutting and 72 returning (Sellers 1895 p. 187), and open-side planers ran 3 or 4 to 1 (Rose p. 411).

A planer's table ran at the same cutting speed for all work and all metals. The shaper took small pieces, and it was quicker on them because its stepped pulley could vary the speed (Rose p. 398). Two heads on a planer, one roughing and one finishing, doubled the output (Rose p. 405).

The bore. A hole that something must fit was bored, and heavy work stayed still. "When work of considerable weight requires to be bored ... it is more convenient that it remain fixed upon a table, and that the boring tools rotate" (Rose p. 218).

A cylinder boring lathe (Rose Fig. 738, p. 219). The stepped pulley D drives a worm that turns the great wheel on bar g, which runs in bearings at H and H'. The cylinder is bolted down in the middle and the cutter head h is fed along the bar by a screw inside it. The outside of the cylinder is never touched; better machines faced both ends at the same setting. Sellers claimed three and a half hours for the largest freight or express locomotive cylinder, where ordinary boring machines seldom took less than thirteen (Sellers 1895 p. 74).
A cylinder boring lathe (Rose Fig. 738, p. 219). The stepped pulley D drives a worm that turns the great wheel on bar g, which runs in bearings at H and H'. The cylinder is bolted down in the middle and the cutter head h is fed along the bar by a screw inside it. The outside of the cylinder is never touched; better machines faced both ends at the same setting. Sellers claimed three and a half hours for the largest freight or express locomotive cylinder, where ordinary boring machines seldom took less than thirteen (Sellers 1895 p. 74).

The cutter head had four cutters where it could: three bore out of round, and four fed four times as fast (Rose pp. 289-291). A dull tool bored a taper, so the finishing cut had to carry its whole length without a regrind (Rose pp. 286-287, 294).

What is round. Shafts, rods and pistons went on the lathe, and with them almost everything else.

The lathe's oldest form, still in use in the Carpathians when Rose wrote (Rose Fig. 448, p. 119). Two trees, a sapling for a spring, a treadle c and a rope a: the work turns one way under the foot and back again under the sapling. Rose calls the lathe "the most important of all metal-cutting machine tools" and the oldest.
The lathe's oldest form, still in use in the Carpathians when Rose wrote (Rose Fig. 448, p. 119). Two trees, a sapling for a spring, a treadle c and a rope a: the work turns one way under the foot and back again under the sapling. Rose calls the lathe "the most important of all metal-cutting machine tools" and the oldest.

The lathe was more than one machine in the shop's own view. Drilling, boring and reaming were all done on it, some planing could be done as well, and a good lathe hand was thought able to run any other tool in the shop (Rose p. 119).

The cuttings told the man how the cut was going. Cuttings from wrought iron should come off almost too hot to hold, short uncoiled cuttings meant too little rake, and a tool that dulled fast had too much clearance (Rose p. 259). Workmen differed by 30% in speed and 50% in feed, and Hartnell's figures run wider still (Rose p. 295).

Flats, keyways and small work. The shaper's ram carried the tool across a piece held still, about 18 in at most and 12 on a small machine (Rose pp. 396-397). It cut keyways in shafting held in its chuck or between centres (Rose p. 397), and its return, by crank or link, was about 40% quicker than the cut (Rose pp. 398-401).

A heavy shaping machine by Morton (Rose Plate LXIX-B, Fig. 1508). The ram at top left carries the tool; the box table below it holds the work. By the date of this book the shaper's place was "not as important as was the case a few years ago, because of the advent of the milling machine" (Rose p. 389).
A heavy shaping machine by Morton (Rose Plate LXIX-B, Fig. 1508). The ram at top left carries the tool; the box table below it holds the work. By the date of this book the shaper's place was "not as important as was the case a few years ago, because of the advent of the milling machine" (Rose p. 389).

Holes in numbers. Where many holes had to match, a template did the laying out. A locomotive cylinder's cover and flange holes were drilled through a template ring, clearing holes first and tapping holes after (Rose pp. 440-442).

Three drilling machines (Rose Plate XCV, Figs. 1676 to 1678). The table rises on the column, the drive enters at the foot by a stepped pulley, and the feed is a hand wheel or lever. A 1/2 in drill through 2 3/4 in of iron took 1 min 20 s and could do 120 to 130 such holes before it wanted sharpening (Rose p. 278).
Three drilling machines (Rose Plate XCV, Figs. 1676 to 1678). The table rises on the column, the drive enters at the foot by a stepped pulley, and the feed is a hand wheel or lever. A 1/2 in drill through 2 3/4 in of iron took 1 min 20 s and could do 120 to 130 such holes before it wanted sharpening (Rose p. 278).

Why the shop grew in the order it did

James Nasmyth set up on his own in 1831 and left the best account in the books of how a shop was bootstrapped. He began with his father's foot lathe, to which he had added a slide rest, and with castings for a big lathe. The foot lathe turned the big lathe's parts. The big lathe's "first child was a planing machine", 3 ft by 1 ft 8 in, and with those two "most important and generally useful tools" he added boring and drilling machines (Nasmyth pp. 178-179). He wrote that the lathe would be "the parent of a vast progeny", and in his shop it was. The shaper does not appear in that passage.

The order of the tools, in one period shop and in the game. Nasmyth's shop starts from a lathe already in the family (Nasmyth pp. 178-179). The game's starts from a bench and cuts teeth first, because a lathe needs gears and no gear is cast with its teeth. In either case, the first machines were made by whatever came before them.
The order of the tools, in one period shop and in the game. Nasmyth's shop starts from a lathe already in the family (Nasmyth pp. 178-179). The game's starts from a bench and cuts teeth first, because a lathe needs gears and no gear is cast with its teeth. In either case, the first machines were made by whatever came before them.

What drove the whole business was accuracy. William Fawcett, a Liverpool engine builder, called Maudslay "the great pioneer in the substitution of the unerring accuracy of machine tools, for the often untrustworthy results of mere manual labour" (Nasmyth p. 168).

Period basis, and what is the game's own

  • Period: the shop's tools overlapped, and the lathe did everyone's work (Rose p. 119). The game gives each tool one verb: turn, bore, shape, plane, drill. The split keeps the number of machines to five and gives each a reason to be built.
  • Period: a heavy cylinder stood still and the bar turned (Rose p. 218), and its outside stayed as cast (Rose p. 219). Planned for the game: every barrel bored with its ends faced at the boring machine, its outside as cast.
  • Period: teeth were cut on gear-cutting engines by revolving or rack-form cutters (Rose pp. 34, 36), and the shaper cut flats and keyways (Rose p. 397). The game's own: the shaper cuts the teeth, one machine instead of a sixth, and the drilling machine the eye first.
  • Period: tool steel, hardened and tempered, for every cutter in Rose (Rose p. 254). The game's own: a cutter of any iron or steel, its temper the gate and its metal the reach and life, so that the shop can start before steel does.
  • Period: cuttings came off every machine (Rose pp. 259, 273), and a casting's skin dulled the tool (Rose p. 286). Planned for the game: every job returns what it removed as cuttings of that metal, to be melted again, and a remainder too small for a cutting leaves as scale.
  • The game's own: the bench. Every part a machine tool makes has a hand route on the same blank at the bench, slower and more wasteful, so the first machines can be built before there are any. The exceptions are the bored cylinder and the slide bar.
  • The game's own: a cut is one hold at the machine. Laying out, setting up and measuring are folded into it.

The numbers

Each job in the game costs energy for the metal removed, and takes as long as that energy lasts at the machine's power. Hartig's figures are used at face value, with no fuel factor (see the scaling page); game time follows scale and units. "Planned" is the rating in design.

In the gamePeriod figureHow it was scaledGame value
Energy to cut cast iron, rotary.0314 hp per lb of cuttings an hour, lathe (Hartig in Rose p. 273)5.918 MJ/kg per hp/(lb/h)185,800 J/kg
Energy to cut wrought iron, rotary.0327 hp, lathe (Rose p. 273)The same193,500 J/kg
Energy to cut wrought iron, reciprocating.0520 hp, planer (Rose p. 273)The same307,800 J/kg
Energy to cut cast iron, reciprocatingNone printedThe lathe's figure times wrought iron's planer-to-lathe ratio295,500 J/kg, derived
Energy to drillNone printedTakes the rotary figureThe game's own
Drilling machine power1/2 in hole through 2 3/4 in of iron in 1 min 20 s (Rose p. 278), about 170 WThe same cut scaled to a 3/4 in holePlanned 360 W; the game's own
Lathe powerCast iron at 45 ft/min, feed 30 an inch (Rose p. 294)With a 1/8 in cut, the depth the game's ownPlanned 822 W
Boring machine powerA locomotive cylinder in 3 1/2 h (Sellers 1895 p. 74)Bore and length of a 22 in by 36 in cylinder, the 3/8 in skin the game's ownPlanned 1620 W
Planer power18 ft/min cut, 72 return (Sellers 1895 p. 187)0.8 of the time cutting; feed and depth the game's ownPlanned 780 W
Shaper powerReturn about 40% quicker (Rose p. 398)The planer's cut at 0.583 of the time cuttingPlanned 570 W
Hand work at the benchRankine's crank and pump rows (Rankine 1876 p. 626)Sustained man's power, the pump row inferred for reciprocating work61.0 W rotary, 44.7 W reciprocating
Hand or machine, one 1.5 kg wrought-iron plate drilledNone givenEnergy over power159 real seconds by hand, 27 at the machine

Open, and what you can tell us

The books at hand describe the shop at the end of the century; Nasmyth's memoir is the one account here of a shop being built up, and it is one man's. They do not say what order a typical works bought its tools in, or whether a shaper usually came before a planer. Nor do they say how a shop of the 1830s cut the teeth of the wheels it wanted true: Rose only says cast wheels could not be (Rose p. 34). A source on either would be welcome.

Picture credits