Vanilla against reality

The base game's numbers are balanced for play, and most players never learn how far they sit from the furnaces and forges of the period. The distance shows which of the mod's numbers follow the period, which follow the base game, and why a design departs from its sources where it does.

Reading the figures

Metal is counted in units (u), and 100 u is one vanilla ingot. Masses on this page reckon a unit at 0.70 kg, the figure Scale and units works out for iron at the game's voxel size. That is a unit's mass as an item: how fast a furnace makes iron is a separate measure, set out on the Foundations page about scaling from the sources. A game hour is 2 real minutes on the default day. "Worked out" marks arithmetic on a book's figures, where the book does not state the result. A - means the row has no figure on that side.

The bloomery

The vanilla bloomery is a single block that holds 6 fuel items and up to 120 nuggets of ore. Twenty nuggets smelt into 100 u, so a nugget is worth 5 u and a full charge comes out as one iron bloom of 600 u, six ingots' worth.

VanillaPeriodGap
Make: 60 u an hour, 42 kg an hourOverman's blomary fire: 16.6 kg an hour, worked out from 5-6 tons a week for the two fires one hammer serves, Overman, p. 383Vanilla makes about 2.53 times the fire
One bloom: 600 u, about 420 kgA ball not over 100 lb (45 kg) at a smelting, Overman, p. 248; 64-96 kg a bloom, Agricola, p. 421; 152 kg of bar in a six-hour heat of the largest hearth, Bauerman, p. 241About 9 times Overman's ball
Fuel: 6 items, 60 kg of charcoal for 420 kg of iron, 0.14 kg a kg300 bushels of charcoal a ton of blooms, Overman, p. 248, which is 2.08 kg a kg worked out at 15.5 lb a bushel, Overman, p. 117; 300 bushels a ton of finished bars, Swank, p. 341; 3.40 kg a kg of bar, Bauerman, p. 241Vanilla burns about 15 times less than Overman's fire
Time: 10 game hours a heat, 20 real minutesFirst blast of 1.5-2 hours, Overman, p. 247; preliminary stage of about 2 hours, Bauerman, p. 238; 8, 10 or 12 hours a bloom, Agricola, p. 421Inside the period range

The time is about right, and everything else is generous. One small block turns out a bloom nine times the weight of a period ball for a fifteenth of the charcoal. The mod leaves that bloomery untouched and measures every later furnace against it, so a new furnace is judged by how many bloomeries it replaces.

Fuel and charcoal

VanillaPeriodGap
Burn values, temperature in C by seconds: charcoal 1300 x 40, coke 1340 x 40, anthracite 1200 x 196, bituminous coal 1200 x 84, lignite 1100 x 77, contaminated coal 900 x 25, firewood 700 x 24--
Coal pile: 16 items to a block. Proposed: an item counts as 1/16 of a cubic metre, so a charcoal item is 10 kgCharcoal at 160 kg a cubic metre, worked out from a bushel of 15-16 lb, Overman, p. 117The pile sets the item's volume, the bushel its weight
Charcoal pit: a column gives a quarter of its firewood times 0.5 to 1.0, so a full block of 32 firewood averages 6 items, 60 kg, and burns 18 hours50-75 kg of charcoal from a stacked cubic metre of wood, worked out from kilns giving 20 lb from 100 lb of wood, Overman, p. 116, and a cord of 128 cubic feet, Overman, p. 84, weighing 2,000-3,000 lb, Overman, p. 870.8 to 1.2 of the period: the pit is period-true

Measured by the coal pile, the charcoal pit is honest and the bloomery is not: the pit makes about what a period kiln made from the same wood, and the bloomery then spends a fifteenth of the charcoal a period fire needed. No single correction fixes both, so the leanness is treated as the base game's own balance. The 10 kg item is proposed, and the mod's code still counts a charcoal item as 5.0 kg. Proposed: every furnace that works iron burns the bloomery's fuel factor per kg of iron, by its period ratio, while boilers, kilns and coke ovens, which heat no iron, keep period figures.

Smithing and metal measure

VanillaPeriodGap
Ingot: 42 voxels of smithing plan, 100 u--
Rod: plan of 2 x 2 x 10, 40 voxels, one ingot--
Plate: plan of 9 x 9, 81 voxels, two ingots, 200 u--
Tool molds: 100, 200 or 900 u--
Iron bloom: hammered into an ingot at the anvil, and the vanilla helve hammer works it fully--

Smithing is measured on the game's own grid, and no period figure is set against it here. Its value is as a ruler: these plans are where the mod's rate of 2.5 u a voxel comes from, as the Scale and units page shows. The ruler is a large one. At 0.70 kg a unit an ingot is about 70 kg, more than the whole 45 kg ball Overman, p. 248, would take from a smelting, so a player carrying a stack of ingots is carrying far more iron than it looks.

How these gaps turn into the mod's numbers, with a period ratio multiplied onto a vanilla anchor, is on the Foundations page about scaling from the sources.