Fuels

A furnace's fuel does two jobs at once. It has to give heat, and it has to stand in the fire in a shape that lets air through. The fuels of the period differ in what they carry with them and how they stand up. How to make and charge them in the game is in the coke and fuel guide. This page is about what each one is and why it goes where it goes.

Bituminous coal: layered, bright and full of what the fire must drive off. Raw, it contains a normal amount of volatile matter (Johnson, Principles p. 185), its tar obstructs a furnace's gas passages (Johnson, Principles pp. 185-186), and in the fire it swells, because it is too close-grained for its gases to escape (Overman p. 103).
Bituminous coal: layered, bright and full of what the fire must drive off. Raw, it contains a normal amount of volatile matter (Johnson, Principles p. 185), its tar obstructs a furnace's gas passages (Johnson, Principles pp. 185-186), and in the fire it swells, because it is too close-grained for its gases to escape (Overman p. 103).
Anthracite: the same coal after the earth has distilled it. Its volatile matter has gone "under conditions of heat and pressure", and the pressure "closed up the cells", so it is "the most close-grained of any variety of coal" (Johnson, Principles pp. 183-184).
Anthracite: the same coal after the earth has distilled it. Its volatile matter has gone "under conditions of heat and pressure", and the pressure "closed up the cells", so it is "the most close-grained of any variety of coal" (Johnson, Principles pp. 183-184).

Four fuels, and what each is good for

Wood and coal both hold water, hydrogen and oxygen as well as carbon, and those harm the iron, most of all in the blast furnace. Charring gets rid of them (Overman p. 103). Coke is to coal what charcoal is to wood.

Making charcoal in heaps (Overman p. 106, Fig. 26). A stack of 20 to 50 cords of wood, covered in leaves and dust, is lit at the bottom of the centre and left to char by its own heat with the air shut out (Overman pp. 105-106). The vents let the smoke go. The cover sinks after three or four days, and four or five more cool the kiln before the coal is raked out at the foot (Overman p. 106).
Making charcoal in heaps (Overman p. 106, Fig. 26). A stack of 20 to 50 cords of wood, covered in leaves and dust, is lit at the bottom of the centre and left to char by its own heat with the air shut out (Overman pp. 105-106). The vents let the smoke go. The cover sinks after three or four days, and four or five more cool the kiln before the coal is raked out at the foot (Overman p. 106).
A charcoal pile stacked and left uncovered at Stuebing, under a shelter. The wood stands on end, with a ladder up the side as Overman describes (Overman p. 107). Dust and leaves would hide all of this.
A charcoal pile stacked and left uncovered at Stuebing, under a shelter. The wood stands on end, with a ladder up the side as Overman describes (Overman p. 107). Dust and leaves would hide all of this.

Charcoal is close to pure, and Johnson calls it "almost an ideal furnace fuel": a few hundredths of 1% of sulphur against about 1% in coke, and about 1% of ash against about 10% (Johnson, Principles p. 183). Its ash is largely lime and alkalis, so it helps flux the ore instead of adding silica to be fluxed. It is so porous that it burns fast for its hearth. It costs less fuel a ton of iron than coke does, in spite of holding only about 69% fixed carbon (Johnson, Principles p. 183). Its faults are that it comes from forests, and that it is weak: it "could only be used in the old-time forges and low furnaces with feeble blast" (Fulton p. 328). Charcoal furnaces were always small, and Johnson doubts it could have stood the conditions of a large one (Johnson, Principles p. 183).

Anthracite was the principal American blast furnace fuel until about 1860 (Johnson, Principles p. 184), and it is simple: hard enough not to fall into slack, and low in hydrogen. Overman in 1851 called good anthracite "undoubtedly the most perfect of all fuels for the manufacture of iron" (Overman p. 99). Johnson in 1918 lists what went wrong (Johnson, Principles pp. 184-185). With no cells it shows little surface and burns slowly, so the furnace's output is small; it spalls in the heat and chokes the gas passages; its density leaves the charge heavy. It also needed less than 5% of ash to be of any use in a blast furnace (Overman p. 99).

Raw coal is what remains cheap and plentiful, and the blast furnace is the one place it fails: it is not porous, it burns slowly, and its tar blocks the gas (Johnson, Principles pp. 185-186). Dry coals with little tar were used raw (Johnson, Principles p. 185), and the rest went where the fuel never touches the metal. That is the point of the reverberatory furnace.

A Pittsburgh coke oven in section (Overman p. 124, Fig. 36): a low brick dome built into a hillside so that carts can tip coal in through the top, its charge of coal lying on the floor. The doorway a, two feet wide, is walled up with brick and clay, and the hooks b, b hold an iron bar that braces the temporary brick. Openings left in that brickwork regulate the fire until "the fire has penetrated through the mass of coal" (Overman p. 124).
A Pittsburgh coke oven in section (Overman p. 124, Fig. 36): a low brick dome built into a hillside so that carts can tip coal in through the top, its charge of coal lying on the floor. The doorway a, two feet wide, is walled up with brick and clay, and the hooks b, b hold an iron bar that braces the temporary brick. Openings left in that brickwork regulate the fire until "the fire has penetrated through the mass of coal" (Overman p. 124).
Beehive oven remains in Britain: the arched door of one oven in the bank and, on the hill above, the ring that held its charging hole. Banks of these ovens stood along rising ground, the earth behind them storing heat (Fulton pp. 150, 373-375).
Beehive oven remains in Britain: the arched door of one oven in the bank and, on the hill above, the ring that held its charging hole. Banks of these ovens stood along rising ground, the earth behind them storing heat (Fulton pp. 150, 373-375).

Coke gave the furnace what none of the others did: strength with cells. Coal is baked until the gas has gone and a hard sponge of carbon is left. A furnace coke wants hardness of body, full cell structure, purity, uniform quality and coherence in handling (Fulton p. 330), and good coke was not crushed by the charge above it (Johnson, Principles p. 170). Fulton names anthracite and coke together as the fuels that bear the highest furnace (Fulton p. 328); with anthracite held back by its slow burning, coke won the tall furnaces.

Fulton's 48-hour charge in a Connellsville beehive oven, drawn as it stands (Fulton p. 159, Fig. 10). The coal, 23 inches deep, is coked from the top down: 3 1/2 inches after 2 hours, 12 3/4 after 21, the floor at about 33 hours. Air comes in over the bricked-up door and burns the gas above the charge, and the heat that bakes the coal is that burning gas. The coal swells to 31 1/2 inches, and shrinks to 21 when watered.
Fulton's 48-hour charge in a Connellsville beehive oven, drawn as it stands (Fulton p. 159, Fig. 10). The coal, 23 inches deep, is coked from the top down: 3 1/2 inches after 2 hours, 12 3/4 after 21, the floor at about 33 hours. Air comes in over the bricked-up door and burns the gas above the charge, and the heat that bakes the coal is that burning gas. The coal swells to 31 1/2 inches, and shrinks to 21 when watered.

A beehive oven gives up some of the coal to heat the rest. Its yield is 63 to 66% (Fulton p. 348), against about 79% in a closed crucible (Fulton p. 163). The oven is covered more fully on the beehive coke oven.

What a fuel bed does to a fire

Fuel in a furnace is not a heap of energy. It is a porous layer through which air has to find its way, and everything a fireman did was aimed at keeping that layer even.

Proper firing (Hawkins p. 26, Fig. 1). Air rises under the bars and through the fuel, shown by the arrows. An even depth gives "a uniform generation of gas throughout the charge, and a uniform temperature in the flues" (Hawkins p. 26). Half the coal heaped at the door and the bridge end left bare wastes air and fuel (Hawkins p. 27).
Proper firing (Hawkins p. 26, Fig. 1). Air rises under the bars and through the fuel, shown by the arrows. An even depth gives "a uniform generation of gas throughout the charge, and a uniform temperature in the flues" (Hawkins p. 26). Half the coal heaped at the door and the bridge end left bare wastes air and fuel (Hawkins p. 27).

A boiler fire was kept 3 to 5 inches deep (Hawkins p. 27). Coke asks for more than coal does. A pound of coal takes 9 to 10 lb of air and a pound of coke 12 to 13, so the draught must be stronger, and the bed is burned more slowly: 9 1/2 lb of coke an hour to a square foot of grate, where 14 1/2 lb of coal could be burned (Hawkins pp. 28-29). Having little hydrogen, coke has no quick flame and the fire is more even (Hawkins p. 29). Its advantage over raw coal is that otherwise useless slack can be mixed into it when it is made (Hawkins p. 29).

A shaft furnace is the same idea stood on end. The fuel and ore go in separate layers, a coke layer about 2 feet thick in a furnace of 22 by 90 feet (Johnson, Principles p. 287), and the blast passes only through the gaps between the lumps, about a quarter of the hearth area (Johnson, Principles p. 118). A fuel that crumbles or swells closes those gaps, which is why a shaft furnace asks for strength and cells before it asks for heat.

The game keeps the two beds apart: a shaft holds its fuel in courses under the charge, and a reverberatory or boiler holds it on bars. Each firebox shows its fuel in up to six courses, and that is how much is left.

Period basis, and what is the game's own

  • Period: charcoal in small furnaces and hearths, anthracite and then coke in the tall ones, raw coal where a furnace could use it and otherwise where the flame alone reaches the metal (Johnson, Principles pp. 183-186, Fulton p. 328). The game follows the charcoal and coke of this, and the reverberatory furnaces and boilers burn raw coal and anthracite on a bed.
  • The game's own: a shaft furnace takes only coke and charcoal and refuses anthracite and raw coal at its door, though anthracite ran American blast furnaces until about 1860 and dry coal was used raw (Johnson, Principles pp. 184-185).
  • Period: charcoal could not bear a tall column (Johnson, Principles p. 183). Today the cold blast furnace refuses it for that reason. Planned, it takes charcoal and runs cooler and shorter on it, because a course of charcoal carries much less carbon than a course of coke of the same height.
  • The game's own: any item that burns at 1000 C or more may lie on a bed, whatever it is. There is no rule about what kind of thing it is, so a fuel from another mod is taken as it comes. The floor is not a period figure.
  • The game's own: lignite lies on a bed and a boiler burns it, more slowly, but a puddling or reheating furnace refuses it for want of heat. Overman disagrees (see the last section).
  • The game's own: each bed holds one kind of fuel, and the heat a bed gives does not depend on its depth or evenness. A real fire had to be spread and raked; the game's is laid in whole courses.
  • The game's own: ash is not modelled, sulphur does not enter the iron, and no fuel spalls or chokes a furnace.
  • The game's own: coke comes from an oven and charcoal from the base game's pit. See vanilla against reality.

The numbers

Fuel is priced by the scaling page and measured on scale and units. "Planned" is the rating in design; values without that word are what the game has now.

In the gamePeriod figureHow it was scaledGame value
Burn figures: temperature, seconds an itemNone; the books give heat by analysisThe base game's own numbers, keptCoke 1340 C, 40 s; charcoal 1300 C, 40 s; anthracite 1200 C, 196 s; bituminous 1200 C, 84 s; lignite 1100 C, 77 s
Lowest fuel a bed takesNoneThe game's own1000 C, which shuts out contaminated coal at 900 C
Carbon of an item, against coke69% fixed carbon in charcoal (Johnson, Principles p. 183); 88% for coke is the design's own estimateItem mass x fixed carbonCharcoal is 0.5 of coke; planned 0.28
Mass of an itemHardwood charcoal 15 to 16 lb a bushel of 2675 cu in (Overman p. 117)160 kg/m3 from that bushel, coke at 450 kg/m3 the design's own estimate, an item 1/16 of a cubic metrePlanned charcoal 10 kg, coke 28.1 kg
Fuel a unit of ironCharcoal 180 bushels a ton of pig (Overman p. 151); coke 45.3 cwt a ton (Truran p. 120)Share of the bloomery's fuel, by the scaling pagePlanned charcoal 0.00600 items a unit, coke 0.00388
Coke from coal63 to 66% (Fulton p. 348)The base game's rate, kept75%
Baking a charge48 or 72 hours (Fulton p. 158)The base game's time, kept12 game hours
Charcoal from wood40 bushels a cord (Overman p. 117)The base game's pit, unchangedAs the base game
Bed of a furnace firebox3 to 5 inches on a boiler grate (Hawkins p. 27)The game's own, six courses of 2 units a cell12 units a cell
Burning downCoal 14 1/2 lb, coke 9 1/2 lb an hour a sq ft of grate (Hawkins p. 29)The game's ownPlanned 1.2 units a game hour, a full bed lasting 10 game hours
Boiler on poor coalNone usedThe game's ownLignite burns at a 9% lower rate

Open, and what you can tell us

Overman writes that some lignites are "a good fuel in the puddling furnace, as well as in re-heating and sheet ovens" (Overman p. 100), and the game's reverberatory furnaces refuse it. The books at hand do not say how widely lignite was puddled with, or which works did it. The two books on anthracite also disagree across nearly seventy years, as the section above shows, and neither gives a comparison on the same furnace. If you know a record of a puddling furnace on lignite, or of a furnace that ran on anthracite and coke in turn, we would like to read it.

Picture credits