Rolling mill

A rolling mill squeezes hot iron between two turning cast-iron rolls, so that it comes out thinner and longer. How to run the game's mill is in the rolling guide, and its parts are in the catalogue. This page is about the real one, and about what the game keeps of it.

The Iron-Rolling Mill, painted by Adolph Menzel and signed Berlin 1875. The white-hot piece lies on its wheeled carriage at the stand in the middle, with crews on tongs at both sides of the rolls. Overhead run the shafts and pulleys, and behind them the great flywheel. Taking the piece between mills on a carriage is one of the devices Bauerman lists (Bauerman p. 301).
The Iron-Rolling Mill, painted by Adolph Menzel and signed Berlin 1875. The white-hot piece lies on its wheeled carriage at the stand in the middle, with crews on tongs at both sides of the rolls. Overhead run the shafts and pulleys, and behind them the great flywheel. Taking the piece between mills on a carriage is one of the devices Bauerman lists (Bauerman p. 301).
A generalised stand, Bauerman's Fig. 32 (p. 300), labelled here. He drew flat and angular grooves on one pair of rolls to save a second figure; no real pair had both (p. 300). Two cast-iron housings carry the roll necks in brass bearings. The screws set the gap, and spur pinions make the top roll turn with the bottom one. The coupling at the right is built to fail first: a fluted loose spindle, held by collars and wooden stops, breaks before a roll can (pp. 302-303).
A generalised stand, Bauerman's Fig. 32 (p. 300), labelled here. He drew flat and angular grooves on one pair of rolls to save a second figure; no real pair had both (p. 300). Two cast-iron housings carry the roll necks in brass bearings. The screws set the gap, and spur pinions make the top roll turn with the bottom one. The coupling at the right is built to fail first: a fluted loose spindle, held by collars and wooden stops, breaks before a roll can (pp. 302-303).
The game's mill in its planned drawing: one two-high stand between its housings, with the rolls geared together at the drive end and a screw over each housing. The screw acts on the wide set only., iso
The game's mill in its planned drawing: one two-high stand between its housings, with the rolls geared together at the drive end and a screw over each housing. The screw acts on the wide set only.

How the real one worked, and why it was built so

Before the rolling mill, wrought iron was drawn out under a hammer, one blow at a time. Henry Cort took out his patent for grooved rolls in 1783 and paired them with puddling in 1784 (Percy pp. 627-629). A pair of rolls does continuously what a hammer does in strokes. By Bauerman's time rolls were generally used for finished iron "in preference to the hammer", which kept to the old open forges (Bauerman p. 299).

The two rolls are cast iron, with their axes one above the other, geared to turn at one speed (Bauerman p. 299). Plate rolls are smooth. Bar rolls are grooved, each roll carrying half the section, so that the pair forms "an aperture or rotating die" (Bauerman p. 299). The piece gets smaller by closing the rolls, by moving to a smaller groove, or by both (Bauerman pp. 299-300).

The train at Cyfarthfa ironworks, Truran's Plate 53, Fig. 303, in elevation. Power comes in at the crab on the right, through the pinions and long spindles, to the flat-grooved stand. The angular-grooved roughing stand lies beyond it, and the crank of the squeezer is coupled to its far end, as Truran says was usual (p. 220). A row like this, coupled and driven by one motor, is a mill or train (Bauerman p. 301); Overman calls any row of rollers a train (p. 345).
The train at Cyfarthfa ironworks, Truran's Plate 53, Fig. 303, in elevation. Power comes in at the crab on the right, through the pinions and long spindles, to the flat-grooved stand. The angular-grooved roughing stand lies beyond it, and the crank of the squeezer is coupled to its far end, as Truran says was usual (p. 220). A row like this, coupled and driven by one motor, is a mill or train (Bauerman p. 301); Overman calls any row of rollers a train (p. 345).

The rolls ran one way only. After a pass the bar had to be lifted back over the top roll to the entry side, which wasted time and iron, because the piece lost metal to scale all the while it lay out in the air (Bauerman p. 301). Three-high stands and reversing mills were the later answers (Bauerman pp. 301-302).

A stand was built to survive its own accidents. Each screw of wrought iron, four and a half inches thick, turned in a brass box in the top of the housing, and it pressed down on a cast "safety-cap" that was "calculated to break before any other part of the machinery" (Overman p. 350). Aprons of cast iron filled the space between the housings and carried the iron to the roll, and wrought-iron scrapers lay in the grooves to stop the bar from wrapping round a roll (Overman pp. 350-351).

Why a roll will only take so much

Why a groove had to be large enough to catch, drawn for this page. The roll has to drag the piece in by friction alone at the first point of touch; the deeper the cut, the steeper the angle it has to pull against. The right side shows the game's limits to one scale. A round of 0.25 voxel bites a hot piece, a whole gap of 0.5 does not, and cold iron bites almost nothing. The formula is plain mechanics; the friction values are the game's own, as no book read for this page gives one.
Why a groove had to be large enough to catch, drawn for this page. The roll has to drag the piece in by friction alone at the first point of touch; the deeper the cut, the steeper the angle it has to pull against. The right side shows the game's limits to one scale. A round of 0.25 voxel bites a hot piece, a whole gap of 0.5 does not, and cold iron bites almost nothing. The formula is plain mechanics; the friction values are the game's own, as no book read for this page gives one.

The period books feel for this limit without stating it. Overman's first groove had to be "sufficiently large to catch" (Overman p. 347), and in parts of Europe the first grooves had projecting ribs "for catching" (Overman p. 344). Roughing rolls were often roughened to get a better hold on the bloom (Bauerman p. 301). A flat groove sequence had one more groove than the shapes needed, which "would not be actually needed, were it not for the catching of the bar" (Overman p. 348).

Flat rollers for bars four inches wide, Overman's Fig. 106 (p. 348): fourteen inches across, with the finishing groove at a. The bars walked from the high narrow groove to the low wide one, and the iron widened as it thinned (p. 348). In the roughing rollers before them, each groove took about half the section, so the bar nearly doubled its length every pass: seven grooves from six inches to one inch square (p. 347).
Flat rollers for bars four inches wide, Overman's Fig. 106 (p. 348): fourteen inches across, with the finishing groove at a. The bars walked from the high narrow groove to the low wide one, and the iron widened as it thinned (p. 348). In the roughing rollers before them, each groove took about half the section, so the bar nearly doubled its length every pass: seven grooves from six inches to one inch square (p. 347).

Heat was the working margin. The rollers wanted the iron fast and hot, and if it cooled in the rough rolls the piece was in trouble: "the loss at the roughing rollers, caused by the iron getting too cold, is, of all others, the most disagreeable, because the iron is generally too long to be re-heated, and too thick to be cut" (Overman p. 360). Plate was the hardest case. Plate rolls wanted "the momentum of a large fly-wheel", and even then "the plates cool and stick fast in the middle" (Fairbairn Mills II p. 259).

The screw, the plate stand and the shear

On a bar groove the screw is hardly touched. For rails it is set to bring the product to its proper weight and then left alone, because the section gets smaller by moving along the grooves (Bauerman p. 304). Plate has no grooves, so there the gap is the whole job. The foreman "regulates the thickness of the sheet by these screws", and the wrenches on them form a cross so that a handle always faces the men (Overman p. 367). The heads were graduated so that both ends of the roll came down alike (Bauerman p. 304).

Plate mills usually had three pairs of rolls: a grooved pair to bloom the pile, a roughing pair, and a chilled, polished finishing pair, 5 to 6 ft long and 20 to 24 in across (Bauerman p. 309). Boiler-plate rollers of four and five feet were in use (Overman p. 366). This is where the game's wide hall comes from.

The common force-shear, Overman's Fig. 127 (p. 379): a cast-iron lever seven to twelve feet long, its steel blades bolted in near the fulcrum, driven from below by the eccentric on the main shaft at the right. It needs a foundation "not inferior in solidity to the roller trains".
The common force-shear, Overman's Fig. 127 (p. 379): a cast-iron lever seven to twelve feet long, its steel blades bolted in near the fulcrum, driven from below by the eccentric on the main shaft at the right. It needs a foundation "not inferior in solidity to the roller trains".
Steam-driven shears, preserved at the G R Morton ironworks at Blists Hill, Ironbridge: a small engine and flywheel on the left, and the heavy wheels and shaft that work the blades on the right. Shears cut bars to lengths for piling and trimmed the ends and edges of finished plates and bars (Bauerman p. 309).
Steam-driven shears, preserved at the G R Morton ironworks at Blists Hill, Ironbridge: a small engine and flywheel on the left, and the heavy wheels and shaft that work the blades on the right. Shears cut bars to lengths for piling and trimmed the ends and edges of finished plates and bars (Bauerman p. 309).

Smaller work had hand shears as well: two-foot lever shears on a plank at the end of each pile, where the boys cut the bad ends off small rod and hoop (Overman p. 378).

Period basis, and what is the game's own

  • Period: rolling is a hot job. A cooled piece stalls, and iron must go back to the fire (Overman pp. 360, 373). The game follows this strictly: below rolling heat a piece will not bite and it loads the stand ten times harder, so the reheat furnace sits by the mill.
  • Period: bar passes go through grooves of falling size, and plate is set by the screw (Bauerman p. 304, Overman p. 367). The game keeps both. The flat and grooved roll sets have fixed gaps and the piece walks along them; only the wide set has a screw.
  • Period: a piece turned a quarter at each roughing groove to keep its edges sound (Overman p. 346). The game keeps the turn as a rule: a gap takes two rounds, the half-step and then the gap itself.
  • Period: a mill gave off roll scale, and roll scale went into the puddling charge (Overman p. 298). Planned: each pass sheds mill scale, which goes back to the fettling of the puddling furnace.
  • Period: plate mills had a line of stands (Bauerman p. 309). Planned: the wide hall is four ordinary mills on one drive shaft, each screwed to its own gap, and the steel line adds two more at its front. Setting one mill over and over stays allowed, and costs handling instead of iron.
  • The game's own: friction decides the order of the rolling. A jump deeper than the bite limit skids, and nothing else enforces the schedule. The real rule, that the roller knew his grooves, is not modelled.
  • The game's own: every gap is 0.5 voxel below the last, where real grooves took a share of the section (Overman p. 347).
  • The game's own: a piece is a section and a length. Camber, guides, side guards, roll wear and roll changes are left out.
  • The game's own: the rolls turn one way, and the player walks the piece round the stand. No three-high stands or reversing mill.
  • The game's own: no hand shears. Every crop goes through the one shearing machine, and a crop keeps the heat of its piece. A hot cut is easy, and a cold one needs the drive to have the torque for it.
  • The game's own: steel roll sets differ from iron ones by the torque they need, not by what they are made of. Planned: the steel line's torque gate is not read yet. See cast and wrought iron for what the iron itself does.
  • Today: no roll set can be crafted, so the mill runs in creative mode only.

The numbers

Rolls are drawn at true size (scale and units). Friction, load and the ladder of gaps are the game's own. "Planned" is the design value; values without that word are what the game has now.

In the gamePeriod figureHow it was scaledGame value
Roll diameterMerchant rolls 18 in (Fairbairn Mills II p. 259); 12 to 16 in (Bauerman p. 309)Whole voxels at true size8 voxels, 19.7 in
Barrel lengthMerchant 2.5 to 3 ft (Fairbairn Mills II p. 259)Whole voxels at true size16 voxels, 3.3 ft
Wide barrelPlate rolls over 6 ft (Fairbairn Mills II p. 259); 5 to 6 ft (Bauerman p. 309)Limited by the block size; the game's own16 voxels, 15 usable; planned 24
Roll speedRough 30 to 40 rpm (Overman p. 349), merchant 60 to 75 (Bauerman p. 309), heavy plate 25 to 30 (Bauerman p. 309)Not scaled; the speed is whatever the drive givesSet by the drive
Reduction per passSection x about 0.54, 11 squared to 15 squared (Overman p. 347)Replaced by a fixed ladder; the game's own0.5 voxel a gap, 0.25 a round
Bite limit, hotNone givenThe game's own: friction 0.3, radius 4, friction squared x radius0.36 voxel draft
Bite limit, coldNone givenThe game's own: friction 0.0550.0121 voxel draft, about 30 times less
Rolling heatNone givenThe game's own900 C; ten times the load fully cold, reached 400 C below that
Stand loadNone givenThe game's own340 Nm hot, 3.4 kNm cold
Wide screwThe foreman's own setting (Overman p. 367)The game's own steps2.5 to 1.0 in steps of 0.5; planned 2.0 to 0.16, with rungs at 0.75, 0.5, 0.25
Plate standsUsually three pairs (Bauerman p. 309)The game's own countPlanned 4, the steel line 6
One mill or a hallNone givenThe game's ownPlanned 12 feeds for 2 plates on narrow rolls, 28 feeds and 5 stamps for 15 on wide ones
Shear lever7 to 12 ft (Overman pp. 378-379)True sizePlanned 2.9 m

Open, and what you can tell us

None of the books read here gives a working limit for how much a roll could take at one pass, or a figure for hot friction. They give ratios of grooves, and they say only that a groove must be large enough to catch. If you know a period table of draft against roll diameter for wrought iron, we would like to read it. We also found no freely licensed photograph of a surviving two-high wrought-iron stand with its rolls in place.

Picture credits