Machine-tool sizes

A machine tool was sold by a size in its name: a 48-inch lathe, a 36 by 36 planer, a 24-inch shaper. The game's five take their measures from those names, out of catalogues of the 1890s, and they are drawn at true size. The tools are in the catalogue from the lathe to the planer, and how a casting moves through them is on the machine shop. This page is about where the numbers come from. Nearly everything here is planned: the machines stand in the game at their first drawn sizes, and the catalogue sizes come in with their redraws.

The five tools against what the catalogues sold (Sellers 1895 pp. 23, 75, 128, 175-177 and 188; Niles pp. 74, 113, 153-155 and 179-181). Each name means something different: a lathe's is the diameter that clears the bed, a planer's the width and height it will take, a shaper's its stroke, a drill's the width of work whose centre it can reach. Most of the game's choices sit in the middle of the range. The shaper is at the top of it: the Niles machine was offered as the heaviest built in the country (Niles p. 113).
The five tools against what the catalogues sold (Sellers 1895 pp. 23, 75, 128, 175-177 and 188; Niles pp. 74, 113, 153-155 and 179-181). Each name means something different: a lathe's is the diameter that clears the bed, a planer's the width and height it will take, a shaper's its stroke, a drill's the width of work whose centre it can reach. Most of the game's choices sit in the middle of the range. The shaper is at the top of it: the Niles machine was offered as the heaviest built in the country (Niles p. 113).
The game's planer in its planned drawing: the rail raised on its housings to clear work 36 in high, as on the Sellers 36 in machine, and the table long enough to carry a 10 ft casting., iso
The game's planer in its planned drawing: the rail raised on its housings to clear work 36 in high, as on the Sellers 36 in machine, and the table long enough to carry a 10 ft casting.

What a size meant

The Sellers 48-inch lathe (Sellers 1895 p. 113). The figure in its name is the diameter that clears the bed, 48 in; the slide rest stands up off the bed and leaves about 38 in over it. This is the machine the game's lathe is measured from: centres 24 in above the bed, half the swing as Rose says they must be (Rose p. 120), and 8 ft 10 in between them.
The Sellers 48-inch lathe (Sellers 1895 p. 113). The figure in its name is the diameter that clears the bed, 48 in; the slide rest stands up off the bed and leaves about 38 in over it. This is the machine the game's lathe is measured from: centres 24 in above the bed, half the swing as Rose says they must be (Rose p. 120), and 8 ft 10 in between them.

Rose gives the rule for naming a lathe: by the swing and the total length of the bed, or by the height of the centres and the length of the shears. "The height of the centres is obviously equal to half the swing of the lathe" (Rose p. 120), so a 28-inch swing and 14-inch centres are the same lathe. A longer bed did not make a bigger lathe in this sense: the swing was what it could hold, the length only how much.

The Sellers table of lathe sizes (Sellers 1895 p. 128). The first column is the name, the second what will swing over the rest. The last two are the length between centres and the shortest bed: a 48 in lathe turns 8 ft 10 in on a bed of 17 ft 0 3/4 in, because the heads themselves stand on the bed. Longer beds went up by the distance between the girts, set by the core boxes of the casting, and not by whole feet.
The Sellers table of lathe sizes (Sellers 1895 p. 128). The first column is the name, the second what will swing over the rest. The last two are the length between centres and the shortest bed: a 48 in lathe turns 8 ft 10 in on a bed of 17 ft 0 3/4 in, because the heads themselves stand on the bed. Longer beds went up by the distance between the girts, set by the core boxes of the casting, and not by whole feet.

The game's lathe is drawn on the 48-inch row: 19.5 voxels of swing and a bed of about 80 voxels, five cast bed sections, against the 83 voxels the catalogue length would make. Rose's worked examples are lathes of 12 to 28 in (Rose pp. 133, 140), and he shows 44 and 90 in as well (Rose pp. 143, 150). No book at hand gives the height of the centres above the floor, and the game's 1.1 m is its own.

A Niles cylinder borer, No. 2 (Niles, facing p. 153), built for a cylinder 28 in across and 39 in long, on a bar 9 in thick. The bar turns between its two heads and the work is bolted down in the middle. Niles sold these up to 60 in; the Sellers locomotive machine bored 10 to 22 in on a 6 in bar (Sellers 1895 p. 75). The game's bores run from 10 to 44 in, up to 60 in long, to take every cylinder the engines ask for.
A Niles cylinder borer, No. 2 (Niles, facing p. 153), built for a cylinder 28 in across and 39 in long, on a bar 9 in thick. The bar turns between its two heads and the work is bolted down in the middle. Niles sold these up to 60 in; the Sellers locomotive machine bored 10 to 22 in on a 6 in bar (Sellers 1895 p. 75). The game's bores run from 10 to 44 in, up to 60 in long, to take every cylinder the engines ask for.

The cylinder borer is the one tool whose size comes from the job instead of a catalogue row. Niles's Nos. 3 to 5 reach 36, 60 and 42 in (Niles pp. 154-155), which is the bracket the game's machine is drawn in, and the top bore of 44 in is the Watt blower's own. The bars vary too much to read a rule from: 6 in for 10 to 22 in bores (Sellers 1895 p. 75), 8 in for 16 to 22 and 9 in for 28 (Niles p. 153), 7 in up to 18 and 12 above (Niles p. 155).

The Sellers 25 by 25 planer (Sellers 1895 Plate 109, p. 187). The numbers are the width and height it will take. Under the plate is the figure the game's planer rating uses: "Usual speed of cut, 18 feet per minute; return speed of table, 72 feet per minute."
The Sellers 25 by 25 planer (Sellers 1895 Plate 109, p. 187). The numbers are the width and height it will take. Under the plate is the figure the game's planer rating uses: "Usual speed of cut, 18 feet per minute; return speed of table, 72 feet per minute."
The Niles 24-inch shaper (Niles, facing p. 113), its name the stroke of its ram. The head travels 70 in along an 8 ft 4 in bed, and the two tables on its front face hold the work. The tables rise 21 in, the 8.5 voxels of the game's table.
The Niles 24-inch shaper (Niles, facing p. 113), its name the stroke of its ram. The head travels 70 in along an 8 ft 4 in bed, and the two tables on its front face hold the work. The tables rise 21 in, the 8.5 voxels of the game's table.
The Sellers 36-inch vertical drill with its two tables (Sellers 1895 Plates 10 and 11, p. 23). Thirty-six inches is the width of work it can drill at the centre, so the spindle stands 18 in from the column. Square table 26 in by 18 in, or a round one 26 in across on a swinging bracket; stroke 12 in; lower bearing 5 ft above the floor. All of these are the game's planned numbers.
The Sellers 36-inch vertical drill with its two tables (Sellers 1895 Plates 10 and 11, p. 23). Thirty-six inches is the width of work it can drill at the centre, so the spindle stands 18 in from the column. Square table 26 in by 18 in, or a round one 26 in across on a swinging bracket; stroke 12 in; lower bearing 5 ft above the floor. All of these are the game's planned numbers.

Why a stroke or a table is that long and no longer

A shaper's tool slide leaves its guides on the stroke, so its use was "limited to work that does not require a greater tool stroke than about 18 inches", and 12 in on a small machine (Rose p. 397). Rose names one of 20 in (Rose p. 397), the Sellers machines stop at 16 (Sellers 1895 p. 177), and the Niles 24 in is the longest in the books at hand (Niles p. 113). The game's shaper takes that 24 in stroke, 10 voxels, so a face fits when one side is at most 10 under the stroke and the other at most 10 on the table.

A planer has the opposite problem, and a table long enough to carry the work sets everything else. Sellers lists the 36 in with a 5 ft shortest table (Sellers 1895 p. 188), and Niles sells the nearest size, 38 by 38, from 8 to 16 ft (Niles p. 91). The game takes a 10 ft table, 48.7 voxels, with a 41-voxel stroke, 8.4 ft, and raises the rail to clear 36 in of work. Parts longer than that stay at the bench. No book at hand plans one face in two settings, shifting the work along the table partway through.

Why they cut at the speed they do

Cutting speeds in the books, in feet of metal past the tool a minute (Rose pp. 278, 294 and 411; Sellers 1895 p. 187). Harder work runs slower, and a tool that turns while the work stands still runs slowest of all, "rarely exceeding 18 feet per minute" (Rose p. 294). The planer's quick return is four times its cut, and it cuts nothing on the way back. Orange marks the three speeds the game's ratings were worked out from.
Cutting speeds in the books, in feet of metal past the tool a minute (Rose pp. 278, 294 and 411; Sellers 1895 p. 187). Harder work runs slower, and a tool that turns while the work stands still runs slowest of all, "rarely exceeding 18 feet per minute" (Rose p. 294). The planer's quick return is four times its cut, and it cuts nothing on the way back. Orange marks the three speeds the game's ratings were worked out from.

Period machines took their speed from a countershaft and made it what they needed with cones and gears: the 36 in drill's ran at 110 revolutions a minute (Sellers 1895 p. 23), a Niles cylinder borer's at 125 (Niles p. 153), the 24 in shaper's at 200 (Niles p. 113). A big Sellers lathe had fifteen speeds (Rose p. 143).

The game has no speed changes. Each machine has a power, and a job takes as long as its energy lasts at that power. The powers are worked back from the period rates. A lathe cutting cast iron at 45 ft a minute (Rose p. 294), 30 feed turns to the inch (Rose p. 294) and an 1/8 in cut removes 4.4 g of iron a second. Hartig's 185,800 J/kg (Rose p. 273, see work rates) makes that 822 W. The Sellers planer's 18 ft a minute gives 980 W while cutting, and with 72 ft back it spends 0.8 of its time cutting, 780 W. The shaper's return is 40% quicker than the cut (Rose p. 398), so 0.583 of its time, 570 W. The planer's feed and depth of cut and the lathe's depth are the game's own, as the books give no matching figure.

A slower shaft stretches a cut, and one that cannot carry the torque stalls it. The boring machine's 1620 W comes from Sellers's three and a half hours on a 22 in by 36 in cylinder (Sellers 1895 p. 74), on a skin of 3/8 in the game assumes. A running machine counts 30 period seconds in each second on the clock (how we scale).

Period basis, and what is the game's own

  • Period: a machine named by the size of work it takes, in sizes running from 12 to 72 in for a lathe and 20 to 120 in for a planer (Sellers 1895 pp. 128, 188). The game takes one size of each.
  • Period: the planned sizes are from the Niles catalogue of 1891 and the Sellers catalogue of 1895. Sellers's lathe table is from the same family as the 1877 treatise. No earlier British tool tables were found.
  • Period: lathe centres at half the swing (Rose p. 120), a shaper's stroke limited by its slide (Rose p. 397). The game keeps both.
  • Period: cones and back gears gave each tool many speeds (Rose p. 143). The game's own: one rated shaft speed and one power for each tool. All five are rated at 5 rad/s today, about 48 revolutions a minute, a value the game sets; the drill is planned at 10.7 rad/s, 102 revolutions, the speed of a 3/4 in drill at Rose's 20 ft a minute (Rose p. 278).
  • The game's own: the height of the lathe's centres above the floor, the planer's feed and depth, the lathe's depth of cut, and the boring machine's bar of 4 voxels with its small bar of 3 for the 10 in bores.
  • The game's own: the base game has no metal-cutting machine tools, so nothing here replaces a vanilla number. See vanilla against reality.

The numbers

The machines are drawn at 16 voxels to the metre, 1 in being 0.406 voxels (scale and units), and powers take the period rates without a fuel factor (how we scale). "Planned" is the value in design; today's drawn size follows where the design gives one.

In the gamePeriod figureHow it was scaledGame value
Lathe swing48 in over the bed (Sellers 1895 p. 128; Niles p. 74)True sizePlanned 19.5 voxels, 1.22 m
Lathe centres over the bedHalf the swing, 24 in (Rose p. 120)True sizePlanned about 10 voxels
Lathe, between centres8 ft 10 in (Sellers 1895 p. 128)True sizePlanned 43 voxels, 2.69 m
Lathe bed17 ft 0 3/4 in, the shortest (Sellers 1895 p. 128)Five whole cast sectionsPlanned about 80 voxels, 5 m
Lathe spindle6 1/4 in on the 48 in (Niles p. 74)True sizePlanned 2.5 voxels; 4 today
Lathe centres above the floorNone givenThe game's ownPlanned about 1.1 m; 1.6 m today
Cylinder bores10 to 22 in (Sellers 1895 p. 75); to 36, 42 and 60 in (Niles pp. 154-155)To the game's cylinders10 to 44 in, planned
Longest cylinder60 in, Niles No. 3 (Niles p. 154)True size, near enoughPlanned 24 voxels, 1.5 m
Boring bar6 in to 12 in by bore (Sellers 1895 p. 75; Niles pp. 153, 155)The game's own4 voxels, 3 for the 10 in bores
Planer, under the rail36 in class (Sellers 1895 p. 188)True sizePlanned 14.6 voxels; 5.7 today
Planer table5 ft shortest (Sellers 1895 p. 188); 8 to 16 ft, 38 in class (Niles p. 91)A 10 ft tablePlanned 48.7 by 14.9 voxels; 41.1 by 14.9 today
Planer strokeNone statedFits the tablePlanned 41 voxels; 34.4 today
Planer, between housings36 in class (Sellers 1895 p. 188)The drawing's16 voxels
Shaper stroke24 in (Niles p. 113); 9 to 16 in (Sellers 1895 pp. 175-177)True sizePlanned 10 voxels
Shaper table rise21 in (Niles p. 113)True sizePlanned about 8.5 voxels
Shaper tableNone for this machineThe drawing'sPlanned 10 by 10 by 10 voxels
Drill reach, spindle to column18 in, the 36 in machine (Sellers 1895 p. 23)True sizePlanned 7.3 voxels; 5 today
Drill table26 in by 18 in (Sellers 1895 p. 23)True sizePlanned 10.6 by 7.3 voxels; 8 across today
Drill spindle stroke12 in (Sellers 1895 p. 23)True sizePlanned 4.9 voxels
Spindle bearing above the floor5 ft (Sellers 1895 p. 23)True sizePlanned 24 voxels
Largest drilled hole3 in; bored to 10 in, Niles No. 3 (Niles p. 179)True sizePlanned 1.2 voxels; eyes bored to 4
Lathe powerCast iron at 45 ft/min, 30 turns an inch (Rose p. 294)With a 1/8 in cut, the depth the game's ownPlanned 822 W
Boring powerCylinder 22 in by 36 in in 3 1/2 h (Sellers 1895 p. 74)With a 3/8 in skin, the game's ownPlanned 1620 W
Planer power18 ft/min cut, 72 return (Sellers 1895 p. 187)0.8 of the time cutting; 1/16 in feed and 1/8 in cut the game's ownPlanned 780 W
Shaper powerReturn 40% quicker (Rose p. 398)The planer's cut at 0.583 of the timePlanned 570 W
Drill power1/2 in through 2 3/4 in in 1 min 20 s (Rose p. 278), about 170 WThe same cut scaled to a 3/4 in hole, 28.7 kJ over 80 sPlanned 360 W; the game's own
Shaft speed20 ft/min (Rose p. 278), taken on a 3/4 in drillRevolutions at the drill's edgeDrill planned 10.7 rad/s; all five 5 rad/s today, the game's own

Open, and what you can tell us

Rose's "40 per cent. quicker" return is read here as a speed 1.4 times the cut, and the shaper's 570 W rests on that; read as 40% less time it would be 610 W, and the books do not settle which he meant. The size tables are all American and from the 1890s: no British tool list of the 1840s to 1870s has been found, and nothing here says how large a lathe or planer a provincial works of that time would have bought. A catalogue or a works inventory from those years would be welcome, as would any printed height of a lathe's centres above the floor.

Picture credits

  • The five tools against the catalogues, and cutting speeds: drawn for this page from Sellers 1895, Niles and Rose, at the pages named in their captions.
  • 48 in lathe, the lathe table, the 25 by 25 planer and the 36 in drills: Sellers 1895 pp. 113, 128, 187 and 23, Library page.
  • No. 2 Cylinder Boring Machine and 24-Inch Shaping Machine: Niles pp. 152 and 112, unnumbered plates, catalogue of 1891, Library page.
  • The game's planer: the mod's planned drawing.