Vice bench and drawing table

A casting or a forging comes out rough. Before it could go into a machine, someone had to make its faces flat, its holes true and its sizes right, and for most of the age of iron that someone stood at a bench with a vice, a chisel and a file. Beside him lay a drawing that said what the part had to be. How to draft and assemble in the game is in the diagrams guide. This page is about the real work and how the game's two stations follow it.

A blacksmith's leg vice on its post, in a working forge at Berriew. The long fixed leg runs down to the floor, so a hammer blow on the work goes into the ground and not into the bench. The moving jaw hinges near the foot and closes by the screw and its bar. The game's bench carries this kind of vice on its front corner.
A blacksmith's leg vice on its post, in a working forge at Berriew. The long fixed leg runs down to the floor, so a hammer blow on the work goes into the ground and not into the bench. The moving jaw hinges near the foot and closes by the screw and its bar. The game's bench carries this kind of vice on its front corner.
A fitter's parallel-jaw bench vice of 1912. By this date the vice is a bought tool bolted to the bench top, with a quick-release screw. The jaws close square at any opening, where the leg vice swings through an arc. The game's vice is the leg vice, not this.
A fitter's parallel-jaw bench vice of 1912. By this date the vice is a bought tool bolted to the bench top, with a quick-release screw. The jaws close square at any opening, where the leg vice swings through an arc. The game's vice is the leg vice, not this.
A locomotive fitting shop in 1905. The belts of the machine tools run overhead at the right, and the men along the benches at the left and at the frames in the middle are working parts by hand.
A locomotive fitting shop in 1905. The belts of the machine tools run overhead at the right, and the men along the benches at the left and at the frames in the middle are working parts by hand.
The game's vice bench: a heavy timber bench with the leg vice bolted up its front corner and its leg running to the floor., iso
The game's vice bench: a heavy timber bench with the leg vice bolted up its front corner and its leg running to the floor.
The game's drawing table: a sheet pinned at its corners to a deal board, with the square, charcoal, a stack of paper and two candles., iso
The game's drawing table: a sheet pinned at its corners to a deal board, with the square, charcoal, a stack of paper and two candles.

Why the work began at a vice

The chicken and egg of the machine shop is real. A planing machine makes flat surfaces, but its own bed has to be flat first. Nasmyth, who worked for Henry Maudslay in Lambeth from 1829, says that flat surfaces were sometimes got from the lathe and slide-rest, "but in most cases the object was attained by the dexterous use of the file", and that flat filing "then was, as it still is, one of the highest qualities of the skilled workman" (Nasmyth p. 148). As a boy he had watched the men's "dexterous use of the hammer, the chisel, and the file" (Nasmyth p. 73). Even after the planing machine came into the works, it was meant for the larger parts: "a very considerable proportion of the detail parts still continued to be executed by hand labour, in which the chisel and the file were the chief instruments employed" (Nasmyth p. 415).

The trade had a name to match. Rose names the "vice hand and erector" beside the lathe hand or turner among the men who use a shop's gauges (Rose p. 377).

Holding a tool in the vice, not only the work (Rose p. 457, Figs. 1789 and 1790). The vice grips frame A, which carries a table T for the work W and a seat for the feed screw of a drill crank turned by hand. With no drilling machine, the vice is what stands still while the hand does the rest.
Holding a tool in the vice, not only the work (Rose p. 457, Figs. 1789 and 1790). The vice grips frame A, which carries a table T for the work W and a seat for the feed screw of a drill crank turned by hand. With no drilling machine, the vice is what stands still while the hand does the rest.
Another hand drill, "very old but a very excellent device for hand drilling when no drilling machine is at hand" (Rose p. 457, Fig. 1791). A weight on a lever presses the drill down onto work resting on a bench, and two posts from floor to ceiling take the reaction. A shop made its feed force out of whatever it had.
Another hand drill, "very old but a very excellent device for hand drilling when no drilling machine is at hand" (Rose p. 457, Fig. 1791). A weight on a lever presses the drill down onto work resting on a bench, and two posts from floor to ceiling take the reaction. A shop made its feed force out of whatever it had.

How a surface was proved

Filing by eye is not enough for a slide valve, so the bench carried its own standards. Maudslay had true planes "placed on the benches beside his workmen, by means of which they might at once conveniently test their work" (Nasmyth p. 148). They were made three at a time: rubbing each on each removes the high spots, and with three the errors cannot hide, because two plates can match while both are curved and a third will not match both. Hard steel scrapers took off the last points, until the plates would float on the air between them (Nasmyth p. 149).

A surface plate, Professor Sweet's form (Rose p. 383, Fig. 1485). The back is heavily ribbed, the ribs equal in length and thickness to the plate so that it warms evenly and does not twist. Planing came first, then heating to at least 200 degrees F to relieve the casting, and only then the handwork. Straight-edges were finished the same way (Rose p. 382).
A surface plate, Professor Sweet's form (Rose p. 383, Fig. 1485). The back is heavily ribbed, the ribs equal in length and thickness to the plate so that it warms evenly and does not twist. Planing came first, then heating to at least 200 degrees F to relieve the casting, and only then the handwork. Straight-edges were finished the same way (Rose p. 382).

Measurement went the same way. Maudslay distrusted the verdict of callipers, whose answer depended on the hand that held them, and built an instrument he "always had on his bench beside his vice" (Nasmyth p. 149).

Maudslay's bench micrometer, the "Lord Chancellor" (Nasmyth p. 150), so called because he treated it as a court of final appeal. Two hardened flat faces close on the work by a fine screw, read off an engraved scale and a divided disc. The work lies "between the jaws of a vice, but without any squeeze".
Maudslay's bench micrometer, the "Lord Chancellor" (Nasmyth p. 150), so called because he treated it as a court of final appeal. Two hardened flat faces close on the work by a fine screw, read off an engraved scale and a divided disc. The work lies "between the jaws of a vice, but without any squeeze".

The scraper, in Rose's account, was a lathe finishing tool as well as a bench one, its edge shaped to the work and kept short to stop it chattering (Rose p. 333).

Why a drawing, and what a drawing table was for

A drawing lets a part be made by someone without its designer at his elbow. William Watson, a foreman at the iron foundry where the young Nasmyth spent his Saturday afternoons, drew his designs "on large deal boards", and they "were passed into the hands of the mechanics to be translated by them into actual work" (Nasmyth p. 92). In Mr. Field's office, after Maudslay's death, Nasmyth drew out the working drawings of a 200 horse-power engine from Field's rough sketches, and they "were handed out for execution in the various parts of the factory" (Nasmyth pp. 176-177).

Nasmyth put the value of it bluntly: "Mechanical drawing is the alphabet of the engineer. Without this the workman is merely 'a hand.' With it he indicates the possession of 'a head.'" (Nasmyth p. 125). Field kept his sketches of consultations in dated and indexed "talking books" on a shelf in front of his drawing table (Nasmyth p. 178). A drawing was kept, consulted and used again, which is what the game's diagram does.

The game's order follows the shop's. The drawing table makes a diagram from a drawing medium and parchment. The bench takes the diagram and works the bill of parts to it. The diagram is never used up, as a works' drawing was not.

Why vice work comes before machine tools in the game

The game has the same closed circle as the period, and it is a sharper one. A shaper needs gears, and the machines that cut gears need gears. So nearly every machined part has a route by hand at the vice as well as its machine route: the same blank, seated in the vice, chipped with the chisel, filed, scraped where the part needs it and gauged with calipers. Each blank finishes to one part, so no diagram is needed for it. The hand route is the only way the machine line can start at all, and the machines then do the same parts with far less labour, as Nasmyth's small planing machine of 1836 was built to do (Nasmyth p. 415). See the lathe and the shaper and planer.

Period basis, and what is the game's own

  • Period: chipping, filing and scraping at a vice to prove a part flat and to size, with the surface plate and straight-edge beside it (Nasmyth pp. 148-149, Rose pp. 333, 382-383). The game's vice steps take the chisel, the file, the scraper and the calipers.
  • Period: drawings were made on a board and passed to the men who worked to them (Nasmyth pp. 92, 177). The game's table drafts a diagram that the bench reads.
  • Period: hand drilling at the vice or bench when no drilling machine was at hand (Rose p. 457). Drilling a blank at the vice with a hand drill is planned in the game.
  • The game's own: the base game has no vice and no bench where a bill is worked with tools. See vanilla against reality.
  • The game's own: a bench recipe is worked as a sequence of tools held in turn, with a hand animation for each. Seven recipes have this today; the rest of the bench's recipes are planned to. It stands for the work, and does not measure it: a part is not scraped more or less true.
  • The game's own: a step is done by holding its tool for its time. The calipers pass or fail nothing, and no surface is proved against a plate.
  • The game's own: a draft costs one piece of charcoal or coal and one sheet of parchment, both base-game materials, and any diagram can be drafted from the first table. The books give no price or material list for a shop's drawings.

Open, and what you can tell us

No book held here describes a drawing office from the inside: who drew, on what paper, how a drawing was copied before the blueprint, or how it travelled through the shop. The account above is one engineer's memory of two firms. The books at hand also do not say when the leg vice gave way to the parallel-jaw bench vice in fitting shops, or how a fitter's apprenticeship at the vice was arranged. If you know a source for any of these, we would like to read it.

Picture credits