Nails, rivets and bolts

A nail holds wood, a rivet holds plate tight, and a bolt holds cast iron and comes apart again. Each was headed in its own way and by its own machine. The machines are in the catalogue as the rivet heading machine and the nail machine. This page is about the real practice and what the game keeps of it.

A cut-nail machine of about 1850, patented by Ezra Jenks Coates, used at Christiania Spigerverk in Norway and now in the Norwegian Museum of Science and Technology. Reed's patent of 1798 had already joined cutting and heading in one operation (Swank p. 448), and a machine of this kind fed a strip of plate and gave back finished nails.
A cut-nail machine of about 1850, patented by Ezra Jenks Coates, used at Christiania Spigerverk in Norway and now in the Norwegian Museum of Science and Technology. Reed's patent of 1798 had already joined cutting and heading in one operation (Swank p. 448), and a machine of this kind fed a strip of plate and gave back finished nails.
Hamilton's bolt and rivet header, Fig. 29 (Hamilton p. 24), a rivet in four steps. A: the hot bar is fed through the bushing to the stop. B: the movable gripping die shears off a blank and carries it into the stationary die. C: the heading tool strikes once and forms the head. D: the dies open and the ejector throws out the finished rivet.
Hamilton's bolt and rivet header, Fig. 29 (Hamilton p. 24), a rivet in four steps. A: the hot bar is fed through the bushing to the stop. B: the movable gripping die shears off a blank and carries it into the stationary die. C: the heading tool strikes once and forms the head. D: the dies open and the ejector throws out the finished rivet.
Two bolts in the double-deck dies of Hamilton's Fig. 11 (Hamilton p. 11). A and B are the gripping dies, opened out. The lower punch C is cupped to a hexagon and gives one blow in the lower impression; the upper punch D gives two in the upper, which finishes the head without fins or burrs. Three blows against the single blow of a rivet.
Two bolts in the double-deck dies of Hamilton's Fig. 11 (Hamilton p. 11). A and B are the gripping dies, opened out. The lower punch C is cupped to a hexagon and gives one blow in the lower impression; the upper punch D gives two in the upper, which finishes the head without fins or burrs. Three blows against the single blow of a rivet.
Heading bolts in a railway shop, Fig. 9 (Hamilton p. 9). Bars sheared to length come in the truck at the right to the oil furnace, set as close to the header as possible, and the man who heats them hands each one on to the operator (Hamilton pp. 9-10).
Heading bolts in a railway shop, Fig. 9 (Hamilton p. 9). Bars sheared to length come in the truck at the right to the oil furnace, set as close to the header as possible, and the man who heats them hands each one on to the operator (Hamilton pp. 9-10).
The game's rivet heading machine in its planned drawing. It is the period header: gripping dies, a heading ram, and a crank driven off the line shaft. It makes rivets and heads bolts; it does not close a rivet in a seam., iso
The game's rivet heading machine in its planned drawing. It is the period header: gripping dies, a heading ram, and a crank driven off the line shaft. It makes rivets and heads bolts; it does not close a rivet in a seam.
The game's nail machine in its planned drawing: a big flywheel and a crank working shears in a cast frame, with a tray for the nails. Built to stand in a row of identical machines on one shaft., iso
The game's nail machine in its planned drawing: a big flywheel and a crank working shears in a cast frame, with a tray for the nails. Built to stand in a row of identical machines on one shaft.

Nails: from the hammer to the machine

A wrought nail was made by hand from nail-rod, iron slit into narrow strips at a rolling mill (Swank p. 449). The American cut nail changed that. About 1775 Jeremiah Wilkinson of Rhode Island cut tacks from sheet and headed them in a vise; Ezekiel Reed invented a machine for cutting nails from the plate in 1786 and patented cutting and heading at one operation in 1798; by the close of the century there were twenty-three patents (Swank p. 448).

A blacksmith's header bar from the lower Missouri valley, for nails and bolts. Each hole is a different size. The books at hand describe heading at the spring vice and the machine; this is the smith's plain tool for the same job.
A blacksmith's header bar from the lower Missouri valley, for nails and bolts. Each hole is a different size. The books at hand describe heading at the spring vice and the machine; this is the smith's plain tool for the same job.

The early machines were small things. At Brownsville about 1795, wrought nails were made by hand in one shop and cut nails by machines in another, the machines worked by the foot of the workman while his hands guided the iron (Swank p. 216). A county smith of 1818 cut his nails at a red heat and carried them cold to a spring vice closed by his right foot, one nail at a time: one stroke of the hammer made a brad, two more a clapboard nail (Swank p. 449).

Nail iron was a class of its own. A nail needs neither strength nor the ability to weld, only to be malleable in one direction and cheap (Overman p. 391). Long, small nail plates were best, cut into strips crosswise so that each nail was cut along the fibre (Overman p. 392). The nail machine of the game takes a plate of that kind and cuts it whole.

Rivets: why a boiler is riveted

A rivet goes in hot, is headed in place and shortens as it cools, so it pulls the plates together, and the seam is then caulked. A boiler shell has to be both strong and tight, and a rivet gives both at one setting. Rivets were driven by hand, by steam riveting machines, or by pneumatic machines striking light blows while the rivet was hot (Hawkins p. 92). Holes were punched in soft iron and mild steel and drilled in anything brittle (Hawkins p. 92).

Hawkins's four patterns of seam (Hawkins p. 93). Every hole is plate that no longer carries load, so the pattern sets how much of the plate's strength the seam keeps. That share decides the pressure a boiler shell may run at, as the numbers table below shows.
Hawkins's four patterns of seam (Hawkins p. 93). Every hole is plate that no longer carries load, so the pattern sets how much of the plate's strength the seam keeps. That share decides the pressure a boiler shell may run at, as the numbers table below shows.

Wilson sets the rule. Taking the entire plate as 100, a double-riveted joint is 70 and a single-riveted joint 56, "originally deduced by Sir W. Fairbairn from his experiments" (Wilson p. 73), and Courtney gives the same two factors (Courtney p. 92). A circle seam carries half the strain of a longitudinal one under the same pressure, so round seams were single riveted and long seams double (Hawkins p. 93). The rivet was made nearly 2 1/2 times the thickness of the plate across (Wilson p. 76), and the plate between the rivets had to be as strong as the rivets themselves (Hawkins p. 93).

A zig-zag seam in section and in plan (Hawkins p. 94, Fig. 41). The plates lap, and the rivet heads stand on both faces, formed from one shank. After riveting the edge of the plate was closed with a blunt chisel about a quarter of an inch thick and a 3 or 4 lb hammer: caulking, which closes the seam. A plate under a quarter of an inch could hardly be caulked at all.
A zig-zag seam in section and in plan (Hawkins p. 94, Fig. 41). The plates lap, and the rivet heads stand on both faces, formed from one shank. After riveting the edge of the plate was closed with a blunt chisel about a quarter of an inch thick and a 3 or 4 lb hammer: caulking, which closes the seam. A plate under a quarter of an inch could hardly be caulked at all.

Rivets were of good charcoal iron or very soft mild steel (Hawkins p. 93). The US government's test for steel boiler rivets flattened them cold to half the diameter and hot to a third without cracks (Hawkins p. 95), and Lowmoor listed rivet iron from 3/16 to 9/16 inch (Percy p. 757). Long rivets gave trouble: the heads set and the middle cooled before the hole was filled, and the contraction could crack a head (Hawkins p. 93).

Rivets were made off the bar. A bar heated for four or five feet was pushed into the header and sheared, gripped, headed and ejected in one turn of the flywheel, over and over until the hot part of the bar ran out (Hamilton pp. 5, 20). The dies were kept cold under a constant stream of water (Hamilton pp. 9-10), and carried four grooves, so a worn one was replaced by turning the block (Hamilton p. 21).

Bolts and nuts

A bolt needs more than a rivet. Bars for a stop-motion header were sheared cold to length first, and then one end heated (Hamilton p. 5). In plain dies a square head took two or more blows in each of two positions, and a hexagon head "at least six blows", the operator turning the bar one-sixth of a turn between them (Hamilton pp. 6, 9). Double-deck dies brought that down to three (Hamilton p. 11), which is the figure the game takes.

A power bolt cutter (Rose p. 466, Fig. 1820). The bolt is gripped in vice L by hand wheel M and run up to the head D by hand wheel Q. A rod R on the vice trips a catch when the thread has reached its set length, a spring throws the clutch ring H, and the dies open by themselves, so every bolt in a batch is threaded to the same length without the operator judging it.
A power bolt cutter (Rose p. 466, Fig. 1820). The bolt is gripped in vice L by hand wheel M and run up to the head D by hand wheel Q. A rod R on the vice trips a catch when the thread has reached its set length, a spring throws the clutch ring H, and the dies open by themselves, so every bolt in a batch is threaded to the same length without the operator judging it.

Threading was the second machine. Rose sets the two arrangements side by side: where the bolt turns, "the machine must be stopped to take out each finished bolt"; where it is held and the dies open at a set length, every bolt is threaded "to an equal distance or length without care on the part of the operator" (Rose p. 464). The chasers were plain pieces of rectangular steel, cheap to renew when worn short (Rose p. 467), and dies at work all day were ground once or twice a day. "The two important points in operating threading machines is to keep the dies sharp and to well lubricate them with oil" (Rose p. 464). Taps ran at the dies' speed (Rose p. 474), and the same class of machine held nuts in a recessed plate for tapping (Rose p. 465).

Bolts belong with cast iron for a plain reason. A rivet is closed with blows and pulled up by shrinking, which a brittle casting will not stand. Cast parts met at flanges: flange couplings were two bolted discs, turned and bored true (Fairbairn Mills II pp. 79-82).

Period basis, and what is the game's own

  • Period: nails for timber, rivets for a tight plate joint, bolts for cast iron (Swank p. 449, Hawkins p. 92, Fairbairn Mills II pp. 79-82). The game makes this the rule: nails are the iron age's fastener, rivets the steam age's, and bolts belong to whatever is cast. Boilers take rivets and nothing else.
  • Period: a bolt and rivet header is two gripping dies and a heading ram (Hamilton p. 5). The game's rivet heading machine is that machine, and one die in it makes the difference between a rivet and a bolt. A die fitted to the wrong machine is refused.
  • Period: Hamilton's book is of 1914, later than the game's period. The books searched for this page give no earlier account of a header, so the game takes the principle and not the date.
  • Period: a nail plate cut at the nail machine, as Swank and Overman describe (Swank p. 448, Overman p. 392). The game keeps the plate and cuts all four bundles at one stroke, and the machine is meant to stand in rows on one shaft.
  • Period: a seam was closed by hand or by a riveting machine, then caulked (Hawkins pp. 92, 94). The game plans a riveting set as a tool step on each seam of a boiler's construction; the hot driving and the caulking are otherwise lines in the bill.
  • The game's own: rivets have no forge route. The first boiler waits for a mill and a heading machine on purpose, so the machine rung comes before the steam.
  • The game's own: fasteners are spent in bundles, a whole number at a time. The nut is inside the bolt bundle and there is no nut item.
  • The game's own: one stroke of the bolt cutter threads one bolt and taps one nut. In the shop those were separate machines, and this one is built as a double head to carry both.
  • The game's own: nails are the base game's item, from the anvil. See vanilla against reality.
  • The game's own: a cast part held by bolts comes off whole with a wrench and hands its bolts back.

The numbers

Metal is counted in units, one ingot being 100 u (scale and units); the nail anchor is taken from the base game and not scaled (the scaling page). "Planned" is the rating in design; values without that word are what the game has now.

In the gamePeriod figureHow it was scaledGame value
Nails per ingotNone givenThe base game's anvil plan and smelting ratio, kept as they stand4 bundles from 100 u, 25 u a bundle
Rivet bundleNone givenThe game's own: half a nail bundle, whole and mass-neutral12.5 u; 8 bundles from 100 u. A thinner rod is planned, 3.125 u cut to 20 rivets
Bolts and nutsNone givenThe game's own: half a nail bundle again12.5 u, four bolts with their nuts; a heavy bolt of 50 u is planned
Nail plateLong small nail plates, cut crosswise (Overman p. 392)The game's own: one plate, one stroke100 u to 4 bundles; planned 25 u to 1 bundle
Blows on a rivetOne, on a continuous header (Hamilton p. 20)The period figure1, a 3 s stroke
Blows on a bolt headAt least six in plain dies (Hamilton p. 6), three in double-deck dies (Hamilton p. 11)The double-deck figurePlanned 3 strokes of 3 s
Nail strokeNone givenThe game's own2 s for one plate
Threading a boltThe Adams double machine, one ton of track bolts in a 10-hour day (Rose p. 471); about 27 s a bolt a head if a bolt is taken at 0.75 lb, the book giving no weightThe game's own: about a tenth of the shop's timePlanned 2.25 s a bolt, 9 s a bundle
Thread die lifeDies ground once or twice a day at full work (Rose p. 464)The game's own life in bundlesThread die, planned: 100 iron, 120 meteoric iron, 250 steel
Seam strengthEntire plate 100, double riveted 70, single 56 (Wilson p. 73)The rule at face value in the boiler's pressurePlanned 3.8 atm double riveted, 3.0 single; see the Cornish boiler

Open, and what you can tell us

The books searched for this page describe the cut-nail machine by inventors and patents, not by its stroke. The game's plate is flipped between shears, alternating the cut so that the nail tapers, and none of them states how the taper was made. If you know a source that describes the feed of a cut-nail machine, we would like to read it.

Picture credits