Bearings and grease

A shaft has to turn in something that holds it still, and every turn rubs. The plain bearing is the period's answer: a cast block, a lining and a film of oil or fat between lining and shaft. How power moves through a works in the game is in the shaft power guide, and the part itself is in the catalogue. This page is about the real thing and what the game keeps of it.

A plummer block on a preserved beam engine at the Birla Industrial and Technological Museum, Kolkata, under later paint. A cast base bolted to its timber, a cap held down by two studs, and a line of rust along the split where cap and base meet. The shaft end is capped off.
A plummer block on a preserved beam engine at the Birla Industrial and Technological Museum, Kolkata, under later paint. A cast base bolted to its timber, a cap held down by two studs, and a line of rust along the split where cap and base meet. The shaft end is capped off.
The parts of a small plummer block, from the 1911 Encyclopaedia Britannica, labelled here. The two half-round brasses are the only parts that touch the shaft. Lugs and flanges stop them turning or walking along it; the cast iron only holds them. The shaft is laid in the lower brass, the upper brass and cap go on after it, and oil enters through the hole in the cap and spreads along grooves cut in the upper brass.
The parts of a small plummer block, from the 1911 Encyclopaedia Britannica, labelled here. The two half-round brasses are the only parts that touch the shaft. Lugs and flanges stop them turning or walking along it; the cast iron only holds them. The shaft is laid in the lower brass, the upper brass and cap go on after it, and oil enters through the hole in the cap and spreads along grooves cut in the upper brass.

There is no drawing of the game's plain bearing as a placed machine: it is an item, paid into the machines that run on one.

How the real one worked, and why it was built so

The simplest support of a mill shaft (Fairbairn Mills II p. 93, Fig. 229): a cast-iron base plate and column, with deep wings to keep it from shaking. The head is hollowed for the lower brass step, and the cap carries the upper one. Fairbairn's own economy follows: where the whole load presses down the upper brass is left out and the cap is cast hollow "and kept full of grease" (pp. 93-94).
The simplest support of a mill shaft (Fairbairn Mills II p. 93, Fig. 229): a cast-iron base plate and column, with deep wings to keep it from shaking. The head is hollowed for the lower brass step, and the cap carries the upper one. Fairbairn's own economy follows: where the whole load presses down the upper brass is left out and the cap is cast hollow "and kept full of grease" (pp. 93-94).

A mill shaft was held up in three ways, "on foundation stones in the floor, beneath beams suspended from the ceiling, and to the walls" (Fairbairn Mills II p. 93), and each way has its own casting around the same two brasses. The shafts themselves are on the line shafting page.

The wall version (Fairbairn Mills II p. 94, Fig. 230), seen from the side and from the front. The plate is bolted through the wall, and the cap at a is held by a wedge at c instead of bolts. Where the pull is upward and two brasses are needed, lugs are added so that pedestal and cap can be bolted together.
The wall version (Fairbairn Mills II p. 94, Fig. 230), seen from the side and from the front. The plate is bolted through the wall, and the cap at a is held by a wedge at c instead of bolts. Where the pull is upward and two brasses are needed, lugs are added so that pedestal and cap can be bolted together.
A shop of 1895 with its shafts hung from the roof beams (Sellers 1895 p. 381, Plate 229). Each small dark bracket along the lines is a hanger with a bearing in it. Every one of them had to be kept oiled and stay in line (Sellers 1895 p. 380).
A shop of 1895 with its shafts hung from the roof beams (Sellers 1895 p. 381, Plate 229). Each small dark bracket along the lines is a hanger with a bearing in it. Every one of them had to be kept oiled and stay in line (Sellers 1895 p. 380).

Two numbers ruled a journal: how long it was and how hard it was pressed. Fairbairn made it one and a half diameters long on a cast-iron shaft and one and three quarters on wrought (Fairbairn Mills II p. 73). His table runs from 20 to 40 lb on each square inch of bearing for a horizontal line, to 178 for a fly-wheel shaft and 243 for the toe of a vertical shaft (p. 73). Even at the top figure it was "difficult to keep the shafts cool" (p. 74), and any dust or sand in the step was a danger (p. 74). The shoulder of a journal was hollowed, never cut square, because a square corner cost the shaft much of its strength (p. 74).

Sellers made his boxes far longer, four diameters, and hung each on a ball and socket so that it could follow a shaft that had deflected or settled and still carry the load along its whole length (Sellers 1895 p. 380).

What grease does

Morin's experiments at Metz, in 1831 to 1833, are the ones Fairbairn leans on (Fairbairn Mills II p. 74). Dry, friction goes with the load and does not care about the area touching (pp. 74-75). With a continuous film between the surfaces it depends "rather upon the nature of the unguent than upon that of the surfaces" (p. 75), so that lard or olive oil gave a coefficient of 0.07 to 0.08 on wood or on metal alike, and tallow 0.10 between metals (p. 75). Rennie found the harder unguents, tallow and soft soap, better under weight, and the softer oils and lard worse, so the choice "must be accommodated to the pressure" (pp. 75-76).

The lubricator Fairbairn preferred (Fairbairn Mills II p. 78, Fig. 207): a small cistern of oil at a, on top of the block. A woollen thread hangs from a tube standing just above the oil level and draws oil up by capillary action, in "very minute quantities", on to the neck of the shaft.
The lubricator Fairbairn preferred (Fairbairn Mills II p. 78, Fig. 207): a small cistern of oil at a, on top of the block. A woollen thread hangs from a tube standing just above the oil level and draws oil up by capillary action, in "very minute quantities", on to the neck of the shaft.

The saving was real and easily lost. In large cotton mills a change in the quality of the oil took up ten to fifteen horse-power, and a mill that had stood cold over Sunday needed more power on Monday morning than on any other day (Fairbairn Mills II p. 77). An indicator on an engine of 50 horse-power put its whole friction at 5 (p. 77). Fairbairn names pure sperm and olive oils as the best, and says that they were to be applied sparingly (Fairbairn Mills II p. 77).

The job itself was held in low regard: oiling was "generally left to the most negligent and most untidy person in the establishment" (Fairbairn Mills II p. 77). The result, in his words, was that "every opening for the oil to get to the bearings is plugged up, the brass steps are cut by abrasion, and the necks or journals of the shafts destroyed" (Fairbairn Mills II p. 78). Pouring it on was no cure, since nine tenths ran to the floor or hardened on the hangers (Fairbairn Mills II p. 77). This is what wear meant in a bearing: not a part reaching the end of a set life, but a film that failed.

By 1895 Sellers's boxes came two ways: an ordinary box, oiled by hand or by a drop feeder, with two cups on top for grease or candle lubricators, and a self-oiling box in which rings or chains hanging into a bath carried oil up to the journal, a single charge lasting for several months (Sellers 1895 pp. 380, 382).

What the bearing was lined with

A lathe spindle bearing before and after lining (Rose p. 125, Figs. 465 and 466; text on p. 124). On the left, the cast box as it is machined, with recesses cut in it.
A lathe spindle bearing before and after lining (Rose p. 125, Figs. 465 and 466; text on p. 124). On the left, the cast box as it is machined, with recesses cut in it.
On the right the same box lined with Babbitt metal and ready for service: "nothing but Babbitt metal is in contact with the lathe spindle" (Rose p. 124). The lining fills the recesses of the box.
On the right the same box lined with Babbitt metal and ready for service: "nothing but Babbitt metal is in contact with the lathe spindle" (Rose p. 124). The lining fills the recesses of the box.

The steps of Fairbairn's mill pedestals are brass (Fairbairn Mills II p. 93). The toe of a vertical shaft needs "the very best quality of gun metal" (p. 74). By the later century a machine shop lined its boxes with Babbitt (Rose p. 124), and the 1911 Encyclopaedia Britannica lists gun metal and phosphor bronze for brasses. Sellers went the other way for ordinary hangers: cast iron bored true, which his firm found "superior to other metals as a material for boxes", with Babbitt, brass or bronze made to order (Sellers 1895 p. 382).

Period basis, and what is the game's own

  • Period: a cast pedestal with a lower step and a cap carrying the upper one (Fairbairn Mills II p. 93). The game's plain bearing is a cast block and its cap, cast apart in one pour, with a brass bush between them, assembled at the bench.
  • Period: Fairbairn names pure sperm and olive oils as the best lubricants (Fairbairn Mills II p. 77). The game takes one grease at the fit: vanilla's rendered fat or a half litre of its olive or flax oil, whichever the player has.
  • The game's own: a single brass, where a period block had two or one with a grease cap (Fairbairn Mills II pp. 93-94). A bearing that is only a bore in a larger casting takes a bare bush, and the same bush goes in a gland.
  • The game's own: grease is paid once, when the fit is made, and nothing that runs consumes it. Today no bearing is oiled, runs hot or wears out, and a bearing is an item in a machine's making rather than a part that changes how it runs.
  • The game's own, planned: oil cups drawn at a machine's bearings, filled from an oil can, a fill lasting days of running. A dry machine would draw more torque and run hot but would never break by itself, and a sight-feed lubricator on an engine would keep it oiled. The period's stakes, a cut step and a ruined journal (Fairbairn Mills II p. 78), are not planned.
  • The game's own: vanilla has no bearing at all. Its axle only draws a stand where it finds itself unsupported, and its wooden axle takes fat in its recipe. See vanilla against reality.
  • The game's own, planned: tooling wears, machines do not. Dies, roll sets, blades and cutters are planned to wear by the grade of their metal, breaking up into 80% bits and 20% mill scale when spent. Of all this only the wooden pattern wears today, after 240 impressions. Whether a bearing should ever become a wear part is undecided, and the working assumption is that it will not.
  • The game's own, planned: a ball bearing in the steel-age mod, standing in for a plain one and required by the highest-pressure machines. The books at hand do not cover how balls were made or the industry that made them.

The numbers

Bearing figures are period reference only: the game does not simulate a journal's pressure, its length or its coefficient, so nothing below is scaled (see the scaling page and scale and units).

In the gamePeriod figureHow it was scaledGame value
Length of a journal1.5 diameters on cast iron, 1.75 on wrought (Fairbairn Mills II p. 73); 4 diameters in a swivel box (Sellers 1895 p. 380)Not modelledNone
Pressure on a journal20 to 40 psi on a horizontal shaft, 178 on a fly-wheel shaft, 243 on a vertical toe (Fairbairn Mills II p. 73)Not modelledNone
Friction with an unguent0.07 to 0.08, oil or lard; 0.10, tallow on metal (Fairbairn Mills II p. 75)Not modelled in the bearingNone; the shaft network has its own running friction, not tied to any bearing
Lost in an engine5 of 50 hp (Fairbairn Mills II p. 77)Not modelledNone
Grease at a running fitNo book gives a quantity for a fitThe game's ownOne rendered fat, or 0.5 L of olive or flax oil
Life of a wooden patternNone givenThe game's own240 impressions
A spent tool, plannedNone givenThe game's ownPlanned 80% back as bits, 20% as mill scale

Open, and what you can tell us

The books at hand do not explain why the lining was brass or a white metal rather than iron, and Sellers's preference for bored cast iron (Sellers 1895 p. 382) sits oddly beside Fairbairn's brass steps. They also disagree on length by more than double, one and a half to four diameters. If you know a period source that argues the choice of lining, or that gives the running clearance or the rate at which brasses wore in service, it would be welcome.

Picture credits