Percy, Nasmyth, Bauerman, Fairbairn and Swank on steam hammer uses - what a works forged under it that the belly helve could not, 1839-1892
Books Metallurgy: Iron and Steel, An Autobiography, ed. S. Smiles, A Treatise on the Metallurgy of Iron, Iron, its History, Properties and Processes of Manufacture, The Manufacture of Iron, The Iron Manufacture of Great Britain, Handbook of the Steam-Engine, A Treatise on the Steam Engine, Treatise on Mills and Millwork, Part II, History of the Manufacture of Iron in All Ages
Sources
- J. Percy, Metallurgy: Iron and Steel (1864). Already digested in the Percy note and the anvils note; this page extends them (pp. 693-701 in full, plus pp. 739-741, 762). No text layer: read through noisy OCR and page images where a figure matters.
- James Nasmyth, Engineer: An Autobiography, ed. Samuel Smiles (London 1883). Clean text layer.
- H. Bauerman, A Treatise on the Metallurgy of Iron (title page 1870; the first edition is 1868). Clean text layer.
- W. Fairbairn, Iron: its History, Properties and Processes of Manufacture, new edition 1865. No text layer, read through archive.org's OCR text of the same scan, folio checked against the page image.
- Overman, The Manufacture of Iron (1850). Truran, The Iron Manufacture of Great Britain (1855). Bourne, Handbook of the Steam-Engine (1865). Farey, A Treatise on the Steam Engine (1827). Fairbairn, Treatise on Mills and Millwork, part 2 (edition date not read). J. M. Swank, History of the Manufacture of Iron in All Ages (an edition after 1891: it describes the Bethlehem hammer completed that year). Text layers read.
- Searched and not useful: Rose, Modern Machine-Shop Practice, has no steam hammer or forging-shop text, only tool forging; Hamilton, Bolt, Nut and Rivet Forging (undated, c. 1910) is a drop-hammer shop book outside the window, not used.
Page convention p is the PDF page. Printed folio: Percy PDF - 20 (pp. 693-701, 739-741) but PDF - 26 at the Dowlais page; Nasmyth PDF - 32; Bauerman PDF - 12; Overman PDF - 6; Truran PDF - 26; Fairbairn Iron PDF - 27; Fairbairn Mills PDF - 42; Bourne PDF - 16; Farey PDF - 18; Swank PDF - 28. A page is written PDF (folio). Metric long ton (2240 lb) x 1.016, cwt x 50.8 kg, lb x 0.4536, in x 25.4 mm, ft x 0.3048 m. INFERRED marks my arithmetic or reading, never a source statement. Where a Percy scan is illegible the row says so.
Companion pages: the Percy note (the ball, the helve and Nasmyth's hammer), the anvils note (anvil, sole-plate and foundations). Nasmyth's folio offset changes where plates are inserted (PDF 271-283 less 32, PDF 305-312 less 34, PDF 353-354 less 36, PDF 384 less 40); every Nasmyth folio here is the printed header.
1. Why the helve could not forge the big shaft (Nasmyth's account)
- Nasmyth received Humphries's letter on 24 Nov 1839: "I find that there is not a forge hammer in England or Scotland powerful enough to forge the intermediate paddle-shaft of the engines for the Great Britain ! ... Do you think I might dare to use cast-iron ?" The shaft was "of thirty inches diameter" (762 mm). Nasmyth 271 (239).
- Nasmyth's diagnosis, in his words: the old hammers "became 'gagged;' so that, when the forging required the most powerful blow, it received next to no blow at all, as the clear space for the fall of the hammer was almost entirely occupied by the work on the anvil." The cause was "want of compass, of range and fall, as well as ... want of power of blow". Nasmyth 271-272 (239-240).
- His first sketch is dated 24 Nov 1839 ("a page of my Scheme Book"); the sketch had an anvil, a hammer block and an inverted cylinder, steam lifting on the underside of the piston and a slide valve under the attendant's hand. Nasmyth 272-274 (240-242).
- The Great Britain paddle shaft was never forged: the ship went over to the screw, the engines were abandoned, Humphries died, and the trade was depressed, "they had not sufficient orders to keep the forge hammers they already possessed in work". Nasmyth 275 (243).
- The first hammer built was Schneider's at Creusot (Bourdon copied the sketch in Nasmyth's absence); on 1842 Nasmyth saw "a large wrought-iron marine engine single crank, forged with a remarkable degree of exactness ... the large eye of the crank had been punched and drifted with extraordinary smoothness and truth". Bourdon: "It was forged by your steam hammer !" Nasmyth 278 (246). The Creusot hammer's size is not given.
- Nasmyth's own demonstration hammer: "one of 30 cwt. of hammer block, with a clear four feet range of fall" (1.52 t, 1.22 m). Nasmyth 280 (248). Patent secured June 1842, "little short of 500 pounds" to take out. Nasmyth 279-280 (247-248).
- Disagreement on dates: Percy 715 (695), 721 (701): patent 9 June 1842 "contains the first drawings of the perfected single-acting hammer". Swank PDF 91: "Nasmyth ... invented the steam hammer in 1838". Fairbairn Iron 160 (133): patent "in 1833". Nasmyth himself 1839 invention, 1842 patent. Nasmyth is the first-hand account and Percy the dated patent; Swank and Fairbairn's years look like errors (INFERRED).
2. What the steam hammer did better, in the sources' words
| Quality | Statement | Page |
|---|---|---|
| Regulated blow, from gentle to hard | "The hammer could be made to give so gentle a blow as to crack the end of an egg placed in a wine glass on the anvil ; whilst the next blow would shake the parish, or be instantly arrested in its descent midway." The attendant could "think in blows". | Nasmyth 273-274 (241-242), 281 (249) |
| Same, as a forging rule | "A great advantage possessed by the steam hammer consists in the power of regulating the force of the blow according to the necessity of the work, as the block may be stopped at any portion of its stroke". In shingling, "consolidate the ball by short, light strokes, afterwards increasing the force by working with a longer fall ... This cannot be done with a helve hammer, whose height of fall, and consequent impact, is invariable." | Bauerman 304 (292) |
| Coaxing weak work | "Balls, which would crumble to pieces under the helve, may, by gently regulated blows under Nasmyth's hammer, be easily wrought into solid blooms or slabs ... With the helve, 'coaxing' or 'humouring' ... is impossible". | Percy 715 (695) |
| Range and clearance for thick work | Cause of the helve's failure was "want of compass, of range and fall"; the hammer "lifted to a sufficient height above the object". Rushton and Eckersley's 5 t hammer "had a clear fall of five feet" (1.52 m). Percy's 15 cwt Atlas Works hammer had stroke 40 in (1.02 m) and "working space of about 5 ft. in length by 2 ft. in height". Condie's hammer: working space between guides; Bauerman's 8 t Thwaites and Carbutt piston stroke 6 ft (1.83 m). | Nasmyth 271 (239), 282 (250); Percy 718 (698); Bauerman 304 (292) |
| Welding large masses built up | "nothing could be better adapted for building up a large mass by the union of successive portions, since the vis inertia of the slabs to be welded on to the original core is not so great as to absorb the momentum of the falling hammer". Fairbairn also: it "affords facilities for the welding of large blocks of malleable iron that could not be accomplished by the tilt and helve hammers formerly in use". | Fairbairn Iron 216 (189), 162 (135) |
| Whole forgings, not bit-by-bit | Anchors: under "the 'bit by bit' system ... flaws often occurred; the parts would break off - blades from the stock, or flukes from the blades"; "By means of the steam hammer ... The slag was driven out during the hammering process. The anchor was sound throughout because it was welded as a whole." | Nasmyth 282 (250) |
| Free work around the anvil | Anchor forging: "where the cast-iron standards are in the way, they are dispensed with, and the cylinder is supported on wrought-iron beams spanning the smithy, so as to leave a free space all round the anvil". Small hammers below 12-15 cwt: "a single standard overhanging its base, giving a clear working space on three sides of the anvil". | Fairbairn Iron 162-163 (135-136); Bauerman 306 (294) |
| Round bars and shafts: swage or V-anvil | "the V anvil ... the natural offspring of the steam-hammer ... chiefly employed for forging round bars and shafts"; blows on a flat anvil "diverging", on the V "converging action, thus consolidating the mass", else a round shaft goes elliptical and "produces a spongy, porous centre". Percy: a swage face is fixed to the anvil "when the hammer is used for forging round bars". | Fairbairn Iron 163-164 (136-137); Percy 718 (698) |
| Die and stamp work | See section 5. | Nasmyth 282-283 (250-251) |
| Punching, drifting | Creusot crank eye "punched and drifted". Percy's list of patents includes Nasmyth's 1843 steam pile driver. No source says the hammer forged a hole of stated size. | Nasmyth 278 (246); Percy 721 (701) |
| Upsetting, drawing down | Not stated for the steam hammer as such. Overman says it is poor at drawing small iron: "the smaller kind of these steam hammers work so slowly that they do not answer for drawing iron ... they make but eighty or 100 strokes per minute ; while it is necessary that a hammer suitable for drawing iron should make at least 150 strokes, and smaller hammers from 150 to 300, and even 400". | Overman 343 (337) |
| Against: ordinary bar-iron mill | Truran (1855): "The steam hammer has been employed in some mills, but for the ironmaster's purposes, it possesses no superiority over the common hammer. Where a great range in the force of the blow is required the steam hammer stands unrivalled, but in manufacturing bar iron the blooms are required to be hammered with the same force throughout ... a mill hammer costing only one-fifth or sixth as much, is equally efficient." | Truran 257 (231) |
| Against: cast steel ingots | Fairbairn, quoting Bessemer's reasoning: for a 20 in x 30 ft marine shaft "a solid steel ingot of 3 feet square and 8 feet in length would be required, weighing over 15 tons ... the exterior portion of the mass is only elongated, and this causes either the tearing asunder of the central part, or the sliding of the exterior portion of metal over it, so as to form at the end of the shaft a cup of 1 or 2 feet in depth. Hence ... the sudden impact of the hammer must be replaced by a powerful and steady pressure." | Fairbairn Iron 216-217 (189-190), 221 (194) |
INFERRED reading: the hammer's gain is range (height under the hammer for thick work, a heavy block lifted clear), a regulated blow and whole welded masses; it is not faster bar-drawing, and for ordinary merchant bar Truran says the helve does as well. The designers' question "what can the player forge at the steam hammer that the helve cannot" is therefore "thick or massive built-up work and die work", not "more of the same".
3. Hammer sizes against the work
| Hammer | Size | Rate, stroke, steam | What it forged | Page |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Tilt hammer | block 1-5 cwt (51-254 kg); Bauerman "heaviest ... 5 cwt" | "driven at considerable speed"; used for drawing bars, spikes and finishing | Small bars, spikes, finishing; Overman's wooden-frame tilt hammer 50-400 lb (23-181 kg), 400 lb for "blooms of from 60 to 100 pounds" | Percy 713 (693); Bauerman 300 (288); Overman 340 (334) |
| Belly or head helve, usual | 30 cwt to 5 t (1.5-5.1 t); "made of all weights up to 10 tons" | 70-100 blows a minute, lift 16-20 in (406-508 mm). Percy's Mersey 10 t: lift 18-24 in, up to 60 strokes a minute | Shingling puddle balls; in Staffordshire 5-6 t for shingling and 7-8 t "for blooming piles for finished iron" | Bauerman 301 (289); Percy 714 (694) |
| Helve, extreme | 10 t moving mass (10.2 t); cast T about 10 t | lift 18-24 in, 60 strokes a minute | The 27 t Horsfall 13 in gun "in the rough state, probably the largest mass ever wrought under a lever hammer" (Percy). Fairbairn gives the same gun (Mersey, Clay) as 25 t before boring, built "in seven distinct layers", forged "under the largest belly-helve hammer" | Percy 714 (694); Fairbairn Iron 164-165 (137-138) |
| Dowlais forge helve | helve 5-7 t, hammer face 18 in square | 18-19 rev of the cam ring, 4 wipers, 72-76 blows a minute, lift 16 in; 15-25 blows (18-30 s) turn a ball to bloom | Puddle balls to blooms; mill hammer helve 7-8 t, face 4 ft x 18 in, a pile takes 12-20 blows in 10-18 s | Truran 244-245 (218-219), 257 (231) |
| Steam hammer, first Nasmyth | block 30 cwt (1.5 t), clear fall 4 ft (1.22 m) | hand valve; top steam added 1843 | Nasmyth's own smith and forge work; shown at the 1851 Great Exhibition as "a fair average specimen" | Nasmyth 280 (248), 281 (249), 384 (344) |
| 5 t hammer | block 5 t (5.1 t), "clear fall of five feet" (1.52 m) | Rushton and Eckersley, Bolton, first order; "hammering out some wrought-iron forgings of the largest class, as well as working upon smaller forgings"; Lowmoor and Hawkes (Newcastle) bought the same. Fairbairn lists Rushton and Eckersley's works with "2 Five-ton and 2 fifty-cwt. steam-hammers" and "3 Helve-hammers" | Nasmyth 282 (250), 301 (269); Fairbairn Iron 131 (104) | |
| 50 cwt (2.5 t) | block 50 cwt (2.54 t) | Devonport Dockyard's first Admiralty hammer, with boiler, crane and forge furnace; the Admiralty then equipped all the royal dockyards' forges | Nasmyth 301-302 (269-270) | |
| 15 cwt double-acting | block 15 cwt (762 kg); stroke 40 in (1.02 m); anvil about 5 1/2 t (5.6 t) | Nasmyth's Atlas Works, Sheffield, as drawn by Percy | Percy 718 (698) | |
| 8 t double-acting | block 8 t (8.1 t), piston 28 in (711 mm) bore, stroke 6 ft (1.83 m) | Thwaites and Carbutt of Bradford, Bauerman's example | Bauerman 304-305 (292-293) | |
| Condie, largest class | hammer-block with cylinder 15 t (15.2 t) | "for making forgings of the largest class, as for example crank shafts for marine engines, piles for armour-plates" (image read) | Percy 719-720 (699-700) | |
| 6 t Condie, single acting | 6 t (6.1 t) | The intermediate shaft of the Great Eastern, 31 t 2 cwt (31.6 t), "probably the largest single crank shaft ever forged", by the Lancefield Forge Company (image read) | Percy 720 (700) | |
| 95 cwt Condie | 95 cwt (4.8 t) | 50-60 strokes a minute of 4 ft (1.22 m), Steyer (Tunner) | Blooming and welding for two double puddling and two reheating furnaces; steam from the waste heat of one reheating furnace | Percy 720 (700) |
| Ironworks blooming hammers | 1 1/2-5 1/2 t (Percy), 30-60 cwt (Bauerman); "one 50-cwt. hammer" serves 11-15 puddling furnaces (Percy), "twelve furnaces" (Bauerman) | steam from waste heat of one or two reheating furnaces | Puddled blooms and slabs "of ordinary dimensions" | Percy 720 (700); Bauerman 304 (292) |
| Heavy forging hammers | 5-50 t block; the largest "only made single-acting; the use of steam above the piston being rarely resorted to when the weight is more than 12 or 15 tons" | "piles for armour plates, marine engine-crank shafts, and large, irregular forgings for ships, as well as in steel works" | Bauerman 304 (292) | |
| 4 t steam hammer, 6 t helve | 4 t (4.1 t) balling; 6 t (6.1 t) piling | Brown's rolled armour plates, 1862: balled under the 4 t hammer, piled under the 6 t helve, then rolled | Percy 760 (740) | |
| Steam pile driver | block 4 t, 80 blows a minute, fall 3-4 ft; guide case and cylinder 7 t resting on the pile | Piles 18 in x 70 ft (457 mm x 21.3 m): Nasmyth's drove one in 4 1/2 minutes against over 12 hours by the old machine, 1845 | Nasmyth 305-310 (271-276) | |
| Reading Steam Forge, 1856 | four hammers 1/2, 3/4, 1 1/2 and 7 t (0.5, 0.76, 1.5 and 7.1 t) (image read) | Two Adriatic shafts; see section 4 | Swank 490 (462) | |
| Krupp | 50 t, lift 10 ft (3.05 m), anvil 185 t | Steel works | Bauerman 307 (295) | |
| Park Brother, Pittsburgh, 6 Sep 1881 | 17 t falling parts (17.3 t), bore 40 in (1.02 m), stroke 9 ft (2.74 m); anvil 160 t; framing riveted plate; cost $52,000; steam on top adds about 50 t of force | "will work steel ingots two feet square"; in Aug 1883 a steel steamboat shaft 32 1/2 ft, 30,240 lb (13.7 t) from 32,000 lb (14.5 t) open-hearth ingots | Swank 491 (463) | |
| Bethlehem | 125 t single-acting; 76 in cylinder; 90 ft high | Not read further (1891, outside the window) | Swank 492 (464) | |
| Naylor, Rigby (double acting, light) | "250 blows per minute" | Small hammers | Fairbairn Iron 163 (136) | |
| Ryder and Platt forging machine | 700 and 1100 spm | Bolts, spindles, small articles | Fairbairn Iron 165-166 (138-139) |
Rule of thumb tying hammer weight to the section of work: not stated in any source. Bauerman gives block weights by kind of work (30-60 cwt for blooms, 5-50 t for armour piles, marine cranks and ship forgings). INFERRED from the paired figures above, forged mass over falling mass: Great Eastern shaft 31.6 t / 6.1 t = about 5; Adriatic shaft 35.6 t / 7.1 t = 5; Mersey gun 27 t / 10 t helve = 2.7; Park steel shaft 13.7 t / 17.3 t = 0.8 (steel, from an ingot, not built up). Iron shafts were built up on the hammer from piles in 5 to 6 times its mass.
4. Named forgings, masses and which hammer
| Part | Mass or size | Hammer and how | Page |
|---|---|---|---|
| Great Britain intermediate paddle shaft, wrought | 30 in (762 mm) diameter; never forged | no hammer in the kingdom could; Nasmyth's design answered it | Nasmyth 271 (239) |
| Great Eastern intermediate shaft | 31 t 2 cwt (31.6 t) | 6 t single-acting Condie, Lancefield Forge Co. | Percy 720 (700) |
| Adriatic paddle shafts (two), 1856 | each 35 1/2 ft (10.8 m) x 27 1/2 in (699 mm), 78,500 lb (35.6 t); forged in 12 working days each | 7 t hammer (largest of the forge's four); built on a porter bar in piles of bloom bars of about 250 lb (113 kg) each | Swank 490-491 (462-463) |
| Adriatic cranks (two) | 12 ft stroke (3.66 m), 18,800 lb (8.5 t) each | same forge | Swank 490 (462) |
| Marine crank shaft, general | "ocean-steamers' paddle-wheel and screw-shafts, some of them weighing upwards of 20 tons" | steam hammer | Fairbairn Iron 162 (135) |
| Ship's stem posts and cutwaters | no mass | steam hammer | Fairbairn Iron 162 (135) |
| Marine engine single crank (Creusot, 1842) | no mass | early steam hammer; eye punched and drifted | Nasmyth 278 (246) |
| Steel marine shaft, 1883 | 32 1/2 ft (9.9 m), 30,240 lb (13.7 t), hexagonal centre tapering to round ends | Park's 17 t hammer, ingot 32,000 lb | Swank 491 (463) |
| Steel shaft, projected | 20 in x 30 ft (508 mm x 9.1 m), ingot 3 ft x 8 ft, over 15 t | hammer unsuitable, press wanted | Fairbairn Iron 216 (189) |
| Anchors | no mass; "welded as a whole" | steam hammer, all royal dockyards equipped from 1843 | Nasmyth 282 (250), 302 (270) |
| Wrought-iron gun (Horsfall 13 in), Mersey | 27 t rough (Percy), 25 t before boring (Fairbairn); 15 ft x 32 in, breech 44 in, muzzle 27 in (4.57 m, 813 mm, 1.12 m, 686 mm) | belly helve 10 t, 7 layers, 7 weeks; core of 8 ft rolled bars, V bars packed round | Percy 714 (694); Fairbairn Iron 164-165 (137-138) |
| Hammered armour plate, Mersey, 1862 | 21 ft 3 in x 6 ft 3 in x 5 1/2 in (OCR "5%"), over 13 t | steam hammer, "neither smithed nor tooled afterwards" | Percy 761 (741) |
| Rolled armour plate, John Brown, 1862 | 21 ft 8 in x 4 ft 2 in, 10 t 12 cwt; and 24 ft x 3 ft 8 in x 5 in, 7 t 17 cwt (thickness of first illegible) | 4 t steam hammer balling, 6 t helve piling, rolled | Percy 760 (740) |
| Armour plate, piled | Bauerman: piles of 1-1 1/2 cwt of scrap "balled in threes or fours into a slab at one heat", reheated, forged to a slab, joined by tapered edges, final forging at moderate red heat with water thrown on; porter bar with capstan-headed ring welded on. Rolled: slabs 12 x 30 x 1 in, five or six to a 4 ft square slab, again five or six to a plate 8 ft x 4 1/2 ft x 2 1/2 in, 30 cwt, 25-36 original slabs | hammered or rolled | Bauerman 332-333 (320-321) |
| "Uses" | "those variously-shaped masses of wrought-iron which are employed by the engineer and millwright": frames and parts of steam engines, iron ships, railway carriages and locomotives | steam hammer | Fairbairn Iron 150 (123); Fairbairn Mills 295 (253), 299 |
| Engine shafts | "well adapted for forging steam-engine shafts" (Merrick and Towne steam hammer, Philadelphia) | Overman 343 (337) | |
| Spherical steel shot | swaged under a steam hammer with hemispherical dies | Bauerman 390 (378) | |
| Locomotive axles and cranks, piston rods, beam gudgeons, rolls | not found in a source with a hammer size; see the next table and Gaps |
Wrought or cast, 1827-1865
| Part | Statement | Page |
|---|---|---|
| Marine engine: paddle shafts, cranks, "all the other working parts" | "are made of wrought-iron, except the side levers, which are of cast-iron, and the air-pump rod, which is of copper or brass" (Bourne 1865). Eye of crank wrought, with rules for the crank pin journal, the eye and the web | Bourne 295-296 (279-280), 287-288 (271-272) |
| Marine connecting rod | wrought, with rules for ends and middle (middle one-fifth thicker than the ends) | Bourne 279 (263) |
| Land engine connecting rod | "now usually made of wrought-iron"; when cast, a cross-shaped section, length three times the stroke | Bourne 254 (238) |
| Land engine beam | cast, first "like a long hollow box"; better "an open or skeleton beam, encircled with a great wrought-iron hoop, after the American fashion"; side lever cast but "encircled by a strong wrought-iron hoop" riveted to a cast flange; "strength will be increased three times if wrought-iron be substituted" for the top and bottom flanges | Bourne 253 (237), 283 (267) |
| Land engine fly-wheel shaft | Bourne gives the rule "when it is of cast-iron" and the eye of the crank for it; the cast shaft is the land default. Percy's Dowlais great mill engines: "The crank-shaft is of cast-iron, hollow", "fly-shaft ... of cast-iron, also hollow", "The cranks are of cast-iron, blocked and wedged upon the shafts; the crank pins are of wrought-iron" | Bourne 255-256 (239-240); Percy 788 (762) |
| Watt-type beam axis (gudgeon) | "For small engines up to 20 horse-power, the axes were usually made of wrought iron, but the larger sizes are made of cast iron" (Farey 1827); joint pins wrought in the first engines, cast "in modern engines" | Farey 622 (604) |
| Watt-type connecting rod | cast; "it would be an improvement to make them of wrought iron" | Farey 622 (604) |
| Crank axes | "In modern engines for steam-boats, the axes for the cranks are usually made of wrought iron, and it would be a good practice to use wrought iron, for the main axes of steam-engines for many other purposes." (1827) | Farey 638 (620) |
| Piston rod | not stated in the pages read (Bourne's rule gives its diameter as a fraction of the cylinder; the material is not said) | Gaps |
| Rolls and roll necks | Not found: no source read says how a roll or roll neck was made. | Gaps |
| Helve and anvil | cast iron with wrought striking faces (existing digests) | Percy 714 (694) |
INFERRED for the stationary-engine question: by 1865 the connecting rod, crank pin and hoops of a beam engine are wrought-forged; the beam, flywheel shaft, crank (rolling-mill type), gudgeon on engines above 20 hp and the flywheel are cast. A marine engine's shafts and cranks are all forged. A designer who wants a forged part on a beam or horizontal engine has: the connecting rod, crank pin, piston rod (material not stated here), the beam hoop and straps, bolts and cotters. The big shafts (paddle, screw, crank) and the large "uses" are marine, ship or ordnance work.
5. Welding up large forgings
- Pile: scrap cut by shears, tumbled in a "revolving hexagonal drum", "piled and faggoted into convenient-sized masses of one or two hundredweight" (51-102 kg), heated in a reheating or piling furnace "similar to the reverberatory furnace employed in puddling", under the helve "united into a bloom or slab. These slabs form the masses of which larger forgings are built up", handled by a crane beside the hammer. Fairbairn Iron 159-160 (132-133).
- Shaft on a porter bar: "They were commenced on what is called a porter bar, forming a tapering handle, to which are attached levers, or cranks, to turn the shaft in its slings while under the hammer. The porter bar was first heated, and then flattened at its thick end to receive a pile of bloom bars each about 250 pounds' weight, all of which were welded solid with each other and the bar ... The end of the shaft thus commenced was again heated to receive another pile ... the same process thus repeated until the shaft was made the length required." Cut off the porter bar at the end. 35 t in 12 working days. Swank 491 (463).
- Porter bar and capstan ring for plates: "a staff, or porter bar, with a capstan-headed ring fixed to it, is welded to one of the unfinished plates, in order that it may readily be turned on the anvil, as is usual in all large forgings." Bauerman 333 (321).
- Gun: a core of rolled bars about 8 ft long welded and drawn out; V-shaped bars packed round it (fig. 48), heated in a reverberatory furnace and forged under the largest belly helve; another series of bars, again heated; a longitudinal series; then two layers of hoops "laid at right angles to the axis"; "after two more heatings, and careful welding"; seven weeks in all. Fairbairn Iron 164-165 (137-138).
- Heats per mass: no source states a number per tonne. Only the Adriatic (one pile of about 250 lb per heat, INFERRED from the account: 35 t is about 310 piles of 113 kg; 12 working days) and the gun (seven layers, "two more heatings" at the end) are close.
- Crane: Bessemer's works moved "a 6 or 8 ton forging" with a hydraulic-traverse crane, "the ease and rapidity with which a boy can move" it. Fairbairn Iron 208-209 (181-182).
- Helves have no such clearance: the hammer was "gagged" by a large work on the anvil (Nasmyth 271), so the big built-up pieces came to the steam hammer after 1842; the gun and the Mersey armour plates are the helve's and the first steam hammers' last big jobs.
6. Die work and stamping
- Nasmyth: "At a very early period of my employment of the steam hammer, I introduced the system of stamping masses of welding hot iron as if it had been clay, and forcing it into suitable moulds or dies placed upon the anvil. This practice had been in use on a small scale in the Birmingham gun trade. The ironwork of fire-arms was thus stamped into exact form. But, until we possessed the wide range and perfectly controllable powers of the steam hammer, the stamping system was confined to comparatively small portions of forge work. The new power enabled the die and stamp system to be applied to the largest class of forge work." Nasmyth 282-283 (250-251). He contrasts it with the "bit by bit" building up from separate welded pieces.
- Woolwich, 1847: "a suitable supply of small hand steam hammers" in the Ordnance workshops; "I showed the managers and the workmen the docile powers of the steam hammer, in producing in a few minutes, by the aid of dies, many forms in wrought-iron that had heretofore occupied hours of the most skilful smiths, and that, too, in much more perfect truth and exactitude ... often complex forms of wrought-iron work were frequently required by hundreds at a time for the equipment of naval gun carriages and other purposes". Nasmyth 353-354 (317-318).
- Percy and Bauerman: swages and moulds for round bars and spherical steel shot, plain faces fixed on the hammer and anvil "by dovetailed wedges". Bauerman 308-309 (296-297); Percy 718 (698).
- Ryder's and Platt's machines forge small bolts and spindles at 700-1100 blows a minute between small anvils about 3 in square (not die forging as such). Fairbairn Iron 165-166 (138-139).
- Drop stamps before 1880, as a hammer type with dies and stock: not found in the books read. A web search (a trade-journal summary on newequipment.com, undated, secondary) attributes a "steam drop hammer" to Nasmyth's 1847 patent and an American board drop hammer to the 1860s and credits Colt's armoury with precision dies; not verified in a book. Treat as a lead only.
7. Steel ingots: tilting and cogging
- Bessemer ingots "are always more or less unsound, and require to be compacted by hammering ... raised to a bright red heat in a reheating furnace ... hammered to a smooth face under a steam hammer, and at a second heat swaged down to the form of the first groove of the rolling mill, when intended for bars or rails. The length of the ingot is extended from 4 1/2 to 8 feet under the hammer. In rolling rails two heats are required in addition." Bauerman 390 (378).
- Crucible steel and cementation: the Swedish and German steel forges use 5-6 cwt hammers at 70-120 strokes a minute, lift about 2 ft, or 3-4 cwt tilt hammers for small bars; blooms divided under the hammer into ten or twelve pieces. Bauerman 348 (336), 346 (334).
- Steel ingot vs hammer: see Section 2 last row; Bessemer patented the hydraulic press for forging steel in 1856, Haswell's hydraulic "hammer" is described as driving "nearly as quickly as a steam hammer ... owing to the substitution of an intense slow pressure, for the percussive impact of the hammer, massive foundations are not required". Fairbairn Iron 217-221 (190-194); Bauerman 310-311 (298-299).
- Ramsbottom's duplex steam hammer (two rams, 30 t tups in the newest form, no anvil, the ingot fixed upright in a carrier) works steel ingots. Bauerman 307-308 (295-296).
- Tilting a cast-steel ingot at sizes of hammer: no hammer size per ingot size beyond Park's 17 t for ingots "two feet square" (Swank 491) and Krupp's 50 t.
Gaps
- Locomotive axles and cranks, piston rods, beam gudgeons (as forgings), rolls and roll necks: not found with a hammer size. Locomotive material is only the general "uses" list (Fairbairn Mills, Fairbairn Iron).
- A rule tying hammer weight to the section of work: not stated; the ratios in section 3 are INFERRED.
- Number of heats per tonne of a built-up forging: not stated; only the porter-bar procedure and Adriatic 12 days are given.
- Percy's Condie table of dimensions (p. 699-700) is illegible in this scan; only the 15 t block is in the running text.
- Drop forging before 1880 as a separate hammer type: not found in a book. Nasmyth's die work and the Birmingham gun trade are the only sourced die-forging lines.
- Truran's remark that the steam hammer is of little use to the ironmaster (1855) conflicts with Percy and Bauerman (1864-1870) on shingling; Truran is the older and speaks of bar iron, Bauerman of "erecting new forges at the present time".
- Fairbairn Iron says patent 1833 and Swank 1838 for the invention; Nasmyth and Percy say 1839 sketch, 1842 patent (section 1).
- Percy gives the Horsfall gun as 27 t and Fairbairn as 25 t before boring; same forging (Mersey, Clay).
Table
| Part | Mass, size | Hammer that forged it | Page |
|---|---|---|---|
| Great Eastern intermediate shaft | 31.6 t | 6 t Condie, single acting | Percy 720 (700) |
| Adriatic paddle shaft | 35.6 t, 10.8 m x 699 mm | 7 t hammer, porter bar, piles of 113 kg | Swank 490-491 (462-463) |
| Adriatic crank | 8.5 t, 3.66 m stroke | same forge | Swank 490 (462) |
| Great Britain paddle shaft | 762 mm diameter | none; the hammer was invented for it | Nasmyth 271 (239) |
| Steel steamboat shaft 1883 | 13.7 t, 9.9 m | 17 t Park hammer | Swank 491 (463) |
| Anchors | whole, no mass | steam hammer from 1843 | Nasmyth 282 (250) |
| Wrought-iron gun | 25-27 t, 4.57 m x 813 mm | 10 t belly helve | Percy 714 (694); Fairbairn Iron 164-165 (137-138) |
| Hammered armour plate | over 13 t, 6.5 m x 1.9 m | steam hammer | Percy 761 (741) |
| Rolled armour plate balls and piles | 10.8 t finished | 4 t steam hammer, 6 t helve | Percy 760 (740) |
| Puddle blooms and slabs | 50-80 lb balls to bloom | 1 1/2-5 1/2 t steam hammer or 30 cwt-5 t helve | Percy 720 (700); Bauerman 301, 304 (289, 292) |
| Marine crank, single | no mass | early Creusot hammer | Nasmyth 278 (246) |
| Steel ingots, Bessemer | 4 1/2 to 8 ft drawn | steam hammer then rolls | Bauerman 390 (378) |
| Die forms, small | "hundreds at a time" | small hand steam hammers, Woolwich 1847 | Nasmyth 353-354 (317-318) |
| Piles 18 in x 70 ft | driven in 4 1/2 minutes | 4 t block, 80 blows a minute | Nasmyth 310 (276) |
| Land engine connecting rod, crank pin | wrought | not stated | Bourne 254 (238) |
| Marine shafts, cranks, rods | wrought | not stated | Bourne 295-296 (279-280) |
| Beam, flywheel shaft, mill-engine crank | cast | Bourne 253 (237); Percy 788 (762) |