Rankine, Wilson, Truran, Bauerman, Percy and Kirk on the draught of a chimney and the stack heights of the iron furnaces

Books A Manual of the Steam Engine and Other Prime Movers, A Treatise on Steam Boilers, The Iron Manufacture of Great Britain, A Treatise on the Metallurgy of Iron, Metallurgy: Iron and Steel, The Cupola Furnace, The Manufacture of Iron

Sources:

  • W. J. M. Rankine, A Manual of the Steam Engine and other Prime Movers (London, 1859). No text layer. Printed page = PDF page - 30. The formulas were read on the page images (PDF 316-318) and the text on archive.org's OCR; Articles 232-233 are printed pp. 284-290, the furnace losses pp. 292-293.
  • R. Wilson, A Treatise on Steam Boilers (London, 1873). No text layer; read from archive.org's OCR text, printed pages from the running heads. Chapter XIII (Combustion of Coal, from p. 254 on) and XIV (Smoke Prevention and Firing) are in the volume and carry no chimney draught formula and no chimney height: Wilson's only figures are the air per lb of coal and the escaping gas temperature (below). The draught rule is Rankine's.
  • W. Truran, The Iron Manufacture of Great Britain (London, 1862). Printed page = PDF page - 26.
  • H. Bauerman, A Treatise on the Metallurgy of Iron (1870 printing). Printed page = PDF page - 12.
  • J. Percy, Metallurgy: Iron and Steel (London, 1864). No text layer; archive.org's OCR text, pages from the running heads.
  • W. Kirk, The Cupola Furnace (1892, American; Ireland's cupola is English, about 1856). Printed page = PDF page - 24. Outside 1840-1880 as a book; the one figure used from it that is English describes a cupola of 1856.
  • F. Overman, The Manufacture of Iron (1851), for two figures.

The other notes on the iron furnaces were searched for "chimney" and "stack": none carries a stack height; the note on Overman's blowing says outright that its range has no 33 ft stack.

Conversions: 1 ft = 0.3048 m, 1 lb = 0.4536 kg, 1 lb/sq ft = 47.88 Pa, 1 in of water = 249.1 Pa. Cells marked COMPUTED are this note's arithmetic on the book's formula, not a book figure.

The rule (Rankine, Articles 232-233)

Rankine states the draught as the head, the height of a column of the hot gas in the chimney whose weight equals the pressure that moves the gas, and converts it to an inch of water for a siphon gauge. The terms:

SymbolMeaningUnitValue or source
Hheight of the chimney above the grateftthe design figure
hhead: draught pressure as a height of hot gasft of hot gaseq 8 or 4
T2, tau2external air, absoluteF + 461.250 F gives 511.2
tau1gas in the chimney, absoluteF + 461.2the design figure
tau0freezing point, absoluteF32 F = 493.2 (Rankine writes the 32 deg ordinate)
V0volume at 32 F of the air supplied per lb of fuelcu ft150, 225, 300 for 12, 18, 24 lb of air a lb of fuel (p. 286)
Asectional area of the chimneysq ftfor a conical chimney, the area at the top (p. 287)
uvelocity of the gasft/seq 4
wweight of fuel the furnace can completely burnlbeq 5
l, mlength of chimney plus flue; hydraulic mean depth, area / perimeter (a quarter of the diameter, round or square)ftp. 287
ffriction coefficient on sooty surfaces (Peclet)-0.012
Gresistance of grate and fuel bed (Peclet; furnaces burning 20 to 24 lb of coal per sq ft of grate)-12

The equations as printed (Rankine pp. 285-289):

  • Volume of the gas at a temperature T: V = V(32 F) x (T + 461.2) / 493.2 (p. 286, with a table of cubic feet a lb of fuel for 12, 18 and 24 lb of air from 3275 F down to 32 F; the furnace gas is taken equal in volume to the air supplied, the hydrogen's steam being neglected).
  • Density of the discharged gas, eq 3: D = (tau0 / tau1) x (0.0807 + 1 / V0) lb per cu ft; "from 0.084 to 0.087 x tau0 / tau1". 0.0807 lb per cu ft is air at 32 F.
  • Head and velocity (Peclet's formula "confirmed by practical experience"), eq 4: h = (u^2 / 2g) x (1 + G + f l / m); with the constants, eq 4A: h = (u^2 / 2g) x (13 + 0.012 l / m). g = 32.174 ft/s^2.
  • Fuel burned, eq 5: w = u A tau0 / (V0 tau1). Rankine first defines w "per second", and ends the paragraph "per hour"; the per-second reading is the one that fits the units.
  • Head as pressure, eq 6: p = h D lb per sq ft; in inches of water, eq 7: 0.192 p = 0.192 h (tau0 / tau1) (0.0807 + 1 / V0) ("the multiplier is 1 / 5.204 = 0.192").
  • Head a chimney gives, eq 8: h = H [0.96 (tau1 / tau2) - 1], and the height for a given head, eq 9: H = h / [0.96 (tau1 / tau2) - 1]. The 0.96 is 0.0807 / (0.0807 + 1 / V0) for 24 lb of air a lb of fuel (V0 = 300: 0.0807 / 0.0840). "The head produced by the draught of a chimney is equivalent to the excess of the weight of a vertical column of cool air outside the chimney, and of the same height, above that of a vertical column of equal base, of the hot gas within the chimney."
  • Best temperature, eqs 10-11 (p. 289): the weight of gas discharged goes with the velocity, which goes with the root of (0.96 tau1 - tau2), times the density; it is greatest when tau1 / tau2 = 25 / 12 (a ratio of 2.083), and then h = H. "The density of the hot gas is one-half of that of the external air." Rankine's example: external air 50 F (511.2 absolute), gas for the best draught 1065.0 absolute, "603.8" F, "a little below the temperature of melting lead"; the rule: "to insure the best possible draught through a given chimney, the temperature of the hot gas in the chimney should be nearly, but not quite, sufficient to melt lead". With 24 lb of air a lb of fuel, 650 cu ft of hot gas a lb of fuel at that temperature.
  • A chimney too hot is not cooled with cold air but by using the heat (steam, water heating); "it is never advantageous to raise the temperature in the chimney above that limit" (p. 289).
  • Cost: with the fire about 2400 F above the air and the chimney gas about 600 F above it for the best draught, "under no circumstances can it be necessary to expend more than one-fourth of the total heat of combustion for the purpose of producing a draught by means of a chimney"; "by making the chimney of large enough dimensions as compared with the grate, a much less expenditure of heat than this may be made to produce a draught sufficient for the rate of combustion" (pp. 292-293).
  • Air for combustion: chimney draught needs 24 lb of air a lb of fuel, "the weight of air required for dilution is equal to that required for combustion" (Rankine, in the article before 232, printed p. 284 by the OCR; Wilson p. 254 the same, 24 lb); "with very powerful chimney, or artificial draught" Wilson takes one and a half times the minimum, 18 lb a lb of fuel (p. 254). A blast pipe or fan needs no chimney heat.

Worked examples

Rankine gives the best-draught temperature but no printed number for a given height; these are this note's use of eqs 3, 4A, 5, 7 and 9, not book figures. V0 = 300 (24 lb air a lb of fuel), outside air 50 F.

CaseCalculationResultSource
Gas at the best temperature (604 F), H = 100 fth = H [0.96 x 1065.2 / 511.2 - 1] = 100.0 ft of hot gas; D = (493.2 / 1065.2) x 0.0840 = 0.0389 lb/cu ft; p = 3.89 lb/sq ft; x 0.1920.75 in of water; 186 Pa for 30.5 m (6.1 Pa a metre)COMPUTED from eqs 3, 7, 8
The same, gas at 500 F, H = 100 fth = 80.5 ft of hot gas, D = 0.04310.67 in of water; 166 PaCOMPUTED
Puddling stack, H = 36 ft, 604 Fh = 36.0 ft; p = 1.40 lb/sq ft0.27 in of water; 67 Pa for 11.0 mCOMPUTED
The same at 500 Fh = 29.0 ft0.24 in of water; 60 PaCOMPUTED
Fuel a flue of 24 in square can burn: H = 36 ft, 604 F, l = 36 + 20 ft of flue (assumed), m = 0.5 ftu = sqrt(2g h / (13 + 0.012 x 56 / 0.5)) = 12.7 ft/s; w = u A tau0 / (V0 tau1) with A = 4 sq ft0.0785 lb/s = 282 lb/h = 128 kg/hCOMPUTED from eqs 4A, 5

The last row is of the order of Bauerman's puddling furnace burning "from 1 1/2 to 2 cwt. per hour" (168 to 224 lb/h, 76 to 102 kg/h) on a grate of 7 to 8 sq ft (p. 267). It leaves out Truran's contraction of the flue to about a third of its area at the roof, which cuts the figure. Peclet's G = 12 holds for furnaces burning 20 to 24 lb of coal a sq ft of grate.

Rates of combustion with chimney draught (Rankine p. 285)

Rate, lb of coal a sq ft of grate an hourCase
4the slowest in Cornish boilers
10ordinary, Cornish
12 to 16ordinary, factory boilers
16 to 24ordinary, marine boilers
20 to 23quickest complete combustion of dry coal, air through the grate only
24 to 27quickest of caking coal, with air holes above the fuel (area one-sixteenth of the grate)
40 to 120locomotives, blast pipe or fan

Wilson p. 258: the gases leave the boiler at 400 to 700 F and "seldom less than 25 per cent" of the heat goes up the chimney (the escaping gas of the best draught, 604 F above, is inside that range).

The rule for height against grate and fuel

Neither Rankine nor Wilson prints a table of chimney height against grate area. The rule is the formula: the height H and the gas temperature fix the head h; the head fixes the velocity u through the resistance of the flue and grate (eq 4A); the area A of the chimney and u fix the fuel burned (eq 5). Rankine's statements:

  • "By making the chimney of large enough dimensions as compared with the grate, a much less expenditure of heat ... may be made to produce a draught sufficient for the rate of combustion" (p. 293): height or area can buy draught.
  • A conical chimney counts as a prism of its top area (p. 287).
  • The temperature in a chimney "may often be reduced with advantage considerably below that corresponding to the most effective draught", provided the heat taken out is used, as long as the draught still burns the fuel (p. 289).

The books give these empirical figures:

RuleValueSource
Boiler grates, 15 lb a sq ft an hour, "easily maintained by having a chimney-stack from 110 to 120 feet high, when the grate surface is 180 to 200 square feet"33.5 to 36.6 m for 16.7 to 18.6 m2 of grate; 2700 to 3000 lb of coal an hour (1.2 to 1.4 t)Truran 117 (PDF 143)
Flue to stack sectional area, puddlingone-fifth of the grate for bituminous coal, one-seventh for anthraciteBauerman 267 (PDF 279)
Stack for a single puddling furnace"from 30 to 50 feet high, and about 20 inches square"; when several flues are led into one, "especially when a part of the heat is taken away by passing the flame under steam boilers, it is necessary to increase the height to 100 feet or more, in order to overcome the additional resistance"Bauerman 267-268 (PDF 279-280)
Draught cannot be had through a deep bed"A chimney cannot draw through a high column of coal an amount of air sufficient to give it the requisite heat"; anthracite needs blastOverman p. 278 (PDF 278), printed page not read
Heating furnace needs a hot, tall stack"The rapid draught necessary to the production of an intense heat can be produced only by a chimney stack of the requisite height, maintained at a comparatively high temperature. If it be cold, the drawing power is reduced to a minimum"; a boiler or other conductor in the stack reduces itTruran 239-240 (PDF 265-266)
Damper cools the stacka damper at the foot of the stack opens it to a column of cold air when shut, and the stack is slow to recoverTruran 239 (PDF 265)
Mill furnace draws harder than the puddling furnace"The mill-furnace being always the hottest has a stronger draught than the puddling furnace" (Percy, on boilers heated by the waste heat of both; the informant and works names are garbled in the OCR)Percy 691

Stack heights by furnace

FurnaceStack heightIn SIOther figuresBook and page
Puddling furnace30 ft above the cast-iron framework, 36 ft altogether, "for the generality of forge coals"9.1 m above the frame, 11.0 mflue 24 in square inside, contracted at the furnace roof to about a third of that area (17 x 9 in for a coal near anthracite, 18 x 18 in for a more inflammable one); walls 1 brick for 14 ft, 1 brick for 10 ft, 1/2 brick the last 6 ft; damper at the top, worked by lever and chainTruran 207 (PDF 233)
Puddling furnace30 to 50 ft, about 20 in square, one furnace to a stack9.1 to 15.2 m100 ft or more when several flues are led to one stack past boilersBauerman 267-268
Puddling and reheating furnaces on boilers (Dowlais)150 ft, 12 ft square, flues carried in culverts of about 60 sq ft45.7 mboilers away from the forge; "no chimneys whatever in the forge"Percy 692 (Menelaus's letter)
Reheating (balling, heating, mill) furnace"has a chimney of like dimensions" to the puddling furnace'sas puddling: 36 ft, 11.0 mthe furnace is 8 or 9 in wider and 2 ft longer; fireplace area about 12 sq ft; a damper at the foot of the stack in some worksTruran 226 (PDF 252), 239 (PDF 265)
Reheating furnaceno height; its flue slopes to the stack; "a small fire is usually placed in front of the stack both in reheating and puddling furnaces"-a second fireplace at the flue end for platesBauerman 312-313 (PDF 324-325)
Crucible (steel melting) furnace"about 40 feet high, in order to command a strong draught", same section as the furnace12.2 mmelting hole 3 ft deep, 1.5 to 2 ft square, a short flue near the top into the stack; several furnaces to one stackBauerman 356 (PDF 368)
Cupola, English, c. 1856 (Ireland's)25 ft from the bottom plate to the top of the stack, 12 ft to the sill of the charging door7.6 m; 3.7 m; 3.9 m of stack above the sillcasing 50 in to the door, 2 ft 3 in at the top; blast, so not a chimney draughtKirk 157 (PDF 181)
Cupola (Ireland's, bottom tuyere)27 ft to the top, 12 ft to the sill8.2 m; 4.6 m above the sill4 ft 6 in to the door, 2 ft 6 in at the topKirk 159 (PDF 183)
Cupola, the stack where the foundry is shut in"from a few feet above the foundry roof to twenty or thirty feet"6.1 to 9.1 mthe stack "must be made of sufficient height to give the necessary draught for lighting up in all kinds of weather"; a contracted stack draws well and throws sparks, an enlarged one draws poorly "unless it is very high"Kirk 5 (PDF 29)
Blast furnace waste gas, boiler stack80 ft, 6 ft in diameter, "an overpowering draught"24.4 mgas through and under the boiler, 120 ft of flue; 4 times throughPercy 467
Boiler battery (reference)110 to 120 ft for 180 to 200 sq ft of grate at 15 lb a sq ft an hour33.5 to 36.6 m-Truran 117 (PDF 143)
Converting (cementation) furnace"conical chimney, forty or fifty feet high", to lead the smoke above the roof12.2 to 15.2 mfurnace 12 or 15 ft wide, 20 or 25 ft deepOverman (PDF 477), printed page not read

Reading the figures

  • The cupola's stack is a collar, not a chimney that draws: it takes the cupola's own blast (Kirk pp. 5, 157, 159). Its height above the charging door is 13 to 15 ft (4 to 4.6 m) in Ireland's examples, and Kirk's "twenty or thirty feet" above the roof is the limit, where the stack is the draught for lighting up.
  • The reheating furnace has no figure of its own beyond "like dimensions" (Truran p. 226), so its height is the puddling furnace's, about 36 ft (11.0 m), with the mill furnace drawing harder (Percy p. 691). The first-hand gap is that no book here prints a reheat height.
  • The crucible furnace's 40 ft (12.2 m) is the tallest of the single-furnace stacks, with the smallest grate.
  • The books give no drop for a cold stack beyond Truran's description of its effect; Rankine's rule gives h = 0 at the air's own temperature (0.96 tau1 / tau2 = 1 at tau1 / tau2 = 1.042, about 21 F above the air).
  • Rankine's coefficients are Peclet's for coal grates of 20 to 24 lb a sq ft an hour; a charcoal or coke bed, or a grate burning 10 lb, has no figure in these books.