Kirk on how a cupola's iron and fuel were measured into a charge (1899)

Books The Cupola Furnace, Metallurgy: Iron and Steel, The Manufacture and Properties of Iron and Steel

Sources: E. Kirk, The Cupola Furnace (1899), Chapter IV "Cupola Management" (pp. 78-84), Chapter V "Experiments in Melting" (pp. 113-127), Chapter IX "Scales and Their Use" (pp. 211-213), Chapter XIV "Cost of Melting" (pp. 230-231), the examples of bad melting (p. 243) and the scaffold (p. 7); J. Percy, Metallurgy: Iron and Steel (1864), the Parry cupola (p. 665); H. H. Campbell, The Manufacture and Properties of Iron and Steel (1907) (p. 107). Pages are printed folios.

Purpose: how the metal and the fuel of a cupola charge were measured out: by barrow, box, weight or count of pigs. Facts are the books'; no figure is converted or reckoned here.

Searched: Kirk, read in full text for charge, weigh, scale, barrow, basket, shovel, bushel and measure; Percy, Fairbairn (Iron, its History, Properties and Processes) and Courtney by their OCR text for "cupola"; Bolland, The Iron-Founder (1892); Johnson, The Blast Furnace; Overman; Bauerman; Swank; Truran; Bessemer's autobiography; the Lippincott Encyclopaedia of Chemistry; Campbell; Fulton on coke; Van Nostrand's 1870 magazine volume; Gill. Of these only Kirk, Percy and Campbell say anything on how a charge is measured.

0. What the books do not give

  • No book gives the weight or volume of a barrow load, a box or a basket of iron or fuel. Kirk names barrows, baskets, boxes, riddles and shovels but never what one holds, except that a basket of coal "weighed almost twice as much as the melter stated" (p. 243).
  • No book gives a count of pigs to a charge, or a pig's weight, as a way of fixing a charge. Kirk rejects the count (p. 212).
  • Bolland names the cupola only in passing (p. 10, "a knowledge of" it "indispensable") and has no charge.
  • Fairbairn and Percy use "cupola furnace" for a lightly built blast furnace (Percy, p. 361; Fairbairn, Iron, the Cupola Furnace paragraph); that is not a foundry charge and is left out.
  • Johnson, Overman, Bauerman, Swank, Truran and Bessemer mention foundry cupolas only as a place iron is remelted; none says how it was charged.
  • Kirk gives no charge in barrows or boxes, and no figure for iron to fuel by volume.

1. Kirk, charges are weights

FigureValuePageQuote
Fuel and iron in layerseach layer of fuel separated from the next by a layer of iron; this is "charging the cupola"80"This way of stocking a cupola is known as charging the cupola."
The old way, by shovelfulsfuel to fill above the tuyeres, then 50-500 lb of iron by cupola size, then 1-4 shovels of fuel and 50-200 lb of iron, repeated80"On this fuel or bed are placed from 50 to 500 pounds of iron, according to the size of the cupola, then from one to four shovels of fuel are put in and from 50 to 200 pounds of iron"
The old way, by hundredweight1 or 2 cwt of iron to 1 or 2 shovels of fuel; elsewhere 5 to 20 cwt of iron to a layer of fuel113"In some foundries one or two hundred-weight of iron were put in on the bed, then one or two shovels of fuel"
Modern chargethe iron of each charge is "the exact amount of iron the fuel will melt" while the bed settles through the melting zone; the fuel "the exact amount" to raise the bed back81"The amount of iron placed upon the bed in the first charge and in each charge through the heat must be the exact amount of iron the fuel will melt while settling from the melting point to the bottom of the melting zone."
Iron to fuel6-14 lb of iron to the pound of anthracite; 6-15 to the pound of coke82"the weight of the charges of iron to the charges of anthracite coal varies from 6 to 14 pounds of iron to the pound of coal. With coke they vary from 6 to 15 pounds of iron to the pound of coke"
First chargeone-third to one-half heavier than later charges; 2.5-4.5 times the weight of the bed with anthracite, 1.5-4.5 times with coke81-82"The weight of the first charge of iron varies from two and one-half to four and one-half times the weight of the bed"
Bedchanged by 50-100 lb of fuel a heat; no weight can be given for a bed by cupola diameter, because tuyere heights differ78-79"No definite or even approximate weight can be given of the amount of fuel required for a bed in cupolas of different diameters"
Charge in his trial cupolairon charges of 4 to 8 cwt with fuel at 1 lb to 10 lb of iron: 4 cwt with 40 lb coke, 5 cwt with 50 lb, 6 with 60, 7 with 70, 8 with 80125-126"we made the charges of fuel placed between the charges of iron at a ratio of one pound of fuel to ten pounds of iron"
Best charges there4 and 5 cwt even; 6 cwt good on a 20 in bed; 8 cwt went dull126-127"the most even melting was done with four and five hundred weight charges"

Kirk's charge is always given as a weight of iron and a weight of fuel. The one volume he gives is the shovelful of the old practice (p. 80).

2. Kirk on weighing

FigureValuePageQuote
The scale"nothing more essential" to good melting and mixing than an accurate weighing scale on the scaffold by the charging door; platform scales on wheels, platform about 2 ft up or level with the door211"There is nothing more essential to the good melting and mixing of iron, than an accurate weighing scale upon the scaffold near the cupola charging door."
Room for itthe scaffold large enough to put a weighing scale in front of the charging door, with iron and fuel for several heats7"The scaffold should be made large enough to place a weighing scale in front of the charging door"
A box on the scalewhere much light scrap, gates and sprews are remelted, an iron box of boiler plate, open at one end for shovelling out, stands on the scale211"an iron box made of boiler plate and open at one end for shoveling out iron and fuel should be placed upon the scales"
Scale sizea 1 or 2 ton scale serves almost any cupola; iron and fuel are weighed in charges "or drafts" seldom over that; large pieces are weighed in the yard211"A one or two ton scale is sufficient for charging almost any cupola"
Barrows on floor scalesscales in the scaffold floor, on which barrows of iron and fuel are weighed as they are brought up, give the weight of stock used but not the division into charges, unless the stock goes direct from the barrow to the cupola, "which is seldom done"211"they are of no value in dividing it into charges if the stock is not charged direct from the barrows into the cupola, which is seldom done"
Weighed in the yard, guessed in charginga melter given weighed stock but no scale at the door cannot divide it evenly212"the melter cannot in charging divide it evenly"
Scrap and pigsno melter can guess the weight of a mixed lot of scrap, sprews and gates, or "accurately estimate the weight of pig iron by counting the pigs"212"No melter can guess the weight of a promiscuous lot of scrap, sprews, gates, etc., or accurately estimate the weight of pig iron by counting the pigs."
Fuel by countcounting shovels, riddles or baskets of fuel is "the greatest fallacy of all": riddles and baskets hold more the longer they are used, shovels hold less, and extra shovelfuls are added212-213"The counting of shovels, riddles or baskets of fuel in charging is the greatest fallacy of all"
Baskets stretchan old basket holds one-third more than a new; 10-20 lb more can be piled on top of a full one230"an old basket frequently holds one-third more than a new one"
Fuel to be weighed"every pound of fuel that goes into the cupola should be accurately weighed", with a check on the melter231"every pound of fuel that goes into the cupola should be accurately weighed"
Worn scalesan old worn scale from another part of the works is guess-work213"The weighing of cupola stock upon such scales is only guess-work"

3. Kirk on how the charge goes in

FigureValuePageQuote
Not from a barrowiron or fuel must never be dumped from a barrow, since it all falls on one side and good melting cannot be done with the fuel on one side and the iron on the other84"Iron or fuel should never be dumped into a cupola from a barrow, for it all falls on one side of the cupola."
Not from a basket or boxfuel must not be emptied from a basket or box; it falls in one place84"Fuel should never be emptied into a cupola from a basket or box, for it all falls in one place"
By handthe iron is thrown in by hand, the fuel by shovel or fork84"the iron must all be thrown in with the hands, and the fuel with a shovel or fork"
Placingpig broken to short pieces and set end to the lining, close together; gates and scrap on top to level; fuel spread evenly over the iron82-83"The pig should be broken into short pieces and placed in the cupola with the end toward the lining."
A basket-fed cupolaa cupola charged with coal "measured in a basket and dumped from the basket"; the basket weighed almost twice what the melter said, and the melter was getting about 3 lb of iron to the pound of coal, not the 7 he claimed243"the coal when charged was not weighed, but measured in a basket and dumped from the basket into the cupola"

4. Other books

BookFactPageQuote
Percy (1864), Parry's cupola for wrought scrapa patent charge given by weight: about 7 cwt of coke to the ton of wrought iron, put in as 1.25-1.5 cwt of coke to 4 cwt of iron at a time, "a convenient quantity for each charge"665"applying these materials in successive quantities of from 1 1/4 cwt. to 1 1/2 cwt. of coke to 4 cwts. of iron, which will be found a convenient quantity for each charge"
Campbell (1907), steelworks cupolaslarge pieces of scrap picked out of vessel slag are "returned to the cupolas without reweighing"; INFERRED: scrap is weighed before it is charged107"these are generally returned to the cupolas without reweighing"

5. What this establishes

  • Kirk measures a cupola charge by weight, fuel and iron each. He condemns the count of pigs, shovels, riddles and baskets as guess-work (pp. 212-213, 230-231), and gives the scale, with or without a boiler-plate box on it, as the remedy (p. 211).
  • A barrow is a carrier to the scale or the scaffold, not a measure: floor scales weigh barrows as they arrive (p. 211), and the charge is not tipped from the barrow (p. 84).
  • The books give no barrow, box or pig count that stands for a charge. A charge in weights is the only form the books carry: 4-8 cwt of iron to a layer of fuel in Kirk's trial cupola (pp. 126-127), 50-500 lb in the old way for the first layers (p. 80), Percy's 4 cwt of iron to 1.25-1.5 cwt of coke (p. 665).
  • Kirk never says that a charge was a number of boxes or barrows.