Spencer, Roll-Turning for Sections in Steel and Iron (1894)

Books Roll-Turning for Sections in Steel and Iron

Covers A. Spencer, "Roll-Turning for Sections in Steel and Iron" (2nd edition, 1894, 188 PDF pages). The book is folded plates of roll drawings with about eight pages of text: the preface (unnumbered, PDF 13-14), the appendix introduction (pp. i-iv, PDF 17-20) and the lists of plates (PDF 9-11, 21-24, with the key to Plate LXXVIII on pp. vii-viii). There are no folios on the plates, so plates are cited by number and PDF page. The text layer is OCR of the plate captions and little else; PDF pages 1, 3-4, 6, 8, 12, 16, 26 and most even pages from 26 to 188 carry no text (the backs and fold-outs of plates). The plates were read as images at 110-500 dpi: I, II and its erratum, III (the blooming and billet rolls), LVII-LXVI (three-high guide and bar mills, 8 to 18 in.), LXXII and LXXIV (billet blooming, flat and edge grooves) and LXXVIII (the method of drawing grooves). Skipped: IV-LVI (rails, sleepers, girders, bulbs, angles, tees, tram rails), LXVII-LXXI (sash bars, saddles, colliery rails, large rounds), LXXIII and LXXV-LXXVII. Numbers marked "read off the scan" come from small italic figures that the scan only partly resolves; the Fig. I ratios were measured in pixels off a 200 dpi render. Purpose what the book says about roll turning: the groove families, the draughts, the spread and the schedules of the blooming, billet and bar mills.

What the book says

The frame (preface, PDF 13-14; appendix pp. i-iv)

  • The drawings are "working drawings - that is, drawings of rolls which have passed through the ordeal of actual work". Size of train, speed of rolls, temperature of the material and "the setting of the rolls by the roller" all govern the result; the book gives no roll speeds.
  • The collars are tapered where the top roll fits into the bottom "to provide for sinking and dressing, and thus take up the slack occasioned by wear" (PDF 13): a worn groove is re-turned deeper, not replaced.
  • The appendix mills are "three-high roughing rolls, with grooves for finishing in two-high rolls", for 8, 10, 12 and 14 in. mills (p. i). The 14 in. mill with three-high roughing is the Cleveland district mill "where guide iron, medium sized merchant-bars, small rails, fish plates, and light sections are rolled in large quantities" (p. ii).
  • Terms (pp. ii-iii): "Spread" is "an allowance in width of groove, so that the piece or bar may enter each succeeding groove easily". "Contraction": the hot bar is larger than the cold, about 1 in 77 on Plate LXXVII, 1 in 42 from a pair of hot and cold templates. "Spring" is the bending of the rolls under the draught. "Space": the collars are drawn touching but run clear in practice. "Tailoring" rounds the collar edges so the bar does not fin.
  • The erratum to Plate XXIII (PDF 72): "The width of grooves in blooming should be less than those in the roughing, and those of the roughing less than the finishing ... This necessary 'spread' every roll-turner will provide for."
  • Plate LXXVIII: squares are drawn at 92 degrees, diamonds and Gothics at 95.5 degrees, "some roll-turners use ... 100 degrees" (p. ii).

The slab roll (Plate I, PDF 25)

  • "Bloom roll (one of pair) for steel plate slabs. Top roll arranged to lift 30 inches." Between the outer collars: a 6 in. collar, a 14 in. edging groove turned to 24 in., a 3 1/2 in. collar, a plain body 48 in. long at 34 in., a 3 1/2 in. collar, a 9 in. edging groove at 29 in., a 6 in. collar. Collars 36 in., necks 20 in., wobblers 18 in. The plain body is 48 of the 90 in. between the outer collars.

Cogging and billets (Plate II and its erratum, PDF 27-29)

  • "Cogging and billet rolls 9'0" x 36"", "to take an ingot 14 in. sq. at small end and 15 in. sq. at large end", top roll balanced (a screw-down on the cogging end).
  • One barrel carries the whole schedule: box grooves 15 in. wide (depth left open), 8 x 8, 8 wide (a shallower box, read off the scan), 6 x 6 1/4 and a chamfered box of about 6 1/2, then squares set on edge measured face to face (PDF 28): 5 3/4, 5, 4 1/4, 3 5/8, 3, 2 1/2, 2 1/8, 1 3/4, 1 1/2 in.
  • The on-edge squares step down by 3/4, 3/4, 5/8, 5/8, 1/2, 3/8, 3/8, 1/4 in.: on one 36 in. roll the draught shrinks with the section. Side to side each is 0.82-0.87 of the last.

Blooming (Plate III, PDF 31)

  • "Blooming for 7 x 7 blooms", top roll, 40 in. marked either side of the pass line, 8 ft 11 1/16 in. long. Six box grooves, 1 1/2 and 4 in. collars, "Note: Pass twice through each hole."
  • Groove widths at the collar / at the bottom: 16 1/8 / 15 3/4, 14 1/4 / 13 1/8, 12 11/16 / 12 3/8, 10 7/8 / 10 5/8, 9 1/8 / 8 7/8, 7 1/16 / 7 1/16. Depths of the first four: 13 3/4, 12 1/4, 10 1/2, 8 3/4 (the last two read off the scan as about 7).
  • So a 15-16 in. ingot takes about 2 in. in its first pass and 1 1/2-1 3/4 in. a groove after: 0.04-0.05 of the roll's diameter. Each groove is 0.83-0.89 of the one before.

Billet blooming (Plate LXXII, PDF 171; a 34 in. train)

  • Collars 34 1/4 and 31 in. Six box grooves from 8 in. deep by 9 1/2 wide down to about 4 1/2 in., then squares on edge 4 1/2, 3 3/4, 3 1/4 and 3 in. "Note: The two first grooves to be used twice viz: piece to be edged & made square."
  • Plate LXXIV (PDF 175): "Flat & edge leading grooves to roughing for large rounds" - four box grooves the piece takes flat and on edge in turn before the Gothics.

Merchant bar and guide mills (Plates LVII-LXVI, PDF 141-159)

  • 8 in. guide mill, Welsh practice (LVII-LVIII): first roughing three-high - a box, two Gothics, flattened ovals and diamonds, eight grooves plus six more diamonds; second roughing three-high, eleven diamonds and eight ovals; finishing two-high, eight rounds 5/8 to 3/16 in., one oval to each round.
  • 10 in. guide mill, north of England practice (LIX-LX): two boxes, then twelve diamonds in the first roughing; the second roughing's ovals are labelled "works into 1/2 diamond", "works into 3/8 diamond", interleaving two size series on one roll; finishing rounds 1 1/16 down to about 3/16 in.
  • 12 in. bar mill (LXI-LXII): four boxes then thirteen Gothics on the three-high roughing; the finishing roll carries sixteen rounds, 1 9/16 to 5/8 in., collar to collar.
  • 14 in. bar and guide mill (LXIII, 6 ft 6 in. rolls, necks 7 1/2 in. by 8 in.): three rolls; four box grooves worked forward through the lower pair and back through the upper pair (lower pass depths 6, 5 3/4, 4 3/4, 3 1/2 in., upper about 5 1/4, 4 1/2, 3 5/8, 3 1/4, read off the scan), then some twenty Gothics and diamonds, and a flat groove at the far end. Collars about 11 1/2 in., groove bottoms 7 1/4 to 11 in.
  • 16 and 18 in. mills (LXV-LXVI): two-high roughing, four box grooves (18 in.: 8, 6 3/4, 6 5/8, 5 5/8 in. wide at the bottom, groove bottoms 11 7/8-12 7/8 in. against 20 in. collars), four Gothics at 18 1/8 in., and a shaped leader.
  • In every plate the grooves of one family stand side by side along the barrel in descending order, and a given bar uses a run of them, not all.

The groove scale (Plate LXXVIII, PDF 183; key pp. vii-viii)

  • Fig. I is one triangle ruled with fifteen lines, "the horizontal lines numbered 1 to 15 represent draughts of a corresponding number of grooves for Gothic, and Diamond, roughing rolls". Measured off the scan each line stands 0.85-0.91 of the one below from the apex: fifteen grooves at about 0.89 each, the draught shrinking in proportion to the section. Squares, diamonds and Gothics are all read off it (Figs. IV-VI).

Against Overman

  • Overman's roughing grooves reduce "in the proportion of the squares of eleven to fifteen" (Overman p. 347, recorded in the Overman note): 0.73 side to side. No consecutive pair on Spencer's plates is that steep: 0.83-0.89 on the blooming roll, 0.82-0.87 on the billet end, about 0.89 on the scale. Spencer is steel in 1894, Overman puddled iron in 1851. Spencer gives no roll speeds, so Overman's 30-40 rpm stands neither confirmed nor overturned.