Ten period books against each other
Books The Manufacture of Iron, Modern Machine-Shop Practice, The Iron-Founder, Roll-Turning for Sections in Steel and Iron, The Cupola Furnace, Coke, The Manufacture and Properties of Iron and Steel, Bolt, Nut and Rivet Forging, Blast-Furnace Construction in America, The Principles, Operation and Products of the Blast Furnace
Covers the ten book digests of 2026-09-24 in this folder: Overman 1851, Rose 1887/1901, Bolland 1892, Spencer 1894, Kirk 1899, Fulton 1905, Campbell 1907, Hamilton 1914, Johnson-C (Blast-Furnace Construction) 1917 and Johnson-P (Principles, Operation and Products) 1918. Where two digests conflicted the book text decided it: Overman pp. 450-451, Campbell pp. 206, 409, 411, Rose pp. 441-442. Pages are the books' printed folios. Subject how the books judge each other: the claim each row tests, the first reading, the later book and the verdict.
| # | Claim at stake | First reading | Later book | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | hot blast "cut fuel by roughly two thirds" | Overman: 30-60 % on coke, 20 % on hard charcoal (p. 442) | Johnson-P: Clyde 3.42 : 1 cold to 600 F blast, a 72 % cut (p. 39) | Stands for coke. Charcoal gained less: 1.7 : 1 (Johnson-P p. 39) |
| 2 | "The 48-72 h real cycle" | Overman: 10-12 h coking, 8-10 h cooling (p. 125) | Fulton: 48 h on 5 t at 23 in., 72 h on 6 t at 26.5 in. (p. 158) | Stands. Depth sets the time; Overman's 12 in. charge is about a day at Fulton's rate (p. 192) |
| 3 | charcoal is the lean charge that needs pressure | Overman (pp. 170-171, 426) | Johnson-P (pp. 41, 50, 183), Johnson-C (p. 99), Kirk (p. 343), Fulton p. 328 | Confirmed by five: charcoal took the weakest blast. Its weak body capped furnace size (Johnson-P p. 183, Fulton p. 328), so charcoal's weak body capped furnace size, which is the lean-charge half of the claim, and its "high pressure" is the half that fails |
| 4 | standard flux 3-8 % | Overman: Phoenixville about 30 % lime (p. 182) | Johnson-P: charcoal about 8 % (p. 51), coke 14-24 % of ore and stone (pp. 268-271); Kirk: cupola 1-5 % (pp. 84, 137) | The band is charcoal practice; coke ran two to three times it. |
| 5 | "stiff tap cinder, not a pour" | Overman: tapped into a hand-cart (p. 270) | Campbell: tappings drawn from the bottom or left and charged with the next heat (p. 88) | Confirmed: tappings were drawn off |
| 6 | loss "8-12 %" | Overman: 4-5 % on good white metal, 20 % and more on bad (pp. 301-302) | Campbell prints no loss | One book |
| 7 | "capture needed a closed top (Parry's cup-and-cone, 1850)" | Johnson-C: pipe stoves over open tops, flues below the stock line (pp. 100, 285) | Overman, 1851: charcoal furnaces take gas from the top chimney; coke and anthracite furnaces tap it 3-4 ft below the top to boilers and the hot-blast stove, "generally adopted" (pp. 450-451) | Confirmed by the earlier book |
| 8 | "Skip hoists belong to the hot blast era" | Johnson-C: skips first worked at Edgar Thomson; barrows stayed after the closed top (pp. 48, 61-62) | Overman: barrows, a suspension railroad and a water-balance hoist on 1851 hot-blast furnaces (pp. 191-194) | Confirmed |
| 9 | "iron checkers inside a brick shell" | Johnson-C: brick checkers in a riveted plate shell (pp. 192, 202) | Campbell: regenerators of brick checkers at about 1000 C (pp. 123, 126, 129-131) | Confirmed |
| 10 | "Raw coal crushes to dust under the burden column" | Johnson-P: coke never crushes; raw coal failed by tar and low porosity (pp. 170, 184-186) | Kirk: raw anthracite in cupolas (pp. 78, 130); Fulton: anthracite bears the highest furnace (p. 328); Overman: Phoenixville on anthracite (p. 182) | Confirmed by four: crushing is charcoal's fault |
| 11 | "A fuller hearth is a colder hearth ... Intended" | Johnson-P: stock kept at the stock line; a furnace let down loses its top-gas heat (pp. 2, 324-325) | Kirk: a high cupola melts more on less fuel; keep it charged to the door (pp. 13, 85) | Confirmed. Warming of the charge by the gas exists, but the net rule runs opposite |
| 12 | "Draining runs only while the furnace is Melting" | Johnson-P: a chilling furnace is cast through any opening (pp. 334, 355-364) | Kirk: when iron runs dull "draw all the melted iron off at once" (p. 339) | Confirmed |
| 13 | "Blast demand is a property of the charge" | Johnson-P: pressure follows volume, rises when too hot (pp. 302, 311-312) | Kirk: volume melts; gauge pressure is tuyere restriction (pp. 117-118, 293) | Confirmed |
| 14 | "Coke burns whenever the furnace is lit" | Johnson-P settles banking against on this line (pp. 333-335) | Kirk: cupolas banked overnight with tuyeres shut (pp. 276-279, 340-341) | No conflict: a reduced smoulder keeps the line |
| 15 | the cupola carburises by contact | Kirk: iron dripped through a bed "very little softened" (pp. 131-132, 143-145) | Campbell: steel and iron in a cupola change "by absorption of carbon" (p. 409); sulphur rises (p. 110) | Kirk overturned for steel scrap; the sentences stand |
| 16 | "Bessemer plants kept a cupola melting spiegeleisen" | Kirk: not in Kirk | Campbell: melted spiegel run into vessel or ladle (p. 112); the open hearth could not, "a cupola becomes chilled" on its irregular charges (p. 206) | Confirmed |
| 17 | cast coarse gear, cut meshing gear, "the boring mill's close cousin" | Bolland: wheels moulded with teeth, "a great demand" (pp. 305-324, 312) | Rose: a wheel that runs "without noise or jar" is finished in a gear-cutting machine (p. 34); cast wheels kept in stock (p. 64) | Bolland overturned: cast coarse gear and cut meshing gear stay apart (Rose, pp. 36, 45) |
| 18 | against : is the cylinder turned first | Bolland: the cylinder is bored, its ports cored (pp. 157, 250-255) | Rose: bolted to the table, bored and both ends faced at one setting, outside as cast (p. 219); cored ports trued through a false plate in 30 min (pp. 441-442) | Bored and faced at one setting, no lathe step. Cored ports and trued ports are one practice |
| 19 | life "wrought < cast < crucible steel" | Rose: every cutter is crucible tool steel, graded by temper (pp. 254, 444) | Hamilton: chilled cast-iron nut dies outlast carbon steel eight times (p. 39) | Confirmed and widened: no metal ladder for cutters, no monotone one for dies |
| 20 | wear "does not degrade the product" | Rose: a worn reamer shrinks its holes (p. 283) | Hamilton: fins grow as tools wear (p. 35) | Both point the other way |
| 21 | re-make or re-grind a worn tool | Spencer: collars tapered "for sinking and dressing" (PDF 13) | Rose: tools reground, drills resharpened by 1/64 in. (pp. 271, 278, 289); Hamilton: dies turned to a fresh groove, redressed (pp. 21, 41) | Three books: re-grind |
| 22 | every gap 0.5 below the last | Overman: roughing grooves reduce as "the squares of eleven to fifteen", 0.73 a side (p. 347) | Spencer: 0.82-0.89 a groove (Plates II, III, LXXVIII) | Both proportional, neither uniform; steepness differs (puddled iron 1851, steel 1894) |
| 23 | coked without air | Overman: bricked door with draught holes, a 20-24 in. crown hole (pp. 123-125) | Fulton: "air partially excluded", gas burned in the crown to the 24th hour (pp. 145, 193) | Confirmed |
| 24 | yield 0.9, "more efficient" | Overman: 75 % a good English yield (pp. 130-132) | Fulton: beehive 63-66 %, closed ovens 70-73 % (pp. 137, 348-349); the crown burns carbon (p. 167) | Both below 0.9 |
| 25 | beehive "from the 1830s" | Overman describes Pittsburgh, English and Silesian ovens in 1851 (pp. 123-128) | Fulton: grown "through a century and a half" by 1905 (p. 148) | Earlier than the 1830s |
| 26 | a top flame that shows the state of the furnace (Overman) | Johnson-C: the open-top flame "visible at night for miles" at cold-blast charcoal furnaces (pp. 100, 285) | Johnson-P: taller as the stock falls (pp. 324-325); Kirk: none charged to the door, blue then yellow as the stock sinks (p. 85) | Confirmed, with a second axis: size reads the stockline, character reads the state |
| 27 | a glow at the tuyere (Overman) | Johnson-C: a peep glass on every tuyere (p. 283) | Kirk: a healthy cupola tuyere darkens under cold blast in minutes (p. 89) | Confirmed for the blast furnaces; on the cupola dark is not a fault |
| 28 | smoke from the coke chamber (Overman) | - | Fulton: gas heaviest to the 24th hour, flaming ceases before drawing (p. 193) | Confirmed, with its profile |
| 29 | flux as a heat load (Overman) | - | Johnson-P: charcoal slag runs free near 1260 C (p. 50); Johnson-C: cold-blast hearths at 1204-1316 C (p. 233) | The two books agree |
| 30 | reheat burn-off and blast humidity (Overman) | - | Campbell: 1-2 % lost to scale in coal-fired reheating (p. 170); Johnson-P: 20 % more fuel in summer (pp. 31, 38, 368) | Corroborated |
| 31 | Slag quantities | Johnson-P: blast furnace 6 : 1 iron to slag against 1.8 : 1 on coke, 4.5 : 1 on charcoal (pp. 48, 219, 270) | Kirk: cupola 13 % against 1-5 % (pp. 84, 137-142); Campbell: converter 6 % against 12 % (p. 107) | Off both ways: too little slag on the blast furnace and converter, too much on the cupola |