Ten period books against each other

Books The Manufacture of Iron, Modern Machine-Shop Practice, The Iron-Founder, Roll-Turning for Sections in Steel and Iron, The Cupola Furnace, Coke, The Manufacture and Properties of Iron and Steel, Bolt, Nut and Rivet Forging, Blast-Furnace Construction in America, The Principles, Operation and Products of the Blast Furnace

Covers the ten book digests of 2026-09-24 in this folder: Overman 1851, Rose 1887/1901, Bolland 1892, Spencer 1894, Kirk 1899, Fulton 1905, Campbell 1907, Hamilton 1914, Johnson-C (Blast-Furnace Construction) 1917 and Johnson-P (Principles, Operation and Products) 1918. Where two digests conflicted the book text decided it: Overman pp. 450-451, Campbell pp. 206, 409, 411, Rose pp. 441-442. Pages are the books' printed folios. Subject how the books judge each other: the claim each row tests, the first reading, the later book and the verdict.

#Claim at stakeFirst readingLater bookVerdict
1hot blast "cut fuel by roughly two thirds"Overman: 30-60 % on coke, 20 % on hard charcoal (p. 442)Johnson-P: Clyde 3.42 : 1 cold to 600 F blast, a 72 % cut (p. 39)Stands for coke. Charcoal gained less: 1.7 : 1 (Johnson-P p. 39)
2"The 48-72 h real cycle"Overman: 10-12 h coking, 8-10 h cooling (p. 125)Fulton: 48 h on 5 t at 23 in., 72 h on 6 t at 26.5 in. (p. 158)Stands. Depth sets the time; Overman's 12 in. charge is about a day at Fulton's rate (p. 192)
3charcoal is the lean charge that needs pressureOverman (pp. 170-171, 426)Johnson-P (pp. 41, 50, 183), Johnson-C (p. 99), Kirk (p. 343), Fulton p. 328Confirmed by five: charcoal took the weakest blast. Its weak body capped furnace size (Johnson-P p. 183, Fulton p. 328), so charcoal's weak body capped furnace size, which is the lean-charge half of the claim, and its "high pressure" is the half that fails
4standard flux 3-8 %Overman: Phoenixville about 30 % lime (p. 182)Johnson-P: charcoal about 8 % (p. 51), coke 14-24 % of ore and stone (pp. 268-271); Kirk: cupola 1-5 % (pp. 84, 137)The band is charcoal practice; coke ran two to three times it.
5"stiff tap cinder, not a pour"Overman: tapped into a hand-cart (p. 270)Campbell: tappings drawn from the bottom or left and charged with the next heat (p. 88)Confirmed: tappings were drawn off
6loss "8-12 %"Overman: 4-5 % on good white metal, 20 % and more on bad (pp. 301-302)Campbell prints no lossOne book
7"capture needed a closed top (Parry's cup-and-cone, 1850)"Johnson-C: pipe stoves over open tops, flues below the stock line (pp. 100, 285)Overman, 1851: charcoal furnaces take gas from the top chimney; coke and anthracite furnaces tap it 3-4 ft below the top to boilers and the hot-blast stove, "generally adopted" (pp. 450-451)Confirmed by the earlier book
8"Skip hoists belong to the hot blast era"Johnson-C: skips first worked at Edgar Thomson; barrows stayed after the closed top (pp. 48, 61-62)Overman: barrows, a suspension railroad and a water-balance hoist on 1851 hot-blast furnaces (pp. 191-194)Confirmed
9"iron checkers inside a brick shell"Johnson-C: brick checkers in a riveted plate shell (pp. 192, 202)Campbell: regenerators of brick checkers at about 1000 C (pp. 123, 126, 129-131)Confirmed
10"Raw coal crushes to dust under the burden column"Johnson-P: coke never crushes; raw coal failed by tar and low porosity (pp. 170, 184-186)Kirk: raw anthracite in cupolas (pp. 78, 130); Fulton: anthracite bears the highest furnace (p. 328); Overman: Phoenixville on anthracite (p. 182)Confirmed by four: crushing is charcoal's fault
11"A fuller hearth is a colder hearth ... Intended"Johnson-P: stock kept at the stock line; a furnace let down loses its top-gas heat (pp. 2, 324-325)Kirk: a high cupola melts more on less fuel; keep it charged to the door (pp. 13, 85)Confirmed. Warming of the charge by the gas exists, but the net rule runs opposite
12"Draining runs only while the furnace is Melting"Johnson-P: a chilling furnace is cast through any opening (pp. 334, 355-364)Kirk: when iron runs dull "draw all the melted iron off at once" (p. 339)Confirmed
13"Blast demand is a property of the charge"Johnson-P: pressure follows volume, rises when too hot (pp. 302, 311-312)Kirk: volume melts; gauge pressure is tuyere restriction (pp. 117-118, 293)Confirmed
14"Coke burns whenever the furnace is lit"Johnson-P settles banking against on this line (pp. 333-335)Kirk: cupolas banked overnight with tuyeres shut (pp. 276-279, 340-341)No conflict: a reduced smoulder keeps the line
15the cupola carburises by contactKirk: iron dripped through a bed "very little softened" (pp. 131-132, 143-145)Campbell: steel and iron in a cupola change "by absorption of carbon" (p. 409); sulphur rises (p. 110)Kirk overturned for steel scrap; the sentences stand
16"Bessemer plants kept a cupola melting spiegeleisen"Kirk: not in KirkCampbell: melted spiegel run into vessel or ladle (p. 112); the open hearth could not, "a cupola becomes chilled" on its irregular charges (p. 206)Confirmed
17cast coarse gear, cut meshing gear, "the boring mill's close cousin"Bolland: wheels moulded with teeth, "a great demand" (pp. 305-324, 312)Rose: a wheel that runs "without noise or jar" is finished in a gear-cutting machine (p. 34); cast wheels kept in stock (p. 64)Bolland overturned: cast coarse gear and cut meshing gear stay apart (Rose, pp. 36, 45)
18against : is the cylinder turned firstBolland: the cylinder is bored, its ports cored (pp. 157, 250-255)Rose: bolted to the table, bored and both ends faced at one setting, outside as cast (p. 219); cored ports trued through a false plate in 30 min (pp. 441-442)Bored and faced at one setting, no lathe step. Cored ports and trued ports are one practice
19life "wrought < cast < crucible steel"Rose: every cutter is crucible tool steel, graded by temper (pp. 254, 444)Hamilton: chilled cast-iron nut dies outlast carbon steel eight times (p. 39)Confirmed and widened: no metal ladder for cutters, no monotone one for dies
20wear "does not degrade the product"Rose: a worn reamer shrinks its holes (p. 283)Hamilton: fins grow as tools wear (p. 35)Both point the other way
21re-make or re-grind a worn toolSpencer: collars tapered "for sinking and dressing" (PDF 13)Rose: tools reground, drills resharpened by 1/64 in. (pp. 271, 278, 289); Hamilton: dies turned to a fresh groove, redressed (pp. 21, 41)Three books: re-grind
22every gap 0.5 below the lastOverman: roughing grooves reduce as "the squares of eleven to fifteen", 0.73 a side (p. 347)Spencer: 0.82-0.89 a groove (Plates II, III, LXXVIII)Both proportional, neither uniform; steepness differs (puddled iron 1851, steel 1894)
23coked without airOverman: bricked door with draught holes, a 20-24 in. crown hole (pp. 123-125)Fulton: "air partially excluded", gas burned in the crown to the 24th hour (pp. 145, 193)Confirmed
24yield 0.9, "more efficient"Overman: 75 % a good English yield (pp. 130-132)Fulton: beehive 63-66 %, closed ovens 70-73 % (pp. 137, 348-349); the crown burns carbon (p. 167)Both below 0.9
25beehive "from the 1830s"Overman describes Pittsburgh, English and Silesian ovens in 1851 (pp. 123-128)Fulton: grown "through a century and a half" by 1905 (p. 148)Earlier than the 1830s
26a top flame that shows the state of the furnace (Overman)Johnson-C: the open-top flame "visible at night for miles" at cold-blast charcoal furnaces (pp. 100, 285)Johnson-P: taller as the stock falls (pp. 324-325); Kirk: none charged to the door, blue then yellow as the stock sinks (p. 85)Confirmed, with a second axis: size reads the stockline, character reads the state
27a glow at the tuyere (Overman)Johnson-C: a peep glass on every tuyere (p. 283)Kirk: a healthy cupola tuyere darkens under cold blast in minutes (p. 89)Confirmed for the blast furnaces; on the cupola dark is not a fault
28smoke from the coke chamber (Overman)-Fulton: gas heaviest to the 24th hour, flaming ceases before drawing (p. 193)Confirmed, with its profile
29flux as a heat load (Overman)-Johnson-P: charcoal slag runs free near 1260 C (p. 50); Johnson-C: cold-blast hearths at 1204-1316 C (p. 233)The two books agree
30reheat burn-off and blast humidity (Overman)-Campbell: 1-2 % lost to scale in coal-fired reheating (p. 170); Johnson-P: 20 % more fuel in summer (pp. 31, 38, 368)Corroborated
31Slag quantitiesJohnson-P: blast furnace 6 : 1 iron to slag against 1.8 : 1 on coke, 4.5 : 1 on charcoal (pp. 48, 219, 270)Kirk: cupola 13 % against 1-5 % (pp. 84, 137-142); Campbell: converter 6 % against 12 % (p. 107)Off both ways: too little slag on the blast furnace and converter, too much on the cupola