Overman, Bauerman and Swank on the bloomery's make and fuel (1851-1892)
Books The Manufacture of Iron, A Treatise on the Metallurgy of Iron, History of the Manufacture of Iron in All Ages
Sources: Frederick Overman, The Manufacture of Iron (Philadelphia, 1851), the Catalan forge (pp. 245-248) and General Remarks (p. 383); H. Bauerman, A Treatise on the Metallurgy of Iron (London, 1870 printing), Chapter XII (pp. 237-241); J. M. Swank, History of the Manufacture of Iron in All Ages (Philadelphia, 1892) (pp. 97, 129, 142-143, 341-342); Agricola, De Re Metallica, Hoover translation, by the Agricola note (pp. 420-423). Pages are printed folios; PDF page = folio + 6 in Overman, + 12 in Bauerman, + 28 in Swank.
Purpose: a period bloomery's make and fuel per weight of iron. Facts are the books'; INFERRED marks arithmetic or a reading added here. Metric is converted here (1 lb = 0.4536 kg, 1 cwt = 50.80 kg, 1 long ton = 1016 kg, 1 net ton = 907 kg, 1 cu ft = 0.02832 m3, 1 in Hg = 3.386 kPa); a charcoal bushel is Overman's 15-16 lb (p. 117), taken at 15.5 lb (7.03 kg).
0. What the books do not give
- Percy's Iron and Steel carries the Catalan process, but the scan has no text layer and its note did not read it; nothing here is from Percy.
- Overman gives no hours for a Catalan heat end to end, only the first blast of 1.5-2 h; the make a fire is the weekly make of the hammer that serves two fires.
- Agricola gives no charcoal for the hearth bloomery.
- No book gives a bloomery's make per volume of air; Overman's air for a "charcoal forge" (p. 401) is the only figure.
- The week: Overman's forge week and his furnace week are both "a week", with no day count. The stueckofen digest (the air furnace note, Beck I p. 823) has German smelters working Monday to Saturday; American blast furnaces ran through.
1. Overman, the Catalan forge or blomary fire
| Figure | Value | Metric | Page | Quote |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Name | the Catalan forge, called the blomary fire in Vermont and New Jersey, smelting magnetic ore | - | 245 | "This forge is extensively employed in Vermont and New Jersey, to smelt the magnetic ores of these States. It is there called the blomary fire." |
| Hearth | stone hearth 6-8 ft square; fire-place 24-30 in square, 15-18 (often 20) in deep, lined with cast-iron plates | 1.8-2.4 m; 0.61-0.76 m square, 0.38-0.51 m deep | 245-246 | "a level hearth of stonework from six to eight feet square, at the corner of which is the fire-place, from twenty-four to thirty inches square, and from fifteen to eighteen, often twenty, inches in depth" |
| Blast | wooden bellows or, more often, square wooden cylinders driven by waterwheels | - | 247 | "by square, wooden cylinders, urged by waterwheels" |
| Charge | 400 lb of ore, two-thirds smelted at first, a third held back | 181 kg | 247 | "Four hundred pounds of ore are the common charge, two-thirds of which are thus smelted" |
| First blast | most of the iron melted after 1.5-2 h of blast | - | 247 | "When the blast has been applied for an hour and a half, or two hours, most of the iron is melted" |
| Ball | worked into a ball 12-15 in across; not over 100 lb at a smelting | 0.30-0.38 m; 45 kg | 248 | "It is not advisable to make, at one smelting, balls heavier than 100 pounds." |
| Ore and fuel a ton | 4 tons of ore and 300 bushels of charcoal a ton of blooms (Vermont) | 4 kg ore and 2.08 kg charcoal a kg of bloom (INFERRED at 15.5 lb a bushel) | 248 | "To produce this quantity, four tons of ore and three hundred bushels of charcoal are required." |
| Make | a 150-200 lb hammer serves two fires and draws 5-6 tons a week | 2.5-3 long tons a fire a week = 2.54-3.05 t; 16.6 kg/h over 168 h at the middle, 19.4 kg/h over 144 h (INFERRED) | 383 | "A hammer 150 or 200 pounds in weight is sufficient to do a great deal of work, at least work for two fires, and will draw, every week, from five to six tons of iron" |
| Air | a charcoal forge takes 400-500 cu ft a minute | 189-236 L/s | 401 | "A charcoal forge requires from 400 to 500 cubic feet per minute" (digest the Overman blowing note) |
| Blowing duty | one tub machine blows one charcoal blast furnace or 4-5 forge or Catalan fires | - | 396 | "It will work one blast furnace for charcoal, or from four to five forge, or Catalan fires." (same digest) |
| Small hearth (section I) | the Asiatic hand-blown hearth: 3-4 h a heat, 25-30 lb of iron | 11-14 kg a heat | 244-245 | "The whole process lasts from three to four hours, at the end of which time twenty-five or thirty pounds of iron may be removed by tongs" |
INFERRED: 2.75 t a week is 61 balls of 100 lb, a heat about every 2.7 h over 168 h, which fits a first blast of 1.5-2 h and the working of the ball after it. The fire's 400-500 cu ft on 16.6 kg/h is 46 m3 of air a kg of bloom, against 16.5 m3 a kg of pig for the charcoal furnace on Overman's own figures (p. 165, p. 401), and the 4-5 fires one tub machine blows make 67-83 kg/h against its furnace's 103 kg/h.
2. Bauerman, the Catalan forge in the Pyrenees
| Figure | Value | Metric | Page | Quote |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Blast | trompe or a wooden engine with a square piston; never over 1.5-1.75 in of mercury | 5.1-5.9 kPa | 238 | "its pressure never exceeds 1 1/2 to 1 3/4 inches of mercury" (OCR "Ij to If") |
| First stage | gentle blast about two hours, then full blast and the slag tapped | - | 238 | "The preliminary stage lasts about two hours, after which the blast is turned full on" |
| Largest hearth heat | 9.5 cwt of ore at 45-48 % iron in a six-hour operation, 10.75 cwt of fuel, about 3 cwt of finished bar | 483 kg ore, 546 kg charcoal, 152 kg bar a 6 h heat; 25.4 kg/h (INFERRED) | 241 | "The weight of ore treated in a hearth of the largest size in one operation lasting six hours is about 9 1/2 cwt., containing 45 to 48 per cent. of iron, the fuel consumed about 10 3/4 cwt., and the produce of finished bar iron about 3 cwt." (OCR "9 J", "lOf") |
| Ore and fuel a weight | 312 lb of ore and 340 lb of charcoal a 100 lb of bar | 3.12 kg ore, 3.40 kg charcoal a kg of bar | 241 | "The average consumption of materials per 100 lbs. of bar iron is, of ore 312 lbs., and charcoal 340 lbs." |
| Yield | 100 lb of ore gives 31 lb of bar and 41 lb of slag at 30 % iron; 71 % of the iron reduced | - | 241 | "100 lbs. of ore in good work should yield 31 lbs. of bar iron" (OCR "'31") |
| Hearth sizes | Catalan fire 20 in square, 16 in deep, 3-4 cwt charge; Navarrese 30 x 24 in, 5-6 cwt; Biscayan 40 x 30-32 in, 24-27 in deep, 7-9 cwt | 0.51 m; 0.76 x 0.61 m; 1.02 x 0.76-0.81 m | 241 | "The largest, or Biscayan hearth, is 40 inches long, 30 to 32 inches broad, and 24 to 27 inches in total depth" |
| Reheating | the previous bloom is reheated in the top of the hearth and drawn while the next charge reduces | - | 239 | "During the first period of the process, while the ore is being reduced, the bloom obtained from the preceding charge, after having been cut up into several pieces, is re-heated in the upper part of the hearth" |
INFERRED: the 3.40 kg a kg is of finished bar, after the bloom is drawn; the heats run back to back, so 25.4 kg/h is a running rate.
3. Swank, American bloomaries and early furnaces
| Figure | Value | Metric | Page | Quote |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Arkansas bloomary, 1857-58 | two fires and a hammer, 250 lb of swedged iron a day a fire on cold blast; perhaps 800 lb on hot blast; 300 bushels of charcoal a ton of finished bars | 113 kg a day, 4.7 kg/h over 24 h (INFERRED); 363 kg a day hot | 341-342 | "a bloomary with two fires and a hammer, making 250 pounds of swedged iron per day per fire, with a cold-blast in November, 1857, but has now a hot-blast, and is making perhaps 800 pounds, using 300 bushels of charcoal to the ton of finished bars" (Lesley) |
| Champlain forges, 1880s | hot blast, water-wheel power, charcoal only; bloom 300-400 lb; about a ton of billets a forge in 24 h | 136-181 kg bloom | 142-143 | "About one ton of billets is produced at each forge in twenty-four hours." |
| Champlain census, 1880 | 22 forges, 141 fires, 31,580 net tons of blooms | 224 net tons a fire a year = 203 t (INFERRED) | 143 | "In the census year 1880 there were only 22 forges, with 141 fires, and they produced 31,580 net tons of blooms in that year." |
| English foot-blast bloomery (Dud Dudley, 1665) | one bloom a day, under a hundredweight | under 51 kg a day | 97-98 | "by which way they could make but one little lump or bloom of iron in a day, not 100 weight" |
| Salisbury furnace, Lakeville, Conn. (blast furnace, 1760s) | 2.5 tons of iron in 24 h on 3 tons of ore and 250 bushels of charcoal a ton | 2.54 t a day | 129 | "It made two and a half tons of iron in twenty-four hours, and three tons of ore and 250 bushels of charcoal were used per ton of iron." |
4. Agricola, the hearth bloomery (from the digest)
| Figure | Value | Metric | Page | Quote |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Hearth | 3.5 ft high, 5 ft square, crucible 1 ft deep and 1.5 ft wide; water bellows in a pipe | 1.0 m, 1.5 m, 0.30 x 0.44 m | 420 | "The hearth is three and a half feet high, and five feet long and wide; in the centre of it is a crucible a foot deep and one and a half feet wide" |
| Time | 8, 10 or 12 hours a bloom | - | 421 | "He is able to complete this work sometimes in eight hours, sometimes in ten, and again sometimes in twelve" |
| Bloom | 2-3 centumpondia | 64-96 kg; 8.0 kg/h at 80 kg in 10 h (INFERRED) | 421 | "a mass weighing two or three centumpondia may be made, providing the iron ore was rich" |
5. The figures side by side (INFERRED)
Make is per hour of running; fuel is charcoal per weight of iron out, bloom or bar as the source names it.
| Bloomery | Make | Charcoal a kg of iron | Basis |
|---|---|---|---|
| Overman blomary fire | 16.6 kg/h (168 h week), 19.4 (144 h) | 2.08 | p. 383 weekly make, p. 248 300 bu a ton |
| Bauerman Biscayan hearth | 25.4 kg/h | 3.40 | p. 241, finished bar |
| Agricola hearth bloomery | 8.0 kg/h | - | pp. 420-421 |
| Lesley's Arkansas fire, cold blast | 4.7 kg/h | 2.08 | Swank p. 341 |
| Champlain fire, hot blast, 1880 | about 23 kg/h over 365 days | - | Swank p. 143 census |
| Dudley's foot-blast bloomery | under 2.1 kg/h | - | Swank p. 97 |
Against the charcoal blast furnace on Overman's own figures (180 bushels a ton of pig, p. 151; 16-18 t a week, p. 165), the bloomery's charcoal a ton is 300 over 180 bushels, the furnace burning 0.60 of the fire's charcoal a weight of iron whatever the bushel weighs; Lesley's 300 bushels a ton agrees with Overman's. Salisbury's 250 bushels a ton of pig in the 1760s sits between them.