McNaught compounding of beam engines (Fairbairn, Bourne, Rankine, 1859-1870)
Books Van Nostrand's Eclectic Engineering Magazine, Treatise on Mills and Millwork, Treatise on Mills and Millwork, Part I, Handbook of the Steam-Engine, A Manual of the Steam Engine and Other Prime Movers, The Engineer, vol. 13
All page numbers are the printed ones unless a row says otherwise. INFERRED marks arithmetic of this digest, not a source figure. Quotes are from the scan's text layer (OCR), with line breaks joined; checked against the page image only for Fairbairn p. 245.
Sources
| id | title | year |
|---|---|---|
| vannostrandsecle31870newy | Van Nostrand's Eclectic Engineering Magazine, vol. III (July 1870); article "Steam Power in Mills", reprinted "From Engineering", pp. 33-36 | 1870 |
| sim_engineer_january-3-june-27-1862_13 | The Engineer, vol. 13, Jan-Jun 1862; letters to the editor of 30 May 1862 ("Compound Engines") and 13 June 1862 ("Single Cylinder and Compound Steam Engines") | 1862 |
| treatiseonmills04fairgoog | W. Fairbairn, Treatise on Mills and Millwork, Part I (copy with p. 246) | 1864 |
| treatiseonmills01fairgoog | the same; its scan lacks p. 246 (a duplicate p. 237 stands in its place), so the McNaught paragraph breaks off at p. 245 | 1864 |
| handbookofsteame00bouriala | J. Bourne, Handbook of the Steam-Engine, pp. 362-368 | 1865 |
| amanualsteameng01rankgoog | W. J. M. Rankine, A Manual of the Steam Engine and Other Prime Movers, Art. 336 and 353 | 1859 |
Page numbers: Van Nostrand, Fairbairn and Bourne from the running heads. Rankine: Art. 336 is indexed at p. 479, Art. 353 falls on pp. 401-402 (the text layer shows the head "402" after its item IV). The Engineer's OCR carries no page numbers, so its rows cite the issue date. Only Fairbairn and Bourne were read as text; Rankine and Fairbairn's PDFs carry no text layer, the quotes come from the archive.org OCR of the same scans.
Not downloaded, read from archive.org text only: Bourne, Treatise on the Steam Engine 1846 (atreatiseonstea00bourgoog) and Handbook have no McNaught passage beyond indicators; the 1846 Treatise predates the patent.
What McNaughting was, and where the cylinder stood
| figure | value | metric | page | quote |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| definition | add a high-pressure cylinder to the same beam | power "increased, or even nearly doubled" | Fairbairn 245 | "McNaughting the old ones. This process, the invention of Mr. McNaught, consists in increasing, or even nearly doubling, the power of a condensing engine by the introduction of a high-pressure cylinder attached to the same working beam, that is, provided the beam is strong enough to bear the increase of strain." |
| position | high-pressure cylinder "b" on a pedestal, "worked half stroke from the main beam at c" | beam attachment half way along the beam arm | Fairbairn 246 | "a is the cylinder of the condensing engine, b the high-pressure cylinder mounted on a pedestal to a convenient height and worked half stroke from the main beam at c" |
| position | between the main centre and the crank shaft | "McNaught's original plan" | Van Nostrand 33 | "the high pressure-cylinder is placed between the main centre and the crank shaft on McNaught's original plan" |
| position | cylinders under opposite ends of the beam, pistons moving opposite ways | steam passes from the nearest end of the small cylinder to the large | Rankine 401 | "In Mr. M'Naught's engine the cylinders are under opposite ends of a beam, their pistons move opposite ways, and the steam passes from either end of the small cylinder to the nearest end of the large cylinder." |
| other forms | horizontal high-pressure cylinder beside the old one, own crank on the same shaft; Ramsbottom three-cylinder group | Van Nostrand 33 | "a horizontal high-pressure cylinder is placed by the side of the existing low-pressure one, the piston ... being coupled by a connecting rod to an independent crank" | |
| why | smoother motion, allows higher pressure and more expansion | Van Nostrand 33 | "the practice of 'compounding' has, by rendering permissible the employment of higher pressures of steam and greater expansion, effected an important economy in the vast majority of instances" | |
| cost | long passages lose effect | Van Nostrand 33 | "there is of course a considerable loss of effect due to the length of the passages connecting the high and low pressure cylinders" | |
| cost | loss of heat and fuel against a plain expansive engine | Fairbairn 246 | "it has unfortunately the same drawbacks as regards loss of heat and expenditure of fuel, although it must be admitted that the power of the engine is increased to a large degree" | |
| failure | refit with a high-pressure cylinder as large as the old one gave nothing | Van Nostrand 33 | "the high-pressure cylinder had been made of the same capacity as the existing low-pressure one!" |
The sources put the new cylinder on the crank side of the main centre, opposite the old cylinder.
Bore and stroke against the low-pressure cylinder
| figure | value | metric | page | quote |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Shay-lane Mill, McNaught beam engine | HP 16 in x 3 ft 3 in; LP 37 in x 6 ft 6 in | bore ratio 2.31 (INFERRED), stroke ratio 0.50 (INFERRED), capacity 1 : 10.7 | Van Nostrand 35 | "the high-pressure cylinder is 16 in. in diameter, with 3 ft. 3 in. stroke, and the low-pressure cylinder 37 in. in diameter, with 6 ft. 6 in. stroke, the relative capacities being thus as 1 to 10.7" |
| Holmfield Mill, same construction, 70 lb | HP "made larger in proportion" | lower pressure wants a larger HP cylinder; size not given | Van Nostrand 35 | "at the Holmfield Mill the high-pressure is made larger in proportion to the low-pressure cylinder, on account of the lower pressure of steam with which it is supplied" |
| Lambeth water-works double-cylinder beam engine (Woolf-type, both cylinders on one beam end, not McNaught) | LP 46 in x 8 ft; HP 28 in x 5 ft 6.75 in | bore ratio 1.64 (INFERRED), capacity about one-fourth | Bourne 363 | "diameter of large cylinder, 46 ins.; diameter of small cylinder, 28 ins.; stroke of large cylinder, 8 ft.; stroke of small cylinder, 5 ft. 6 3/4 ins." and "its effective capacity is nearly one-fourth that of the large cylinder" |
| ideal work split | half in each cylinder; in practice two-thirds in the small | Rankine 401 | "the attempt should be made so to proportion the cylinders to each other, that the steam shall perform half its work in the small cylinder and half in the large. In most actual engines two-thirds of the work are performed in the small cylinder." | |
| Woolf engine, 1864 | HP 23 in x 6 ft; LP 40 in x 8 ft | contents "as 1 to 4" | Fairbairn 248-249 | "23 inches in diameter and 6 feet stroke ... 40 inches in diameter and 8 feet stroke; their contents being as 1 to 4" |
| horizontal compound, Dean Clough | 20.5 in and 41 in x 5 ft; 48 rpm, 480 ft/min, 826 ihp | bore ratio 2.0 | Van Nostrand 35 | "cylinders 20 1/2 in. and 41 in. diameter respectively, the stroke being 5 ft. ... indicating 826-horse power" |
Boiler pressure, power and coal, before and after
| figure | value | metric | page | quote |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| refit of a mill beam engine, before | boiler 25-30 lb; 170 ihp; 6 lb coal per ihp-hour | piston speed 300 ft/min | Engineer 13 Jun 1862 | "working at a pressure in the boilers varying from 25 lb. to 30 lb. per square inch ... speed of piston 300ft. per minute ... the indicated horse power being 170" and "the consumption of coal before alteration being 6 lb. per indicated horse power per hour" |
| same engine, after McNaughting | new boilers 50 lb; 200 ihp; coal "4 lb" per ihp-hour on 200 | same machinery, no change to the mills | Engineer 13 Jun 1862 | "the engine was McNaughted, new boilers put in, and worked at 50 lb. per square inch; the same amount of machinery as before ... now being indicated comes up to 200 indicated horse power" and "if I divide by 200 ... it gives 4 lb.; but if I divide by 170 it gives 4.75 lb." |
| derived | +17.6 % ihp on the same load; coal per hour 6 x 170 = 1,020 lb before, 4 x 200 = 800 lb after, -22 % | INFERRED | ||
| the gain in indicated power is partly apparent | "nearly 20 per cent. more H.P." on indicating a pair of engines before and after | friction accounts for some | Engineer 30 May 1862 | "the diagrams give out nearly 20 per cent. more H.P.; hence arises an advantage apparent and not real in calculating the consumption of fuel" |
| same, Manchester Boiler Association | Engineer 30 May 1862 | "engines which have been compounded invariably indicate more horses' power than before, the machinery remaining the same" | ||
| the writer asks how much is the cylinder, how much the pressure | Engineer 13 Jun 1862 | "how much of that saving results from McNaughting, and how much from the extra pressure now carried in the new boilers" | ||
| Shay-lane, McNaught beam | steam 140 lb; 171 ihp | 2.5 lb coal/ihp-h on slack, 1.894 lb on Denaby main | Van Nostrand 35 | "the consumption of fuel was 2.5 lbs. per indicated horse power per hour ... 1.894 lbs." |
| Holmfield, same engine | steam 70 lb | "just under 3 lbs." per ihp-h | Van Nostrand 35 | "has been found to use just under 3 lbs. per indicated horse power per hour" |
| general mill pressures about 1870 | 50, 60, 70 lb common; 30 lb once thought high | Van Nostrand 34 | "of late years pressures of 50 lbs., 60 lbs., and even 70 lbs. per square inch have become common" | |
| ceiling | no gain above 100 lb or 7-8 expansions in land practice | Van Nostrand 36 | "nothing is to be gained in ordinary land practice by using a higher pressure than 100 lbs., or a greater measure of expansion than 7 or 8 times" | |
| doubts | compounding gave "not one atom of real economy" in some cases; Mooltan at 25 lb run better on the large cylinder alone | Van Nostrand 36 | "Over and over again have engines been 'compounded' and 'McNaughted' ... without securing one atom of real economy" | |
| Lambeth, 1850s | 1.7 lb coal per ihp-h; 14 rpm | duty 97 million ft-lb per 112 lb coal | Bourne 367-369 | "equivalent to a consumption of 1.7 lb. per indicated horse-power per hour" |
Rating compound engines
| figure | value | metric | page | quote |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| nominal horse-power rule | 7 lb mean effective pressure, piston speed 128 ft/min x cube root of the stroke in feet | NHP = 7 x 128 x (stroke ft)^(1/3) x piston area in sq in / 33,000 | Rankine 479 | "Assume the velocity of the piston to be 128 feet per minute x cube root of length of stroke in feet; Assume the mean effective pressure to be 7 lbs. on the square inch" |
| nominal against indicated | no fixed relation | Rankine 479 | "bears no fixed relation to indicated or to effective horse-power" | |
| compound power | sum of the powers of the two cylinders from their own diagrams | Bourne 362 | "The total power is obviously the sum of the two." | |
| rule for the nominal figure of a compound engine | not given in any source read | |||
| piston speed of stationary engines | 120 to 300 ft/min | Rankine 403 (OCR, page head not read) | "range accordingly from about 120 to 300 feet per minute" | |
| mill engine worked example | 50 in bore, 1,963.5 sq in, 350 ft/min piston speed, mean 7.17 lb less 2.0 lb friction = 5.17 lb effective, 107.63 hp | Fairbairn 239 | "Speed of piston . . 350 feet per minute ... Effective pressure . . = 5.1684 ... Actual horse-power = 107.63." | |
| friction | water-works engines lose 12-15 % of indicated power to friction and pumps | Bourne 367 | "all the losses were brought down to from 12 to 15 per cent. of the indicated power" | |
| measuring caution | compound diagrams over-state power | Engineer 30 May 1862 | "the gross amount of power exhibited by 'compound diagrams,' as at present calculated, is fallacious" |
Gaps
- McNaught's 1845 patent specification (patent no. 11001, from Wikipedia, unverified) was not found; no primary description of the original plan beyond Fairbairn and Van Nostrand.
- No source gives the beam-arm distances (main centre to HP pin) for a refit; only Fairbairn's "half stroke from the main beam".
- Both rating-practice sources (Rankine, Bourne) give the NHP rule for a single engine; how a McNaught engine was rated nominally is not documented in what was read. Wikipedia mentions ihp about 2.6 x nhp, not verified in a period source.
- The Engineer's page numbers were not captured; cite by issue date.
- The refit letters give pressure and power, not cylinder sizes. Shay-lane and Holmfield are 1870 and were built as McNaught engines, not shown to be refits of older engines.
- Farey 1827 and Watt-era engines are not in this digest.