Calcining kilns, the skip hoist and the bell top
Books The Manufacture of Iron, Metallurgy: Iron and Steel, Blast-Furnace Construction in America, The Principles, Operation and Products of the Blast Furnace, A Treatise on the Metallurgy of Iron
Covers (printed folios unless said)
- F. Overman, Manufacture of Iron (1851); folio = PDF page less 6. Text of pp. 39-48 read; plates not opened, so Figs. 1-2 are known from captions and text.
- J. Percy, Iron and Steel (1864); folios from the running heads.
- J. E. Johnson Jr., Blast-Furnace Construction in America (1917); folio = PDF page less 17; pp. 7-100 and 250-303 re-OCR'd. His Principles (1918): nothing on kilns (only sulphur asides, pp. 18-19).
- H. Bauerman, Treatise on the Metallurgy of Iron (title page 1870, archive lists 1868); Turner, The Metallurgy of Iron, 3rd ed. 1908, archive.org metallurgyofiron00turnrich. Printed folios.
- E. Westman, US patent 85,881 (signed 3 June 1868, dated 12 Jan 1869), patents.google.com/patent/US85881A/en.
- Encyclopaedia Britannica 9th ed. vol. 13 (1881), "Iron", pp. 291-292, en.wikisource.org Page:...v._13.djvu/307 and /308 (OCR, unproofread).
- Grace's Guide "1908 Iron and Steel Institute: Visits to Works" and "John Gjers" (1898 obituaries); G. Sundbarg, Sweden: Its People and its Industry (1904) pp. 717, 719 (runeberg.org/sverig01en/0739.html, 0741.html). Purpose facts on the masonry shaft kiln, the gas-fired kiln, the skip hoist and the bell top. Statements are what the source says; lines starting "Inference" are the writer's reading.
A. The masonry shaft kiln, about 1840-1870
- Overman: all ovens "can be reduced to that of the blast furnace, or the limekiln", either "perpetual, or work by charges", 12-18 ft high, 50-100 t of ore at once (p. 41). Ore broken to 2-3 in. (p. 40). Fuel: wood and small charcoal, or stone coal "properly applied"; "coke or anthracite is preferable"; bad or sulphurous coal avoided or coked first; peat or brown coal where cheap (p. 41).
- Overman Fig. 1 perpetual oven: "a is the shaft or circular hearth, where ore and fuel are thrown in; b, b are the grate bars, which can be removed to let down the roasted ore; c, c are side arches, which permit access to the draft holes; d, d, d, d are four arches, including the work arch" (p. 41). So: one grate across the bottom, four arches, the work arch and three air-hole arches.
- Overman start-up and run: grate covered with wood, then small charcoal or coal or coke or turf, then alternate layers of coal and ore to the top, then fired. "When the lower portions of ore are sufficiently roasted and cool, they are taken out, and either carried to the furnace, or, in case the ore is not sufficiently roasted, returned to the top." The air holes d admit air "and enable us to observe the progress of the work". "As the top of the ore sinks, it is replaced by fresh charges of coal and ore." A 50 t oven "ought to yield thirty tons of well roasted ore in twenty-four hours", depending on the ore (pp. 41-42).
- Overman: the perpetual oven suits hydrates, carburets and easy ores, "but will not answer for carbonates, sulphurets, or even magnetic ore, for these ores are too soon melted" (p. 42). Carbonates want low heat and, if possible, steam: too hot and "the carbonate melts together with the oxide, and forms a black cinder" (p. 40). Magnetic ore melts to a slag at a cherry red (p. 39).
- Overman Fig. 2, the better oven: interior a cone wide at the base; at its foot "an arch of coarse pieces of iron ore" carries the charge and "will admit enough fuel to keep up a lively fire"; the fuel does not touch the ore, "the workmen are enabled to give just so much heat as they consider necessary", and it can roast any ore coarse enough to pass the draught; dearer to work but the product is better oxidised (pp. 42-43). Swedish and Norwegian ovens with outside fireplaces are named as dearer still (p. 43).
- Overman on signs: well roasted ore red or brown, sticks to the tongue, breaks easily; clinkered ore worse than raw (p. 172). Fire too fierce is smothered with small ore or dust; heaps are holed with a bar for air (p. 45). Roasted ore is screened on iron bars 1/4-3/8 in. (p. 46).
- Bauerman p. 110: kilns "generally to be preferred, when economy of fuel is of importance"; ore piled "above a thin bed of fuel at the bottom of the kiln-shaft, which may be conical, cylindrical, barrel, or wedge-shaped"; "ore roasted by the combustion of the fuel at the bottom, where the air has access to the kiln, is withdrawn, and the next layer falls". Circular sections for moderate kilns; for large ones the centre gets too hot, so flattened ellipses or rounded rectangles (p. 111). This is the source's statement of the hot-centre fault; the cure it gives is the plan shape.
- Bauerman, Dowlais kiln (pp. 111-112): oval plan (rectangle with semicircular ends), 9 ft wide at top narrowing to 2 ft at bottom, 20 ft long, 18 ft high; cast-iron floor plates 2 in.; fire-brick lining inside, rough masonry outside; two splayed arched passages on one side with four rectangular draw openings at floor level and "a numerous series of smaller holes above" for air; cast-iron ring on the top edge against abrasion. Working: two or three coal fires on the floor, raw stone 9 in. deep on them; next layer with "about 5 per cent. by weight of small coal" once the first is dull red, and so on; the lowest ore is cold enough to draw when the kiln is full. About 70 t held, 146 t a week, about 3.5 days in the kiln, 1 cwt small coal per ton, against 2 cwt small plus 1/2 cwt large for clamps (p. 112).
- Bauerman, Siegen spathic kiln (p. 114): cylinder over a cone, 17.5 ft high, 5.5 ft across at top, 3.5 ft at bottom, about 500 cu ft; the cone's foot 3 ft above ground, closed by a grate of bars 3 in. apart, and a second grate about 2 ft below it "for starting the fire". Charge: 4 in. of pine charcoal, then ore broken small and cheap fuel (breeze, coke, puddling cinders) "40 cubic feet of ore to 8 of fuel"; a wood fire on the lower grate three days; draw by removing the upper bars; "about one-fourth of the whole contents of the kiln are drawn at a time", then refill with half the fuel measure; draw every 24 h; roasting time about four days (pp. 114-115).
- Percy, French kilns (p. 281): brick, 5.5-7.5 ft high, 6.5-8 ft across, 30-40 t of ore piled with wood, 2 days dry or 3 green; heat held down "to prevent coagulation, that is, incipient fusion of the ore", which would defeat loosening it for the furnace gases.
- Percy (p. 374): Swedish mountain ores "not larger than the double-fist" are always calcined, then rolled to under an inch, "no good explanation of this has yet been presented". Prussia (p. 572): newest spathic kilns 23 ft high, 13 ft wide, up to 500 cu ft.
- What the kiln does when the draw stops: not stated. Inference from Overman p. 42 and Bauerman pp. 111-115: the fire stays in the column and the ore roasts longer, which Overman p. 172 and Percy p. 281 name as the clinker fault.
- Fuel ratio: Overman 1 in. of fuel to 1 ft of ore in heaps (pp. 44-45); Bauerman 5 per cent. small coal by weight (p. 112), 40:8 by measure at Siegen (p. 114).
B. The gas-fired iron kiln, about 1870-1900
- Terms: the British standard kiln of the period, the Gjers or "Cleveland" kiln, burns small coal mixed with the ore, not gas (Bauerman p. 113; Turner p. 91: "generally circular in section, and fired with coal"). Gas-fired kilns are the Swedish kilns (Westman and others), the American kilns of Cornwall (Pennsylvania), the Davis-Colby, Taylor-Langdon and Siemens kilns (Turner pp. 91-94; Britannica p. 291). Inference: a gas-fired iron kiln of the 1870s combines the Gjers iron-cased circular shell with Westman's gas ports.
- Westman. Introduced "in 1850" by E. Westman, director of Jernkontoret; fired "with wood or gas from the blast furnace" in kilns that replaced roasting-stalls (Sundbarg 1904, p. 717). The US patent text (1868/69) is the only drawing-level description found: gas "from a blast furnace or a separate gas generator" enters by pipes e e round the shaft and small tubes g; blast air through pipes h into small tuyeres in the iron supports f that carry the shaft lining; more air by openings i; gas set by a valve in the main and by small sliding cast-iron dampers; roasted ore withdrawn through openings i just below the gas pipes, broken loose with bars through working holes k, l, m "accessible from all points through the large working-holes", so ore can be heated close to melting without baking; the shaft "taller and more conical", gas entering low enough for ore to be drawn directly; a chimney n with a damper, which "for easily roasted ores" and blast may be omitted; if furnace gas runs short "another fuel can be used in a common gas generator". No dimensions are given ("various sizes to match the blast furnaces they serve"). Charging: a truck hoisted on a rope over a pulley along an elevated track strikes a swinging shutter p, tips onto an inclined plane s, and a movable funnel c on a sliding handle guides ore to any part of the mouth; the charge is kept up to a marked line (patent 85,881).
- Britannica 1881 (p. 292): Westman's kiln "a nearly tubular vertical kiln slightly diminishing in diameter upwards", fed at the base with blast-furnace waste gas and air, for magnetite and quartzose hematite.
- Swedish gas kiln, Safvenas (Bauerman pp. 115-116, Fig. 2): shaft 18.5 ft high, 5 ft across at the top widening to 7 ft at the bottom; three concentric brick walls, inner fire-brick on a cast-iron ring, middle and outer common brick separated by sand, outer wall about 2 ft thick with horizontal moisture channels and wrought-iron hoops; five splayed radial draw passages at the base lined with cast iron; gas by a wrought-iron tube from the furnace into a cast-iron ring main with ten jets at equal spacing, air through apertures with sliding plates over the jet mouths; a second ring of holes higher for bars "for breaking up lumps in the event of the charge clotting together from overheating". Ore: hard magnetite and micaceous hematite; 20-30 t a day; fuel only "a portion of the waste gases of a small charcoal blast furnace".
- Soderfors (Bauerman pp. 116-117): the same plus a 28 ft conical chimney with damper and 24 small tuyeres on a hollow base ring fed from the blast engine "to prevent fusion of the ore"; shaft 21 ft high, 9 ft across at the base, 5.75 ft at the throat; 35-50 t a day.
- Percy, Sten near Finspong (1837 furnace; pp. 370-372): the mine-kiln is two truncated cones of equal height, the upper nearly cylindrical, the lower "much more conical, in order to allow the ore, after it has become agglomerated into masses in the hottest part of the kiln ... more easily to break up in its descent"; circular outside and in; fire-brick lining on a cast-iron ring of four segments, common-brick casing, iron hoops; floor a low four-sided pyramid with four draw openings ("a") with tight cast-iron doors and air registers; 1 in. cast-iron plates below the ring; gas pipe c from the furnace to a flue b round the kiln, then through 12 equal rectangular openings at one level, gas set by sliding bricks over the passages; a second row above for bars and for looking in; a wooden building round it against weather and wind; three stages (top for charging, bottom for drawing, middle for the gas work). Ore goes by barrow to a five-bay ore-house (one bay per ore) beside the railway, and the calcined ore is crushed between grooved rolls to 3/4-1 cu. in. Percy gives no tonnage here.
- Gas fed to kilns from the stack: Bauerman p. 179, small charcoal furnaces draw gas through wrought-iron pipes in the wall 10-12 ft below the top, "commonly used in Sweden for supplying gases to mine kilns, hot blast stoves"; supply "apt to be somewhat irregular". Sundbarg p. 719: in the 1860s-70s a sheet-iron cylinder hung from the charging floor and gas ran "through ports and flues to the kilns". Percy p. 374: in Sweden calcination is "now everywhere carried on ... by means of the waste-gases".
- American gas kilns (Turner pp. 93-94): Cornwall Ore Hills, Pennsylvania, magnetite with 2-2.5 per cent. sulphur cut to under 0.5 per cent. (coal firing leaves about 1); iron-plate shell on cast-iron columns, gas passages in the lower fire-brick lining, ports for the gas, air by natural draught; gas from producers or the blast furnace. Davis-Colby: ore in an annular chamber, a gas combustion chamber round it and a central flue; ore fed over a central cone and drawn below; one Taylor producer burning about 3 t of coal in 24 h roasts 125 t of ore. Taylor-Langdon (Bristol mines, Canada): central gas chamber ringed by ore chambers fed from a common top receptacle, drawn by chutes, fist-sized lumps, about 6 t of anthracite to 100 t of ore. Dates of these designs: Turner cites Iron and Steel Institute papers of 1887 and 1894, not their invention dates.
- Siemens calciner (Britannica p. 291): "combustible gas and air being led into the centre and distributed by a cone" (quoted from the fetched summary).
- Gjers kiln, for the iron shell and the plant fit (all are coal-fired):
- Bauerman p. 113 (Fig. 1): fire-brick shell 15 in. thick cased in wrought-iron plates "in a similar manner to that now adopted usually in blast furnaces"; two cones, 18 ft across at the top, 20 ft at the widest (the boshes), 14 ft at the bottom; 4 in. cast-iron bottom plate on 27-in. vertical columns leaving an open space round the base; cast-iron floor 20 ft across, 2.5 in. thick, in segments, carrying a central upright cone 8 ft high and 8 ft across; 24 ft from the foundation plate to the filling gallery; 5,500 cu ft; ore stays about 2.5 days; 1 t slack to 20 t ore, 1 t to 25 t in the 34 ft kilns; air through holes near the bottom, radiating flues in the foundation brickwork and the hollow of the cone's overlap; ore drawn "through the openings between the pillars, being directed outwards by the slope of the interior cone".
- Turner p. 91-92 (Fig. 18): plate or mild-steel shell lined with about 14 in. of fire-brick; cast-iron floor plates and a cone 8 ft high on an 8 ft base "to cause the descending materials to pass outwards"; short columns carry a cast-iron ring that carries the kiln; about 33 ft high, 24 ft across, about 8,000 cu ft or 350 t of ore, "rather less than 1,000 tons of ore weekly", about 1 cwt of coal per ton; ore and fuel come in trucks on two lines of rails at the top, bottom-opening; "in the lower row of plates is a number of openings ... doors by means of which the draught can be regulated, and any obstruction removed in case of irregular working".
- Britannica p. 291: "some 20 feet maximum diameter, and a little more in height", over 5,000 cu ft, slack 4-5 per cent. of the ore.
- 1908 visit reports: Bell Brothers, Port Clarence, "sixteen kilns, 24 feet outside diameter by 40 feet high" behind the furnaces, loaded trucks reach the gantry top by an incline; New Side fourteen kilns 24 ft by 45 ft; Gjers, Mills, Ayresome eight "Gjers" kilns, "now generally known as the Cleveland kiln"; Tees Ironworks nine Gjers kilns, trucks raised to a 45 ft gantry "by means of a direct-acting steam ram" and lowered by "the usual balance drop" (Grace's Guide, 1908).
- Date: no period text gives one. Bauerman's copy (1870) calls it "now largely employed in the Cleveland district"; Turner cites John Gjers, "A Description of the Ayresome Iron Works", J. Iron Steel Inst. 1871 pt. 2 p. 202 (kiln p. 212); Ayresome was blown in 29 March 1871 (Grace's Guide). The IMechE obituary (1898) credits him with the circular kiln over "the older angular forms".
- Layout (Turner pp. 97-98, after Sir B. Samuelson): Cleveland plant of three furnaces: ore arrives on mineral sidings, a hoist raises trucks to the calciner top, they run down a gentle incline over the calciners and dump into one; five calciners serve three furnaces; "several lines of rails should be provided behind the calciners"; two lifts bring calcined ore, fuel and limestone to the furnace tops.
- Faults named for gas or shaft kilns: clotting or agglomeration in the hottest zone (Percy p. 371, Bauerman p. 116), incipient fusion (Percy p. 281), irregular working needing the draw doors cleared (Turner p. 92), uneven heat across a wide shaft (Bauerman p. 111). "Scaffolding" by that name: not found. Temperature kept: no figure; Overman "cherry-red" (pp. 39, 48), Bauerman "dull red" (p. 112).
C. The skip hoist
- Johnson p. 9: power hoists replaced the hillside bridge when furnaces grew from 25-30 ft to 50-70 ft; first a platform carrying barrows, a double-acting pair balancing; hydraulic, pneumatic, water-balance and engine-driven hoists were tried. Engine: vertical two-cylinder, cranks at right angles, geared to the rope drum, reversed by steam through the ports, no lap or lead, about 120 lb of steam per horse-power; motor hoists in the last 10-15 years (pp. 9-10).
- Johnson on the skip proper (pp. 39-44): the skip is "a sort of tank, either rectangular, round or elliptical ... runs on an inclined plane, generally very steep ... from a pit beneath the filling floor to a hopper above the furnace top, where it turns upside down and dumps"; filled from a motor-driven scale car or "larry" (truck, motive power, hopper with quick discharge, scales) under the bins, which tips into a hopper that delivers into the skip at the bottom; coke is sometimes spouted straight into skips and measured by skipful. Dumping (p. 42): the main rails bend down but two wider-gauge rails continue level; the rear wheels' extra tread rides them, tilting the skip to 45 deg or more "in something less than twice the length of the skip". Single skip needs a counterweight (a tower weight on a sheave block-and-tackle, Fig. 23) or the Brown friction-clutch drum and brake; a double skip is self-balancing but dumps off-centre; the Pueblo double skip on a divided track dumps on the centre line (pp. 40-42). Hoisting-sheave placement problem (p. 41). Bucket system (bell-bottom bucket hung from the hook, never breaking bulk) is the other mode (p. 39).
- Johnson date and first use (pp. 61-62, 67): "The skip which dumps by turning nearly upside down ... has been known for a long time. I am told that it was used two hundred years ago in Sweden"; Fayette Brown tried skip filling and it was abandoned; his son A. E. Brown combined the skip with a central rotating hopper, "at least one of which was in operation several years before the Duquesne revolution"; "the first installation of skip filling commercially successful on a large scale" was at the Edgar Thomson works (D. G. Kerr, E. E. Slick), undated in the text. Mechanical filling spread in "the middle nineties".
- Turner pp. 113-116 (1908): "mechanical charging ... was introduced at the Duquesne blast-furnace plant ... 1896", a "self-filling and self-emptying skip drawn up an inclined electric tramway", two lines of rails balancing; skips "usually carry about 2 tons of ore", sheet iron, four flanged wheels, front pair half the thickness of the rear, a circular guide rail at the top that only the broad rear wheels climb, tipping the skip; one man works the hoist. Disagreement: Johnson (1917, later, a furnace specialist) says Duquesne used bell-bottom buckets (p. 66) and that skips and the Brown top predate it; take Johnson, and read 1896 as the year mechanical filling became general.
- Earlier alternatives (Bauerman pp. 148-151, 1870): inclined planes on trestles, 25-30 deg, a triangular-frame truck with a platform for four or more loaded barrows, a 10-20 hp engine on a pair of winding drums, wire rope or flat chain; at Barrow two planes serve seven furnaces, "about 4,000 tons ... lifted weekly by each plane". A vertical colliery-type cage "most approved" for height. Water balance: two cages over a pulley, a water box under each, the top one filled until it outweighs the other; simple but leaky. Armstrong hydraulic lift with multiplying tackle. Pneumatic: a gasometer-style bell 6-8 ft across at 3-4 lb/sq in. carrying the wagon; Gjers's pneumatic lift "much used in the newer Cleveland furnaces". Turner pp. 111-113 repeats these. Barrow loads: Turner p. 112 after Ridsdale 7 cwt coke, 13 cwt calcined ore, 15-16 cwt limestone; Johnson (pp. 13-14) about 1500 lb.
- Charging a calciner: no kiln skip is described. Turner p. 98 and the 1908 visits show an incline or ram lift raising ore trucks to a gantry over the kilns; Westman's patent hoists a cart on a rope to the kiln mouth.
- Skips per charge and their cubic capacity: not in these sources.
D. The bell top and the double bell
- First application: Parry at Ebbw Vale, "March, 1850", the idea taken from a Jessop cylinder-and-cone charger described in Ure's Dictionary supplement (1844) (Percy p. 471); Turner p. 116 "G. Parry at Ebbw Vale in 1850, though a cone and cylinder had been previously used".
- Bauerman p. 180-181, cup and cone: inverted conical cast-iron funnel with its lower aperture about half the throat diameter; the cone hangs by a chain from a counterweighted arch-headed lever, raised by a hand-wheel pinion on a segmental rack; "only the small amount of gas that is lost during the time of charging is allowed to escape"; gas leaves by a lateral flue into a square wrought-iron main feeding boiler fires and hot-blast stoves. Cleveland variant: external cylindrical stopper with a conical ring on three chains as distributer. Turner p. 117: the gas at the top stands at "about half an inch" of water, enough to carry it to stoves or boilers.
- Johnson p. 99-100 (history): in the earliest days gas burned at the throat; then stoves above the throat; then boilers and stoves on masonry at furnace-top height drawing gas through flues "several feet below" the top with a chimney draught, burning it as flame; the bell and hopper sealed the top, "ordinarily only about 5 per cent. of the time" open, and the upper bell saved the gas lost then. With a closed top "a constant pressure is maintained sufficient to force the gas through the downcomer and mains to the boilers and stoves, or to the cleaning system". Ch. VII p. 285: the final step was "closing the top ... with a bell and forcing the gas ... into a pipe leading down to the ground level ... the 'downcomer'". Outlets on the top (p. 287): early side outlet, then two to six; "good practice now very generally uses four, though ... three properly located are sufficient"; one side outlet gives unsymmetrical flow.
- Johnson says nothing of gas to calcining kilns; see section B (Bauerman p. 179, Sundbarg p. 719). Turner sends furnace gas to "stoves or boilers" (p. 117).
- Skip into receiving hopper (Johnson pp. 62-69): the hopper sits over a small upper (gas-seal) bell, "not ... nearly so large as the lower", and the skip drops into it about 7-8 ft (p. 66); the skip's horizontal velocity throws stock to the far side (p. 65); plain double-bell skip filling was judged unreliable by many users, because distribution shifts with ore size, moisture and skip speed (p. 62). Roberts top (Figs. 35-37, p. 64): hopper a truncated pyramid cut in two between the skips, each half on four wheels on a cross track, slewable. Rowe top: a vertical plate and two crossed inclined plates under the dump send each load to two quarter points. Brown rotating top (pp. 67-69): the skip dumps into a central hopper with a side spout, turned by a ratchet from the hoist sheave a little more or less than a quarter turn per skip; gas seal a flap valve on the spout, closed by the first travel of the main bell. Dates not given.
Gaps
- Gjers's own 1871 paper (J. Iron Steel Inst. 1871 pt. 2 p. 202) was not found online; the archive.org volumes returned are indexes. Gjers kiln figures are Bauerman's and Turner's, which disagree on size (24 ft high, 5,500 cu ft, 2.5 days vs 33 ft, 8,000 cu ft); Bauerman is the earlier.
- The Westman kiln: no dimensions, tonnage, gas volume or temperature in the patent or Britannica; the 1850 date rests on Sundbarg (1904). Not found: Turner or Bauerman text naming Westman.
- Tons per day for the Gjers kiln beyond Turner's "less than 1,000 weekly" and Bauerman's 146 t a week (Dowlais); gas per ton for any blast-furnace-gas kiln; kiln temperatures in degrees.
- What a masonry kiln does when the draw stops, and how the burning zone is held in the middle (Section A inference only).
- Date of the Edgar Thomson skip hoist, skips per charge, skip capacity in cubic feet.
- Historic England kiln listings (1018981, 1018982, 1296302) returned 403 and are not used. Siemens and Rachette calciners: Britannica only. Turner cites Percy p. 376 for Swedish gas kilns; the Sten kiln is p. 371 in the OCR'd copy.