Tribe, Henthorn, Shillitto, Denton, Sandhurst, Thurston and Allis on the compound Corliss mill engine (1876-1903)

Books Compound Corliss Engines, The Corliss Engine, ed. C. D. Thurber, Handbook of Corliss Steam Engines, Water Consumption of an Unjacketed 1600 Horse Power Compound Harris-Corliss Engine (ASME), The Great Centennial Exhibition, A Manual of the Steam-Engine, Part I, A History of the Growth of the Steam-Engine, Engine Book

Sources: J. Tribe, Compound Corliss Engines (1903); J. T. Henthorn, The Corliss Engine, ed. C. D. Thurber (1897); F. W. Shillitto Jr., Handbook of Corliss Steam Engines (1899); J. E. Denton, D. S. Jacobus and R. H. Rice, Water Consumption of an Unjacketed 1600 Horse Power Compound Harris-Corliss Engine (ASME, 1894); P. T. Sandhurst, The Great Centennial Exhibition (1876); R. H. Thurston, A Manual of the Steam-Engine Part I (1891), and A History of the Growth of the Steam-Engine (1886) (read for the Corliss cut-off only, no figure taken); Allis-Chalmers, Engine Book (undated catalogue). Pages are printed folios read from the running heads (PDF page = folio plus a small offset, 4 in Tribe).

Not found or not used: Holmes, The Steam Engine, was not read. The Allis text layer is garbage for tables; Eng. 8 was read from a rotated page image and its table has no horsepower column. Tribe's Table 5 (desirable pressures) is illegible in the OCR and is not used. No Corliss-specific rope-drive, Bessemer-blowing or rolling-mill hp figure was found (rope drive is sourced only by Thurston's Fowler compound, p. 237). Henthorn's and Shillitto's figures were taken in an earlier pass and are cited as that pass recorded them.

Purpose: period size, speed, rating and steam use of a large compound Corliss engine. Facts are the books'; INFERRED marks arithmetic or a reading added here. Conversions: 1 in = 25.4 mm, 1 ft = 0.3048 m, 1 lb/in2 = 6.895 kPa, 1 hp = 745.7 W, 1 lb = 0.4536 kg, 1 long ton = 1016 kg. "ihp" is indicated horsepower.

A. The valve gear and why it saves steam

Thurston, Manual, pp. 99-102 (Corliss engine "the prototype of a large number of engines", p. 100). Leading features as he lists them:

  1. Four valves, two steam and two exhaust, placed "so as to reduce 'clearance' to a minimum".
  2. A rotating (oscillating) valve, cheap to fit, easily moved, worked by connections outside the steam spaces.
  3. A wrist-plate swung by a single eccentric and joined to all four valves, so each opens and closes quickly and is "held open and nearly still" at either end of its range, giving near full port opening for an appreciable interval (p. 101).
  4. A detaching gear: the steam valve is released from the driving mechanism and closed rapidly at the moment of cut-off.
  5. The governor acts directly on the point of cut-off, so the ratio of expansion follows the load (p. 101).
  6. The dash-pot (air cushion; Sickels' original used water) stops the closing valve without shock (pp. 99-100). Corliss introduced the governor-controlled cut-off in 1849 (p. 89). Tribe: the expansion curve with the Corliss gear "approaches very closely to the Hyperbolic curve", and "at least twenty-five per cent. of the fuel can be saved as compared with the slide valve arrangement" (p. 50). His worked case (p. 51): steam 95 lb absolute, cut off at 1/5 stroke, non-condensing against 16 lb absolute gives about 29 per cent more power than full-stroke admission; condensing against 7 lb absolute the saving is about 40 per cent against the non-expansive non-condensing engine (p. 51). Thurston: compounding gives about 20 per cent saving (Manual, recorded in the earlier pass, page not re-read); best Corliss compound mill engine about 16 lb steam per hp-hour (p. 587). INFERRED reading: the gain comes from letting steam do work through a long expansion with little clearance steam lost and no throttling, the load held by cut-off, not by the throttle.

B. Forms: tandem and cross compound

  • Tandem and cross-compound forms are compared in Thurston, Manual, pp. 107-111; the Namquit cross-compound is his example.
  • Tribe: rolling-mill engines are poor candidates for compounding (p. 14).
  • Triple-expansion Corliss: cylinders 20, 34, 36 and 36 in x 5 ft, 1000 ihp or more, 1.44 lb coal per ihp-hour (Thurston p. 111).
  • Reversing rolling-mill engine: 40 x 54 in, 5-120 rpm, geared to the rolls (Thurston pp. 115-116).
  • Henthorn: a 22 and 40 x 60 in cross-compound at 60 rpm (pp. 70-71).
  • Fowler compound with a rope-grooved flywheel (Thurston p. 237).

C. Size tables

EngineCylinders (in)StrokerpmPiston speedPowerSteamSource
Bristol cotton mill, cross-compound Harris-Corliss30.025 and 55.91572 in65.2783 ft/min1592.2 ihp125 lb boiler, cut-off 0.30 in HP, 25.6 in vacuumDenton et al. pp. 1-2
Tribe worked example, generatorabout 42 HP and two LP of about 66 (INFERRED from the rating)5 ft77770 ft/min (INFERRED)3685 ihp for 2500 kWTribe p. 125
Warren engine32 and 6860 in75750 ft/min (INFERRED)155 lb, 12.44 lb steam per ihp-hourTribe p. 124
Henthorn cross-compound22 and 4060 in60600 ft/min (INFERRED)Henthorn pp. 70-71
Allis Reynolds belted cross-compound, smallest12 and 2436 inAllis Eng. 8
Allis Reynolds belted cross-compound, largest40 and 8060 in310,000 lb without wheel; wheel 195,000 lb, 26 ft acrossAllis Eng. 8

Rules: piston speed up to 800 ft/min (Tribe); at most 500 ft/min (Henthorn, Appendix from p. 93); rpm by duty: blowing 40-60, cotton and woolen mills 70-80, electric 85-95 (Tribe). Flywheel about 4 times the stroke across, rim speed at most 4,500 ft/min (Henthorn, Appendix from p. 93). The 26 ft Allis wheel on a 60 in stroke is 5.2 times the stroke.

D. Steam and coal per horse-power hour

  • Bristol 1600 hp test: 13.50 lb steam per ihp-hour; 1 1/3 lb coal per ihp-hour at 10 1/3 lb water per lb coal (Denton et al. p. 2).
  • Warren: 12.44 lb steam per ihp-hour at 155 lb (Tribe p. 124).
  • Triple-expansion Corliss: 1.44 lb coal per ihp-hour (Thurston p. 111).
  • Condensing Corliss: 2.25 to 3.5 lb coal per hp-hour (Shillitto pp. 132-133).
  • Boiler: 14 lb coal per sq ft of grate per hour at 8 lb water per lb coal (Shillitto pp. 132-133).
  • Corliss cut-off saves at least 25 per cent of fuel against slide valves (Tribe p. 50).

E. Drive and flywheel

Gear drive, belts, ropes: the Centennial engine drove a 252 ft main shaft through a 30 ft geared flywheel and eight belts of 30 in (Sandhurst, below); the Allis engines are listed as belted with a 26 ft wheel; ropes appear only in Thurston's Fowler example (p. 237). Henthorn gives the flywheel rule in C.

F. The Centennial engine, 1876

Sandhurst pp. 362-368. It is a pair of simple beam engines, not a compound.

  • Nominal 1400 hp (700 hp each), rated up to 2500 hp; cylinders 40 in x 10 ft stroke; 36 rpm; piston speed 720 ft/min; steam 25-80 lb.
  • Gear flywheel 30 ft across, about 56 tons, 216 teeth; crank-shaft 19 in x 12 ft; total weight about 680 tons.
  • Power out through a 252 ft main shaft and eight belts of 30 in.
  • Boilers: 20 Corliss upright boilers of 70 hp each, feeding an 18 in steam pipe 320 ft long.

G. Boilers that fed them

Centennial: 20 boilers of 70 hp, 1400 hp of boiler for 1400 hp nominal engine (Sandhurst, F). Bristol: 125 lb working pressure (Denton et al. p. 1). Shillitto's grate rule in D: 14 lb coal per sq ft per hour. INFERRED from D: 1592 ihp at 13.5 lb steam is 21,500 lb water an hour, about 2,100 lb of coal at 10 1/3 lb per lb, about 150 sq ft of grate at 14 lb/ft2 h.

H. Duties served

Rolling mills: reversing engine 40 x 54 in (Thurston pp. 115-116); compounding poor for them (Tribe p. 14). Blowing: 40-60 rpm (Tribe). Cotton and woolen mills 70-80 rpm, the Bristol 1600 hp mill engine (Denton et al.). Electric stations 85-95 rpm, the 2500 kW example at 3685 ihp (Tribe p. 125). Waterworks pumping is named by Tribe as a worked case; no hp figure was read.

I. Sizing arithmetic (INFERRED, not source figures)

  • Bristol constant: 1592 ihp / (30.025 in)^2 / 783 ft/min = 0.00226 ihp per in2 of HP piston per ft/min, at 125 lb and cut-off 0.30.
  • At 700 ft/min: 500 ihp needs about 17.8 in HP bore, 1000 ihp about 25 in, 1500 ihp about 31 in. At Tribe's worked-example constant (0.00271, HP bore 42 in at 770 ft/min) the same powers need about 16, 22 and 28 in.
  • A 40 and 80 x 60 in engine at 60-75 rpm (600-750 ft/min) comes to about 2200-2700 ihp by the Bristol constant; the Centennial's rating of 2500 hp is of that order.