How a blast furnace's charge was counted and kept: Overman, Truran, Percy, Bauerman, Fairbairn (1851-1870)

Books The Manufacture of Iron, The Iron Manufacture of Great Britain, Metallurgy: Iron and Steel, A Treatise on the Metallurgy of Iron, Iron, its History, Properties and Processes of Manufacture

Sources: F. Overman, The Manufacture of Iron (Philadelphia, 1851); W. Truran, The Iron Manufacture of Great Britain (2nd ed. 1862); J. Percy, Metallurgy: Iron and Steel (1864); H. Bauerman, A Treatise on the Metallurgy of Iron (1870 printing); W. Fairbairn, Iron, its History, Properties and Processes of Manufacture (1865). Pages are printed folios; PDF page = folio + 6 in Overman, + 26 in Truran, + 22 in Percy (OCR text, read from the scan text), + 12 in Bauerman. Fairbairn's folio is the running head of the OCR page.

Purpose: what a furnace keeper and filler did to count, keep and change the proportion of fuel, ore and flux a round. It builds on the charging practice note, which has the vessels, hoists and spreading; this note takes only the counting, the keeping and the changing. Facts are the books'; INFERRED marks a reading added here.

0. What the books do not give

  • No book searched has a tally board, pegs, a slate or a count of barrows kept in the filler's sight. Searches of Overman, Truran, Bauerman and the Percy and Fairbairn OCR for tally, register, slate, counting and clerk found no such device (the one register, Truran p. 67, is a weighing record, section 3).
  • No book gives a standing ratio of coke barrows to ore barrows a round (such as "2 and 10"). The ratios given are weights of ore, fuel and flux for one charge (sections 1 and 2).
  • No book names a person who keeps the count. The filler fills; "the superior agents" and "the manager" order the quantities (sections 3 and 4).
  • Not searched for this note: Turner and Johnson, whose barrow loads and platform-scale practice are in the charging practice note (Turner p. 112; Johnson pp. 7-8).

1. The charge and the burden as units

FigureValuePageQuote
Charcoal furnace coal chargethe same bulk or weight every time; 15 bushels an averageOverman 165"The coal charges of a charcoal furnace should have, invariably, the same bulk or weight."
Fuel in one charge10-15 bushels = 450-600 lb of charcoal or coke; 600-1200 lb of anthracite; larger on a narrow throatOverman 195"The amount of fuel for one charge is, in charcoal or coke, from ten to fifteen bushels"
Ore chargevaries with ore, coal, blast and managementOverman 165"The ore charges vary according to the quality of the ore and coal, and according to blast and management."
Ore after the fuela charge of ore follows each coal chargeOverman 195"Immediately after a coal charge is filled, a charge of ore is thrown into the furnace."
Burden (Truran)weight of calcined ironstone charged for a definite measure of fuelTruran 64-65"the weight of calcined ironstone which is charged into the furnace for a definite measure of the fuel used is termed the 'burden.'"
Charge (Truran)ore with its assigned fuel and fluxTruran 65"A definite quantity of ore with its assigned proportion of fuel and flux is termed a 'charge'"
South Wales coal furnaces10 cwt calcined mine to 9 cwt coals; limestone about 3.5 cwtTruran 65"10 cwt. of calcined mine to 9 cwt. of coals"
Burden (Percy)a heavy burden is a large share of iron-yielding materials and a small share of fuelPercy 350"a heavy burden, i. e. a large proportion of iron-yielding materials and a relatively small proportion of fuel"
Lightening the burdenthe same thing as more cokePercy 473"The burden was lightened, or in other words, the proportion of coke was increased"
Burden per ton of iron (no per-round figure)South Wales anthracite: 3 tons 7 cwt argillaceous carbonate, 1 ton 15-17 cwt anthracite, 17 cwt limestone to 1 ton of ironFairbairn 76"the burden is about 3 tons 7 cwts. of argillaceous carbonate"
Order of fillingfuel and flux are filled in between each barrowful of oreTruran 64"Between each barrowful of calcined ore the proper quantities of fuel and flux are filled in."

Truran's term for the filling pass is "rounds": fillers were seen to "charge several rounds of ironstone through one side of the tunnel-head without the usual complement of coal, which has been charged at the opposite side" (Truran 66). The unit is ore with its complement of coal; a round that lacked its coal chilled the nearest tuyere (Truran 66).

2. Counting charges

FigureValuePageQuote
Charges as a clocka furnace "has gone one charge" each time a charge is filled; the make is estimated from the charges in a given time, "say twelve hours, the period usually taken"Truran 65"By the number of charges which the furnace goes in a given time say twelve hours, the period usually taken the probable make of iron is estimated."
Charges and blastthe charges brought down in 12 or 24 hours depend much on the blast, but air does not fix the descent with certaintyOverman 200"The number of charges brought down in twelve or twenty-four hours, or the quantity of iron produced, depends very much on the amount of blast"
Filling to a leveleach new charge of coal and ore should "just fill the furnace, and no more than fill it"Overman 191"every new charge of coal and ore should just fill the furnace, and no more than fill it"
The charge measureat narrow-topped charcoal furnaces a rod of two half-inch iron bars, one sunk into the stock, the other a handle, with a small plate to stop it sinking into the spaces; unneeded at coal or coke furnaces and wide tops, where the stock is not let sink low before refillingOverman 191-192"a charge measure is generally employed at charcoal furnaces with narrow tops"
Cost of irregular filling"Irregular filling produces irregular work, bad iron, and small burden, as well as trouble to the keeper."Overman 192same
Man-countSouth Staffordshire: three men to a furnace, one keeper, one hot-air man, one filler; coke-wheelers and limestone-breakers help at the castPercy 492"one keeper, one hot-air man, and one filler"

INFERRED: the books count by the charge as a whole, and by the level of the stock, not by barrows; the only barrow count given is the blowing-in fill below.

Blowing-in at Ebbw Vale (Percy 491, after Mr. George Parry): 3-4 ft of old timber, then "18 barrows of coke, of 7 cwts. each"; then "regular charges of coke, limestone, and a very light burden of ore", the burden "very gradually increased up to that required for the production of good grey iron in the ordinary working"; blast at about a third of the full volume for a day or two, then opened (Percy 491). Overman starts a new furnace on about half the regular burden: if a full ore charge is 700 lb, the starting charge is 350 lb, not raised for three or four days or a week (Overman 165), and the full blast comes after a week, the ore charges "gradually increased", the full make in three weeks (four for a new furnace) (Overman 186).

3. Who set the proportion and who kept it

  • Set by analysis or trial, ordered by the managers: "The proper proportion of ironstone, flux, and fuel having been determined by analysis or experiment, it is most important that the workmen engaged in filling should maintain it regularly in the consecutive charges." (Truran 66).
  • Kept by weighing. Overman prefers weighing the ore, the fuel charge by measure or weight (Overman 194-196, in the charging practice note). Truran: "one or more weighing machines are placed in the barrow-road to the tunnel-head, having suitable weights placed beyond their control" (Truran 66); lock-up platform machines "weighted according to the burden on the furnace" at each stocking place, the barrow resting on the machine while it is filled (Truran 31).
  • The filler's discretion was the weak point. Truran: the arrangement leaves "too much at the discretion of the workmen"; weighing "is too generally omitted when the superior agents are not by, and even in their presence it is at best but a rough approximation" (Truran 66-67).
  • The one record kept. At Dowlais a mercury-plunger weighing machine, needing no effort from the filler, carried a paper cylinder good for a week's working, so that "the weight of every barrow-load that had passed over the platform during a given time could be ascertained at intervals of a few days" and "the agreement of the quantities charged with those ordered could be easily ascertained" (Truran 67). Truran calls it a check on "the present careless system of weighing" and expects it to become general (Truran 67).
  • Fillers and the keeper: the filler is a separate hand from the keeper (Percy 492). Overman's "keeper" is the man who works the hearth (irregular filling and half-melted balls give him trouble, Overman 191-192).

4. How the burden was changed

CaseWhat was donePageQuote
Fuel fixed, ore variedcoal charges are a given measure or weight; any alteration is made in the ore chargesOverman 195"should any alteration in their quantity be required, this is effected in the charges of the ore"
Ore weighed so it can be changedweigh the ore and, if the furnace goes wrong, lessen or raise the ore chargeOverman 195"to dimmish or increase the ore charge"
Cold hearththrow on dead charges, charges without ore, six, twelve or moreOverman 187"dead charges, that is, charges without any ore, the number of which can be increased, according to circumstances, to six or twelve, or even more"
A disturbance is not a reason to changemanagers who cut the ore on every trouble follow "a bad habit" unless the furnace is overburdenedOverman 187"it is advisable not to change burden, simply because a disturbance happens"
Overburdened and coldcut the ore charges and give dead charges meanwhileOverman 187"a reduction of the ore charges, and the application of dead charges, in the mean time, may be required"
Brown streaks in the cinderif the brown has not gone in five or six hours, lessen the ore charges; black cinder follows within 24 hours; "If light charges should not be near at hand, the difficulties would thus be greatly augmented"Overman 204"it is advisable to diminish the ore charges"
Top flame and irona heavy dark flame means a cold furnace and too heavy a burden; gray iron means the burden can be raised, white iron only cautiouslyOverman 204-205"If the iron is gray, the burden can be increased; but if it is white, this should be done cautiously."
Iron madesmall burden makes gray, heavier burden white; white iron is prevented "only by carrying as heavy a burden as possible"Overman 202"Small burden will produce gray, and heavier burden white iron."
Lightening for gray ironBlackwell, closed-top furnace: burden lightened, then lightened further, coke raised, iron stayed white; the closed mouth, not the filling, was the cause ("the mode of filling was precisely the same")Percy 473"The burden was further lightened, and, although the cinder was exceedingly grey, the iron still remained white."
Cold blast after hotthe original burden makes more iron for 24-30 hours; "unless the burden of ore and the diameter of the blowpipes be reduced" the effects are ruinousPercy 423-424"the furnace makes more iron with the original burden"
Overburden costs metaldark or black cinder (forge-iron furnaces) averages 12% metal against 6% for grey; the grey cinder needs about 8 cwt more fuel a ton of pigTruran 65"the quantity of metal lost in the cinders produced with a heavy burden"
Stepping the ore in blowing inore raised in steps and lowered again, a blank charge of fuel at each change (Vordernberg charcoal furnace): "gradually raised from 3 to 6 cwt. per charge, and then diminished similarly, a blank charge of fuel being given at each change"Bauerman 201same

5. What this establishes

  • The ratio was never a count of barrows in the books: it was a weight of ore against a fixed fuel measure, held by the filler against scales set by the managers (sections 1 and 3).
  • The usual way to change the burden was to change the ore and leave the fuel alone (Overman 195); the other way was dead charges (fuel with no ore), used to warm a cold hearth (Overman 187).
  • The charge, not the barrow, was the counted unit: charges a half-day gave the make (Truran 65).
  • The books say nothing on a wall tally, pegs or a count the filler kept in his head or on a board.