Five period books against the first ten

Books Treatise on Mills and Millwork, Part II, The Manufacture of Iron and Steel Tubes, An Autobiography, A Study of the Open Hearth, The Basic Open-Hearth Steel Process, Metallurgy: Iron and Steel, The Manufacture and Properties of Iron and Steel, The Manufacture of Iron, The Cupola Furnace, The Iron-Founder, Modern Machine-Shop Practice, Roll-Turning for Sections in Steel and Iron

Covers the five digests of the second shelf in this folder: Percy 1864, Fairbairn (Mills and Millwork, Part II) 1863, Marks 1903, Bessemer 1905, and H-W and Dichmann 1909 and 1915, read against the synthesis of the first ten. Only what the second shelf adds is listed. Where two digests conflicted the book text decided it: Percy pp. 657, 695, 701, 721-722, 814, 823-824, 835-836, 838 (the OCR); Bessemer pp. 158-159, 161, 187, 203, 268, 271; Campbell pp. 8, 95, 102, 123; Overman pp. 301-302, 340-341; Dichmann p. 119; Fairbairn pp. 82, 259, 270. Pages are the books' printed folios. Subject which claims the second shelf confirms or overturns, row by row against the first ten books.

1. Books against each other

#Claim at stakeFirst readingLater bookVerdict
1a Bessemer blow "about twenty minutes with no correction possible"Campbell: 7-12 min at 20-30 psi, corrected by scrap and steam (p. 102)Bessemer: 15-20 min on Swedish pig, about twenty at Sheffield (pp. 158, 174, 187); Percy: 12-20 min in 1863, then spiegel and five more (p. 823)Overturned on the minutes: twenty is 1856-63 practice at 8-15 lb, Campbell's is 1890. "No correction" was British practice in 1864 (Percy p. 814), not the process (Bessemer p. 270)
2a Bessemer blast of 2.5 atmCampbell: inside 20-30 psi (p. 102)Bessemer: 8-15 lb (pp. 143, 157); Percy: 15 psi at Sheffield (p. 823)Stands on 1890s practice; the 1860s blast, 1.5-2.0 atm absolute, would not count as blast
3a Bessemer steel yield of 90 %Campbell: loss 8-11 % (p. 107)Bessemer: 12.5 % to ingot iron, steel about 2.5 % less (pp. 158, 161); Percy: about 15 % at Sheffield, plus 7.5 % in the air furnace (p. 824)Stands on two books; Percy's is 1863 practice on remelted pig
4without Mushet's spiegel the process "does not work"Campbell: blown iron without it is red-short (pp. 8, 22)Bessemer: 1856-58 failed on phosphorus; Swedish pig blew to steel "wholly without" spiegel (pp. 170-174, 275-276); Percy: spiegel "has given a value to Bessemer's process ... which certainly it did not previously possess" (p. 814)"Did not work at all" fails; "made it an industry" holds for British coke pig (Percy; Bessemer pp. 194, 289). The step is mandatory on manganese-free pig
5the blow "does not stop where the player wants it"Campbell: Swedish works stopped high in carbon (pp. 104, 108-109)Bessemer: "any quality of metal may be obtained" (p. 161); Percy: in Britain the stop could not be judged, so the metal was blown out and spiegel added (p. 814)Split by country: British practice matched the sentence, Swedish manganese pig did not. The sentence holds
6spiegel met the blow in the ladle; "Bessemer plants ladled"Campbell: into vessel or ladle (p. 112)Bessemer: fluid additions poured into the vessel, solid pushed in from the upper chamber (p. 268); Percy: run into the converter and blown five minutes more (p. 823)Confirmed; in the 1860s the vessel was the usual place
7spiegel "roughly a tenth of FeMn's strength"Campbell: spiegel 10-26 % Mn, ferro 80 % (pp. 8, 82)Bessemer: spiegel 8 % Mn, English at most about 9 % (pp. 271, 273)Both hold: English spiegel of the 1860s is a tenth of 80 % ferro, American spiegel of 1907 a third to an eighth. "A tenth" holds for the 1860s
8a 10-15 % spiegel doseCampbell: "for every ten tons of steel about one ton" for rail steel (p. 8)Percy: "usually from 5 to 10 %" at Sheffield (p. 823)About 10 % is where the books meet; 15 % is above both
9"a steel ladle is basic-lined"Campbell: acid heats drew slag sand from the ladle linings (p. 183)Bessemer: "the ganister used for lining the vessel and ladle" (p. 203)Confirmed
10"cut the blast, or tilt away. Both work"Campbell: the vessel is turned down before the blast stops (p. 100)Bessemer: the fixed vessel blew before the metal ran in (p. 158); the tilting vessel turned its tuyeres above the metal (p. 148)Confirmed
11the cupola carburises by contactKirk, overturned by Campbell p. 409Percy: "Cupola furnaces cannot be employed" to melt steel, the metal "materially changed ... by contact with solid carbonaceous matter" (p. 838)Confirmed; the sentences stand
12"Bessemer plants kept a cupola melting spiegeleisen"Campbell: spiegel melted and run into vessel or ladle (p. 112)Bessemer: molten pig "from the finery or cupola" (p. 270), Holley's cupolas (p. 341); Percy: "from a small furnace" (p. 823)Confirmed
13pot lifeCampbell: four to six heats, 80 lb when new (p. 95)Percy: "three meltings", 45, 40 and 36 lb (p. 836)Three is Sheffield's clay pot. Both books shrink the charge as the pot ages
14a coke trim "is how Huntsman actually hit a grade"Campbell: graded by fracture, charcoal in the pot American (pp. 94-95)Percy: blister "broken up and assorted"; the Sheffield addition is Heath's manganese, 1-3 % (pp. 835, 840)Confirmed
15"no pickup at all - homogeneous"Campbell: .20-.40 % Si and carbon from the pot (pp. 95, 99)Percy: "perfectly uniform composition throughout" (p. 828); coke dust in the pot clay (p. 834)Confirmed: slag-free holds, and the pickup is the pot's, Campbell's "coke which is mixed with the clay" (p. 95)
16a damper-shut hold after the meltCampbell: the last phase is the "dead melt", the pot lying quiet before it is pulled (p. 95)Percy: the anneal is the pot heated to redness before the hole; it is pulled "as soon as the steel is perfectly molten" (p. 835)No book has a third damper phase. The dead melt is the signal to pull
17"The historical puddling loss band is 8-12 %"Overman: 4-5 % on good white metal, 20 % on bad (pp. 301-302)Percy: Dudley 8 % good work, 17 % bad (p. 721); Bromford 7-9 % (p. 657)Two books to one: the band holds. Overman's figure is good white metal; his grey pig boiled with ore lost 2-5 % (p. 302)
18"stiff tap cinder, not a pour"Overman; Campbell p. 88Percy: tapped into tap-waggons (p. 646), every heat on grey pig, every other on white, once a turn on refined metal (p. 658)Confirmed
19charcoal as the lean chargefive booksPercy: Swedish charcoal blast 1/2-1 1/2 psi, "always much less" than coke (p. 373)Confirmed
20reheat burn-offCampbell: 1-2 % to scale (p. 170)Percy: puddled to finished bar about 10 % (pp. 721-722)Corroborated
21"Nasmyth built the hammer in 1839"; "from 1839"-Percy: "first reduced to a practical form by Nasmyth in 1842", the 9 June 1842 patent holding "the first drawings of the perfected single-acting hammer" (pp. 695, 701)1842. Percy names no hammer of 1839
22the steam hammer "added a size class rather than retiring the helve"Overman p. 341: "the hammer ... crumbles those balls which have been carelessly put together"Percy: helves "to a considerable extent ... replaced" in English forges; regulated blows save balls "which would crumble ... under the helve" (p. 695)No conflict: Overman's hammer is any hammer against the squeezer, and his steam hammer is "perfectly in the power of the hammerman" (p. 340). The helve stays in use
23cast coarse gear, cut meshing gearBolland, overturned by Rose (pp. 34, 64)Fairbairn: millwork meshed as cast, pitches few "for casting" (pp. 14, 35); the cutter a dividing lathe (pp. 9-11)The split sits lower than Rose put it
24"the drilled web is the visible difference"Rose pp. 34, 54; Bolland pp. 305-324Fairbairn: wheels cast with teeth and arms (p. 6, fig. 181)Confirmed
25"identical stands on one line shaft"Spencer: three-high roughing, two-high finishingFairbairn: puddling rolls off the fly-wheel shaft through a coupling, the squeezer through a spur train (p. 255); merchant 60-70 rpm, plate 28-30 (pp. 259-260)Confirmed
26"compression may be cast, tension may not"Bolland pp. 48, 81-85Fairbairn: main and vertical shafts of cast iron by choice, for torsion (p. 51)Confirmed
27a heavy stand "was not re-gapped mid-schedule"; every gap 0.5 below the lastSpencer: slab and cogging stands screwed between passes; 0.82-0.89 a grooveFairbairn: the armour-plate mill screwed down every pass, 12, 10, 8 in (p. 270)Confirmed; a plate mill ran an equal step
28a feeding head on a cast rollBolland pp. 124-125Fairbairn: rolls cast upright in loam, a head feeding the shrinkage (p. 258)Confirmed
29rolls "chilled cast iron in every tier"Rose: chilled rolls turned slowest (pp. 215-216, 258)Fairbairn: bar rolls chilled, shallowly; plate rolls cast "from the most tenacious metals" with a concave barrel; wire rolls cast steel (pp. 258-260)Confirmed for bar sets; the wide roll, a plate roll, was not chilled
30babbitt and bronze journals; "speed is the thing a journal bearing cannot do"Rose: lathe and shafting journals in babbitt (p. 124)Fairbairn: brass steps and gun-metal footsteps (pp. 74, 93-97); plain journals at 94-200 rpm, Table 8 to 1000 rpm (pp. 71, 102-105)Babbitt is the later practice; no book says a journal bearing cannot run fast
31"eight to twelve hours"Campbell (pp. 187, 215-216)Dichmann: melted in 3-4 h and boiled out in about one more (p. 248); timed heats 260-315 min (pp. 254, 276)Confirmed
32"A Siemens furnace is blown"Campbell (pp. 132, 144)Dichmann: the gas side blown from the producer; air by buoyancy, a fan on old choked furnaces (pp. 7-16)Confirmed
33"the open hearth is basic practice"Campbell (pp. 12, 207)H-W: one furnace, only the bottom differs; acid practice first and at length (pp. 14, 50-74)Confirmed
34the slag shareCampbell: converter 12 % (p. 107)H-W: acid open-hearth slag "somewhat under 10 per cent." (p. 63); Dichmann: basic about 11 % (p. 188)Confirmed; about 10 % either way, and the basic slag is not larger
35the regenerator capCampbell: near 1000 C (p. 123)Dichmann: 1200 C "well endured without harm by all furnaces", checkers melting above it (pp. 117-119)Overturned; Campbell's 1000 C is a running figure
36the gas producer: coal, steam and preheating of the gasCampbellH-W: bituminous gas coal (pp. 47-48); steam against clinker, no gain (p. 46); producer gas preheated in its chamber, natural-gas furnaces regenerating the air alone (p. 43); Dichmann: coal and lignite (p. 21)Confirmed, all four
37"the ceiling is time"CampbellDichmann: a charge without carbon "cannot boil" (p. 206); all scrap on coke 315 min against 280 (pp. 253-254)Confirmed, with a carbon floor beside the clock
38the open hearth lit by a fire in the chambersCampbellH-W: a wood fire to dull red, then gas (p. 14); Dichmann: gas is never let into a cold furnace (p. 138)Confirmed