Bourne, Handbook of the Steam-Engine (1865), Rankine, Manual of the Steam Engine (1859) and Farey (1827): steam tables, engine duty, pressures, ports and pipes
Books Handbook of the Steam-Engine, A Manual of the Steam Engine and Other Prime Movers, A Treatise on the Steam Engine
Sources
- John Bourne, A Handbook of the Steam-Engine (London, Longmans, 1865), archive.org
handbookofsteame00bouriala. Pages are printed folios; PDF page less 16. Text layer present; the Regnault table (pp. 159-160) was read from the page image, all other Bourne quotes are from the text layer (OCR, line breaks joined) and not image-checked. - W. J. M. Rankine, A Manual of the Steam Engine and Other Prime Movers (London and Glasgow, 1859), archive.org
amanualsteameng01rankgoog. Pages are printed folios; PDF page less 30. The PDF has no text layer: pages were found through the archive.org OCR text and every figure below was then checked on the page image (pp. 382, 409, 410, 411, 413, 414) except where a row says OCR. - John Farey, A Treatise on the Steam Engine vol. 1 (1827),
treatiseonsteame01fareuoft; only the steam-pipe rule of pp. 589-590 (printed folio is PDF page less 18; text layer) and two proportions from pp. 184 and 490-498. The rest is in the Farey note. Purpose real figures in SI for steam properties, steam per indicated horse-power, cut-offs, working pressures, friction and back pressure, steam-pipe and port areas. Not repeated the Farey note (Watt-era ratings, 33 cu ft per minute per hp, blowing engines) and the McNaught note (1862-1870 mill pressures, coal per ihp-hour 1.7 to 6 lb); both are cited where relied on. INFERRED marks my own arithmetic. Conversions: 1 psi = 6.895 kPa, 1 atm = 14.696 psi, 1 lb = 0.4536 kg, 1 ft = 0.3048 m, 1 in = 25.4 mm, 1 sq in = 645.2 mm2, 1 lb/cu ft = 16.018 kg/m3, 1 hp = 0.7457 kW, t(C) = (t(F) - 32) / 1.8.
0. What the books do not give
- Measured pounds of steam (or feed water) per indicated horse-power hour for any engine. Bourne gives coal per ihp-hour and a rule of thumb (one cubic foot of water an hour per horse-power, section 3); Rankine gives coal per ihp-hour for an ideal engine (section 3). Steam per hour here is coal times the evaporation they state (INFERRED).
- Working pressures by decade for 1780-1870 as a series. Scattered figures only (section 5); nothing for the 1830s and 1840s, and no locomotive working pressure was found in the Handbook.
- A steam-hammer pressure or steam per blow. Bourne's Handbook has no steam hammer (no entry in its index, no hit in the text). Rankine's index has no entry either; he names "steam hammers" only as a class of non-rotative engine (p. 478). The Percy note gives dates only.
- A steam table below 15 psi absolute: Bourne's Regnault table starts at 15 lb. The atmosphere (14.696 psi) lies just under its first row.
- Any Cornish engine figure from Rankine: his Art. 380 (Cornish pumping engine, index p. 623) is past the end of the archive.org OCR and was not read.
- A cut-off by engine type and date. Bourne gives only the Boulton and Watt practice and "a common practice" of one third (section 4).
- Port area for a non-condensing engine as such; the rules are for all slide-valve engines.
1. Saturated steam, Regnault, as printed by Bourne (pressure 1 to about 13.6 atm)
Bourne p. 159: "The principal properties of saturated steam as deduced from the experiments of M. Regnault, exhibiting the pressure, the relative volume, the temperature, the total heat, and the weight of a cubic foot of steam of different densities, are given by Mr. Clark in the following tables" (the text is on p. 158; the tables are pp. 159-160, titled "Properties of saturated steam, by M. Regnault"). Columns: total pressure per square inch (lb, absolute; the table heads it "Total Pressure"), relative volume (steam volume as a multiple of the water it came from), temperature (F), total heat (F, thermal units per lb), weight of one cubic foot (lb). The SI columns are mine (INFERRED conversion only).
| Pressure lb/sq in abs | atm abs | kPa abs | Relative volume | Temp F | Temp C | Weight lb/cu ft | Density kg/m3 | Specific volume m3/kg |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 15 | 1.02 | 103 | 1669 | 213.1 | 100.6 | 0.0373 | 0.597 | 1.674 |
| 20 | 1.36 | 138 | 1280 | 228.0 | 108.9 | 0.0487 | 0.780 | 1.282 |
| 30 | 2.04 | 207 | 881 | 250.4 | 121.3 | 0.0707 | 1.132 | 0.883 |
| 45 | 3.06 | 310 | 608 | 274.4 | 134.7 | 0.1025 | 1.642 | 0.609 |
| 60 | 4.08 | 414 | 467 | 292.7 | 144.8 | 0.1335 | 2.138 | 0.468 |
| 75 | 5.10 | 517 | 381 | 307.5 | 153.1 | 0.1636 | 2.621 | 0.382 |
| 90 | 6.12 | 621 | 323 | 320.2 | 160.1 | 0.1929 | 3.090 | 0.324 |
| 100 | 6.80 | 690 | 293 | 327.8 | 164.3 | 0.2127 | 3.407 | 0.294 |
| 120 | 8.17 | 827 | 249 | 341.1 | 171.7 | 0.2503 | 4.009 | 0.249 |
| 150 | 10.21 | 1034 | 203 | 358.3 | 181.3 | 0.3070 | 4.918 | 0.203 |
| 200 | 13.61 | 1379 | 157 | 381.7 | 194.3 | 0.3970 | 6.359 | 0.157 |
Total heat of the same rows (F units, i.e. lb-F per lb): 15 lb 1178.9; 30 lb 1190.3; 60 lb 1203.2; 100 lb 1213.9; 150 lb 1223.2; 200 lb 1230.8. The full table is every pound from 15 to 80, then 81-130 by ones and 132-200 by tens (pp. 159-160); the Rankine back-pressure remark "152.6 lbs. on the square foot, or 1.06 lbs. on the square inch" at 104 F (p. 381) agrees with it at the low end. Bourne also states the formula source (Regnault's, p. 158: "Log. F = a + b alpha^t
- c beta^t" for 0-100 C and a second form for 100-230 C). The density 0.598 kg/m3 of steam at 100 C matches the 15 lb row (0.597).
2. Expansion, cut-off and its gain
| Figure | Value | SI | Page | Quote |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Gain by cut-off, steam stopped at half stroke | 1.7 times | - | Bourne 182 | "If the flow of steam to an engine be stopped when the piston has performed one-half of the stroke ... the efficacy of the steam will be increased 1-7 times" |
| Gain, further cut-offs | 1/3: 2.1; 1/4: 2.4; 1/5: 2.6; 1/6: 2.8; 1/7: 3.0; 1/8: 3.2 | - | Bourne 183 | "at one-third of the stroke, the efficacy will be increased 2-1 times; at one-fourth, 2'4 times; at one-fifth, 2'6 times; at one-sixth, 2-8 times; at one-seventh, 3 times; and at one-eighth, 3'2 times" |
| Rule | gain = 1 + hyperbolic log of the ratio of expansion | - | Bourne 183 | "The Neperian logarithm of the whole stroke expressed in terms of the part of the stroke performed with the full pressure of steam, represents the increase of efficiency due to expansion." |
| Mean pressure | initial pressure / r x (1 + ln r); terminal pressure = initial / r | - | Bourne 183-184 | "100 divided by 2 and multiplied by 1'693 = 84'65, which is the mean pressure throughout the stroke in lbs. per square inch" (steam of 100 lb cut at half stroke) |
| Mean-pressure tables by eighths and tenths of stroke | tables of mean pressure for initial pressures against cut-off | - | Bourne 185-186 | "MEAN PRESSURE OF STEAM AT DIFFERENT DENSITIES AND RATES OF EXPANSION" (not transcribed; the rule above regenerates it) |
| Boulton and Watt cut-off | lap cuts off at two-thirds of the stroke as the minimum of expansion; link to one-third | - | Bourne 376 | "Boulton and Watt put sufficient lap upon their valves to cut off the steam when two-thirds of the stroke have been performed as a minimum of expansion; and then, by aid of the link-motion, they can expand still more, if required, so as to cut off when one-third of the stroke has been performed." |
| Common marine cut-off | one third of the stroke | - | Bourne 375 | "If the steam be cut off from the cylinder when one-third of the stroke has been performed, as is a common practice, the efficiency of the steam will be somewhat more than doubled" |
| Ceiling of useful expansion, land | 7 or 8 expansions; no gain above 100 lb | - | Van Nostrand 36, in the McNaught note | (see the McNaught note) |
| Rankine's ideal tables | cut-off 0.1 to 1.0 of the stroke at set pressures | - | Rankine 410-411 | section 3 |
INFERRED: Watt-era engines with a one-third cut-off gain 2.1 times the steam; a cut at two-thirds gains 1 + ln 1.5 = 1.41 times (Bourne's rule). The Bourne figure at one-half (1.7) equals 1 + ln 2 = 1.693.
3. Steam and coal per indicated horse-power hour
3a. Bourne
| Figure | Value | SI | Page | Quote |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Water evaporated per ihp-hour, locomotive without expansion | 1 cu ft of water an hour is about one actual hp; 1 cu ft = 62.5 lb | 62.5 lb = 28.35 kg per hour per hp (INFERRED conversion) | Bourne 331 | "in locomotive boilers working without expansion the evaporation of a cubic foot of water in the hour will be about equivalent to an actual horse-power" |
| Coal to evaporate that, marine, modern | 7 lb coal per cu ft of water on 70 sq in of grate and 10 sq ft of heating surface | 3.2 kg coal per 28.35 kg water | Bourne 375 | "a cubic foot of water will be evaporated in the hour by 7 lbs. of coal burned on 70 square inches of fire-bars, and the heat from which is absorbed by 10 square feet of heating surface" |
| Coal per hp at one-third cut-off | "something less than 3 1/2 lb" | 1.6 kg per ihp-hour | Bourne 375-376 | "a horse-power will be generated with something less than 3 1/2 lbs of coal" |
| Coal per hp, efficient modern steamer | not more than 2 1/2 lb | 1.13 kg per ihp-hour | Bourne 376 | "In modern steam-vessels of efficient construction, therefore, the consumption of coal is not more than 2 1/2 lbs. per actual horse-power." |
| Coal per ihp-hour, Lambeth double cylinder | 1.7 lb | - | Bourne 367-369 | in the McNaught note |
| Water per lb coal, locomotive | 7.5 to 8 lb water per lb coke | - | Bourne 331 | "The evaporation in locomotive boilers is 7 1/2 to 8 lbs. of water per lb. of coke" |
| Water per lb coal, assumed | 8 lb coal per cu ft of water (62.5 lb) in a large marine plant | 7.8 lb water per lb coal (INFERRED) | Bourne 315 | "if we reckon 8 lbs. of coal as necessary to evaporate a cubic foot" |
| Heating surface per cu ft water an hour | 9 sq ft (marine plant); 4 sq ft in a forced marine boiler; 10 sq ft modern | 0.84, 0.37, 0.93 m2 (INFERRED) | Bourne 315, 380, 375 | "If we take 9 square feet as evaporating a cubic foot of water per hour"; "1 cubic foot of water was evaporated by every 4 square feet of heating surface" |
| Heating surface per nominal hp | 12 sq ft in the best plain boiler; up to 35 sq ft in a fast steamer | 1.1 to 3.3 m2 | Bourne 332, 375 | "marine boilers have been constructed with only 12 square feet of heating surface per nominal horse power, and in which the consumption was only 2 1/2 lbs. of coal per actual horse power" |
| Actual over nominal hp | about 4 to 4.5 in 1865; twice that in special cases | - | Bourne 376 | "about 4 or 4 1/2 times appears to be the prevalent proportion in 1865" |
| Rate of combustion | Cornish boilers 3.5 lb per sq ft of grate an hour; older land 10; later land 13-14; marine 16-24; locomotive 80-120 | 17, 49, 63-68, 78-117, 390-586 kg/m2 h (INFERRED) | Bourne 179 | "In Cornish boilers it is 3 1/2 lbs. per square foot; in the older class of land boilers, 10 lbs.; in more recent land boilers, 13 to 14 lbs.; in modern marine boilers, 16 to 24 lbs., and in locomotive boilers 80 to 120 lbs." |
| Air pump and condenser | one-eighth of the cylinder's capacity (Watt) | - | Bourne 215 | "The proportions of the condenser and of the air-pump were determined by Mr. Watt at one-eighth of the capacity of the cylinder." |
| Condenser surface | 0.15 of the boiler's heating surface | - | Bourne 380 | "A common proportion of condenser surface in modern engines is '15 that of the boiler surface." |
INFERRED: steam per ihp-hour, from Bourne's evaporations. Non-expansive locomotive: 62.5 lb (28.4 kg) of steam. Marine at 2.5 lb of coal and about 7 lb coal per 62.5 lb water: 2.5 x 62.5 / 7 = 22 lb (10 kg) of steam. At 3.5 lb and one-third cut-off: 31 lb (14 kg). The ratio 62.5 : 31 is Bourne's "somewhat more than doubled".
3b. Rankine's computed table (ideal dry saturated steam, no cylinder condensation)
Rankine pp. 409-411 compute, for "a regular series of values of the initial absolute pressure, p1, and of the ratio of expansion", the mean effective pressure and "the quantities of fuel consumed per indicated horse-power per hour", "on the assumption, that the mean absolute back pressure in condensing engines is 4 lbs. on the square inch, and in non-condensing engines, 18 lbs.; and that the available heat of combustion of 1 lb. of the coal employed is 5,400,000 foot-lbs." (p. 409; 5.4 million ft-lb = 7.32 MJ per lb = 16.1 MJ/kg). The tables' heading gives "an effective evaporative power of 7.24" lb of water per lb of coal (pp. 410, 411). Initial pressures are absolute. Columns are the cut-off (admission, fraction of the stroke). Coal per ihp-hour, lb (1 lb = 0.4536 kg); the water column is coal x 7.24 (INFERRED, ideal steam).
Condensing, back pressure 4 lb abs (27.6 kPa), Rankine p. 410:
| Initial abs pressure lb/sq in (atm, kPa) | Cut-off 0.1 | 0.2 | 0.3 | 0.4 | 0.5 | 0.6 | 0.8 | 1.0 (no cut-off) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 20 (1.36 atm, 138 kPa) | - | - | 3.88 | 4.07 | 4.42 | 4.89 | 5.87 | 7.04 |
| 40 (2.72, 276) | - | 2.80 | 3.11 | 3.46 | 3.85 | 4.19 | 5.15 | 6.32 |
| 60 (4.08, 414) | 2.30 | 2.62 | 2.93 | 3.30 | 3.67 | 4.07 | 5.02 | 6.11 |
| 80 (5.44, 552) | 2.14 | 2.49 | 2.86 | 3.21 | 3.59 | 4.03 | 4.95 | 6.00 |
| 100 (6.80, 690) | 2.07 | 2.44 | 2.79 | 3.19 | 3.55 | 3.99 | 4.89 | 5.91 |
Non-condensing ("high-pressure"), back pressure 18 lb abs (124 kPa), Rankine p. 411:
| Initial abs pressure lb/sq in (atm, kPa) | Cut-off 0.2 | 0.3 | 0.4 | 0.5 | 0.6 | 0.8 | 1.0 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 60 (4.08, 414) | - | - | 4.91 | 5.24 | 5.72 | 6.67 | 8.15 |
| 80 (5.44, 552) | - | 4.03 | 4.26 | 4.58 | 5.02 | 6.01 | 7.33 |
| 100 (6.80, 690) | 3.49 | 3.67 | 3.94 | 4.31 | 4.76 | 5.72 | 6.90 |
| 120 (8.17, 827) | 3.19 | 3.42 | 3.73 | 4.11 | 4.52 | 5.47 | 6.67 |
| 160 (10.89, 1103) | 2.89 | 3.19 | 3.52 | 3.89 | 4.31 | 5.24 | 6.42 |
Mean effective pressure, lb/sq in, read on the same tables: condensing 60 lb abs at 0.4 cut-off, 41.4 (285 kPa); non-condensing 100 lb abs at 0.4 cut-off, 57.6 (397 kPa).
Rankine p. 409, on the formulae's range: "for initial pressures up to about 120 lbs. on the square inch, both the exact and the approximate formulae agree with experiment closely enough for practical purposes." Rankine's worked comparison "Example V": "The consumption of coal is stated to be 2.07 lbs. per indicated horse-power per hour, for coal whose available heat of combustion in the furnace and boiler employed is 5,400,000 foot-lbs", reduced to 1.12 lb for 10,000,000 foot-lbs coal "corresponding to an effective evaporative power of 13.4" (p. 409).
INFERRED steam per ihp-hour from the tables (coal x 7.24; the figures assume no cylinder condensation, so a real engine used more, Bourne p. 367 "excess of water" row in section 7):
| Case (Rankine) | Coal lb/ihp-h | Steam lb/ihp-h | Steam kg/ihp-h | kg/kWh (ihp at 0.7457 kW) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Condensing, 60 lb abs, cut 0.4 | 3.30 | 23.9 | 10.8 | 14.5 |
| Condensing, 60 lb abs, no cut-off | 6.11 | 44.2 | 20.1 | 26.9 |
| Condensing, 100 lb abs, cut 0.1 | 2.07 | 15.0 | 6.8 | 9.1 |
| Condensing, 100 lb abs, cut 0.4 | 3.19 | 23.1 | 10.5 | 14.0 |
| Non-condensing, 100 lb abs, cut 0.4 | 3.94 | 28.5 | 12.9 | 17.3 |
| Non-condensing, 100 lb abs, no cut-off | 6.90 | 50.0 | 22.7 | 30.4 |
| Non-condensing, 60 lb abs, cut 0.4 | 4.91 | 35.5 | 16.1 | 21.6 |
| Non-condensing, 160 lb abs, cut 0.2 | 2.89 | 20.9 | 9.5 | 12.7 |
Cross-check (INFERRED): Bourne's non-expansive 62.5 lb (28.4 kg) per hp-hour sits between Rankine's no-cut-off condensing 44 lb and non-condensing 50 lb; his 22 lb marine figure matches Rankine's condensing 60-100 lb rows at a 0.3 to 0.4 cut-off.
4. Nominal horse-power, Bourne's rules
| Figure | Value | SI | Page | Quote |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Low-pressure nominal hp | D^2 x cube root of stroke (ft) / 47, D in inches | 64 in x 8 ft gives 174.3 nhp | Bourne 209-211 | "Multiply the square of the diameter of the cylinder in inches by the cube root of the stroke in feet, and divide the product by 47. The quotient is the nominal horse-power of the engine." |
| High-pressure nominal hp | three times the low-pressure figure | - | Bourne 211 | "The nominal power of a high pressure engine may be taken at three times that of a low pressure engine of the same size." |
| Pressures behind it | 7 lb on the piston (low), 21 lb (high) | 48 kPa, 145 kPa | Bourne 211 | "The assumed pressure in computing the nominal power of low pressure engines is 7 lbs. on each square inch of the piston, and the assumed pressure in computing the nominal power of high pressure engines is 21 lbs." |
| Assumed piston speed by stroke | 2 ft 160; 2.5 ft 170; 3 ft 180; 4 ft 200; 5 ft 215; 6 ft 228; 7 ft 245; 8 ft 256 ft/min | 0.81 m/s at 2 ft to 1.30 m/s at 8 ft | Bourne 211 | "for a 2 ft. stroke, 160 ft.; 2 1/2 ft., 170; 3 ft., 180; 4 ft, 200; 5 ft, 215; 6 ft, 228; 7 ft., 245; and 8 ft., 256 feet per minute" |
| Admiralty rule | D^2 x piston speed (ft/min) / 6000 | - | Bourne 211 | "Multiply the square of the diameter of the cylinder in inches by the speed of the piston in feet per minute, and divide by 6,000." |
| Actual hp | 33,000 lb raised one foot a minute | 745.7 W | Bourne 211 | "an actual horse power is a dynamical unit capable of raising a load of 33,000 lbs. one foot high in each minute of time" |
| Same rule restated | high-pressure effective pressure 21 lb "customary rule proposed by Mr. Bourne" | - | Rankine 479-480 | "assuming the effective pressure to be 21 lbs. per square inch" |
| Real pressures exceed those | in modern engines unbalanced pressure "much more than 7 lbs." and "much more than 21 lbs." | - | Bourne 211 | "In point of fact, in all modern low pressure engines the unbalanced pressure of steam upon the piston is much more than 7 lbs., and in most modern high pressure engines ... much more than 21 lbs." |
| Marine pressure assumed in his rules | 25 lb per sq in on the piston | 172 kPa | Bourne 254 | "a uniform pressure of 25 lbs. per square inch of the area of the piston shall be supposed to be at all times existing" |
This is the Boulton and Watt "nominal" system's later form; the Watt-era basis (7 psi mean effective pressure, 33,000 ft-lb per minute) is in the Farey note section 1. The rating of a nominal hp in McNaught's refit is not answered here: Bourne's rule above is the 1865 one.
5. Working pressures read in these books
| Engine and date | Pressure | SI | Page | Quote |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Low-pressure condensing engine, assumed in nominal hp, 1865 rule | 7 lb mean effective on the piston | 48 kPa | Bourne 211 | section 4 |
| Paddle steamers, boiler, 1850s-1860s ('Ulster', 'Victoria and Albert') | 26 lb per sq in (gauge), vacuum 12.5-13 lb, 23-25 strokes a minute | 179 kPa gauge, vacuum 86-90 kPa | Bourne 352-353 | "the pressure of steam in the boiler when the diagram was taken was 26 lbs. per square inch, and the vacuum in the condenser 13 lbs." |
| Same class, other diagrams | boiler 21-22 lb, vacuum 11 to 11.5 lb | 145-152 kPa gauge | Bourne 355-356 | "The pressure of steam in the boiler was 22 lbs., and that of the vacuum in the condenser 11 lbs. per square inch" |
| Wenham double-cylinder engine, 1862 exhibition | boiler 40 lb; high-pressure cylinder mean 26.6 lb, low 8.5 lb; 3 in x 12 in; 17 rev/min | 276 kPa gauge | Bourne 369 | "working with a pressure of 40 lbs. per square inch in the boiler ... The average pressure on the piston of the high-pressure engine, which is 3 inches diameter and 12 inches stroke, is 26.6 lbs. per square inch" |
| Allen's high-speed engine, 1862 exhibition | boiler 49 lb gauge; 8 in x 24 in; 150 rev/min | 338 kPa gauge | Bourne 356 | "diameter of the cylinder was 8 inches; length of stroke, 24 inches; pressure of steam in boiler, 49 lbs. per square inch; revolutions per minute, 150" |
| High-pressure engines carrying 100 lb | piston rod proportion is the subject; "total pressure of 25 lbs." is the common low-pressure figure | 100 lb = 690 kPa | Bourne 302 | "high pressure engines of any considerable dimensions, carrying 100 lbs. on the inch ... low pressure engines of the common total pressure of 25 lbs. per square inch" |
| Mill engines, 1862 and 1870 | 25-30 lb before, 50 lb after refit; 50-70 lb common, 140 lb for a McNaught beam | 172-207, 345, 345-483, 965 kPa | - | McNaught note, Van Nostrand 34-35 and Engineer 13 Jun 1862 |
| Watt era, 1780-1800 | 1 to 4.5 psi over the atmosphere | - | - | the Farey note |
| Lambeth waterworks double-cylinder engines, 1850s | 14 rev/min, 1.7 lb coal per ihp-h; friction and pumps 12-15 % | - | Bourne 367-369 | McNaught note and section 6 |
| Boiler plate rating, 1865 | single-riveted: P = t x 8900 / D; double-riveted: P = t x 11140 / D (t plate thickness and D diameter, inches; P lb per sq in) | 42 in boiler of 0.377 in plate: 79.8 lb (550 kPa); 36 in of 0.4 in: 99 lb (683 kPa) | Bourne 325 | "Multiply the thickness of the plates in inches by the constant number 8900, and divide the product by the diameter of the boiler in inches. The quotient is the pressure of steam per square inch at which the boiler may be worked." (the words "constant number 8900" and the example numbers are OCR-checked against the examples: .377 x 8900 / 42 = 79.8) |
| Safe fraction of bursting | Fairbairn one sixth; Bourne one seventh to one eighth | - | Bourne 322 | "Mr. Fairbairn considers that one sixth of the bursting pressure will be a safe working pressure; but in my opinion the working pressure should not be greater than between one-seventh and one-eighth of the bursting pressure." |
| Limit of the exact and approximate formulae against experiment | about 120 lb per sq in | 827 kPa | Rankine 409 | section 3b |
| Land-practice ceiling, 1870 | 100 lb | 690 kPa | Van Nostrand 36 | McNaught note |
Gaps in the series: no figure for 1800-1850 beyond what Farey (to 1827) and the McNaught note give; Bourne p. 379 names "a still higher pressure of steam than I contemplated in 1838" without a number. INFERRED reading: the pressures in section 5 run 1 to 4.5 psi (Watt) to 21-26 lb (steamers 1850s-60s) to 25-50 lb (mills 1860s) to 50-140 lb (mills 1870).
6. Friction and back pressure
| Figure | Value | SI | Page | Quote |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Friction of engine and pumps, new engines | up to 25 % of the indicated power | - | Bourne 367 | "when the engines were new, and working at perhaps little more than half their power, the loss in comparing the work done with the indicator diagrams amounts to as much as 25 per cent. of the indicated power" |
| Friction, engines at regular work | 12 to 15 % of the indicated power (engines and pumps, air pump, feed pump, cold-water pumps) | efficiency 85-88 % | Bourne 367 | "all the losses were brought down to from 12 to 15 per cent. of the indicated power" |
| Friction, Lambeth engines | about 20 % | - | Bourne 368 | "the loss by friction and by working the air-pumps, &c., averaged about 20 per cent. of the power, as given by the indicator diagrams" |
| Indicated over useful on the same pair | "nearly 20 per cent. more H.P." | - | Engineer 30 May 1862 | McNaught note |
| Condenser temperature, working properly | 104 F; steam pressure at it 1.06 lb per sq in | 40 C; 7.3 kPa abs | Rankine 381 | "an ordinary temperature in a condenser when working properly, is about 104 degrees Fahrenheit, to which the corresponding pressure of steam is 152.6 lbs. on the square foot, or 1.06 lbs. on the square inch" |
| Best condensers, absolute | scarcely ever less than 2 lb per sq in | 13.8 kPa abs | Rankine 381-382 | "the absolute pressure in the best condensers is scarcely ever less than 2 lbs. on the square inch, or nearly double of the pressure of condensation" |
| Back pressure above the condenser | 1 to 3 lb per sq in greater than in the condenser | 7-21 kPa | Rankine 382 | "the mean back pressure is caused to be from 1 to 3 lbs. on the square inch greater than the pressure in the condenser" |
| Mean back pressure, condensing, by ratio of expansion | 1.5 to 3 expansions: 5 lb; 4 to 7: 4.5 to 3.5 lb; 8 to 15: 3.5 to 3 lb | 34.5; 31.0-24.1; 24.1-20.7 kPa | Rankine 382 | "Ratio of expansion from 1 1/2 to 3 ... 720 [lb on the square foot] ... 5 [lb on the square inch]; from 4 to 7 ... 648 to 504 ... 4 1/2 to 3 1/2; from 8 to 15 ... 504 to 432 ... 3 1/2 to 3" (image-checked) |
| Mean back pressure used in his tables | condensing 4 lb abs; non-condensing 18 lb abs | 27.6 kPa; 124 kPa | Rankine 409 | section 3b |
| Non-condensing back pressure | the atmospheric pressure for the time, plus a rise with speed squared, release pressure and blast-pipe area | - | Rankine 382-383 | "the excess of the back pressure above the atmospheric pressure varies nearly as the square of the speed; as the pressure of the steam at the instant of release; inversely as the square of the area of the orifice of the blast pipe" |
| Clark's locomotive case | 16 % release, half-stroke admission, 600 ft/min: excess back pressure 0.163 of the excess of release pressure over atmosphere | 3.05 m/s | Rankine 383 | "the excess of the back pressure above the atmospheric pressure, in protected cylinders, was about 0.163 of the excess of the pressure of the steam at the instant of release above the atmospheric pressure" |
| Back pressure rises with liquid water | up to 1.72 times in unprotected against protected cylinders | - | Rankine 383 | "being in certain cases greater in unprotected than in protected cylinders in the ratio of 1.72 to 1" |
| Open exhaust | in some high-pressure engines, large ports and a straight pipe give no back pressure, a partial vacuum | - | Bourne 339 | "there is not only no back pressure on the piston, but a partial vacuum is created within the cylinder by the momentum of the escaping steam" |
| Excess of water over the cylinder's steam | about 37 % of the water leaving the boilers did not show as steam used at the cylinder in some trials | - | Bourne 367 | "the excess of water thus disappearing from the boilers was about 37 per cent." (indicator diagrams, large double-cylinder engines; Bourne notes the leaky-valve explanation) |
7. Steam pipe bore and port areas
7a. Bourne p. 216-218
| Figure | Value | SI | Page | Quote |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Port area, moderate speed | 1 sq in per nominal horse-power, "about 1/25th of the area of the cylinder" | 645 mm2 per nhp | Bourne 216 | "The area of steam port commonly given in the best engines working at a moderate speed is about 1 square inch per nominal horse-power" (the fraction "1/25th" is OCR-damaged to "^yth"; the 74.5 in worked example agrees: 224 sq in over 4359 sq in is 1/19.4, "somewhat more than" 1/25) |
| Steam pipe, same engines | 0.66 sq in per nominal hp | 426 mm2 per nhp | Bourne 216 | "the area of the steam pipe leading into the cylinder is less than this, or .66 square inch per nominal horse power" |
| Port rule, any speed | A = D^2 x V x 0.032 / 140 (D cylinder bore in inches, V piston speed ft/min, A each cylinder port in sq in) | 64 in at 220 ft/min gives 206 sq in (0.133 m2) | Bourne 217 | "Multiply the square of the diameter of the cylinder in inches by the speed of the piston in feet per minute and by the decimal .032, and divide the product by 140." |
| Steam-pipe rule, any speed | A = D^2 x V x 0.02 / 170 | 74.5 in at 220 ft/min gives 144 sq in, 13.5 in bore (343 mm) | Bourne 218 | "Multiply the square of the diameter of the cylinder in inches by the speed of the piston in feet per minute and by the decimal .02, and divide the product by 170." |
| Example plant | cylinders 74.5 in, stroke 7 ft; ports 33.5 x 6.7 in = 224.4 sq in; steam pipe 13.5 in diameter inside, 145.8 sq in | 1.89 m, 2.13 m; 0.145 m2; 0.094 m2 | Bourne 217-218 | "the area of each port was 224.4 square inches, being somewhat less than the proportion of 1 square inch per nominal horse power" (nominal power about 234 hp) |
| Doubling with speed | at 440 ft/min the port area is double | 2.24 m/s | Bourne 218 | "At a speed of the piston of 440 feet per minute the area of the port would be double the foregoing." |
| Main pipe of two engines at right angles | nearly but not quite twice a branch | - | Bourne 218 | "The main steam pipe will require to have nearly, but not quite, double the area of each of the branch steam pipes." |
| Locomotive port | 11 in x 1 5/8 in = 17.875 sq in each; branch pipe smaller (fraction lost in the OCR) | 0.0115 m2 | Bourne 330-331 | "The steam ports for admitting the steam to the cylinder are 11 inches by 1 5/8ths, and consequently each has an area of 17.875 square inches. The branch steampipe leading to each cylinder has [OCR gap] less area than this." (the fraction is lost in the OCR) |
| Do not oversize | larger surface radiates heat | - | Bourne 218 | "It is not desirable to make the steam pipe larger than is absolutely necessary, as an increased external surface causes increased loss of heat from radiation." |
INFERRED: Bourne's pipe rule at a piston speed V makes pipe area / piston area = 0.02 V / (170 x 0.7854) = V / 6676. At 220 ft/min that is 1/30; at 600 ft/min, 1/11. His port rule makes port area / piston area = V / 3290: 1/15 at 220 ft/min, 1/5.5 at 600. (Rankine's statement below sits between the two Bourne ratios.)
7b. Rankine pp. 413-415 (image-checked)
| Figure | Value | SI | Page | Quote |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Steam pipe, no appreciable loss | area not less than 1/10 of the piston's for ordinary steam, 1/8 for very dry steam, piston speed not above 600 ft/min | 3.05 m/s | Rankine 413 | "the effect of the resistance in the steam pipe is inappreciable, when the sectional area of that pipe is not less than 1/10 of the area of the piston for steam in an ordinary state as to dryness, and not less than 1/8 for steam in a very dry state; the mean speed of the piston not exceeding 600 feet per minute, or 10 feet per second" |
| Resulting steam speed in the pipe | about 100 ft/s | 30.5 m/s | Rankine 413-414 | "the velocity of the steam through the steam pipe shall not exceed about 100 feet per second" |
| Ordinary rule | piston 200-240 ft/min, pipe area about 1/18 of the piston's (the denominator is a faint "18"; "15" is not excluded) | 1.0-1.2 m/s | Rankine 414 | "where the velocity of the piston is from 200 to 240 feet per minute, the area of the steam pipe should be about 1/18 of that of the piston" |
| Cylinder ports | Clark: piston area over port area 15 at 10 ft/s piston speed gives pressure at cylinder 0.84 of the valve chest's, the chest at about 90 lb per sq in | 3.05 m/s; 621 kPa | Rankine 415 | "when A/a = 15, and V = 10 feet per second, p1/p0 = 0.84 nearly; the pressure in the valve chest, p0, being on an average 90 lbs. on the square inch or thereabouts" (OCR text, not image-checked) |
| Causes of the fall from boiler to cylinder | steam pipe, regulator, ports, kinetic energy at admission; not separable | - | Rankine 413 | "It is impossible, in the present state of our knowledge of the properties of steam, to calculate separately the losses of pressure due to these four causes" |
| Regulator | no appreciable resistance wide open in a properly sized pipe | - | Rankine 414 | "The resistance of the regulator in a properly proportioned steam pipe is inappreciable when it is wide open" |
7c. Farey 1827, steam-pipe rule
| Figure | Value | SI | Page | Quote |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Internal bore | rather more than one-fifth of the cylinder's diameter; area about 1/23 of the cylinder's | - | Farey 589 | "Its internal diameter is usually rather more than one-fifth of the diameter of the steam cylinder, so that its area is about one-23rd of that of the cylinder." |
| Per horse-power | 1 1/4 circular inches (0.982 sq in) per hp, or 0.8 hp to each circular inch; 12 sq ft of heating surface per hp; one circular inch of pipe to 9.6 sq ft of heating surface | 633 mm2 per hp, 850 mm2 per kW (INFERRED); 1.1 m2 per hp | Farey 589 | "This is at the rate of 1 1/4 circular inches (= .982 of a square inch) to each horse-power. Or reciprocally .8 tenths of a horse-power to each circular inch of the steam-pipe." |
| Rule | circular inches of pipe area = hp / 0.8, = heating surface (sq ft) / 9.6, = (D^2 x piston speed ft/min) / 4840; the bore is the square root | 20 hp gives 25 circular inches, 5 in bore (127 mm); 50 hp, 7.9 in | Farey 590 | "Divide the horse-power that the steam is required to exert, by .8 (or the square feet of heating surface in the boiler by 9.6); or the cylindrical inch feet of space per minute in the cylinder, by 4840. The quotient is the proper area of the passage through the steam-pipe in circular inches" |
| Steam speed | mean 80.6 ft/s, 120.6 ft/s at mid stroke (33 cu ft of steam a minute per hp, 1.25 circular inches per hp) | 24.6 m/s mean, 36.8 m/s peak | Farey 590 | "the velocity with which the steam must pass through the pipe would be (6050 / 1.25 =) 4840 feet per minute, or (/ 60 =) 80.63 feet per second" |
| Smeaton's table of 1770s engines | bore one-sixth of the cylinder's for cylinders above 48 in, more proportion for smaller | - | Farey 184 | "The diameter of the steam-pipe is measured internally, and for large engines above 48-inc. cylinder it is one-sixth of the diameter of the cylinder; but a rather greater proportion is allowed for the smaller sizes." |
| Boulton and Watt 20 hp-class engine, ports | seat apertures 4.5 in diameter, about 17 sq in, 0.85 sq in per hp; steam and eduction pipes 5.5 in inside; piston 210 ft/min | 11,000 mm2; 548 mm2 per hp (INFERRED); 1.07 m/s | Farey 490-498 (page header not isolated) | "The apertures of the steam, and exhausting-valve seats, are 4 1/2 inches diameter, or about 17 square inches of uninterrupted passage, that is, .85 of a square inch to each horse power." |
INFERRED: Farey's steam-pipe area (1.25 circular inches, 0.98 sq in) per horse-power is the same order as Bourne's 0.66 sq in per nominal hp (nominal hp being about a quarter to a third of actual hp by 1865; the Watt hp was close to nominal in 1800). Per 1000 ihp the 1865 pipe: 0.66 x 1000 / 4 = 165 sq in of pipe if actual = 4 x nominal. Rankine's 1/10 of the piston at 600 ft/min corresponds to 100 ft/s steam speed; Farey's 80.6 ft/s mean agrees with it.
8. Steam hammers
Not documented in these books (section 0). Bourne's Treatise of 1846 (atreatiseonstea00bourgoog) was not read for it.