Proportioning and charging the furnace, the kiln and the cupola
Books The Manufacture of Iron, The Iron Manufacture of Great Britain, A Treatise on the Metallurgy of Iron, Blast-Furnace Construction in America, The Principles, Operation and Products of the Blast Furnace, The Cupola Furnace
Covers (printed folios unless said)
- F. Overman, Manufacture of Iron (1851); folio = PDF page less 6. Read pp. 39-46, 191-200 in full.
- W. Truran, The Iron Manufacture of Great Britain, 2nd ed. 1862 (revised from Truran's manuscript by Phillips and Dorman; the 1855 first edition was not found), archive.org ironmanuf00trurrich; folios from running heads, some uncertain by one page (marked "about").
- H. Bauerman, Treatise on the Metallurgy of Iron (title page 1870), archive.org treatiseonmetall00bauerich.
- W. Turner, The Metallurgy of Iron, 3rd ed. 1908, archive.org metallurgyofiron00turnrich.
- J. E. Johnson Jr., Blast-Furnace Construction in America (1917); folio = PDF page less 17. Principles of Operation (1918); folio = PDF page less 32 from PDF 85 on. Both are retrospective on 1830-1890 practice and describe their own time (1900-1917).
- E. Kirk, The Cupola Furnace (1899); folio = PDF page less 24.
- Percy (1864): a search for barrow, filler, weighing-machine returned nothing; not used. Kiln figures are in the calcining kilns note section A. Purpose period facts on how the burden of a furnace, a kiln or a cupola was proportioned and charged. Lines starting "Inference" are the writer's; all other lines are what the source states.
A. The blast furnace, about 1830-1870 (open top, charcoal and coke)
- Measure or weight. Overman: "Coal charges are most commonly measured, particularly at charcoal and coke furnaces; but at some of the stone coal furnaces, coal as well as ore charges are weighed, a custom worthy of general adoption." He judges charcoal and coke "will be found to work more regularly" by weight, because wood density varies (hickory and maple nearly twice poplar) (pp. 194-195, 1851).
- Ore is weighed: "The common and undoubtedly the best manner ... is to weigh the ore, and if anything in the furnace should go wrong, to diminish or increase the ore charge"; sheet-iron boxes of equal weight preferred to wooden (they take rain); "The filling of ore by the measure should be repudiated altogether" (Overman pp. 195-196).
- Vessels. Overman: charcoal by basket is "a very imperfect method of measuring" (baskets of two to three bushels); the English coke barrow (two-wheel hand cart, 12-15 bushels) is better; sheet-iron boxes holding one charge, lifted on wagons, are "more useful still" (p. 192). Truran: barrows "containing according to the materials ... and local custom, from 4 to 16 cwts. each"; iron baskets "at some few works" (pp. 51-66 about; section V, 1862). Turner p. 112 (1908, after Ridsdale): about 7 cwt coke, 13 cwt calcined ore, 15-16 cwt limestone. Fuel is filled into the barrow through "pikes" of iron bars so fines fall through (Truran about p. 106).
- Order and unit. Overman: "Immediately after a coal charge is filled, a charge of ore is thrown into the furnace" (p. 195); the fuel "for one charge" is 10-15 bushels, 450-600 lb of charcoal or coke, 600-1200 lb of anthracite, larger on narrow throats (p. 195). Truran: "Between each barrowful of calcined ore the proper quantities of fuel and flux are filled in" (p. 64). He defines "burden" as "the weight of calcined ironstone which is charged into the furnace for a definite measure of the fuel used", and "charge" as "a definite quantity of ore with its assigned proportion of fuel and flux"; a furnace "has gone one charge" each time, and the make is estimated by charges in twelve hours (pp. 64-65). South Wales coal furnaces: 10 cwt calcined mine to 9 cwt coal, limestone about 3.5 cwt (p. 65). At blowing-in around Merthyr: about 5.5 cwt calcined ironstone and (OCR "1-f-") cwt limestone to 4 cwt coke (about p. 40).
- Premixed or separate. Truran: British fillers throw each material in separate quantities of 15-16 cwt; "On the Continent it is usual to mix the limestone and ores before filling, but the higher price of labour in this country is generally given as a reason for not adopting a similar plan"; he thinks complete commingling "in quantities of a few pounds only" would give better yield (p. 66, 1862).
- Overman, the Moellerung (pp. 199-200): where one box holds the whole mixture "the flux, as well as the ore, should be filled by weight; not ... thrown in at random by the shovel"; "the quantitative mixture ... is definite". Ores are mixed "previous to being weighed", "from time immemorial" in Germany: on a level yard spread about 100 barrowfuls of one ore, upon it half that of a second, one-fifth or one-sixth of a third, over all the flux, in beds one to two feet high from which a charge is taken. Where small boxes weigh ore and flux separately, "the distinct separation ... is a matter of no difficulty". Reading note: this is a yard bed for premixing, not the order inside the furnace.
- Who sets the proportion. Truran: "The proper proportion of ironstone, flux, and fuel having been determined by analysis or experiment", the fillers must keep it; the "superior agents" order the quantities (p. 66). Overman: fuel charge fixed by measure or weight, and "should any alteration in their quantity be required, this is effected in the charges of the ore" (p. 195). Bauerman (p. 201, Vordernberg charcoal): fuel measured, "2 tubs", ore "gradually raised from 3 to 6 cwt. per charge, and then diminished similarly, a blank charge of fuel being given at each change"; at Fischer's furnace 14 charges in 1.5 h including a blank charge, 7.5 t a day (pp. 201-202).
- Filling floor and weighing. Truran: tunnel-head floored in cast-iron plate, which "forms a level barrow-road for the fillers"; at each stocking place of fuel, ore and flux "a lock-up platform weighing-machine, weighted according to the burden"; "two, sometimes three, beam weighing-machines at the bridge plates, where the quantities are adjusted", with a small supplementary stock for deficiencies (about p. 30). Same book, p. 66-67: weighing "occupies time", "is too generally omitted when the superior agents are not by"; he describes a Dowlais self-acting mercury-plunger weighing machine with a paper-drum register, to take the weighing out of the filler's hands. Overman: a trunnel-head bridge of timber (p. 191); his own proposal, a suspension railroad with a hinged-bottom box and "a kind of steelyard scale" at the hanger, "so that loading and weighing may be effected at the same time" (pp. 192-193, a proposal, not a report).
- Hoists. Overman: the water-balance hoist from the Crane Works, Pa., "that most in use" where furnaces stand on plains (pp. 193-194); Truran: inclined plane with a counterbalancing carriage, water-balance bucket with platform for the barrow, pneumatic tube lift (pp. 30-33 about). Bauerman p. 148: the platform, gallery and bridges between adjacent furnaces; p. 147 rectangular charging holes in the tunnel head with shutters. Johnson p. 7-8 (1917): old charcoal furnaces stood against a hill with a bridge from the stock house, barrows filled by shovel and "wheeled onto a platform scale set for the correct weight of the given materials. The weight was adjusted by shoveling into or out of the barrows". "bank" and "bridge house" do not occur in these texts.
- Spreading. Overman: ore "spread uniformly over the coal"; with a weak blast or wet ore pile it in the middle of the throat; a furnace with one charging place goes badly when fillers throw to one side, "scaffolding in and above the boshes" (p. 200). Bauerman pp. 189-193: the throat is filled in layers, the centre descends faster than the wall so layers mix lower down; dropped at the centre the fuel rolls to the wall; a charging funnel or plates give the best distribution; Swedish hand-charged furnaces put richer magnetic ore "in a ring close to the wall" and spread siliceous ore and limestone over the surface, charges "weighed in a large wrought-iron scoop ... suspended by a chain above the top" (p. 193). Truran: tunnel-heads have one or more filling places, each with a door; a proposed wide top is filled by shovel and pike (pp. 27 and about 100).
- Rate. Only counts found: Truran's twelve-hour convention (p. 65) and Bauerman's 14 charges in 1.5 h at a 7.5 t a day charcoal furnace (p. 202). Johnson Principles p. 346-347 (1918): a filling stop of one or two hours sends raw charge down.
B. The hot-blast furnace with a bell top, about 1870-1900
- Bins and cars. Turner (1908): "Separate bins are provided for ore, coke, and limestone, and from these bins the skips are filled"; the bins are hopper form (pp. 114-115). Johnson (1917) p. 39: the skip "is usually filled from a motor-driven dumping car, with its body ... mounted on a scale ... called the scale car or larry", traversed along the bins, returned to a hopper that delivers to the skip; "the stock breaks bulk between the bins and the top". p. 40: coke bins are often on each side of the skipway and coke is spouted straight into skips, "measured by skipfuls instead of by weight", satisfactory "if the same coke is always used". Fig. 22, a suspended bin with a line of hand-operated gates; the larry carries means for working the gates (p. 43).
- Weighing. Johnson p. 44: "Changes of the 'burden' (a technical name for the weight of ore for a given fuel charge) as small as one per cent are not infrequently used"; two or three per cent are usual; "accurate weighing" is needed. p. 45-46: charging scales are platform scales sunk in the stock-house floor for barrow filling; three to six beams, the main beam taring the empty barrow, a secondary beam per material "locked fast for the charge weight wanted", thrown in and out in turn. Larry scales later carry a dial with fixed markers at the wanted weights and a paper tape stamped at each portion, locked in the scale box (the first by Streeter-Amet, undated) (pp. 46-47).
- Barrow rounds. Johnson pp. 51-53: hand-filled bell-and-hopper tops dump barrows at four points; coke barrows number four or six to the charge "to agree with the number of dumping points", the ore and limestone barrow counts follow from the coke weight and are seldom divisible by four; the first dump point shifts one place each charge ("spiral filling"). Coke charges "six thousand pounds for small furnaces, up to fifteen thousand, and even eighteen thousand" lb; "the best practice undoubtedly favors dumping the coke separately from the ore and stone" (p. 53). The filling barrow held about 1500 lb (Johnson Construction pp. 13-14).
- Layers, not mixture. Johnson Principles p. 287 (1918): ore and fuel are kept "in separate layers, and ... the effect of the separation was greater the thicker were the individual layers", an upper limit set by the need for intimacy near the hearth; a coke layer about 2 ft in a 22 by 90 ft furnace; a four-barrow charge cost 5-6 per cent more fuel than a two-barrow charge. Ores of different size are charged "separately, not even in the same round" (p. 286). Truran 1862 and Bauerman agree that layers blend in the shaft (Bauerman p. 189).
- Proportions set and recorded. Johnson Principles pp. 265-266: "the coke charge is held constant and the ore varied"; a worked burden is 9000 lb coke, 19,800 lb ore, 4695 lb stone (pp. 268-271); the slag judged by fracture and the lime changed by eye (pp. 260-261). p. 296: a "burden clerk" checked the pen-recorder charts that skips were dumped in sequence and bells worked after the proper number of skip loads. Johnson Construction p. 47: the locked tape, closed to the operator, has a "tremendous" moral effect on the weights.
- Date: Turner p. 113-116 (1908) places mechanical skip charging at Duquesne in 1896; Johnson p. 66 disagrees (calcining kilns note, section C).
C. The calcining kiln
- Calcining kilns note, section A (cited, not repeated): Overman Fig. 1 perpetual oven, Bauerman Dowlais and Siegen kilns, Gjers kiln figures.
- Alternate layers from the top. Overman pp. 41-42: grate covered with wood, then small fuel, "then a layer of coal and ore alternately" to the top; "As the top of the ore sinks, it is replaced by fresh charges of coal and ore." Truran p. 15 (Dowlais): fires on the floor, ore over them, then "a fresh layer of ironstone, 8 or 9 inches thick ... along with about 5 per cent, by weight of small coal", each layer added once the one below is red. Bauerman p. 112 gives the same 5 per cent by weight. Siegen kiln: "40 cubic feet of ore to 8 of fuel" (p. 114, by volume); Mariazell pyritic kiln: charcoal dust four tubs of 7.75 cu ft, then "45 barrows of 160 to 180 lbs." of ore, "alternate layers in the same proportion" (pp. 118-119). Fuel as a measured volume or percentage by weight; no source says how the weight was checked.
- Gjers kiln: slack is "about 1 ton ... for every 20 tons of ore" (Bauerman p. 113); Turner p. 91-92 says "ore and fuel are brought to the kiln in trucks ... the materials readily falling out when the bottom of the truck is released", about 1 cwt coal per ton. Whether slack was mixed into the ore in the barrow or tipped in separate layers: not stated in these texts. Truran p. 16-17: "tipping and filling-in the ironstone and small coal" costs "barely one penny a ton", 1 cwt small coal per ton of stone against 2 cwt small plus 0.5 cwt large in open heaps; hematite 2-6 cwt to the ton of argillaceous stone was calcined in the same kiln.
- Heaps in courses. Overman pp. 44-45: billets as a grid, gaps filled with chips, charcoal, coal, coke "so as to prevent the ore from falling between"; ore broken 3-4 in., larger inside, smaller to cover; fuel foundation about 8 in.; ore 18 in. to 2 ft; "a layer of small charcoal, or of turf, coke, or small anthracite coal, in a uniform thickness of two inches, or one inch of fuel to one foot of ore; then alternate beds of fuel and ore"; covered with small ore; rows 3 ft high and 7-8 ft at the base finish in 10-12 days; large piles 100-2000 t. Truran p. 15 (Staffordshire and Scotland): coal stratum a few inches, ore 10-12 in., small coal thrown over, up to 4-5 ft. Turner p. 89 (1908): rough slack on the ore, "alternate layers of ore and slack", Staffordshire heaps 5-10 yd wide, 2-3 yd high, 10-50 yd long.
- Inference: every period source builds the kiln or heap in courses of ore with fuel on top, fuel a small measured fraction; none mixes coal into ore before it goes in, but the Gjers practice is the one case the texts leave open.
D. The cupola, Kirk 1899
- "The old way ... place a sufficient quantity of fuel ... On this fuel or bed are placed from 50 to 500 pounds of iron ... then from one to four shovels of fuel ... and so on", which "mixes the fuel and iron". The modern way puts fuel and iron "in layers or charges", and melting capacity is "about one-half greater" with less fuel (p. 80). Rule: "place three pounds of iron upon the bed to each pound of fuel placed there, and ten pounds of iron upon the charges of fuel" (p. 333); practice 6-15 lb iron to the pound of coke (pp. 81-82).
- Weighing. "There is nothing more essential ... than an accurate weighing scale upon the scaffold near the cupola charging door": a platform scale on wheels, platform level with the charging door, 1-2 ton, an iron box on it for gates and scrap; iron and fuel "weighed in charges or drafts"; scales in the scaffold floor for barrows give the stock weight but cannot divide it into charges unless charged directly from the barrows (Ch. IX, pp. 210-211 about). Counting baskets is "the greatest fallacy": old baskets hold a third more (pp. 230-231); every pound of fuel "should be accurately weighed", with a "cupola book" recording bed and charge weights and each brand of iron (p. 231). A melter may be given "a slate of charges" to put in (p. 210).
E. Period practice in short
- Weighing per barrow: ore by weight, never by measure (Overman 1851, p. 196); fuel by measure or weight (p. 194); a weighing machine at the stocking place (Truran about p. 30, 1862); beams locked to the charge weight (Johnson p. 46, 1917).
- The charge as a unit of ore with its own fuel and flux, and the burden as ore weight per fuel charge (Truran pp. 64-65); the fuel charge held fixed, the ore charge changed, a blank charge at each change (Overman p. 195, Bauerman p. 201, Johnson Principles p. 265).
- The order of a round: fuel then ore (Overman p. 195); coke dumped apart from ore and stone (Johnson p. 53); flux dumped with or between ore barrows in Britain (Truran pp. 64, 66).
- Premixing is Continental and yard-side: ore and limestone mixed before weighing (Truran p. 66; Overman Moellerung pp. 199-200); in Britain and in 1900 American practice each material is weighed and dumped on its own.
- The bins and the filling floor: stock house and bridge, ore-house bays (kiln note), hopper bins with gates, scale car or larry (Johnson pp. 39-43, 1917; Turner pp. 114-115, 1908).
- The check on the filler: registering scale tape and burden clerk (Truran p. 67; Johnson pp. 46-47, 296). Period proportioning equipment: beam platform scale with locked poises (1862, 1917); mercury-plunger register scale (Dowlais, before 1862); steelyard at a hanger (Overman 1851, proposed); wrought-iron scoop on a chain (Swedish, Bauerman 1870); charge measure rod in the throat (Overman Fig. 67, p. 191); box, barrow, basket, tub as measures; recording larry scale (about 1900); cupola platform scale (Kirk 1899).
Gaps
- Truran 1855 first edition and Percy's smelting chapters not read; Percy PDF text has no hits for the terms.
- No text read gives charges per hour or per day for a British open-top furnace; only the twelve-hour convention and one Swedish count.
- Gjers kiln: whether slack rode in the barrow with the ore; Gjers's 1871 paper not found; no source says how kiln slack was weighed.
- Truran's page numbers are approximate in places; the first Dowlais register scale is undated.
- The order inside a skip round (coke before ore) is not stated in the texts read; B's order rests on the barrow figures and p. 53.