Lean, Hunt, Farey and Bourne on the Cornish pumping engine for mine drainage (1827-1884)
Books Historical Statement of the Improvements made in the Duty performed by the Steam Engines in Cornwall, British Mining, A Treatise on the Steam Engine, Handbook of the Steam-Engine
Sources, each figure below carrying book and printed page:
- J. Lean and T. Lean, Historical Statement of the Improvements made in the Duty performed by the Steam Engines in Cornwall (Marazion, 1839) (Google scan, 183 PDF pages, no text layer; the archive's OCR text and page images were read). Printed page = PDF page - 21 up to the tables, - 25 from Table V on (printed 135 is PDF 160). Narrative pages after p. 14 are cited by the year the passage sits under; the OCR has no page numbers there.
- R. Hunt, British Mining (1884), Book III ch. III (pumping and drainage). Printed page = PDF page - 31 (printed 625 is PDF 656, printed 638 is PDF 669).
- J. Farey, A Treatise on the Steam Engine (1827), printed page = PDF page - 18.
- J. Bourne, Handbook of the Steam-Engine (1865), printed page (header) as given.
Not found: W. Pole, A Treatise on the Cornish Pumping Engine (1844) is not on archive.org under any title, creator (Pole, William, 1814-1900) or subject searched; the only Pole steam titles there are the translation of Alban's High-Pressure Steam Engine (1847) and nothing on the Cornish engine. Nothing below comes from it, so the pump-rod, balance-bob, engine-house and beam sizes are mostly open (section 8).
Conventions: a line marked INFERRED is arithmetic on figures in this file. Duty is Lean's: millions of pounds of water lifted 1 foot by one bushel (94 lb) of coal unless a table says 112 lb (Hunt p. 625). Units are the books' (inches, feet, fathoms = 6 ft, imperial gallons = 10 lb of water, bushel = 94 lb). Where a cell was not legible in the scan it is marked "not read".
1. The duty measure
| figure | value | page | quote or note |
|---|---|---|---|
| Definition | force x space through which it acts, per weight of coal | Lean p. 3; Hunt p. 625, 639 | Hunt: "The term 'Duty,' which is used here, was first employed by James Watt to signify the nett effect resulting from the consumption of a given weight of coal" |
| Unit in Cornwall | millions of lb of water raised 1 ft by a bushel of coal | Lean p. 3-4; Farey p. 337 | Farey: "the number of millions pounds weight of water, which could be raised one foot high, by the consumption of a bushel of coals; the coals in that district are brought by sea from Swansea" |
| Bushel | 94 lb in Lean's trials; 84 lb in Farey and Hunt (p. 620) | Lean (Austen trial, "A bushel of coal weighed, and found to be 94lbs"); Farey p. 337 | Hunt p. 625 table is per 112 lb |
| Water is not weighed | the pump's capacity is taken, as Watt did | Lean p. 3 | "He did not pretend to measure or weigh the water discharged, but he ascertained it by the capacity of the pumps, as we now do" |
| Who pays for the report | the mine proprietors | Lean p. 3 | the monthly reports "are in fact the test by which engineers must submit to be judged" |
| Watt's first proposal, 1778 | 500,000 cu ft of water 1 ft by 112 lb of Wednesbury coal | Farey p. 337 | Farey converts it to 31,250,000 lb per cwt, "23.44 millions" per 84 lb bushel |
| Work per kg of coal | 90 million ft-lb per 94 lb = 2.86 MJ/kg; 20 million = 0.64 MJ/kg | INFERRED | 1 ft-lb = 1.3558 J, 94 lb = 42.64 kg |
Friction of the engine, imperfect vacuum included, "not to exceed 3 1/2 lbs. per square inch" (Hunt p. 639). Hunt on wire-drawn steam: "no valid justification ... we have only to increase the size of the pipes and valves" (Hunt p. 639).
2. Duty by decade (Lean's reports, from 1811)
First report 1811 (Wheal Alfred, three engines, about 20 million; Lean p. 10); August 1811 eight engines 15.7, December twelve engines 17 (Lean p. 10). Averages are the whole reported fleet; "best" is the best engine's yearly average or peak month where Lean gives it.
| year | engines reported | fleet average (millions) | best named | page |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1769 | 15 Newcomen engines at Newcastle (Smeaton) | 5.59 (worst 3.22, best 7.44) | Lean p. 6 | |
| 1772 | Smeaton's altered engine | 9.45 | Lean p. 6 | |
| 1776 | Watt at Soho | 21.6 (his letter); Boulton quoted Carron 19 | Lean p. 6 | |
| 1778-79 | two Watt engines tried by Smeaton | 18.0 and 18.5 | Hawkesbury, 58 in, 8 ft stroke, load 26,064 lb, nearly 19 | Lean p. 7 |
| 1798 | all Cornwall (Gilbert and Jenkin) | about 17 | Herland engine 27 (usually 20) | Lean p. 7-8 |
| 1800 | best about 20 | Lean p. 8 | ||
| 1801 | Crenver and Oatfield, three engines | under 10 | Lean p. 9 | |
| 1812, 1813, 1814 | 21, 29, 32 | 19.3, 19.5, 20.6 | Stray Park 60 in: 32 for 1814 | Lean p. 11-12 |
| 1815 | 35 | 20.5 | Woolf's Wheal Abraham 52.3; Woolf 53 in at Wheal Vor 50 | Lean (1815) |
| 1817 | 35 | 26.5 | Dolcoath 44 (Jeffree and Gribble, 76 in, from 1816, 40); Sims, Wheal Chance 46.9 | Lean (1816-17) |
| 1819, 1821, 1822 | 40, 45, 52 | 26.3, 28.3, 28.9 | Dolcoath 44.1 (1822) | Lean |
| 1825 | 56 | 32 | Wheal Vor (Sims and Richards) 45.5 | Lean |
| 1827 | 51 | 32.1 | Wheal Towan 80 in (Grose) over 60 April-September, 62.2 July; Consols 90 in (Woolf) 63.7 | Lean |
| 1828 | 57 | not read | Wheal Towan 87 in April, 77.3 for the year | Lean; Hunt p. 638 |
| 1829, 1830 | 53, 56 | 41.7, 43.3 | Consols (Hocking and Loam) 61.3, 67.5 | Lean |
| 1832 | 59 | 45.0 | Wheal Vor 80 in (Richards): 91.35 in December, 85 for the year | Lean |
| 1833 | 56 | 46.6 | best engine's average 84.4 | Lean |
| 1834 | 52 | 47.8 | best engines' average 90.9; Fowey Consols 80 in (West) 97.86 in September; trial 125.1 | Lean; Hunt p. 633-634 |
| 1835 | 51 | 47.8 | Fowey Consols 93.1 | Lean |
| 1837 | 68 | 47.x (digit not legible) | United Mines 74.1 | Lean |
| 1838 | 61 | 48.7 | Hunt p. 624 | |
| 1856 | 24 engines (T. Lean) | 47.0 per 94 lb (56 per 112 lb); Browne's 22 engines 35.5 per 112 lb | Hunt p. 624 |
Hunt dates Austen's engine to July 1838 (Hunt p. 634); Lean prints 1834 ("Austen's engine was reported for the first time in July this year", under 1834) and the trial of 22 October 1834. Lean is the primary source.
Hunt p. 641: "no increase has been effected in the economical performance of the Cornish pumping-engine in Cornwall for many years, and it is thought that this cannot be expected until steam of a higher pressure and expanded to a corresponding degree be employed." Hunt's table of the best engines 1840-1880 (p. 625, from Lean's reports; per 112 lb coal, the 1840-45 rows per 94 lb; a dash is a blank cell):
| year | mine, engine, cylinder (in) | load lb/in2 on piston | hp employed | strokes a min | lb coal per hp-h | duty (millions) | water a min (imp gal) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1840 | Wheal Darlington, Eastern, 80 | 15.11 | - | 8.55 | - | 84.0 | 842 |
| 1840 | Wheal Vor, Trelawny's, 80 | 15.25 | - | 8.16 | - | 59.2 | 409 |
| 1840 | Fowey Consols, Austen's, 80 | 11.65 | - | 7.20 | - | 85.2 | 547 |
| 1845 | Wheal Vor, Trelawny's, 80 | 15.90 | - | 7.10 | 3.5 | 53.1 | 962 |
| 1845 | Dolcoath, Jeffrei's, 76 | 12.10 | - | 5.90 | 4.4 | 41.5 | 280 |
| 1845 | Great Work, Leeds, 60 | 14.50 | - | 7.40 | 3.2 | 56.9 | 176 |
| 1850 | United Mines, Taylor's, 85 | 15.60 | 221 | 7.50 | 2.4 | 90.0 | - |
| 1850 | South Wheal Frances, Tredinnick's, 75 | 10.10 | 92 | 6.30 | 2.9 | 76.0 | 491 |
| 1855 | Dolcoath, Hocking, 76 | 12.50 | 101 | 6.50 | 5.0 | 43.0 | 308 |
| 1855 | Great Work, Leeds, 60 | 14.70 | 87 | 7.70 | 3.2 | 69.0 | 297 |
| 1855 | Wheal Tremayne, Michell's, 60 | 13.00 | 59 | 5.30 | 3.1 | 71.0 | 402 |
| 1860 | Alfred Consols, Davey's, 80 | 9.70 | 87 | 5.90 | 2.6 | 82.6 | 522 |
| 1860 | West Wheal Seaton, Harvey's, 85 | 7.70 | 70 | 4.50 | 3.9 | 55.7 | 292 |
| 1865 | Wheal Seton, Tilly's, 70 | 10.30 | 39 | 3.30 | 3.1 | 70.0 | 89 |
| 1865 | West Caradon, Elliot's, 50 | 14.20 | 35 | 4.20 | 3.3 | 65.6 | 135 |
| 1870 | Great Wheal Busy United, Harvey's, 85 | 22.30 | 176 | 4.60 | 3.6 | 61.6 | 506 |
| 1870 | West Wheal Seton, Harvey's, 85 | 12.30 | 90 | 3.60 | 3.3 | 66.6 | 234 |
| 1875 | Crenver and Wheal Abraham, Willyam's, 70 | 11.40 | 85 | 6.60 | 3.3 | 65.5 | 601 |
| 1875 | West Wheal Seton, Harvey's, 85 | 17.40 | 224 | 6.80 | 3.5 | 63.2 | 902 |
| 1880 | West Wheal Seton, Harvey's, 85 | 13.80 | 128 | 4.60 | 3.4 | 64.0 | 391 |
Rows read from the page image at 190 dpi; the 1880 Dolcoath and Mellanear rows (62.7 and 52.2 million) are legible only at lower resolution and are left out.
3. Named engines, dimensions (Lean, 1834 census)
Lean p. 143-145, Table IX "Steam Engines employed on all the Mines in Cornwall, at the end of 1834": cylinder diameter, stroke in the cylinder, stroke in the pump. Selected pumping engines (a few of the many; stamping and whim engines are in the same table, whims 4 to 5 ft stroke in cylinders of 12 to 26 in):
| mine | cylinder (in) | stroke in cylinder (ft) | stroke in pump (ft) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Wheal Darlington | 80 | 10 | 8 |
| Wheal Vor | 80 | 10 | 8 |
| Wheal Vor (other) | 80 | 10 | 7.5 |
| Fowey Consols | 80 | 10.25 | 9.25 |
| Consolidated Mines | 85 | 10.33 | 7.75 |
| Consolidated Mines | 80 | 11.33 | 8.75 |
| Consolidated Mines | 90 | 10 | 7.5 |
| United Mines | 90 | 9 | 8 |
| United Mines | 85 | 10.33 | 7.75 |
| Poldice | 90 | 10 | 7 |
| Dolcoath | 76 | 9 | 7.5 |
| East Wheal Crofty | 80 | 10.33 | 7.75 |
| Wheal Unity Wood | 80 | 10 | 7.5 |
| Binner Downs | 70 | 10 | 7.5 |
| North Roskear | 70 | 10 | 8 |
| Great Work | 60 | 9 | 7 |
| Stray Park | 60 | 8 | 5.5 |
| Wheal Damsel (Stephens's) | 50 | 9.33 | 7.25 |
Detail engines (Lean p. 110, Table IV, 1835 monthly reports with the engineer's remarks):
| engine | cylinder, stroke | pump work | rate | load and duty |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Dolcoath (Jeffree) | 76 in, 9 ft | draws from 190 fathoms below the adit; the lift's pump of 13 5/8 in (INFERRED from the printed 47.46 gal a stroke over 7 ft 6 in), 7 ft 6 in stroke | 47.46 gal a stroke, 211.19 gal a min, 4.45 strokes a min (monthly 3.4 to 7.4) | piston load 12.2 lb/in2; rod load 61,513 to 66,494 lb; average duty 45,020,374 |
| Wheal Damsel (Sims) | 50 in, 9 ft 4 in, working single | draws from 173 fathoms below the adit; 9 in pump, 7 ft 3 in stroke | 20.01 gal a stroke, 57.64 gal a min, 2.88 strokes a min | piston load 12.0 to 12.56 lb/in2; rod load 30,820 to 32,763 lb; average duty 35,756,664 |
Largest at Chacewater under Smeaton, 1775, a Newcomen engine for comparison (Farey p. 190-191): cylinder 72 in, stroke 9 ft (9.5 ft allowed), 9 strokes a min, 81 ft a min; three pump columns of 16.75 in diameter and 9 ft stroke, each lifting about 17 fathoms, 51 fathoms in all; load 31,187 lb = 7.66 lb/in2; "more than 76 horse-power"; three boilers of 15 ft diameter, grates 4 ft 9 in by 4 ft 10 in (23 sq ft each), chimneys 22 by 34 in inside and 52 ft high.
Engines of the trials (Lean, under the year):
| engine and date | cylinder, stroke | pump work | result |
|---|---|---|---|
| Consolidated Mines (Woolf), Dec 1827 | 90 in; stroke in shaft 7 ft 5 in | 5 lifts, 150 fathoms, 14 in plunger | 26 h 30 min, 5.51 strokes a min, 8,763 strokes, 64 bushels, duty 63,663,473; loaded 7 to 8 lb/in2; two round boilers with fire in the tubes |
| Wheal Towan (Grose), 1828 | 80 in; stroke in shaft 8 ft | three boilers; safety valve weighted to about 40 lb/in2 | 54 bushels in 26 h, 10,052 strokes, load in the shaft 58,564 lb |
| Fowey Consols, Austen's (West), 22 Oct 1834 | 80 in; stroke in shaft 9 ft 3 in to 9 ft 5 in (taken at 9 ft 3 in) | 24 h 27 min, 6,287 strokes = 4.29 a min, steam gauge 36.5 to 45 lb/in2, 24 bushels burnt of 28 measured, duty 125,095,713 (3 h allowed for a stopped lift) | |
| United Mines (Loam), 1838 | 85 in, 10 ft | steam valve shut at 1/5 to 1/6 of the stroke (about 22 in) | steam about 50 lb/in2; six months 700 tons of coal, 234,210 cu ft of water, 1,631,000 strokes; 15 cu ft of water per 100 lb of coal; 72 cu ft of steam a stroke (Lean p. iii-iv) |
4. The cycle (Hunt p. 639; Farey p. 190, 355)
Hunt p. 639, single-acting: "steam from the boiler acts only on one side of the piston, while the other is open to the condenser. With the admission of steam the motion of the piston commences, which at the same time lifts a considerable counterpoise depending from the opposite end of the main beam, known as the pump-rods. After the steam has been admitted through the requisite space, the admission or steam valve is shut, and the movement of the piston is continued to the termination of the stroke by the impetus communicated to it at the commencement of its course and by the expansion of the steam." At the end "the outlet or eduction valve closes, and the equilibrium, or valve between the upper and lower portions of the cylinder, opens ... At this moment the pump-rod or counterpoise begins to descend, and brings the piston to the top of the cylinder. When the piston has nearly obtained this position the equilibrium valve shuts, and the steam intercepted at the top of the piston is gradually compressed until the engine is brought to a state of rest. The steam and outlet valves are again opened by the action of the cataract." So the steam stroke (indoor) lifts the pump rods, the rods' weight does the pumping stroke (outdoor, down the shaft), the equilibrium valve joins the two sides between.
The cataract: Hunt p. 639 "a cataract, or mechanical appliance, is connected with the valve gearing, and so set as to control the speed of the engine". Farey p. 190, on Smeaton's engine: the piston "waits at the top of the stroke till the cataract is ready", the wait set by a cock "so as to draw up exactly as much water as drains into the mine"; "If there is but little water in the mine, so that the engine is only required to make four or five strokes per minute, the interval of rest between the successive strokes will be considerable." Watt's single engine (Farey p. 355): the rods weigh more than the piston, "a preponderating counterweight", catch-pins on the beam's arch heads strike spring beams to limit the stroke. The cylinder stands so that the jacket's condensate returns to the boiler; jacket loss 7 degrees from 84 (Hunt p. 639). Lean's expansion scale (p. iv-v) rates steam worked to the end of the stroke against steam admitted throughout (1.000): the printed ratios run 1.405, 1.693, 2.099, 2.386, 2.609, 2.792 to 2.946; the cut-off fractions they belong to are lost in the OCR and not read.
5. Pump rods, balance bobs, plungers, lifts
- Plunger pole: Joel Lean at Crenver and Oatfield (1801) "first introduced ... the plunger-pole, instead of the common box and piston" (Lean p. 9); the mine was then about 170 fathoms from the surface and 140 below the adit, its pit-work "leathern buckets with two or three pistons", the engines idle at least a third of the time changing them (Lean p. 9). Trevithick's plunger at Herland, 1815 (Hunt p. 638).
- Balance bobs: "it is frequently necessary to counterbalance the pump-rods by means of levers or 'balance bobs' placed at the surface of the ground, or in cavities excavated horizontally out of the side of the shaft ... a weighted lever has been employed for this purpose since the year 1770" (Hunt p. 634). V-bobs and bell-cranks carry the rods down an inclined lode, flat rods on rollers to a second shaft (Hunt p. 634-635).
- Pumps in lifts: each column raises water into a cistern from which the next lifts it; upper lifts "almost, without exception, longer than the lower ones" because shallower levels' water is taken at once (Hunt p. 622, quoting Henwood). Examples with figures: Chacewater 3 columns of about 17 fathoms (Farey p. 191); Consols 5 lifts through 150 fathoms with a 14 in plunger (Lean, 1827); Dolcoath 190 fathoms below the adit through a 13 5/8 in pump of 7 ft 6 in stroke (Lean p. 110). The pump stroke is 0.7 to 0.9 of the cylinder stroke in Table IX (section 3).
- A man-engine or capstan was needed to lift the rods when repairing (Farey p. 214, atmospheric engine).
- Not found: rod weights in tons, rod timber sizes, balance-bob weights, lift length against depth as a rule.
6. Boilers and coal
| figure | value | page |
|---|---|---|
| Cornish practice | "slow combustion is usually considered desirable, and boilers are usually made of large dimensions" | Hunt p. 642 |
| East Wheal Rose, Michell's 85 in, 10 ft stroke | four boilers, 36 x 6 ft, 36 x 6, 38 x 6.5, 34 x 6 ft; 45 tons together; 30 lb/in2 maximum; 3.6 lb coal per hp-hour at 4 strokes a min | Hunt p. 642 |
| Par Consols 80 in, two tubular boilers | each 32 ft long, 6 ft 3 in outside, 3 ft 10 in internal; grate 6 ft x 3 ft 10 in, inclined to the bridge; heating surface 1,900 sq ft plus 500 sq ft of feed warmer; feed to about 212 F; flue gases 300 F at the stack | Hunt p. 642 |
| Par Consols trial | 46.5 h, 11,730 lb coal, 119,700 lb water from 92 F: 10.2 lb of water per lb of coal (11.43 from the boiling point) | Hunt p. 642 |
| Wickstead's four cylindrical boilers | 2.475 lb coal per sq ft of grate an hour: 8.258 lb water from 80 F per lb; 5.013 lb: 8.605 lb (4 per cent better when twice as fast) | Hunt p. 642 |
| Lean's measure | 15 cu ft of water evaporated per 100 lb coal at 50 lb/in2; 1 cu ft of water gives 500 cu ft of steam at that pressure | Lean p. iii |
| Fuel cost | coal 17 s a ton delivered; fuel saved by the improvements since 1814 about 84,300 pounds a year for the county | Lean Table X |
| Boiler pressure | 36 to 45 lb/in2 at Fowey Consols; 30 lb/in2 at East Wheal Rose; "about 40" at Wheal Towan | Lean; Hunt p. 642 |
| Smeaton's Newcomen boilers | three of 15 ft diameter, grates 23 sq ft each, chimneys 52 ft | Farey p. 191 |
Coal per hp-hour in the late engines is 2.4 to 5.0 lb (Hunt p. 625, section 2).
7. Water raised against depth
Lean p. 135-138, Table V, from the monthly reports: a mine's engines in a year, depth under the adit, coal and water. Added columns are INFERRED: gal a minute = gal a year / 525,600; hp = gal a minute x 10 lb x depth in ft (6 per fathom) / 33,000, the water horsepower for the stated depth under the adit alone (the adit's own lift is not in the table). Lean's printed 211.19 gal a min for Dolcoath agrees with the 211 here.
| mine | year | cylinder (in) | depth under adit (fm) | coal (bushels of 94 lb) | water (imp gal a year) | gal a min | water hp | duty |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Wheal Darlington | 1835 | 80 | 79 | 29,126 | 477,565,000 | 909 | 131 | 75,133,434 |
| Consolidated Mines | 1835 | 85 | 243 | 34,594 | 161,890,000 | 308 | 136 | 71,281,509 |
| Consolidated Mines | 1835 | 80 | 262 | 29,977 | 141,654,000 | 270 | 128 | 74,128,086 |
| Consolidated Mines | 1835 | 90 | 262 | 43,186 | 163,262,000 | 311 | 148 | 55,776,172 |
| Wheal Vor | 1835 | 80 | 195 | 24,727 | 174,179,000 | 331 | 117 | 82,670,257 |
| Wheal Vor | 1835 | 80 | 226 | 45,132 | 179,887,000 | 342 | 141 | 61,868,195 |
| Fowey Consols | 1835 | 80 | 134 | 9,253 | 124,909,000 | 238 | 58 | 91,672,210 |
| United Mines | 1835 | 90 | 125 | 35,918 | 249,471,000 | 475 | 108 | 49,667,908 |
| United Mines | 1835 | 85 | 137 | 23,745 | 196,511,000 | 374 | 93 | 71,799,395 |
| Wheal Towan | 1835 | 80 | 106 | 21,760 | 179,766,000 | 342 | 66 | 67,219,817 |
| Dolcoath | 1835 | 76 | 190 | 25,686 | 111,001,000 | 211 | 73 | 45,020,374 |
| East Crinnes | 1835 | 76 | 126 | 26,726 | 205,373,000 | 391 | 90 | 59,528,571 |
| Wheal Leisure | 1835 | 70 | 114 | 25,860 | 232,226,000 | 442 | 92 | 59,487,964 |
| Great Work | 1835 | 60 | 116 | 16,840 | 89,210,000 | 170 | 36 | 42,817,551 |
| Wheal Alfred | 1814 | 60+66 | 125 | 39,543 | 120,232,000 | 229 | 52 | 25,804,693 |
| Wheal Abraham | 1814 | 63+45 | 160 | 32,786 | 129,487,000 | 246 | 72 | 32,628,964 |
Lean p. 140, Table VII, average duty by cylinder diameter (millions) and average coal per engine in 1835:
| cylinder (in) | 1814 | 1821 | 1828 | 1835 | coal, bushels, 1835 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| to 30 | 14.33 | 19.91 | 26.47 | 34.22 | 5,650 |
| 30-40 | 18.46 | 23.04 | 26.43 | 38.12 | 9,115 |
| 40-50 | 19.86 | 28.40 | 33.37 | 45.04 | 12,557 |
| 50-60 | 20.08 | 29.10 | 34.77 | 48.75 | 12,931 |
| 60-70 | 23.36 | 28.45 | 41.37 | 52.17 | 15,038 |
| 70-80 | 31.21 | 38.01 | 54.08 | 64.39 | 23,857 |
| 80-90 | 27.44 | 33.41 | 47.88 | 55.12 | 33,501 |
Lean p. 140 note: no engine above 70 in was reported in 1814, so the 70-90 cells of 1814 are made by proportion. Lean on size: "two 57-inch engines are equal in power to one 80-inch ... an 80-inch engine will do one third more duty ... will perform the same work for 6000 bushels of coal per annum less" (Lean, notes to Table VII).
Water pumped from forty mines: maximum 20,000 gal a min in all, minimum about half (Lean p. 141). Maximum in spring, minimum in autumn (Lean p. 143).
Gwennap district (Henwood, Hunt p. 619-622), the great adit of about 26,000 fathoms (nearly 30 miles), 39 ft above high water at Restronguet Creek (Hunt p. 618). For 1839 to May 1840 the means are, in cu ft a minute (Hunt p. 620):
| item | mean |
|---|---|
| rain on the district | 1,954 |
| evaporation | 310 |
| surface water | 40 |
| discharged by the great adit | 1,475 |
| drawn from 100 to 200 fathoms depth (pumped to the adit) | 909 |
For the year 1839 alone the means are rain 2,005, evaporation 309, adit 1,323, deep water 875 (Hunt p. 620). Hunt p. 621: average rain 51.12 in of which evaporation 15.83 per cent; 50 in "represent the average of the whole county", "twice the fall of rain in the Metropolis"; 75 per cent absorbed to a mean depth of at least 35 fathoms (p. 621-622). Pumped water against rain, thirteen mines over seven years: 0.766 to unity (Hunt p. 622). Other absorption figures: Dalton at Manchester 33.55 in a year, 8.41 in penetrating 3 ft, 83 cu ft a day an acre (Hunt p. 619); Thomas on the Fowey, 160 cu ft a day an acre in 1825, 75 in 1826, mean 120 (Hunt p. 619); Gilbert 46 in a year = 166,834 cu ft an acre; Henwood's 0.26 part absorbed (Hunt p. 619). Drainage reach: "for every fathom in depth, the lodes will be drained to the distance of five fathoms at the surface" (Hunt p. 622). The adit saved 24,000 tons of coal a year, about 19,000 pounds, at an average duty of 50 million per 84 lb bushel (Hunt p. 620).
8. Engine house, beam, and what is still open
Not found in the four books read: engine house dimensions, beam length and weight, rod weights, balance-bob sizes. Farey gives only the atmospheric Chacewater engine's boilers and chimneys (p. 191) and Watt's beam as "a single beam of oak ... iron straps ... a king post" truss (p. 355). Pole 1844 is the book that would carry them and is not on archive.org under any title searched. Lean's Table IX has the stroke (cylinder and pump) of every engine; a beam's arm ratio is the ratio of those strokes (INFERRED, about 0.7 to 0.9).
Chacewater, Smeaton's 1775 atmospheric engine, the one engine whose beam and rod weights the books give (Farey p. 175-176; PDF 193-194). Its water went to an adit, so the rod ran 57.5 fathoms below the lever to the lower pump:
| item | figure |
|---|---|
| piston area | 2,124 in2 |
| net descending force on piston (10.5 lb/in2) | 22,300 lb |
| main spear, 6 in square, with iron | about 2.5 tons |
| two bucket rods, 5 in square, 44 fathoms together, with iron | about 2 tons |
| all rods, straps, buckets and arch-head chains at the pump end | about 5 tons, 11,200 lb |
| less water displaced by the 5 in rods (10.85 lb a ft, 264 ft) | 2,864 lb, leaving 8,336 lb |
| piston, shank and chains at the cylinder end | 3,035 lb |
| balance weight loaded on the piston | 1,721 lb |
| preponderance at the pump end | 3,580 lb, of which 925 lb works the injection pump forcer and 2,655 lb lifts the piston (1.25 lb/in2) |
| the great lever | about 170 cu ft of timber, about 4 tons with iron and plug beam |
| lever inertia, one third of its weight at the tip | equal to 1,490 lb at each end |
| moving parts, total | 18,936 lb, 8.45 tons, 1.19 times the water column (15,947 lb) |
| water column in the main pumps | 15,022 lb in the force balance |
| dead weight on the piston | 8.91 lb/in2 |
Farey p. 176 note: rods immersed in the pump lose the weight of the water they displace, on the up stroke as on the down. Cornish single-acting engines worked on the same preponderance rule (Farey p. 190); no Cornish engine's beam is weighed in the books read.
9. Newcomen and Watt against the Cornish engine for drainage
| engine | cylinder | load lb/in2 | duty (millions per bushel) | mine depth reached | page |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Newcomen, 1720-1778 (Enys) | largest 77 in | 6 to 7.5 | highest 3 to 7 | 90 fathoms | Hunt p. 638 |
| Watt low pressure, often expansive, 1778-1812 | largest 63 in (double) | 6 to 9 | average 19.5 in 1793, 17.5 in 1779 | 200 fathoms | Hunt p. 638 |
| Watt high pressure, expansive, 1812-1828 | largest 90 in, single | not read | average about 50 | 290 fathoms | Hunt p. 638 |
Hunt's cells for the highest duty of the two Watt columns and the load of the third are not legible and not quoted. Smeaton's 1775 Chacewater (section 3) is the largest Newcomen drainage engine: 72 in, 9 strokes, 76 hp, duty about 5.6 (1769 average) to 9.45 (his own improvements). Watt's single engine (Farey p. 337) was promised at 23.44 millions per bushel against Smeaton's 9.45 for his improved atmospheric engine, which Smeaton "laid it down as a rule" Watt's would double (Lean p. 6). Watt's Tin Croft engine (Hornblower and Winwood type, Farey p. 369): large cylinder 27 in, small 21 in, 8 ft stroke, 7 strokes a minute, 22 bushels a day, 14.8 millions. Watt said of Cornish practice that "one bushel of good coals ... expansively, was found, by the accounts kept at the Cornish mines, to raise from 24 to 32 millions pounds" (Farey p. 383). Watt in 1798, on the Herland engine's 20 million: "The machine is perfect, and no further improvement can be expected" (Lean, under 1832). Patent: after 1800 Boulton and Watt's representatives left, the engines deteriorated for years until Lean's reports (Lean p. 8). Woolf compound engines gave the fleet's best from 1814 to 1827 and were then overtaken by single-cylinder expansive engines with clothed cylinders (Lean, 1815-1828). Later water-works engines: West Middlesex 1883 compound rotative beam engines, 18 strokes a min, 187 ft lift, 116.1 and 115.5 million per 112 lb, 206 ihp for 164 pump hp (Hunt p. 640-641); Lambeth 97.06 million, Chelsea 103.9, New River 113 per 112 lb, friction 12 to 15 per cent of indicated power (Bourne p. 366-368).
10. What the figures give (INFERRED)
- A Cornish pumping engine's size was named by its cylinder (60 to 90 in, 8 to 11.3 ft stroke); its work is the water lift: water horsepower 36 to 148 hp for the 1835 engines in section 7; Hunt's 1850-1880 table gives 35 to 224 hp employed.
- A mine's water, at the depth the engines served, was a few hundred gal a min (170 to 475 gal a min in section 7, Darlington 909; 1 gal a min = 0.00455 m3/min); a district's deep-drawn water was 909 cu ft a min. 909 cu ft a min is 0.429 m3/s and is the Gwennap district's whole 100-to-200-fathom inflow, not one mine.
- The rate follows the cataract: strokes a minute 2.9 to 8.6 and the engine stood idle between strokes when the mine had less water (Farey p. 190; Lean p. 110).