Rankine, A Manual of Applied Mechanics (1876), the daily effect of a man

Source W. J. Macquorn Rankine, "A Manual of Applied Mechanics", edited by W. J. Millar, Charles Griffin and Company, London, 1876 (PDF 714 pages, the table is PDF page 648 = printed folio 626). The table was read from the page image, not the OCR, which scrambles its columns. Pages below are printed folios. Read Part III, Theory of Machines, Chapter III "On Prime Movers", articles 692-695 (pp. 625-626). Nothing else. Purpose a man's sustained mechanical power, to time hand work (drilling, filing, sawing) by removed-metal energy over power. Rankine has a crank row, so Desaguliers and Smeaton were not needed.

What the book says

Art. 695, "Muscular strength" (p. 625-626): "The daily effect exerted by the muscular strength of a man or of a beast is the product of three quantities; the useful resistance, the velocity with which that resistance is overcome, and the number of units of time per day during which work is continued." Each man has "a certain set of values of those three quantities which makes their product a maximum ... any departure from that set of values diminishes the daily effect" (p. 626). The table "of the effects of the strength of men and horses employed in various ways, is compiled from the works of Poncelet and General Morin, and some other sources" (p. 626).

Columns (p. 626): R, resistance in lb; V, velocity in ft per sec; T/3,600, hours per day; RV, ft lb per sec; RVT, ft lb per day.

The table as printed, MAN rows (p. 626)

#WorkR lbV ft/shours/dayRV ft lb/sRVT ft lb/day
1Raising his own weight up stair or ladder1430.5872.52,088,000
2Do. do. do.......10...2,616,000
3(Tread-wheel, see 1.)
4Hauling up weight with rope400.75630648,000
5Lifting weights by hand440.55624.2522,720
6Carrying weights up stairs1430.13618.5399,600
7Shovelling up earth to a height of 5 feet 3 inches61.3107.8280,800
8Wheeling earth in barrow up slope of 1 in 12, 1/2 horiz. veloc. 0.9 ft per sec (return, empty)1320.075109.9356,400
9Pushing or pulling horizontally (capstan or oar)26.52.08531,526,400
10aTurning a crank or winch12.55.0?62.5(blank)
10b(same)18.02.58451,296,000
10c(same)20.014.4(2 mins.)288(blank)
11Working pump13.22.510331,188,000
12Hammering15?8 ??480,000

Horse rows 13-14 (p. 626) are not used here: 13 canter and trot, 22.5 to 50 lb (mean 30.5), 14.67 ft/s, 4 h, 447.5 ft lb/s, 6,444,000/day; 14 draught horse walking, 120 lb, 3.6 ft/s, 8 h, 432 ft lb/s, 12,441,600/day.

Row 10 is one entry with three lines; the 1,296,000 sits on the 18.0 lb, 2.5 ft/s line, and 45 x 8 x 3,600 = 1,296,000 confirms it. The 2 mins. on the third line is the printed duration, in the hours column.

Conversion to W

1 ft lbf/min = 0.02260 W, so 1 ft lbf/s = 1.356 W (60 x 0.02260). W is the power while working (RV column), not the day's mean. Where RV is blank it is RVT over the hours, marked derived.

#RV ft lb/sft lbf/minWnote
172.54,35098.3p. 626, ascending stair or ladder, 8 h
272.7 (derived, 2,616,000 / 36,000 s)4,36098.5p. 626, 10 h; printed R, V, RV blank
4301,80040.7p. 626, rope hauling, 6 h
524.21,45232.8p. 626, lifting by hand, 6 h
618.51,11025.1p. 626, carrying up stairs, 6 h
77.846810.6p. 626, shovelling, 10 h
89.959413.4p. 626, barrow, 10 h
9533,18071.9p. 626, capstan or oar, 8 h
10a62.53,75084.7p. 626, crank, hours printed "?"
10b452,70061.0p. 626, crank, 8 h
10c28817,280390p. 626, crank, 2 minutes only
11331,98044.7p. 626, pump, 10 h
1216.7 (derived, 480,000 / 28,800 s)1,00022.6p. 626, hammering, printed "8 ?" h, V and RV "?"

Chosen figures

Rotary hand job (hand drill, brace, crank): 61.0 W (45 ft lb/s = 2,700 ft lbf/min), row 10b, "Turning a crank or winch", 18.0 lb at 2.5 ft/s for 8 hours a day, p. 626. Read from a printed row; the only crank row with both a printed hours figure and a printed daily total. A brace or hand drill is a crank motion, so the match is direct for the motion and inferred only in treating a tool's load as the crank's resistance. Rows 10a (84.7 W, hours unprinted) and 10c (390 W, 2 minutes) are not sustained.

Reciprocating hand job (file, saw): 44.7 W (33 ft lb/s = 1,980 ft lbf/min), row 11, "Working pump", 13.2 lb at 2.5 ft/s for 10 hours a day, p. 626. Inferred: Rankine has no file or saw row; a pump handle is the nearest printed back-and-forth arm motion with a stated resistance, velocity and hours. Bounds from other rows, also inferred: hammering 22.6 W (derived, p. 626, with "?" in its velocity and "8 ?" hours, so weaker); pushing or pulling horizontally (oar) 71.9 W (p. 626, a rowing stroke, a stronger whole-body motion). The pump figure sits between them.

Not in the source

Rankine prints no file, saw, drill or brace row, no figure for a skilled workman's tool work, and no rest or break allowance beyond the hours a day. The two chosen figures are therefore a man's sustained output at the nearest printed motion, not a measured tool rate.