Blake's stone breaker, patent and period texts
Books The Manufacture of Iron
Covers the sources below. "Stated" is what a source says; "Inferred" is the writer's reading and is marked.
- E. W. Blake, US patent 20,542, "Machine for Crushing Stones", 15 June 1858 (reissued 9 Jan 1866 as No. 2,145); https://patents.google.com/patent/US20542 (OCR text read directly; the drawing sheet was not viewed).
- Appletons' Cyclopaedia of Applied Mechanics, vol. 1 (D. Appleton, 1880), article "Breaker, or Crusher", printed pp. 234-235, Fig. 492 and the size table (both page images viewed); archive.org id appletonscyclopa01benj. Period text.
- Knight's American Mechanical Dictionary, vol. 2 (1876, copyright 1876), "Ore-crusher" and "Ore-mill", printed pp. 1568-1569, Fig. 3417; vol. 3, "Stone-breaker" (cross-reference to Ore-crusher) and "Silver-mill", Fig. 5096; archive.org ids knightsamericanm02knig_0, knightsamericanm03knig_0 (OCR text; no plate viewed). Period text.
- Spon's Dictionary of Engineering, division VIII (1870s), Washoe-process passage; archive.org id sponsdictionaryo08spon (OCR; page number not recovered). The index of the 1874 volume lists "Blake's stone-breaking machine, 2544"; that page was not found. Period text.
- 911Metallurgist reprints (modern web pages reproducing older texts, dated by the site): "Stone Crushers" (2017-02-05), "Crushers" (2016-10-23), "Blake Jaw Crusher" (2016-01-16, credited to an Allis-Chalmers booklet), "Rock Crusher History" (2015-04-16). Secondary.
- Grace's Guide, "H. R. Marsden" (image captions only); a 23 Jan 1872 NZ newspaper reprint seen only as a search snippet (natlib CROMARG18720123.2.18; page itself did not load).
- Library books: Overman 1851 (
manufactureofiro00overrich; printed folio is the PDF page less 6); Rose, Fairbairn, Johnson (Blast-Furnace Construction and Principles of Operation), Percy were searched for Blake, stone-breaker, rock-breaker, crusher, jaw. Purpose the period facts on the jaw crusher, kept apart from inference.
1. Arrangement
- Frame, patent: "a main cast frame" carries all parts; the fixed jaw is bolted at the bottom and its top has lateral projections seated in notches at the top of the frame; a transverse cross bar E and a lower transverse part with a mortise are in the same casting (US 20,542, 1858).
- Frame, later: cast iron, with the 20 x 12 in. size at "no less than 10,000 lb"; some makers carried the strain on steel rods so the frame is lighter; Challenge pattern had timber sides, cast-iron ends, steel rods, heaviest piece 2,400 lb in the 15 x 9 size (911Metallurgist "Stone Crushers", quoting H. M. Howe, Eng. & Mining Journal, 17 Nov 1883).
- Cheeks, Appleton 1880: "The cheeks I I fit in recesses on each side, and hold the plates in place; by changing the position of the cheeks from right to left, when worn, both will have a new surface." (p. 234).
- Fixed jaw: "bedded in zinc, a quarter of an inch thick, against the end of the frame" (Appleton p. 234); Knight: "bedded in zinc against the end of the frame" (p. 1569). Plates PP are "chilled plates ... when worn at the lower end they can be inverted" (Appleton p. 234). Knight: jaws faced with "case-hardened blocks of iron, which can be turned over when worn", with "coarse vertical furrows, the elevation on one opposite the depressions of the other, to prevent the passage of long, slim pieces of rock; but plain jaws may be used" (p. 1569). Patent: jaw faces corrugated vertically.
- Swing jaw, Appleton: "supported round the bar of iron K, which passes freely through it, and forms the pivot upon which it vibrates" (p. 234); in Fig. 492 K sits at the top of the jaw, which hangs from it. Knight: jaw "pivoted at i ... swinging back and forth by every revolution of the crank"; the vibration is "much less toward the pivot".
- Swing jaw, patent 1858 differs: the jaw's lower end enters a mortise in the lower casting (shoulders Z rest on the casting; rounded so the upper end can move), so the lower end is held and the upper end swings. The 1876/1880 texts put the pivot at the top and the largest travel at the bottom. Later texts are newer; the patent is the 1858 form.
- Pitman and toggles, Appleton: eccentric L on the flywheel shaft D; F "a pitman or connecting-rod, which connects the eccentric with the toggles G G, which have their bearings forming an elbow or toggle joint" (p. 234).
- Knight, Fig. 3417 form A: crank a, pitman b, a lever c with fulcrum d on the frame, a vertical piece e on the lever against which the toggles ff bear; form B "without the lever, the rod on the eccentric shaft being connected directly to the toggle-levers ... the form of machine most in use in Europe" (p. 1569); form C has a steam engine on the frame.
- Patent: toggle pieces C and D joined at F (elbow), C seated on cross bar E, D on the back of the jaw; F on lever G, fulcrum H in the casting, rod I to crank K of shaft L. When raised the pieces "should ... deviate from a line with each other by an angle of not less than five degrees" so they do not stick; faces converge "not exceed eighteen degrees" so stone is not ejected.
- Spring: patent, spiral spring M through rod N "tends to hold the jaw back". Appleton: L "a spring of India-rubber, which is compressed by the forward movement of the jaw" (p. 234). Knight: j "a rubber spring which opens the jaw".
- Set: Knight, k "is a wedge which regulates the degree of closure of the jaw" (p. 1569). 911Metallurgist ("Stone Crushers", from a later pattern) shows two wedge blocks R and Q at the rear toggle seat; "Crushers" says the rear toggle plate sat in an adjustable block sliding in the frame. Not stated in the 1858 patent.
- Bearings, Appleton: Q oiling-tubes, R steel bearings, T bush and key (p. 234).
2. Drive
- Patent: on one end of the shaft "a fly wheel ... four feet in diameter, weighing seven hundred and fifty pounds"; on the other a belt pulley; no rpm.
- Appleton: one fly-wheel B and driving pulley C on the shaft; the shaft "should make from 225 to 250 revolutions per minute" (p. 234); table speeds below, 125 to 250.
- Two flywheels appear in the Challenge pattern of 1883 (911Metallurgist "Stone Crushers"). Fig. 492 (viewed) draws one large spoked wheel on the near side.
- Throw: "one fourth of an inch, more or less" at the lower end of the jaw (patent; Appleton; Knight).
- Power from the Appleton table: 4 hp for 10 x 4, 6 hp for 10 x 7, 9 hp for 15 x 5 to 15 x 11, 12 hp for 20 x 15 and 24 x 18. Knight: the full power of the engine acts through a small space on large stone, a larger space on small.
- A 1872 Scottish-reprinted notice (snippet only): 15 x 7 needs about 4 hp, 100 tons in 24 hours; 20 x 9 about 5 hp, 150 tons. Differs from Appleton's 9 hp for 15 x 7; the snippet was not read in full.
3. Sizes (Appleton 1880, p. 234, "Table of Sizes and Capacity, Blake's Stone Breaker", read from the page image)
Size in. / cu yd per hour / total weight lb / speed rpm / hp A 10 x 4 / 3 / 4,000 / 250 / 4 1 10 x 5 / 3 / 6,700 / 180 / 5 2 10 x 7 / 5 / 8,000 / 250 / 6 3 15 x 5 / 6 / 9,100 / 180 / 9 4 15 x 7 / 6 / 10,490 / 180 / 9 5 15 x 9 / 7 / 13,360 / 250 / 9 6 15 x 11 / 7 / 11,600 / 180 / 9 8 20 x 15 / - / 32,600 / 150 / 12 (coarse or preliminary breaker) 7 15 x 13 / - / 11,760 / 180 / 9 (coarse or preliminary breaker) 9 24 x 18 / - / 37,500 / 125 / 12 (coarse or preliminary breaker) 10 16 x 12 / 6 / 7,000 / 230 / 9 (plaster crusher)
- Footnote: output is for jaws set "1 1/4 inch open at the bottom" at proper speed and "diligently fed"; hard stone or ore "that breaks with a snap will go through faster than sandstone"; "A cubic yard of stone is about one and one-third tons". Road metal from hard stone: jaws set 1 1/4 to 1 1/2 in. apart at the bottom; wider for soft stone.
- Knight, Fig. 3417 text: jaws "set about 1 1/4 inches apart at the bottom" (the OCR reads "14"; inferred misread, Appleton gives 1 1/4). Knight, Silver-mill: an "8 x 10" size "may crush 20 tons per day", broken ore "of the size of a walnut or smaller".
- Patent example: built for trap-rock blocks up to 3 1/2 in. thick and 9 in. square; "any size" possible.
- Inferred: the size is mouth width across the jaw by gape top to bottom (a 15 x 9 takes stone to 9 in.); gape to set for the 15 x 9 is 9 to 1.25, about 7 to 1; 7 cu yd an hour is about 9 tons an hour. The 15 x 9 weighs 13,360 lb against 10,490 lb for the 15 x 7 at the same jaw width.
- Modern sizes (Allis-Chalmers booklet, undated, via 911Metallurgist): 15 x 10 to 60 x 48 in.; crushing angle "in the neighborhood of 27 deg". Not 1860-80 data.
4. Working
- Feeding: stone is dropped between the converging faces; "the next succeeding bite" breaks it, fragments fall lower and are broken again until small enough to pass out at the bottom (Appleton p. 234; patent). The mouth should be level with the feeding floor so rock can be pushed in; large crushers have no hopper; do not fill the mouth before full speed; at North Star mine a rack-and-pinion gate on the coarse-ore bin fed the crusher (911Metallurgist "Stone Crushers", 1880s mining practice; secondary).
- Discharge: Appleton Fig. 492 shows broken stone falling to the floor under the jaw; Knight Fig. 5096 text: from the crusher "the broken ore falls on to a floor, and thence by a chute to the automatic feeder, which delivers it to the stamps". A screened machine appears in Grace's Guide captions: 1881 "Stone Breaker with Automatic Screening Apparatus" (Marsden, Royal Agricultural Show).
- Nip: patent limit is 18 degrees convergence of the faces. No other nip figure in a period text found.
- Wear: plates reversible end for end (Appleton); cheeks reversible left for right (Appleton); Knight says jaw blocks "cheaply replaced". Dies "last from 6 to 8 months", steel twice as long (911Metallurgist, mining practice, 1880s; secondary). Chilled iron later gave way to manganese steel because it broke (Allis-Chalmers booklet, undated).
- Weak link: no 1860-80 text found that names the toggle as the part that fails. Inferred, not stated: the patent's five degree rule and the toggle-seat parts are where a stalled stone loads the machine hardest.
- Soft wet ore packs and clogs; water may be added (911Metallurgist, secondary).
- Larger machines, Knight: a large crusher first breaks rock for smaller ones, used "in the Lake Superior copper-mines, and at Freiburg, Saxony".
5. Use for iron ore
- Overman 1851 (printed p. 40; the PDF text shows ore "broken into small fragments of the size of walnuts" and for open-heap roasting "pieces of uniform size, of from three to four inches") predates Blake, and names no breaking machine; hand breaking and screening by hand are implied (Overman, PDF p. 51-53).
- Stone-breaker use for ore: Spon's (1870s): larger ore pieces are broken for the stamps "either by a sledge or a mechanical rock-breaker, Blake's machine being in general use for this purpose" (precious metals, Washoe). Knight 1876: "Usually a preliminary breaking preparatory to stamping". An 1885 AIME paper said it was soon used for iron, copper and zinc ores (seen through a search summary only).
- Before Blake: Cornish rolls and hand spalling (911Metallurgist "Rock Crusher History"); Dan Mims, 17 Oct 2014, says macadam stone was broken by hand from the 1820s (Daily Nutmeg; popular).
- Britain: H. R. Marsden brought the machine to Leeds after 1862 and patented improvements in 1871 (Grace's Guide; the page also gives 1858 for the firm, unreconciled). Knight 1876 says form B, without the lever, "most in use in Europe".
- Blake v. Robertson, 94 U.S. 728 (Oct. term 1876) concerns the 1858 patent; not read.
- Not found in any local book: Rose, Fairbairn, both Johnson books and Percy have no stone-breaker or Blake entry.
Gaps
- No catalogue wording from Blake's own circulars, nor Rankine or Percy on the jaw crusher; no scan was reached.
- No period nip angle, no 1860-80 statement of the toggle as safety link (a toggle-plate breaking), no flywheel count or diameter beyond the patent's one 4 ft, 750 lb wheel and Appleton's one wheel.
- The patent drawing sheet, and Knight's Fig. 3417, were not viewed; the patent text omits an eccentric (a crank K).
- The patent's lower mortise hold differs from the 1876-80 top-pivot jaw; the date of the change is not documented.
- Spon page 2544 (Blake's stone-breaking machine) and the 1872 newspaper were not read.
- No source says when machines replaced hand breaking at an iron works; the 1850s to 1870s range is inferred only.
- 911Metallurgist "Stone Crushers" credits the Challenge pattern to Theodore A. Blake and Howe 1883; the 1858 patentee is E. W. Blake. The rubber spring and wedge details there are a later pattern, not the 1858 machine.