Hunt, British Mining (1884), ore dressing: crushing, jigs, buddles, trunking, copper, lead and blende
Books British Mining
Source Robert Hunt, British Mining: a treatise on the history, discovery, practical development, and future prospects of metalliferous mines in the United Kingdom (London, Crosby Lockwood, 1884), (978 PDF pages, OCR layer). Book III, Chapter IV, "Dressing Metalliferous Ores - Preparation for the Smelter", printed pp. 686-791, the Appendix table of specific gravities p. 889. Page numbers below are printed folios read from the running heads; the PDF page is the printed page plus 31 in the chapter (plus 27 at the Appendix). Hunt compiles Phillips and Darlington (1857), Henderson (Inst. Civ. Eng., 1858), Moissenet (1857, 1866), Ferguson (1873), Sopwith (1870), Rittinger (1867-70) and Cornish mine managers; works seen 1750s-1884, the machines described are the 1840-1884 forms. Not found or not used J. H. Collins, Principles of Metal Mining (1875): the copy on archive.org could not be downloaded and was not read. Ure's Dictionary art. "Dressing of Ores" (Darlington, 80 pages) and Rittinger's Lehrbuch are named by Hunt (p. 692) and not downloaded. A second source for the copper floor and the round buddle dimensions would be Henderson's 1858 paper or Ure; Hunt is the only one read. Purpose period dimensions, drive, rates and products for a mechanised washing branch after the ore crusher: power jigs and round buddles driven from shafting, fed by stamps or crushing rolls. Facts are Hunt's; INFERRED marks arithmetic or a reading added here. OCR is rough: figures read through garbled OCR are marked "OCR". Conversions: 1 in = 25.4 mm, 1 ft = 0.3048 m, 1 cwt = 50.8 kg, 1 imperial gallon = 4.546 L, 1 hp = 745.7 W, 1 long ton = 1016 kg. "Stuff" is Hunt's word for broken vein material.
A. Where the machines sit in the line
Order on a floor (p. 783, "the machinery to be employed ... is almost settled by common consent"):
- "For tinstone the reduction commences with the stone-breaker and stamps, while for copper, lead, and zinc ore hand-cobbing may form the first stage in the operations, but reduction will be performed by the stone-breaker and the crushing-mill. From the crusher the sand is usually divided into slimes for buddles and sand for jiggers." (pp. 782-783)
- "In tin-dressing the jigger is not used ... the stamped stuff either goes into strips or runs directly to round buddles and frames." (p. 783) Jigs are for copper, lead and zinc; stamps and round buddles are the tin line, and also take the slimes of a lead or copper floor.
- Site: ample room, cheap transport, "a natural and constant supply of water", "a suitable fall of ground for gravitating, as it were, the stuff from one to another set of dressing-machines", and fall for the tailings; then "no lifting of the orey products". "To run the stone-breakers, crushing-mills, jiggers, and buddles, shafting, belts, and riggers may be satisfactorily employed, but ... the machinery should be placed within covered building." (p. 782)
- Where water is short it is returned to the head of the floor "by an ordinary plunger" pump; stuff is lifted to the rolls and the pass of the stamps by a short wooden incline with waggon, chain, drum and clutch (p. 782).
- Grain bands for jigger work (p. 722): 3 to 8 mm rough jigger work, 1 to 3 mm coarse, 1/8 to 1 mm fine; slime is finer than the fine jig (buddles, 0 to 1.5 mm, p. 756).
Steps in history (dates for the sequence of introduction):
- Crushing rolls: John Taylor, Crowndale copper mine near Tavistock, 1806, "two lengths of cast-iron pipe of 16 or 18 inches diameter ... as cylinders or rolls" (p. 693); North Wales 1823; Consolidated Mines, Gwennap 1831; "tumbling-shafts and weight-levers to keep the rolls together, the riddle under the rolls ... and the raft-wheel for returning the latter product to the rolls, were applied by Cornish engineers" (p. 694).
- First jigging machine in Cornwall: Richard Taylor, Consolidated Mines, 1831 (p. 694); Petherick's hydraulic jigger (fixed sieves, moving plunger, hopper) 1828-1830, Tavistock; Derbyshire lever "break-sieves"; Capt. Barratt, Grassington, c. 1830, "several sieves are worked by one small water-wheel" (pp. 694-695); first continuous jigger, Troughton's patent, 23 June 1843 (p. 695); plunger continuous jigger, Vogl and Wimmer, about 1850 (p. 696).
- Round convex buddle first used in Cardiganshire about 1848; concave by Phillips and Darlington, later Hundt, 1856 (p. 696). Trunking machinery in Cornish mines about 1825 (note, p. 691). Self-acting dead frame, Vincent, Cook's Kitchen, about 1860.
B. Specific gravity and the sorting order (pp. 698-700, Appendix p. 889)
- "The dressing of ores consists in effecting a mechanical separation of earthy matter or gangue from metalliferous products." (p. 687) The principle: "sizing grains of different densities into grains of equal volume, or otherwise classifying grains of equal velocities of fall into grains of different dimensions" (p. 687). Two grains of equal fall in water differ in size, the lighter being the larger (p. 764); on a table the lighter, larger grain "will be impelled more rapidly" by a thin stream (p. 764).
- Weight of a cubic foot of water 62.425 lb; galena 7.5, so 468.18 lb a cubic foot; quartz 2.6 (p. 699).
- Appendix Table No. 1 (p. 889), specific gravity (hardness): Galena 7.2-7.6 (2.0-2.5); Wolfram 7.2-7.5 (5.0-5.5); Cassiterite 6.8-7.0 (6-7); Cuprite 6.0 (3.5-4.5); Tetrahedrite grey copper 5.6; Bornite 5.0; Melaconite 5.2; Chalcopyrite 4.2 (3.5-4.0); Malachite about 4.0 and azurite 3.8 (hardness 3.5-4.0; OCR); Blende 3.9-4.2 (3.5-4.0); Calamine 4.5; Chrysocolla 2.2 (OCR); Iron pyrites 4.1-4.3; Mispickel 6.0-6.4 (OCR); Cerussite 6.5; Anglesite 6.0-6.3. Gangue (p. 786): Quartz 2.65, Chlorite 2.5-2.8, Slate 2.6-2.85; Carbonate of lime 2.6, Clay-slate 2.5 (p. 700). Metals: Copper 8.5-8.9 not legible in OCR; Lead 11.35, Silver 10.47, Gold 19.25, Tin 7.3, Zinc 7.0, Iron 7.78 (p. 889 first table).
- Ease of separation by water (p. 700): "Grains of galena and quartz can be readily separated by water dressing, since the specific gravity of the former is 7.5 and the latter 2.6, a difference of 4.9." Against that: "Copper Pyrites specific gravity 4.15, Blende 4.02 Difference 0.13, Carbonate of Iron 4.1 Difference 0.05 ... the separation will be very imperfect." Galena with carbonate of lime and clay-slate "will not only separate readily ... but from the great difference in density ... a considerable variation of their relative sizes may be allowed ... but few mechanical appliances will be required ... a short and cheap" process (p. 700).
- Order of separation of a tinstone's minerals in water (table, p. 786): gangue (quartz, chlorite, slate, 2.5-2.85) lightest; then "(1) copper pyrites, iron pyrites" together; "(2)" mispickel with peroxide of iron; "(3)" wolfram and cassiterite heaviest, each pair "separate approximately together". INFERRED from the SG rows: by increasing density gangue 2.6, malachite/azurite/blende/spathic iron/copper pyrites/iron pyrites 3.8-4.3, then cuprite 6, cassiterite 7, wolfram and galena 7.2-7.6.
- Hardness and brittleness (p. 698): soft, brittle ores (sulphide of silver H 2.0-2.5, galena H 2.5) crushed in water lose fines: "an appreciable portion of the more brittle and precious ore ... frequently floats away and is lost".
C. Preparation before the jigs: picking, wash kiln, trommels, stone-breaker, rolls, stamps
Hand and bench dressing of copper (the older and the Cornish floor), pp. 688-689, 785
- Borlase 1758 on copper (p. 689): ore from below re-examined at the shaft mouth; the best "broken small with hammers, which they call spallings", bucked "upon a rock with a short bar of iron"; small ore "washed and sifted into a tub or keeve ... through an iron sieve, or scarce, called in Cornwall the 'griddle,' the meashes about an inch square", the copper "sorted into best and dredged"; what passes goes "through another scarce of smaller meash called the 'jigging scarce,' which has eight holes in every square inch ... lifted up and down, and turned round in the scarce a few times (which they call jigging), the waste will all rise to the top and settle in the middle like small sand, and what remains underneath will be clean ore". The poorer streaked ore is washed in "strakes" (pits) at the next stream; the richest bits culled "by girls or boys, at the hire of 4d. per day"; the stony remainder to a stamping-mill and a rough grate; the slimy part "must be trunked, buddled, and tozed as the slimy tin."
- The Cornish copper floor of the 1880s (p. 785): vein stuff raised in skips or kibbles; tipped from a waggon on a tramway "about 10 feet from the ground, which underneath is divided into stalls known as slides"; "the larger stones are broken up with a sledge hammer called 'ragging', and if a stone-breaker happens not to be a part of the plant the raggings are further reduced by spalling hammers to a size not exceeding the gauge of a ring 3 or 4 inches diameter. The whole of the stuff is now passed through two revolving sieves of different mesh, and then hand-picked by children and sorted into three qualities: (1) 'prills,' consisting of pieces of very nearly pure ore; (2) dredge, or second quality, in which the ore is more or less interspersed with the matrix; and (3) halvans, or waste." Prill is riddled through 3/4-inch (OCR) square holes: fines, 0 to 3/4 in, to pile and market; roughs, 3/4 to 3 in, to the crushing-mill and reduced to 0 to 3/4 in. Dredge "undergoes crushing, classifying, sizing, jigging."
- Devon Great Consols, Capt. Isaac Richards, about 1856: "in connection with the crushing rolls a set of sizing trommels, mounted successively end to end, and a classifying wheel, the former for sizing the grains into groups suitable for jiggers, the latter for obtaining equivalents for the buddles" (p. 785). Products: heads to pile, middles reduced again in the crusher or retreated, tails to the halvan heap (p. 785, table partly garbled by OCR).
Wash kiln and washing trommel (p. 715)
- Wash kiln of a lead floor: top width 9 ft, top length at back wall 12 ft, depth at back wall 1 ft 6 in, at the grate 4 ft 6 in; the grate 3.5 ft long on 5 x 6 in timber 5 ft long, cast bars 1.25 in thick at top, openings 0.75 in above and 1.5 in below; a picking table 6.5 ft x 8 ft; dividing trommel 5.5 ft long, 1 ft 5 in diameter, 4 in fall, 40 rpm; rotating picking table 10 ft diameter, 22 in high, one turn in four minutes ("a circumferential speed of 7.5 feet per minute" - OCR "7!"). Hands: a man to grate and distribute the stuff, four girls at the picking table, four small girls at the rotating table, men or strong boys to carry waste. Products "prill, dredge, and waste".
- Washing trommel: 4 to 5 ft diameter, 9 to 10 ft long, slope 1 in per ft (ordinary stuff) or 1/2 in (clayey), 10 to 15 rpm, water 10 to 30 gal/min, "quantity of ordinary 'small' vein stuff washed per hour, 6 to 10 tons; dirty clayey stuff, 3 to 5 tons; power required per trommel, from one-half to three-quarters of a horse" (p. 715).
Stone-breaker (pp. 716-720)
- Blake's jaw breaker (1858). Best speed "from 200 to 250 revolutions per minute"; jaws set 2 to 2.5 in apart at the bottom give stuff "three to four times smaller than by hand-spalling" (p. 718); good jaws 12 x 9 in cost 3 pounds and "will break from 2,000 to 3,000 tons of silicious veinstone", bad jaws under 300 tons (p. 718); Marsden's stone-grinder 300 rpm (p. 719). The breaker's rate and horse-power table (p. 718) is unreadable in OCR and is not quoted.
- Cost comparison for 50 tons a day through a breaker: interest, wear, coals, labour about 3 3/4d per ton against hand labour (breaker saves about 2.5d per ton), p. 717 (OCR; INFERRED reading).
Crushing rolls, "the Cornish crushing-mill" (pp. 721-724)
- "The rolls, riddle, and raff-wheel arrangement produces a kind of continuous crushing, the 'roughs' larger than the riddle spaces being again and again returned to the rolls." (p. 721) The rolls are kept together by lever and weight in Cornwall, by india-rubber and iron disc springs in Germany; "The circumferential speed of rolls in German mills is from 90 to 180 feet per minute" (p. 722). Rolls driven by spur gearing, not friction (p. 722).
- Sizes: French rolls "from 8 to 45 inches in diameter, length on face from 8 to 12 inches"; German ore rolls "usually 10 inches long, which are from 10 to 36 inches in diameter"; "coarse jigger work may be advantageously obtained with rolls from 18 to 24 inches diameter, and fine jigger work from rolls 10 to 18 inches diameter." (p. 722)
- A Cornish crusher on lead ore with carbonate of iron, quartz and hard grauwacke (pp. 722-723): "Diameter of rolls, 21 inches; length on face of rolls, 19 inches; weight of new pair of rolls, 2,700 lbs.; weight of worn-out pair of rolls, 1,600 lbs.; number of revolutions of rolls per minute, 8; speed on face of rolls per minute, 42 feet; size of stuff before entering rolls, 20 to 60 millimetres; size of stuff after leaving rolls, 0 to 6 millimetres; weight crushed per hour, 2 1/2 tons; quantity of stuff crushed by a pair of rolls, 2,000 tons; time required to take off and to put on new rolls, 10 hours; number of hands required at the crusher, 3"; steam power five horses; about 9.5d per ton all in.
- Fig. 195-196 (p. 723): spur gearing to the rolls, raff-wheel lifting the oversize to a chute back to the hopper, riddle under the rolls dividing coarse "roughs" (to the rolls again) from fine (sized and classified for jiggers and buddles).
- Sizing result of a pair of rolls (table, p. 724; OCR of the rows is poor): the share returned to the rolls "did not exceed 13 per cent., while the proportion of stuff for the classifier varied from 30 to 48 per cent."; the rest, 3 to 7.5 mm upward, sized by trommels to jiggers Nos. 1 to 4. The table of roll size against rate and horse-power on the same page is too garbled to quote.
- INFERRED: the 21 x 19 in rolls on a 5 hp engine at 2.5 t/h is a supply for one or two jiggers (see section D); the 42 ft/min face speed agrees with pi x 21 in x 8 rpm = 44 ft/min.
Stamps (pp. 724-733); used for tin and for the rough ores that the rolls will not take
- Pryce 1778 (p. 725): "a thin plate of iron ... 12 inches long, and 10 inches wide. The middle of this, from 8 1/2 inches by 7 inches (OCR), is punched full of holes" - the grate. "The lifters are three to each stamp, made of ash timber, 6 inches by 7 inches square, and about 9 feet or 10 feet long ... armed at the bottom with large masses of iron, called stamp-heads, of 140 lbs. weight each or more", lifted by wooden "caps" on a water-wheel axle and let fall between oak planks; "the hinder head lifts first, that falling forces the tin stuff under the second ... on to the small holes in the grate." Woolf built the first steam stamping-mill at Wheal Vor in 1812; wrought-iron lifters and cast-iron guides from about 1830 at Lanescot (p. 725).
- Cornish gravitation stamps (pp. 729-730): "The average weight of a head without lifter is 4 1/2 cwts., with lifter 6 to 7 cwts. The average life of a head is about 4 months, while the loss of chilled cast iron in stamping a ton of stuff is about 3 lbs. The weight of tinstone stamped per 24 hours varies from 15 to 20 cwts. [a head] ... The lifters are usually made of flat wrought iron about 3 1/2 inches wide by 2 inches thick, and the head of hard chilled cast iron about 22 inches long by 11 inches wide and 7 inches thick. The average lift is about 9 inches, the maximum 10, and minimum lift 7 inches. ... The coffers are generally made of wood, the grate-plates being of copper ... each axle lifting 16 heads, set in 4 coffers. In some mines there are as many as 25 sets of coffers or 100 heads." Slow stamping is "50 to 70 drops per minute" (p. 730); Californian stamps 70 to 120, round heads, iron coffers (pp. 733-734).
- Grates at Cook's Kitchen: "front grates are 28 inches long by 9 inches high, the end grates 9 inches long by 9 inches high" (p. 788); No. 36 copper grate, holes barely half a millimetre, at Wheal Agar (p. 789).
- Drive: a 36 in cylinder, 10 ft stroke double-acting engine drove 48 heads at 50 indicated and 30 actual hp, lift 6 in, five cams to the round (Wheal Vor, p. 726). West Basset: 40 in cylinder, 9 ft stroke, 4 axles of 16 heads (64), 107 rpm, average head and lifter 877 lb, "weight of tinstone stamped per head per day after allowing for stoppages, 34 1/2 cwts.", coal 6 1/4 lb a ton of tinstone (pp. 730-731). Polberro: 36 in engine, 72 heads of 600 lb, lift 9 in, 45 blows a minute average, 28 cwt a head in 24 h, 100 tons a day, 55 actual hp (pp. 731-732). Polrose: 30 in engine, 60 heads, 55 blows a minute, 25 to 28 cwt a head a day (p. 733).
- Water: "The quantity of water required for dressing purposes for 80 heads, reducing 70 tons of tinstone per 24 hours, was 800 gallons per minute" (p. 731), about 10 gal/min a head. Tonnage per horse-power: "300 tons of tinstone per horse-power per annum" (p. 729).
- Stamped sizing (p. 730): from a sample through a No. 36 grate, 26.7 per cent coarser than 6,000 holes per square inch, 13.2 per cent 6,000 to 12,000, 60.1 per cent finer than that: "the greater portion of the stuff reduced was ... very much finer than the diameter of the hole in the grate". Hence the great slime of the stamped tin line.
Trommels and classifiers (pp. 746-757)
- Continuous cylindrical trommel: 2 to 3 ft diameter, 18 to 25 rpm, set at 3 to 5 degrees (OCR "30 to 50"), perforated plates of 1, 1.5, 2, 3 mm...in series (p. 746). Single conical trommels in a set of six: "each 42 inches long, diameter at large end 21 inches, and at small end 18 inches, making 20 revolutions per minute, will size from 20 to 30 tons in 10 hours. The water required for the six trommels will be from 12 to 15 gallons per minute." Ten of Darlington's 24-28 in trommels at 20 rpm size about 8 tons an hour (p. 747).
- Cone separator (p. 756-757): iron cone 36 in high and 25 in across, inlet pipe 2.5 in, 6 ft head of water; it divides the rolls' product into slimes of 0 to 1.5 mm for buddles and tables, and sand 1.5 to 6 or 7.5 mm for jiggers. Classifying launders (Hodge, Borlase) deliver "grains of equal fall" to buddles and frames (pp. 753-756).
D. Jigs (pp. 757-764)
Principle (p. 757): heavy and light grains of equal volume drop through water and part; in a jigger "the column of water is too shallow to allow of any appreciable separation ... by simply dropping the grains together, but the desired result is accomplished by subjecting such grains to a series of upward and falling (pulsating) movements". In the hand sieve and the brake the light waste and the dredge are removed by a "limp" (a scraper); "in the mechanical jigger these products are continuously obtained by the flowing action of water". Hand jigs known in Bohemia 1519 and Agricola's Saxony (p. 757). Bedding (Forster 1821, p. 690): "a quantity of the smallest of the sieve ore laid on the bottom of the sieve in the form of a layer about two inches thick"; the heavy grains of the stuff pass down through the bedding and the sieve.
Hand jigging sieve (p. 758): "formed of a hoop of oak 18 to 20 inches diameter, 3/8 (OCR) inch thick, and 6 inches deep ... a screen of copper or iron wire", sometimes a perforated copper plate (a "copper bottom"); "placed in a cistern or tub of water and vigorously jerked until the sterile veinstone is separated from the orey mixture. The waste is then removed with a sheet-iron scraper". A diluting sieve with horse-hair or canvas bottom does the last cleaning (p. 758). Old practice: boys worked it stooping, over a tank sunk in the ground; "many hands were required" (p. 694).
Brake jigger / brake-sieve (pp. 758-759, Fig. 211): a trough or "hutch" through which a small stream of water flows; over its centre a rectangular sieve "having about 25 holes per square inch", bed of coarse ore "about 3/4 (OCR) inch thick"; the stuff is spread on the bed, the sieve is lowered into the water by a lever and jerked by hand "for two or three minutes" between stops that limit the play; then raised, the light particles on the surface "skimmed off and thrown away", the middle laid aside for further treatment, "The 'bottom,' comprising best ore as well as the smaller particles which have fallen through the sieve and into the hutch, are usually sufficiently rich for the smelting furnace." Barratt hung the lever-sieve for mechanical drive from a small water-wheel about 1830 (p. 695).
Continuous (power) jigger, general (pp. 757-758)
- Settings: "For coarse-sand jiggers the speed may be from 60 to 75 strokes per minute, while the water required will be from 9 to 15 gallons per machine per minute. In fine-sand jiggers the speed will vary from 90 to 150 strokes per minute, and the water from 10 to 15 gallons per minute. In slime jiggers from 150 to 300 strokes per minute are made." (p. 757) The practice is "to increase the speed, shorten the stroke, and lessen the thickness of bed with the decreasing size of grains". Stroke by grain size (table p. 757, the inch row is OCR-garbled): grain 10 to 7.5 mm 60-75 strokes, then 100, 110, 150-300 as the grains pass from 3 mm to under 1 mm; stroke from about 2.5 in at the coarse end down to a fraction of an inch.
- "In cases where only one ore is associated with the gangue a jigger 6 feet long will generally be sufficient; but when two or three ores are associated ... a greater length will be found advisable." (p. 758) Coarse jiggers are placed behind sizing trommels, fine ones behind trommels or classifiers (p. 757). Sieve openings must be larger than the grains to be collected, the bed grains larger than the sieve openings (p. 758).
- Drive (p. 758): "the piston is reciprocated by means of eccentrics, in others by a rocking and counter shaft, while a third movement is produced by a revolving disc"; each has "a means for varying the length of the piston stroke"; a fly-wheel steadies it; belts inside a building, "common shafting and wheel gearing" in the open. Wire-woven sieves replaced perforated plates (more waterway, less resistance); discharge by conical valves, slides or plugs worked from outside.
- Sand-bed mode: ore grains settle through the bed into the hutch below and are drawn off; "the waste passes from the end of the machine into a waggon, while the concentrated ore is continuously discharged from the hutch" (p. 761).
Named machines
- Continuous sand jigger, one long sieve (Fig. 212, pp. 759-760): "A jigger 20 feet long provided with a sieve 42 inches wide will despatch approximately - stuff composed of grains 3 to 5 millimetres diameter, 5 tons per hour" (p. 760; the finer rows are lost in OCR). The waste launder lip stands 2 to 3 in above the sand, so the jig works under water.
- Argall's jigger (Fig. 213, pp. 760-761): a piston between two hutches feeding two sieves, two sizes jigged at once (Cornish gauge No. 53 one side, No. 25 the other); "with a 'four-hole' sieve, and a speed of a hundred and fifty revolutions per minute, will jig from 5 to 6 tons of coarse-grained stuff per hour. The pistons are hung to eccentrics" (p. 761).
- Wood-built three-piston compound jigger with cascade sieve bottoms, shifting eccentrics and a fly-wheel (Fig. 214, p. 761).
- Collom's tappet jigger (Fig. 215, pp. 761-762): two pistons struck alternately by a rocker and raised by springs against an adjustable stop; piston stroke "from half an inch to one inch"; the rocker worked by "a crank making about 120 revolutions per minute"; each hutch topped with a fine brass-wire sieve carrying a bed of coarse ore "about 3/4 (OCR) inch thick"; the hutches kept full of clear water "with a pressure of 2 feet of head or upwards"; a second jigger a few inches lower takes the overflow of the first and jigs it again. Ragging gear (tapered plugs in a row of holes) lets stuff too light for the bedding and too heavy to flow off, "which never amounts to much", pass out of the sieve.
- Slime or buddle jigger (Fig. 216, pp. 763-764): "This jigger is taking the place of the round buddle in various dressing works, the piston of which makes from 300 to 500 strokes per minute." Slime falls from a circular distributing table to an annular launder and onto an annular sieve; concentrate passes through the bed into a cistern and out by a gas pipe, waste flows over the sieve's outer edge. Copper sieve holes 1.5 mm (OCR "1 1/2"), the bed "large grains of ore 1/4 inch diameter and 3 1/2 inches thick" (OCR), stroke "about 1/4 inch" (OCR), "not less than 300 per minute", clear water about 18 gal/min. "The working capacity of a buddle jigger is nearly double that of a round buddle 25 feet diameter, while the waste from the former is much poorer in metallic ore." Several in a series, each of lesser diameter, separate "sulphide of lead, blende, mundic, and vein stuff". Size: outside diameter of cistern 9 ft, piston 3 ft, cistern 4 ft high, sieve fall 4 1/2 in.
- Harz continuous machine 1864: piston and a stationary sieve for lead ores of 1/12 to 1/25 in, replacing strake, tye and buddle, "which ... consumes an undue proportion of time and labour" (p. 695).
- Water: 9 to 15 gal/min a jig, 18 for the slime jig. Men: Hunt gives no count of tenders for a continuous jigger; the hand-sieve boys were displaced by the machines (the 1831 Gwennap objection, p. 694).
How the three ores run through the jigs (pp. 783-784, lead floor, taken as the continuous-jig model)
- Apparatus of a lead floor: "a wash kiln, or a washing and dividing trommel; a stone-breaker, frequently fitted with a sizing trommel; a crushing-mill and dividing riddle; a classifier; a separating cone; a set of sizing trommels; coarse and fine sand jiggers; a 'fine' crushing-mill, or a small battery of stamps; side blow shaking tables and round buddles."
- Flow: wash kiln gives stones and fines; the stones give prill (to the ore-house), dredge and waste (to the hillock); prill pure ore; dredge cobbed to ore, dredge for the breaker or rolls, and waste for the attle-heap; after the breaker, dredge to rolls, raggings to rolls, skimpings to hillock. Rolls with a 5-hole riddle (five holes per linear inch, "each being equal to a hole five millimetres in diameter") give grains 0 to 5 mm. The separating cone parts gritless slime and slime sand (0 to 1.5 mm) for the buddles from coarse sand 1.5 to 5 mm for the jigs. The sand is sized "1 1/2 to 2 mm, jigger No. 1; 2 to 3 1/2 mm, No. 2; 3 1/2 to 5 mm, No. 3", each giving pure ore for the ore-house, raggings for the fine crusher or stamps, and waste for the hillock; the grit slime and slime sand "classified into two or three sets of grains, each enriched on a like number of buddles", giving "pure ore, middles for retreatment, and waste".
- Grades: Cardiganshire and Cornish lead veins "do not perhaps contain on an average more than 5 per cent. of lead, which must be dressed to assay from 70 to 75 per cent. of metal. If the loss in tailings be reckoned at one-half unit of lead per ton of stuff, and the dressed product yields by assay 75 per cent. of lead, it follows that 16 1/2 tons of vein stuff will be necessary to afford one ton of ore." (p. 784) Lisburne knife-buddle test: 15 per cent stuff concentrated to 50, then retreated to 75 per cent lead (p. 766).
E. Buddles, frames and tables (pp. 764-771, 788-790)
Hand buddle (p. 764-765, Fig. 217): a wooden box "about 8 feet in length, 3 feet wide, and from 2 to 2 1/2 feet deep, sunk in the ground, and having an inclination of about 2 feet in its whole length"; a distributing board at the head fed from a trough and a water launder; the fine slime goes through a perforated plate "in a thin and uniform stream into the buddle, when the buddler carefully and continually sweeps the slime and water across the buddle"; a tail-board with a vertical row of plugged holes, plugged one after another as the deposit rises, 9 inches of water kept before it. "Four-and-a-half buddlesful are generally finished by two boys in ten hours." The filled buddle is divided by eye into head, fore middle head, middle head and tail; the head (about one third) is buddled again and the head of that "tossed" for the furnace.
Round buddle, convex or centre-head (pp. 766-767, Figs. 219-221):
- Size: "about 22 feet diameter, and from 1 to 1 1/2 foot deep at the circumference, with a raised centre 10 feet diameter, and a floor falling towards the outer circle at a slope of about 1 in 30 for a length of 6 feet." The floor is 6 ft wide each side of the 10 ft centre (22 - 10 = 12 ft). Cook's Kitchen's: external diameter 21 ft with a 10 ft centre-head; "annular working floor" divided into head 1 ft 6 in, crease 2 ft, tail 2 ft (p. 788; the book says the floor is 2 1/2 ft wide, but the three bands sum to 5.5 ft = (21 - 10)/2, INFERRED the print is in error). "Such a buddle will dispose of the stuff reduced by 12 or 16 stamp heads" (p. 788). Borlase's inclined buddle is below.
- Feed and drive: the stuff arrives "in launders, into which a constant stream of water flows" at the centre and is spread "from a revolving pan ... carrying a number of spouts, so as to spread the liquid stream very uniformly in a thin film"; to stop gutters, rollers on arms carry "a sweep consisting of a brush or small piece of cloth ... drawn over the surface of the deposit". "The distributing spouts and sweeps are driven at about 5 or 6 revolutions per minute." The outflow is a wooden partition with horizontal rows of holes "successively plugged up from the bottom as the height of the deposit rises"; the sweeps are raised with the deposit "until the whole buddle is filled to the top of the centre cone, which usually takes about ten hours." (pp. 766-767)
- Products: "The contents are then divided into three concentric portions, each about a third of the whole breadth, called the head, middle, and tail. In tin dressing, the head or portion nearest the centre contains about 70 per cent. of all the tin in the stuff supplied to the buddle, the middle some 20 per cent., while the tail ... only traces." (p. 767) The head is the heavy product at the centre; the tail is carried to the outer trench.
- INFERRED volume and rate: the annulus between 10 and 22 ft is 301.6 sq ft; at an average deposit of 1 ft (the stated depth 1 to 1.5 ft at the rim) about 300 cu ft, 8.5 m3, a batch per ten hours. Hunt gives no tons-an-hour for it. The buddle jigger is said to do "nearly double" a 25 ft round buddle (p. 763), and the Lisburne impeller buddle 40 tons in ten hours (below), the 22 ft round buddle on the stamps of 12-16 heads handles 12 x 15 cwt = 9 t a day to 16 x 20 cwt = 16 t a day (INFERRED from the heads' 15-20 cwt a 24 h, p. 729).
Concave buddle (pp. 767-768, Fig. 222): the heads of several round buddles are thrown "into a trough or launder, into which a stream of clear water flows of sufficient volume to convey the stuff to concave buddles". Borlase's concave buddle: a conical floor "falling at a slope of about 1 in 12, towards the centre"; the stuff goes through a perforated plate to a central box, then "to a circular ledge of the buddle by six revolving spouts"; a centre ring raised by hand on a rod and lever adjusts the height of the central outflow "more gradually and uniformly than by the plugged holes", less guttering. "The greatest proportion of the ore is deposited round the circumference of the floor, while the slime and waste flow over the top of the rising ring into the well." A convex buddle's heads are cleaned on concave ones twice or three times, the final product tossed (p. 789). Ring buddle: a movable ring outside the table that keeps the angle (p. 768).
Borlase's inclined buddle (p. 769, Fig. 224): "a slowly revolving annular table, 24 feet diameter and 6 feet wide, placed at an inclination at 1 in 12 from an horizontal line", one turn "in three minutes", fed by distributors, washed by a gentle stream from above, the richer product on the outer edge washed off by jets at the lower side into one launder, the poorer into another; claimed to save "nine-tenths of the ore at the first washing".
Knife or impeller buddle (pp. 765-766): Lisburne mines, 1845 knife buddle: inclined table and a reciprocating frame of fifteen knives, "fifteen strokes per minute, and washed 40 tons of stuff per ten hours, which stuff yielded 12 tons of best, 4 tons of second class ore and 24 tons of waste, which contained 2 per cent. of ore." (p. 765) Ball's impeller buddle: a trommel frame "9 1/2 feet long and 6 feet diameter" carrying spiral knife blades, turning at "about 20 revolutions a minute, giving the knife blades a speed of about 370 feet a minute" over a sheet-iron-lined casing covering a quarter of the circumference, clear water running down; Lisburne: "2 1/2 tons per hour" of stuff with 15 per cent lead, concentrated to 50 per cent (p. 766). Knife-buddle yield by weight (INFERRED from the 1845 figures): 12 + 4 = 16 of 40 tons kept, 40 per cent, 60 per cent tailings.
Dead frame (pp. 769-771, Fig. 225), the self-acting table of the tin floor: bed 6 ft x 6 ft, "grade of 1 1/2 inch to the running foot", slimes delivered over a head board; every few minutes a V-shaped water launder at the head cants and washes the deposit into a foot launder. Second ("doubling") frame 8 ft long, 6 ft wide, grade 2 in a foot, worked by hand; the cleaning frame two beds of 6 ft square. Great Wheal Vor floor: 48 stamp heads, about 15 of every 48 tons of stuff to the dead frames, 40 ragging frames, 28 doubling and 4 trebling frames; "one girl to 14 frames, or from five to six girls for the whole series"; frames of 1 1/2 in American deal plank; faces swabbed with hemp once a week; water holes 1/2 in and 3/8 in. (p. 771)
Brunton's concentrator (cloth table, p. 771): lead slimes, table 16 ft long, "speed of cloth 3 revolutions per minute", feed apparatus about 9 revolutions per minute (OCR); 75 strokes a minute (OCR) of a 1 1/4 to 1 1/2 in blow; water 12 gal/min; "quantity of stuff worked per 12 hours per table 200 cubic feet", 4 per cent lead on average, 40 cu ft of concentrates per 12 h (20 per cent by volume); "5 boys to 2 tables"; enrichment "from 4 to 10 per cent." in one pass; stuff about 1 mm and passed through a 72-hole-a-square-inch grate.
Tossing and packing (p. 778, Fig. 227): the last cleaning of tin heads in a kieve "about 3 1/2 feet diameter and 2 1/2 feet deep" with an equal volume of water stirred by a shovel, then "packing": tapping the kieve's side with a heavy bar held vertically, "blows of about 100 per minute", "from a quarter of an hour to an hour"; skimmed top rebuddled; the bottom "whits" go to the burning house. A mechanical hammer does the packing at some mines.
Trunking and the strip (tin side of the line, pp. 689, 691, 788-789): Hunt describes the strip or strake, tye and trunk only by name and in lists ("strips, tye", p. 691; trunking machinery about 1825, p. 691 note). The "rows" containing the "dredge tin" go from the stamp-grates into strips and the heads are restamped (p. 788-789). He gives no length, width or fall for a strip or trunk; Borlase 1758 (p. 689) is the only copper trunking line: "must be trunked, buddled, and tozed as the slimy tin". NOT DOCUMENTED in this book: strip, trunk, tye or strake dimensions, inclination and rate.
F. Calcining and roasting on the floor (pp. 771-773), for the tin and copper pyrites lines
- Brunton's revolving calciner: a horizontal table "about 12 feet diameter" in a shell and dome, table turning 4 to 6 revolutions an hour, stirrers fixed in the dome (p. 771). At Wheal Polrose, 12 ft bed, 5 rev/h, "6 to 7 tons" of tin whits a day, bed depth 3 to 4 in, weight loss 10 per cent, coal 56 lb per ton of whits; driven by a 5 ft x 12 in water-wheel (pp. 772-773).
- Oxland and Hocking's cylinder: wrought iron lined with firebrick, 3 ft inside diameter, 32 ft long, inclined 1 in 16 to 1 in 24, 6 to 8 revolutions an hour, stuff passes in 3 to 6 hours; Wheal Basset's 28 ft x 4 ft at 1 in 16, 4 rev/h, 7 tons of whits in 24 h on 17 to 18 cwt of coal (p. 772). Purpose: drive off arsenic and sulphur and change relative densities.
G. How each ore was dressed
Copper ore (copper pyrites 34.6 per cent Cu pure; the other ores red oxide, black oxide, purple sulphide, blue and green carbonate, p. 785):
- Hand-first dressing (section C, p. 785): ragging, spalling to a 3 to 4 in ring, two revolving sieves, picking by children into prill (nearly pure ore), dredge and halvans (waste); prill riddled at 3/4 in; fines straight to the pile; roughs to the rolls.
- Machine route for dredge (pp. 721-723, 785): stone-breaker or rolls with riddle and raff-wheel, sizing trommels (Devon Great Consols arrangement), jiggers on the 1.5 to 8 mm sizes, buddles on the slimes. Jigging is the main concentrator of copper; the buddle takes the slimes only.
- Many Cornish lodes carry both tin and copper (p. 785); copper pyrites 4.1-4.3 is "scarcely separable" from blende and spathic iron by water (p. 700, p. 784).
- Output of the Cornish and Devon copper floors: 182,391 tons of ore containing 11,831 tons of copper in 1859; 43,389 tons and 2,947 tons in 1881 (p. 786), i.e. 6.5 and 6.8 per cent copper in the sold ore (INFERRED, ratio of the two figures).
- Chemical routes beside dressing (pp. 774-777): Henderson's hydrochloric acid leach on cupreous sandstone at Alderley Edge (stone tanks 11 x 8 x 4 ft with false bottoms, 95,000 tons of sandstone for 1,444 tons copper in eight years to 1872, 1.5 per cent); burnt Spanish pyrites (3 to 3.5 per cent Cu) salt-roasted, leached in 16 ton tanks and precipitated on iron (pp. 775-777). Not a dressing route. Lead ore (galena 7.2-7.6): the cleanest case; compact galena with limestone or slate "may be quickly and cheaply dressed" (p. 784); the flow of section D, 5 per cent stuff to 70-75 per cent ore, 16.5 tons stuff to a ton of ore. Barytes and fluor-spar gangue at Derbyshire and North of England (p. 783). Blende (3.9-4.2): "scarcely separable" from copper pyrites and spathic iron by water; methods: in Britain F. J. King's roasting at dull red heat to make the iron carbonate magnetic and parting by magnetic wheels (p. 777), and for copper or iron pyrites a heating "to the condition of magnetic pyrites" first; before that only the jig and buddle together with the trommel/classifier route of section D, sometimes with "dynamo-magneto apparatus" (p. 784). Output: 35,527 tons of blende in 1881 from fifty mines yielding 14,947 tons of zinc (p. 784; 42 per cent, INFERRED). Tin (for the buddle's role, the line the round buddle belongs to): stamps, centre-head buddle, concave buddle (twice or thrice), tossing and packing, calcining, buddling again, then frames; 60,000 tons of tinstone stamped for 1,000 tons of black tin a month (p. 786); tailings 2 to 3 lb of black tin a ton (p. 787); cost of stamping and dressing 3s 3d to 4s a ton of stone (p. 787). Wheal Agar run (pp. 789-790): No. 36 grate to the centre of a centre-head buddle; heads, middles ("crease"), tails shovelled out separately; heads to a concave buddle, then a third or fourth concave pass, then tossing.
H. Drive and power summary (INFERRED where marked)
- Water power is named for the early jigs (Barratt, Grassington, "several sieves worked by one small water-wheel", p. 695) and for the Brunton calciner (5 ft x 12 in wheel with a 9 in pinion and a 33 in spur wheel, p. 773). Larger floors used engines.
- Shafting and belts are Hunt's drive for "the stone-breakers, crushing-mills, jiggers, and buddles" (p. 782).
- Per machine: wash trommel 0.5-0.75 hp (p. 715); crusher rolls 21 x 19 in 5 hp for 2.5 t/h (p. 723); Wheal Vor 36 in engine 30 hp on 48 heads, 0.6 hp a head (p. 726); Polberro 55 hp for 72 heads, 0.76 hp a head (p. 732, INFERRED from 55 / 72). The book gives no hp for a jigger or a round buddle. INFERRED: the buddle's drive is the sweeps and spouts at 5-6 rpm, small; the continuous jigger's is an eccentric and a fly-wheel, a fraction of a horse per sieve; neither is stated.
- Attendance: jigs and buddles are a boy's or a girl's work. Stated: hand buddle two boys, 4.5 buddlesful in ten hours (p. 765); Brunton table 5 boys to 2 tables (p. 771); dead frames one girl to 14 frames (p. 771); crusher 3 hands (p. 723); lead-floor kiln 1 man, 4 girls, 4 small girls, boys to carry waste (p. 715).