Marks, The Manufacture of Iron and Steel Tubes (1903)
Books The Manufacture of Iron and Steel Tubes
Covers E. C. R. Marks, "The Manufacture of Iron and Steel Tubes" (2nd edition, 1903, 176 PDF pages). Pages below are the book's printed folios, which are the PDF page less twelve. PDF pages 2-4, 6, 8, 10, 173 and 176 carry no text layer (binding, blanks and the back cover). The book is a survey of British patent specifications with the practice of the Wednesbury tube trade between them; where a sentence below is a patent and not a practice, the patent's year is given. Read whole: chapter I, butt-welded tube (pp. 1-8); II, lap-welded steam tube (pp. 9-16); III, open and close-jointed, coiled and lock-jointed tube (pp. 16-23); X, cold drawing, annealing and tube steel (pp. 108-121); XI, welded tubes and the maker's list (pp. 121-127); XII, the piled hollow bloom and cased tube (pp. 127-133). Read in part: seamless steel tube (pp. 24-28), the Mannesmann process (pp. 32-35), the universal tube mill (pp. 59-60) and Robertson's press (pp. 70-74). Skimmed by keyword: the rest of IV-IX (seamless steel, piercing, pilger rolls, pp. 28-108). Skipped: the appendix list of patents and the index (pp. 134-156). Figures looked at from rendered pages: the tilt hammer and the tube stand with its mandrel (figs. 3-5, pp. 4-5), Whitehouse's furnace, draw bench, press, die and pincers (figs. 6-9, pp. 6-7), the skelp tongs (fig. 10, p. 12), Muckley's furnace, bevel rolls, skelp die and bench (figs. 11-16, pp. 13-14), Howard's skelp former and welding bell (figs. 17-19, p. 15), Huggins's roll-and-trumpet machine (figs. 21-23, pp. 17-18), Twer's bell with rollers and mandrel (fig. 127, p. 125), Perrins's hollow bloom (fig. 129, p. 129) and the maker's table (p. 123, set sideways and read from the image).
What the book says
Before 1825: hammered tube (pp. 2-4, 7-8)
- The first wrought tube was the gun barrel: a plate or strip bent to a "skelp", its edges "welded together piecemeal by hammering", a rod or mandrel inside (p. 2). Osborn (1812) welded the skelp under a tilt hammer in a grooved swage, and in 1813 tapered barrels in grooved rolls (pp. 2-3).
- Murdoch piped gas through the Soho works in 1815 with old musket barrels "screwed together" (p. 3).
- Russell (1824) kept the tilt hammer, butted the edges instead of lapping them, and "finished between rolls in conjunction with a mandrel" (p. 4). Fig. 4 is a two-high stand with a round groove and the mandrel on a long bar held in a stand before the rolls; fig. 5 shows the roll barrels cut with several grooves.
- By the old modes a tube could not exceed 4 ft without great cost, and the price paid for welding one under the gun-barrel method equalled the selling price of the whole tube under Whitehouse's (pp. 7-8).
Whitehouse's butt weld, 1825 (pp. 5-8)
- "I prepare a piece of flat iron, commonly called plough-plate iron, of a suitable substance and width, according to the intended calibre of the tube." It is "bent up on the sides, or ... turned over, the edges meeting, or nearly so", then "put into a hollow fire, heated by a blast", and "when the iron is upon the point of fusion" drawn out by a chain on a draw bench through a pair of dies (p. 5).
- Fig. 6 (p. 6): the furnace A is a tall brick stack; the draw bench B runs from its mouth, its chain on a spur wheel C "put in operation by a hand winch, or by attaching its axle to ... a steam engine"; the dies sit in a screw press D at the furnace end.
- The tube is welded one end at a time: the far end is gripped, drawn and welded, then "the reverse side of the tube is then grasped ... and that part which has not been welded is introduced into the furnace, and after being heated is drawn through the dies" (pp. 6-7).
- The dies can be replaced by pincers with a hole of "conical figure" held against a standard (fig. 9, p. 7). The principle is "to heat ... to a welding heat - that is, nearly to the point of fusion - and then ... to pass them between dies, or through holes" (p. 7). Lengths of 2-8 ft in one piece (pp. 7-8).
- Still "employed in all such tube manufactories at the present day" (p. 5); the patent ran out in 1845 (p. 8).
Lap-welded steam tube (pp. 9-12, 121-122, 127)
- The Rocket of 1829 "created a demand for a larger and stronger form of tube than could be produced by butt welding". Steam tube is made "by the welding of the overlapping edges of wrought-iron skelps, in machines having rolls in conjunction with a stationary mandrel", which "appears a very simple operation in a well-organised tube works" (p. 9). Ledsam and Bowers used four rolls, the Russells two (p. 10).
- Prosser (1840): skelps "after heating in a reverberatory or other furnace" pass four grooved disc rolls; "the central space between the rolls regulates the external diameter of the tube, and the mandrel the internal diameter"; two seconds a tube (pp. 10-11).
- Russell (1845, p. 122): "The tubular skelp, drawn from a furnace at a welding heat, is placed upon a mandrel ... a 'beak-iron,' which has a working surface of steel", fixed at one end over a draw bench; a roller presses the lap while the chain draws the tube off. Large tubes "are welded thereby at two operations, one-half at a time"; small ones need a longer beak-iron carried on a roller beneath.
- Johnson (1899, p. 127), lap welding in a rolling mill: skelps "placed upon mandrels and heated in a heating furnace, of the ordinary kind, in front of the rolls"; the tube is passed through a first groove which partly welds it, "returned to the furnace", switched by a movable guide to a second groove, "re-heated" and "passed one or more times through the second groove" to finish the weld; "long tubes can be readily welded at one operation"; then "straightened in the ordinary way".
- Kellogg (1883, p. 59): an ordinary mill has its lower roll fixed and adjusts only the top one, which with a supported mandrel leaves the rolls off-centre to it.
Forming the skelp: rolls, dies and the bell (pp. 11-19, 125)
- Russell and Whitehouse (1842): tongs close the flat skelp to a pear section and a hollow bar is put inside as the support; No. 14 gauge, 1.5-2 in locomotive flue tubes (p. 11; fig. 10, p. 12).
- Muckley (1891): the lap edges were bevelled "upon a bevelling table or ... a planing machine" as "a distinct and separate part of the process"; he bevels in a pair of rolls at the furnace mouth instead and draws the hot strip on through a skelp die, saving the metal "so that ... I make a 12 in. strip equal to, say, 12 1/4 in." (pp. 12-14). Figs. 11-12: furnace A in the wall, rolls B at its mouth, the conical skelp die C on the bench, the chain and gripper carriage behind.
- Howard (1890): a skelp former B beside the furnace, a blowpipe or an arc raising the open edges to a welding heat, then "the welding bell or tongs C" (pp. 14-16).
- Huggins (1886), fig. 21: a pair of rolls, one with a semicircular groove and one with a matching flange, bends the hot strip to a trough; the rolls push it through a fixed die "having a trumpet-shaped axial hole", mouth toward them, which closes it; a second pair of half-round grooved rolls draws it through and finishes it. "When butt-welded tubes are to be made ... the strips are raised to a welding heat, and passed through the machine quickly. When unwelded tubes are to be made, the strips are heated only to bright redness, and need not be passed so rapidly" (pp. 16-19).
- Twer (1898), fig. 127: a bell, "which may be in two halves", carries rollers in adjustable bearings, with the mandrel hung inside it from a pivoted arm; the lap is welded as the skelp is drawn forward (p. 125).
Open and close-jointed tube (p. 16)
- Tube "employed in the construction of bedsteads and for other similar purposes not having to resist either an external or internal liquid or gaseous pressure, as in the case of steam, water, and gas pipes, do not require the edges ... securely welding together, but such edges may be simply butted".
The trade and its tube (pp. 121-125)
- Welded gas, water and steam tube is "still chiefly made according to the methods introduced in the first half of last century", established in Wednesbury 1827-1850. "The manufacturer must first obtain his rolled 'strip' from the ironmaster and convert the same into the 'skelp' or open jointed tubular form" (pp. 121-122).
- Butt-welded tube is listed down to 1/8 in bore. Lap-welded tube needs a mandrel and so starts at about 1 in (p. 122). Butt welding is "not ordinarily adopted for steam tubes of more than 2 in.", sometimes 1.5 in; lap welding serves the larger sizes (p. 124).
- "Steam tubes of leading makers are one gauge thicker than water tubes, and the latter one gauge thicker than gas tubes" (p. 122). Spencer's list (p. 123), bores 1/4 to 4 in: 1 in gas .128 in and 1.680 lb/ft, water .144 in, steam .160 in and 2.016 lb/ft; 4 in gas .176 in, steam .212 in.
- Strength: a 1 in gas pipe of 20 t/sq in iron bursts in theory at 5.12 t/sq in, "but the weld will by no means come up to the stated condition", and a particle of scale may leave a tube not even gas tight. "The screwing of the tube ends will of course reduce the effective thickness." "All gas, water, and steam pipes, and fittings for same, must therefore be subjected to hydraulic test before passing from the works": gas sometimes as low as 50 lb/sq in, water and steam "seldom ... less than 300 lb", and the tube must bend cold through a right angle over a block of radius twice the bore (p. 124).
- Fire-tube boiler tubes carry pressure outside and may be thinner (p. 125).
Strip, piles and steel (pp. 24-25, 108-121, 128-130)
- "To produce 'tube strip' from the rough 'puddled bars' ... much rolling is necessary"; the impurities "become squeezed towards the edges, so that at such parts it is particularly difficult to effect welding" (p. 128). Binding a pile with wire does under a steam hammer and is "dangerous and unreliable" in rolls (p. 128). Perrins (1897) rolls puddled bars to trough sections, piles them into a hollow bloom that welds itself in the furnace under its own weight, and rolls it down at one heat to tube (pp. 128-130).
- Seamless tube is the steel route: cast hollow and extended (Stirling 1854, pp. 24-25), then Mannesmann's skew rolls (1885, pp. 32-35), presses and pilger rolls, and cold drawing on a chain draw bench through five or six dies with a mandrel, reeled loose between draws (pp. 108-113), annealed and pickled (pp. 115-118).
- "For boiler tubes a very mild steel is generally employed"; seamless tube has been drawn from steel of .01 to .015 per cent carbon, "less than is usually present in wrought iron" (p. 121). No alloy steel appears.