Fairbairn, Gillmore, Bolland, Kirk and Bauerman on grinding mills (millstones, edge runners, pan mills)
Books Treatise on Mills and Millwork, Part II, Practical Treatise on Limes, Hydraulic Cements, and Mortars (Van Nostrand), The Iron-Founder, The Cupola Furnace, A Treatise on the Metallurgy of Iron
Covers the period sources for a powered grinding mill on a line shaft. Pages below are printed folios. A digest only. Read
- W. Fairbairn, Treatise on Mills and Millwork, Part II (1863): corn mills and millstones (pp. 127-129, 146-155, 169), oil mills (pp. 222-223), powder mills (pp. 246-252), disengaging gear (p. 82). Folios are the book's own; PDF page = folio + 30 to 50 (plates inserted). Fig. 316-317 and the speed table (p. 252) were viewed as images. The runner and stone sizes of the powder mills are not in the text.
- Q. A. Gillmore, Practical Treatise on Limes, Hydraulic Cements, and Mortars (Van Nostrand, 1864), 348 PDF pages, PDF page = folio + 6): cement mills (pp. 47-63), the Pasley chalk mill (pp. 90-91), horse and steam mortar mills (pp. 192-198).
- A. Ure, Dictionary of Arts, Manufactures, and Mines (US ed., listed 1851), read as archive.org's text only: gunpowder (p. 632), oils (pp. 905-906), bone-black.
- Bolland, The Encyclopedia of Founding (1894, archive.org text only) and The Iron Founder (p. 174); Kirk, Cupola Furnace (pp. 94, 99, 119); Bauerman, Metallurgy of Iron (pp. 98-99, 104-105). Not readable Fairbairn Parts I and IV and Percy's Metallurgy have no text layer (one page of text in 400 to 995) and were not read. None of the other books on hand grinds foundry facings, flux or refractory by mill. No source found for the foundry blacking mill itself (see "No source gives").
Form 1: millstones on a stone nut (Fairbairn, corn mills)
Sizes and stone (pp. 152-154)
- "The diameter of the millstones most in use at the present day is 4 feet, and their thickness about 12 inches one half of this thickness is composed of French burr, a very hard, though porous mineral, of a siliceous nature; the other half is made up of plaster of Paris." Built of burr segments cemented and "firmly bound by iron hoops passing round the circumference" (p. 153).
- Dressing (p. 154): face divided into 11 parts, furrows "generally from 1 1/2 to 1 3/4 inches wide", cut square on one side and oblique on the other so the edges meet "after the manner of a pair of scissors"; the land "is cut like the teeth of a file with from 11 to 18 fine grooves to the inch". The upper stone is made slightly hollow near the eye so the grain enters. A brush on the top stone clears the case of flour.
- The runner is suspended on the spindle on a rhind (a cross-head joint, p. 151); the bed stone is fixed in the cone, levelled by three screws and centred by four (pp. 154-155). The runner must be balanced: at 120-130 rpm a stone that stood in balance at rest "would have dipped or 'wabbled' to the extent, on the average, of a quarter of an inch", cured by four balance boxes in the back (pp. 169-170). Drive (pp. 148-151): a cast-iron standard encloses "the principal part of the driving and adjusting gearing for each pair of stones" (p. 147); the driving shaft is "part of the line of horizontal shafting which is common to the whole range" and the velocity of that line "is usually from 70 to 80 revolutions per minute" (pp. 149-150). "A large bevil mortice wheel h ... working into the pinion i, on the mill-spindle, serves to transmit the motion of the shaft f to the latter." The pinion (the stone nut) slides on a feather to lift the stone; the spindle runs up through the bed stone to the runner. The drive is from below; the plummer block of the line shaft sits in the standard's lower diaphragm and the strain is downward (p. 150). The mill spindle has a gun-metal footstep adjustable to set the stone pressure (p. 155). Speed and gearing, Taganrog (pp. 127-128): 36 pairs "for grinding 180 to 200 bushels of clean dry wheat per hour"; two 100 hp engines on a flywheel 24 ft 5 in at 24.7 rpm; pinion gears into it at 87.7 rpm; main shafts 8 1/2 in down to 6 in; pairs of stones 5 ft 6 in apart in a straight line; "The bevil mortice wheels on the main horizontal shaft are 3 feet 4 3/4 inches diameter, and the bevil wheels on the millstone-spindles are 2 feet 1 1/2 inches, and make 140 revolutions per minute." Feed (p. 149, p. 129 footnote): hopper in a tripod over the stone case, wire gauze in the hopper, fed to the eye by the feeding apparatus; the stone case is "a cylinder of thin sheet iron", open so air passes between the stones. Meal drops to creepers and elevators, then to dressing and bolting (p. 128). Output is meal, not powder; the flour is separated from bran by bolting. Ship's mill (p. 138): 20 bushels or 1,120 lb of flour an hour from one set on an 80 hp engine that also drives the ship (the number of pairs is not stated). Conical (Westrup) mill (footnote, p. 129): two pairs per mill, lower stones convex "make about 250 revolutions per minute", upper "about 2 feet 6 inches diameter", 9 in of grinding surface after the eye, a fan blows cool air between to blow the meal out. Works: Taganrog (Black Sea, 1850s, steam), the Bruiser (ship), and mills "in a continuous line".
Form 2: millstones for cement and fine mineral (Gillmore)
- American natural-cement works grind burnt cement rock between French burr stones after a "cracker" (rough crusher, not described): Rondout Lime and Cement Co., "five 'crackers' and eleven run of stone of two and a half feet in diameter, and two run of four and a half feet diameter. Four of the crackers, and five run of stone, can grind eight hundred barrels of cement per day" (p. 47); Round Top works, "two run of four feet French burrs, driven by a forty-horse water-power" (p. 55); Cumberland, "two run of French burrs, 4 1/2 and 5 feet in diameter, ... driven by a 35 horse-power engine. This power is considered sufficient to drive three run of stone" (p. 57); Shepherdstown, "two run of four and a half French burr stones and the necessary crackers, driven by water-power" (p. 54); a Lake Erie steam mill of four run "capable of grinding 300 barrels per day" (p. 59); most other Rondout mills have four run of 4 1/2 to 5 ft stone with 2 to 4 crackers.
- Fineness: cement is tested after "a fine wire sieve, designated No. 80" (p. 29, eighty meshes to the inch); the author names the "difficulty with which a high degree of pulverization can be secured with newly-dressed millstones" as a cause of variation (p. 28).
- Dupont's artificial Portland: "horizontal mill-stones, similar to those used for grinding corn" grind the raw lime and clay with only enough water to make a paste (p. 63). Burnt balls "may be pulverized between millstones, or by any other suitable means" (p. 85).
Form 3: edge runners (chasers, pan mills)
Powder mills (Fairbairn pp. 246-252; Ure p. 632)
- Method: stampers first, then edge stones; "although the system of grinding by edge stones has not been superseded, great improvements have nevertheless been introduced, by substituting turned cast-iron rollers or runners in place of edge stones, and these revolving on turned cast-iron beds give greatly increased accuracy to the movements, and less danger from sparks" (p. 246). At Waltham Abbey Fairbairn made the water wheels and runners; Hick of Bolton "a 40 horse-power steam-engine and six pairs of edge runners" (p. 247).
- Drive (pp. 248-249): a 14 ft by 12 ft water wheel "giving motion to two pairs of runners on each side"; "a line of shafts A and B ... one on each side of the water wheel placed in an underground tunnel, and by the bevil wheels c, d, gives motion to the vertical spindle which passes through a tight brass stuffing box in the large bed plates ... the edge runners above"; a sliding clutch with friction starts and stops each mill, worked by a worm wheel and crank from outside; "All the wheels in these mills have wood and iron teeth, as iron working into iron is always attended with danger". A box keyed on the vertical spindle with a sliding brass box carries the runner; the runners "are not equidistant from the vertical spindle", so one grinds the ridge thrown up by the other (pp. 249-250). Scrapers push the charge under the runners.
- Speed (p. 252): water wheel 6.68 rpm ("4.89 feet per second"); segments 12 ft 9 in on 3 ft 6 1/2 in give 24.2 rpm on the horizontal shaft; bevel wheel 2 ft 3 in on 5 ft 4 1/2 in give "10 revolutions of runner".
- Charge and fineness (p. 250; Ure p. 632): ground "kept moist by a little water ... to form the mass into a sort of paste"; Ure: "From 50 to 60 pounds of cake are usually worked at one operation, under each millstone", edge stones "of a calcareous kind ... incapable of affording sparks by collision with steel", a copper scraper before the stone. Ingredients "have to be pulverised ... by means of a number of revolving drums and balls" (Fairbairn p. 250), the one ball-mill form named, then sifted. Only objection to edge stones: "their liability to strike fire" (p. 250). Trains of edge stones need friction clutches to start under load (p. 82). Oil mills (Fairbairn pp. 222-223; Ure pp. 905-906)
- Fairbairn: "a pair of edge stones, weighing together about 7 tons, and making about 17 revolutions per minute"; faced every three years; a batch is ground "about twenty five minutes"; one pair feeds two double hydraulic presses; seed is first cracked between rolls, 4 ft by 1 ft, 56 rpm, 4 1/2 tons in 11 hours (p. 222).
- Ure: granite stones "from 5 to 7 feet in diameter", "from 30 to 36 revolutions ... in a minute", three tons each, cylindrical not conical so they grind "by a rubbing motion, or attrition"; bed of masonry or iron, rim of oak plank bound with iron, a cast-iron box guards the step, bottom scraper and a slide-plate to turn the paste out; "Some hoop the stones with an iron rim, but others prefer ... the rough surface of granite" (p. 905). Power: a press set "will require a 12-horse power to work it well, along with the rolls and the edge-stones" (p. 906). Ure's itemised mill list has two pairs of 7 ft edge stones over two 6 ft bed stones.
- Ure lists the same machine for bone-black: "Either a corn-mill, an edgestone mill, or a steel cylinder mill, may be employed for grinding bone-black", damped to keep dust down, sieved to grains (folio not taken). Mortar and chalk mills (Gillmore) - the nearest to a general mineral pan mill
- Pasley's chalk mill (pp. 90-91): "two broad vertical iron wheels, on a common axle, carried around by means of a vertical shaft ... in the centre of a cast iron pan"; wheels "four and a half to five feet in diameter, and from ten to fifteen inches wide at the rim", set 18 in and 24 in from the centre "so as not to run in the same track"; the axle is loose in the shaft "to allow the wheels to rise over lumps"; scrapers on the shaft and axle; horse path radius 11 ft; the chalk is ground with water to a thin paste.
- Fort Warren horse mill (p. 193-194): masonry circular trench, "a heavy wheel, 8 feet in diameter, furnished with a tire 1/2 inch thick and 12 inches broad, and loaded by having its interior space filled with sand"; wheel centre 7 ft 6 in from the axis, horse path radius 20 ft; a drum 4 ft 8 in with an 8 in square vertical shaft, a horizontal 8 in square shaft through the wheel. Output "six hundred cubic feet of mortar per day of ten hours" (p. 194), "nearly, if not quite, doubled" at a 12 1/2 ft trench.
- Fort Taylor steam mill, 1857 (pp. 196-198): "a pan geared into a cogged connection with the engine, and supported on large conical bed rollers; and of a pair of hollow cast-iron wheels, so joined by an axle, that they revolve in the opposite sides of the pan with the same velocity as the pan itself" - the pan and wheels both turn, "compound or double velocity"; two helical scrapers on the wheel shaft, a scraper at each end of the axle for the wheel faces and one for the pan wall. Engine "about sixteen to twenty horse-power ... Two-thirds of this power would run the mill"; mill and engine cost $3,466, about $5,000 in place. Fed by batch of one barrel of cement plus sand and lime paste with water; "The greatest resistance is encountered when the dry materials are thrown in, at which time the speed is very much slackened ... As the mixing proceeds, the speed of revolution quickens greatly"; discharged by scoop shovel from a platform a foot below the pan. "over fifty batches in a day"; one driver, one fireman, 2 to 5 men; "It will hardly be found an economy to run the mill for less than twenty to twenty-five batches a day" (p. 198). Used for concrete mortar too; the coarse sand "requires pulverization to make the mortar work well".
Stamps, rolls, other forms (contrast)
- Bauerman (pp. 98-99, 104-105): for iron ores "Roller-crushing mills are therefore to be preferred to stamps" since stamps make dust; rolls suit roasted, not raw, ores; at Eisenerz a pair of 18 in by 12 in rolls set 1 1/2 in at 36 rpm pass about 40 tons an hour on 19 hp, 60-75 tons at 40-42 rpm on 24 hp.
- Kunhardt, Practice of Ore Dressing in Europe (1884, archive.org text, folio not taken): concentrates are passed "to a set of reducing rolls, or to a Chilian mill" to a 3 mm size; "the slow but effective grinding pans of the West" are named in the same book; neither is described.
- Ball or drum mill: only the powder works' "revolving drums and balls" (Fairbairn p. 250), no size or speed.
Uses named for foundries and ironworks (what was ground, how fine)
- Facing and blacking (Bolland, Encyclopedia of Founding, entries Facing, Blacking, Anthracite Facing, 1894): "Facings are composed of finely ground and bolted fireproof substances, principally carbon, as charred wood, coal, graphite"; coal facing "ground from bituminous coal selected for its freedom from slate, sulphur"; "Finely ground Lehigh coal"; charcoal facing is "the dust of pulverized charcoal". West (American Foundry Practice, 1885, archive.org text) says "The finer blacking is ground, the better mixture it will make". Bolland's Iron Founder (p. 174) mixes the bought brands ("hard Lehigh blacking", "XX silver lead", best heavy charcoal) wet with clay water and has the mix "pass through a fine sieve". No mill is described.
- Refractories (Bolland, Encyclopedia, entry Crucible, pp. 125-126): "The burnt fire-clay is simply old crucibles, etc., perfectly freed from slag and scoria and ground into a fine powder"; Mushet's crucible mix of Stourbridge clay 5, kaolin 5, ground crucible 1, ground coke 1 1/2; a cupola daubing of fire-clay 50, fire-sand 25 and "ground fire-bricks" 25. Bauerman (about p. 171): "Fire-brick, ganister, or any similar" lining, no grinding named. Kirk (pp. 99, 119) mixes blacking or sea coal into bod and tap plugs "to make it porous".
- Flux: no source reviewed grinds limestone flux by mill; Gillmore only grinds burnt lime and cement stone.
- Slag: none of the sources grinds slag in a mill.
The forms against the uses
| Form | Grain | Flux/lime | Slag | Refractory (clay, ganister, brick) | Blacking (charcoal, coal) | Crushed ore to powder |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Millstones on a stone nut (4 ft burr, 140 rpm on a 70-80 rpm line, from below) | The corn mill, 5.0-5.6 bu/h a pair at Taganrog (inferred) | Burnt cement rock ground between 4-5 ft burr after a cracker | Not sourced | Not sourced; Dupont's wet clay/lime paste ground this way | Not sourced | Not sourced; burr is for soft stuff |
| Edge runner, stone or iron on a bed (7 ton pair, 10-36 rpm, spindle through the bed) | Not sourced | Not sourced | Not sourced | Same machine as the Pasley and mortar pans | Ure's bone-black in an edgestone mill; no coal or charcoal case | Not sourced; powder and oilseed are the sourced mineral-like charges |
| Pan with both wheels and pan turning (Fort Taylor) | No | Mixes lime paste, cement, sand, with water; 16-20 hp engine | Not sourced | Pasley's chalk mill is the nearest to clay | Not sourced | Not sourced |
| Roll crusher, Blake, stamps (contrast) | No | Crusher stage only | Not sourced | Not sourced | Not sourced | Bauerman: rolls break roasted ore to 1 1/2 in; stamps dust |
Reading of the sources (inference, not stated by them): edge runners and pans are the period mill for wet or damp pasty charges (powder, oilseed, mortar, clay, bone-black); burr stones for dry grain and cement rock; the source texts name no mill for slag, flux or foundry facings.
No source gives
- A foundry blacking, sea-coal, charcoal-dust or plumbago mill: size, speed, power, output. Bolland and West name the product and its fineness only.
- A mill for slag, flux (limestone) or ganister in the books read (Bauerman names ganister only as a lining stone).
- Diameter and width of the powder-mill iron runners, bed-plate size, power per pair, output per hour; Fairbairn gives the speeds (10 rpm) and the 40 hp for six pairs only.
- The edge-runner power per pair in hp for oilseed (only a 12 hp whole press set, Ure p. 906).
- Output per hour of a millstone pair at Taganrog directly; the 5.0-5.6 bu/h and 5.6 hp a pair are 200 hp / 36 and 180-200 bu / 36 (inferred, and the 200 hp also drives elevators and dressing).
- Gillmore's cement rate per run: Rondout gives "five run, 800 barrels a day" with four crackers, no speed or hp. Cumberland 35 hp over 3 run is about 12 hp a run (inferred); Round Top 40 hp over 2 run is 20 (inferred).
- Stone-weight, stone width and rpm of the Fort Warren and Fort Taylor mortar wheels (only diameter, tire width and speed up and down with load).
- Fineness in mesh for grain flour, flux or refractory (only the No. 80 sieve for cement).
- French burr price, supply, or its cast-iron substitute for non-grain stone; the cast-iron "turned runner" bed and wheel sizes (Fairbairn plates 316-317 were viewed, drawn at an unstated scale).
- Fairbairn Parts I and IV and Percy (no text layer, unread); a ball mill beyond Fairbairn's one line; Chilian mill sizes (Kunhardt names one).