Fairbairn, Treatise on Mills and Millwork, Part II (1863)
Books Treatise on Mills and Millwork, Part II
Covers W. Fairbairn, "Treatise on Mills and Millwork, Part II: On Machinery of Transmission and the Construction and Arrangement of Mills" (1863, 332 PDF pages). Pages below are the book's printed folios. The offset to the PDF page grows with the inserted plates: 22 up to p. 32, 26 from p. 33 (Plates IX-X), 30 from p. 127, 34 from p. 150, 38 to 42 from p. 184 on (p. 253 is PDF 295). PDF pages 3-6, 10, 19, 22, 55, 57, 74, 153, 155, 159, 161, 164, 168, 207-208, 211, 223-224, 226, 304, 314, 327-329 and 332 carry no text layer (front matter, plates, blanks). Most tables are printed as images; Tables 1, 3, 4, 8, 9 and 10, the tooth-proportion table (p. 33), the journal table (p. 73), the tooth-pressure tables (pp. 47-48), Plate IX and figs. 179-181, 185, 210-214, 217, 229, 231-234, 238, 244 and 318 were read from the images. Plates I-VIII (the Taganrog, Bombay and Izmet mills) were not looked at. Read in full: Section IV, on wheels, pulleys, shafts, journals, friction, lubrication, couplings, engaging gear, hangers, fly-wheels and main shafts (pp. 1-109), and Chapter X, iron mills, with the armour-plate appendix (pp. 253-261, 268-271). Read for their gearing only: the corn mills (pp. 117-128, 149-155), the woollen mill at Izmet (pp. 184-186) and the powder mill (p. 248). Skimmed: the tooth-curve geometry (pp. 17-32), the strength formulae (pp. 52-70), mill architecture (pp. 110-116). Skipped: the corn-cleaning machinery, the cotton, flax, silk, woollen, oil and paper processes, Appendix I and the index. Subject the shafting, gearing and power arrangement of a mill: fly-wheel, shafts, bevel and spur wheels, couplings, clutches, supports, and the rolls and engines of an iron mill.
What the book says
Straps against gearing (pp. 1-4, 90)
- Americans drive whole mills by leather straps off a great drum; Lancashire and Yorkshire gear with toothed wheels and light shafts at high speed. Fairbairn finds less journal friction with gearing (p. 2).
- Straps suit irregular work (saw mills) and the last step from shaft to machine; they slip as they wear, which loses time but eases shocks (pp. 2-3). Pulley rims are slightly convex to hold a flat strap (p. 3). Table 1 gives strap widths: 1 hp on a 1 ft pulley wants 3.6 in, 10 hp on a 4 ft pulley 9 in (p. 4).
- A strap thrown onto a pulley slips until it brings the machine up to speed, which is "unexceptional when the power to be transferred is not great" (p. 90).
Toothed wheels: wood, cast iron and the cutting machine (pp. 5-11, 14, 33-35, 41)
- Old wheels had hard-wood cogs driven into mortises. Mortise wheels "are still retained"; iron pinions with wooden cogs take the drive off engine fly-wheels to cut noise, and many millwrights make one wheel of a high-speed pair a mortise wheel (p. 5). Powder mills use wood-and-iron teeth throughout, since "iron working into iron is always attended with danger" (p. 248).
- Smeaton used cast iron for wheels at Carron in 1769; Rennie carried cast iron into every part of millwork at Soho and the Albion Mills, 1784-5 (pp. 6-7). The cast wheel of fig. 181 has its teeth and eight arms cast on. Bevel wheels date from Camus, 1752 (p. 7).
- Rennie's pinions were "chipped and turned": turned on the face and the tooth ends, divided, drawn to the curve, chipped with hammer and chisel and filed (p. 9). A cutting machine has since replaced the chisel (p. 9). Peter Fairbairn's (fig. 185, pp. 9-11) is a lathe with a hollow-spindle headstock, a worm-driven dividing wheel and two beds bolted to masonry. First it turns the face and sides of the rim segments, "previously, when bolted to the arms". Then a cutter head replaces the slide rest, the dividing wheel gives the pitch, and a roughing cutter and a finishing rose-cutter are traversed across each space. The same machine cuts worm and bevel wheels (p. 11).
- The worm wheel is "roughly cut out" and finished by a notched steel screw used as the cutter (p. 41).
- Pitches are kept few "with a view to the reduction of the number of patterns required for casting". Spur fly-wheels run 1.5-5 in, spur and bevel wheels 0.5-5 in; below that is machine work, not millwork (p. 14).
- Tooth proportions, traced from one of his own patterns (p. 33): pitch 1.00, depth 0.75, working depth 0.70, clearance 0.05, thickness 0.45, space 0.55, beyond the pitch line 0.35. Cut wood-and-iron gear needs almost no clearance, but "it is ... different where wheels have to gear together direct from the foundry, where the teeth are not unfrequently deranged in the act of moulding in the sand" (pp. 34-35).
- Tooth load is 550 x hp / pitch-line speed in ft/s. A 24 ft fly-wheel at 25 rpm driving a 5 ft pinion with 150 hp puts 2627 lb on the teeth (p. 42). Breadth is sized at 400 lb per inch, wooden teeth are 1.5 times as thick as cast (pp. 43-44), and rolling-mill gearing wants the largest allowance for shock (p. 42).
Shafts (pp. 50-78)
- One prime mover and long lines of shafting made the factory system: 200-300 ft lines, two miles of shafting at Saltaire (pp. 50-51); 450 wheels and 7,000 ft of shafting in an average mill of his, 600 wheels and 10,000 ft over 12 acres at Saltaire (pp. 98-99).
- Material (p. 51): wood is obsolete. Main and vertical shafts are "generally of cast-iron", cheap, stiff and high in resistance to torsion; wrought iron has "in most cases superseded" it for line shafting and wins wherever there is impact. Rankine's modulus of wrenching is 30,000 for cast iron against 54,000 for wrought (p. 66).
- Deflection is what sizes a long shaft: no more than 1/1200 of its length under load (p. 60). "A stiff shaft, although heavier in itself, is lighter to retain in motion than a smaller one which bends" (p. 61).
- Speed (pp. 72-73): run the shafting at about half the speed of the machines. At 50 rpm a shaft needs three times the weight. The shafts of 1800 were cast, square and badly coupled, and "the power required to keep them in motion was in some cases almost equal to that required by the machinery"; Fairbairn credits his success to tripling shaft speed. Table 8 sizes wrought shafting from 1 to 150 hp at 10 to 1000 rpm (p. 71).
- Journals are 1.5 diameters long on cast iron and 1.75 on wrought (p. 73). Working pressure is 178 psi on a fly-wheel shaft, 243 psi on a vertical shaft's toe and 20-40 psi on horizontal shafts. Toes need the best gun metal, limpid oil and no grit. The shoulder is hollowed, never cut square, which saves strength (p. 74).
- Friction (pp. 74-77): Morin gives 0.07-0.08 with oil or lard, 0.10 with tallow on metal. An engine's own friction was 1/10 of its power. A change of oil can absorb 10-15 hp in a large cotton mill, and a mill cold after Sunday takes more power on Monday (p. 77). The cure is a wick lubricator in a cistern on the plummer block (p. 78).
- Long light lines twist: 150-200 ft ranges "effect nearly a complete revolution at the point of imparted motion before the extreme ends begin to move", and whole lines have been taken out for it (p. 107).
Couplings (pp. 79-82, Table 10 p. 109)
- The one-piece square box (it rattled), the claw coupling keyed on, Hewes' half-lap with three keys (they loosened and creaked), and the disc coupling of two flanges and four bolts, good "when properly bored and turned" (pp. 79-81).
- Fairbairn's circular half-lap: two laps turned to a gauge and put together by a cutting machine, a cylindrical box keyed over them, and the whole "turned in the lathe to the same centres as the bearings". The coupling's area is twice the shaft's, the lap one diameter long, the box two (p. 81). The butt coupling has the same proportions and is weaker (pp. 81-82).
Engaging and disengaging (pp. 82-93)
- Clutches between the upright and each room's shafting were given up: "unsteady in practice", they caused accidents by the time lost and the breakages on re-engaging at full speed. The mill keeps its main lines permanently connected, with signals to the engine house (p. 82).
- Levers and sliding plummer blocks that pulled a wheel out of gear were found "inoperative on a large scale"; the block was bolted down for good (pp. 82-84).
- "The best of all are the fast and loose pulleys": a forked lever at the machine moves the strap from the keyed pulley to the loose one (p. 84). A tightening pulley on a lever does the same for sack hoists (pp. 84-85).
- Heavy calendering and rolling machinery needs friction clutches "to communicate the motion by a slow and progressive acceleration from a state of rest" (p. 82): a slipping friction clip (pp. 85-86), friction cones that can be brought on "with the greatest nicety" (p. 86), a leather-faced friction coupling that slips on a sudden stop or reversal (pp. 87-88), and Bodmer's screw-set copper sectors for powder mills (pp. 91-93).
- The disengaging coupling with sloped claws overruns when the driven side gets ahead. It joins a water-wheel and a steam engine on one line, the engine worked harder as the water falls (pp. 88-89). Plain claw clutches join shafts "where it is not necessary to throw into or out of gear when running at full speed"; a reversed engine throws them out on their wedge faces (pp. 90-91).
Supports (pp. 93-98, 105-107)
- Shafting stands "on foundation stones in the floor, beneath beams suspended from the ceiling, and to the walls" (p. 93). The floor pedestal is a cast-iron base plate and column with deep wings, a lower brass step and a cap; with the load all downward the upper brass goes and the cap is a grease box (pp. 93-94, fig. 229). The wall pedestal has its cap held by a cotter (p. 94, fig. 230).
- Hangers bolt to wooden beams or under cast-iron beams (figs. 231-237), one carries a small plummer block for a branch at right angles (p. 94), and the long one is tied to the brick arch with a screw to set the upper step (p. 97). A hanger for bevel or mitre wheels carries double steps for the main line and two cross ranges; hook bolts avoid boring the beam flange (p. 97, figs. 238-239). A cast-iron wall box at a room's corner carries the right-angle pair (p. 98).
- The vertical shaft stands in a brass footstep in a box on a base plate bolted to the foundation and the engine-house wall; the corner of the step opposite the bevel thrust is cut away and kept full of oil (pp. 105-107, fig. 244). Bevel wheels are preferred to the universal joint for any angle (pp. 107-108).
Fly-wheels and the first motion (pp. 100-105, 123, 127-128, 150, 184-186)
- For over twenty years the fly-wheel has been cast with teeth and is the first motion. The power comes straight off its rim through a pinion, which abolished the old spur wheels inside the mill (p. 100). Table 9 (p. 101): 12 to 300 hp, wheels 8 ft 11.5 in to 30 ft 1.5 in, pitch 2-4.5 in, breadth 5-16 in, pitch-line 1,250-1,650 ft/min.
- Piston speeds have risen from 240 to 300-350 ft/min; "the standard speed of a Bolton and Watt 7 feet stroke engine ... was seventeen and a half strokes per minute" (p. 101).
- A 12 hp corn mill: a 9 ft 3.75 in spur fly-wheel on a 4 ft 10.75 in pinion "nearly doubled" the speed on the main shaft (p. 123). Taganrog: two 100 hp engines in one fly-wheel of 24 ft 5 in, 230 teeth of 4 in pitch and 14 in breadth, at 24.7 rpm; the pinion runs 87.7 rpm; main shafts step down 8.5, 7.5, 6.5-6 in from the engine; bevel mortise wheels drive the stones at 140 rpm (pp. 127-128). The stone line runs 70-80 rpm on half-lap couplings, in plummer blocks with no cover, since the load is all downward (p. 150).
- Saltaire: four 100 nhp engines, over 1,250 hp. The vertical shaft is driven from the fly-wheel by a horizontal shaft and gives off each room's power by a bevel pair. It is 10 in through two rooms, 8.5 in through the third, 6.5 in to the top, at 94 rpm. Spinning pulleys turn near 200 rpm (pp. 102-105).
- Izmet: the water-wheel's internal toothed segment, 28 ft 2.5 in, 324 cogs of 3.25 in pitch, drives a 5 ft pinion; the cast-iron vertical shaft tapers 11, 10, 8 in; the heaviest machinery sits nearest the first motion (pp. 184-186).
Iron mills (pp. 253-260, 268-271)
- The vertical engine used to stand with the rolls on one side of its fly-wheel and the hammer on the other. The horizontal non-condensing engine is now preferred. Its steam is raised from the puddling and heating furnaces' waste heat, its speed is regulated by the steam lever, and it sits "upon a large bed plate" with little masonry (pp. 254-258). In fig. 318 the puddling rolls are driven off the end of the fly-wheel shaft through a disengaging coupling, and Brown's squeezer through a train of spur wheels.
- The helve is lifted by cams on a revolving wheel (p. 255). The rolls are "connected by toothed pinions" in "massive framing" (p. 257).
- Rolls are cast by the works themselves. The loam mould is sunk upright in a pit, a head above it feeds the shrinkage, and the metal is stirred until semi-fluid and cooled slowly (p. 258). Plate rolls are cast "from the most tenacious metals", with enlarged necks and a slightly concave barrel against buckling; "bar rolls are generally cast in chill", with care that the chill does not go too deep (p. 259). Staffordshire wire rolls are cast steel (p. 260).
- Roughing rolls are 4-5 ft long and 18 in diameter, merchant rolls 2.5-3 ft by 18 in, plate rolls over 6 ft by 18-21 in (p. 259). Plate rolls want "the momentum of a large fly-wheel", and even with it "the plates cool and stick fast in the middle" (p. 259). Merchant rolls turn 60-70 rpm, plate rolls 28-30, finishing and guide rollers 120-400 (pp. 259-260). Cold rolling stiffens "slender shafts" (p. 260).
- The armour-plate mill: 32 in by 8 ft rolls on a 400 hp engine, a 60 t iron foundation, and a screw through compound levers closing the gap each pass, 12, 10, 8 in; the first bite from 19 to 17 in nearly stopped the engine (pp. 269-270).
A mill's transmission, part by part
What Fairbairn builds a mill's drive from, from the engine outward. "Finished" is what the book says was done to the part; nothing in it is bored on a boring mill.
| Part | Material and form | Finished | Pages |
|---|---|---|---|
| spur fly-wheel | cast iron; toothed rim in segments bolted to cast arms | rim segments turned on face and sides, teeth pitched and trimmed on the dividing cutter; many ran as cast | 9-11, 100-101, 185 |
| first-motion pinion | cast iron, or iron with wooden cogs | bored and keyed on its shaft; teeth turned, divided, chipped and filed, later cut | 5, 9, 248 |
| first-motion and main shafts | cast iron, stepped down along the line | journals turned 1.5 d long, shoulders hollowed | 51, 73-74, 102, 127 |
| vertical shaft and footstep | cast iron; gun-metal step in a box on a base plate | step turned and fitted into a cast socket | 102-107, 155 |
| bevel and mitre wheels | cast iron; bevel mortise wheels in corn mills | "made with the greatest possible care"; cast with teeth elsewhere | 14, 97, 128, 150 |
| line shafting | wrought iron, light and fast; cold-rolled for slender shafts | journals turned 1.75 d | 51, 72, 260 |
| couplings | half-lap: two laps and a box, keyed; disc: two bolted flanges | laps turned and cut; box turned in the lathe on the bearings' centres; disc bored and turned | 79-82, 109 |
| pedestals, hangers, wall boxes, plummer blocks | cast iron frames; brass upper and lower steps; cap by cotter or bolt | steps fitted | 93-98 |
| clutches | claw boxes, friction clip, cones, discs, overrunning coupling | sliding box's lever groove turned | 82-93 |
| pulleys and straps | iron pulleys, slightly convex; leather straps; fast and loose pair | - | 2-4, 84, 105 |
| mill housings and roll pinions | cast iron | rolls turned at necks and barrel | 257-259 |
In this book the transmission is turned, not bored: journals, couplings, wheel faces, footsteps and rolls are turned. The holes are small, wheel eyes and disc couplings bored for a key. Teeth are cut on a dividing lathe or left as cast. A boring mill appears nowhere in Part II.